Last edit by: WineCountryUA
CLE - Impact of other airlines (gates, routes, equipment, & etc) after UA De-Hubbing
#2086
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: CLE
Programs: UA Platinum, Starbucks Gold, PF Chang's Warrior, Wine Century 100
Posts: 1,105
Since I have to depart CLE in the morning, it'll be UA thru ORD or DEN (probably DEN). IAH adds an extra hour to the journey, but winter weather shouldn't be an issue...
On the return LAS-CLE I'm looking at the nonstop redeye on Spirit (in a Big Front Seat or exit row), or Frontier (in a Stretch seat, preferably a mid cabin exit row on their A321 with the unlimited legroom). I've taken both to RSW a handful of times and it's not really that bad. Planes are new and clean. Disclaimer: I've never sat in either airline's standard coach seat which do look rather painful.
#2088
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Cleveland, OH, USA, UA Silver, Hilton Gold
Posts: 772
https://www.clevelandairport.com/austin
#2091
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: CLE
Programs: UA Platinum, Starbucks Gold, PF Chang's Warrior, Wine Century 100
Posts: 1,105
Having CLEAR this past Monday morning was fantastic. (first business day after thanksgiving weekend). I arrived at the checkpoint with a co-worker who has TSA Pre. I breezed right through Clear, and then waited a good 20 minutes for her to make it through.
#2092
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: CLE, DCA, and 30k feet
Programs: Honors LT Diamond; United 1K; Hertz PC
Posts: 4,165
Parking availability has been either 100% wide open or 100% full with very few stops in-between, IME, since they tore down the long-term garage. A while ago I gave up trying to park at the airport unless I'm picking someone up on a Sunday and just use Park Place off Snow
#2093
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: CLE/RSW
Programs: Marriot Lifetime Plat
Posts: 206
Was on CLE-RSW flight on the 5th, was the second day of the seasonal flight, which the agent announced and said “we’re happy to have it back this season.” Great flight, got upgraded as a gold at T-36ish and due to a tailwind landed about 45 min early.
#2095
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: CLE/RSW
Programs: Marriot Lifetime Plat
Posts: 206
Likewise UA2405 LAS-CLE on that Friday (red eye). I always figured the CLE-LAS service would last. It's a popular business and leisure destination and, aside from WN, not served by any reasonable carriers. If CLE-MCO can stick around, why not CLE-LAS?
#2096
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: CLE, DCA, and 30k feet
Programs: Honors LT Diamond; United 1K; Hertz PC
Posts: 4,165
- UA has a GSA City Pair contract for CLE-MCO for government travelers (award based on nonstop service)
- You can actually connect to some smaller destinations via Silver
- A fairly consistent family demand for the theme parks and snow birds
- Significant UA MX base to rotate aircraft and parts between
- etc.
LAS
- UA has a GSA City Pair Contract for CLE-LAS based on connecting service
- AFAIK no real connection opportunities that don't have equal/better service from UA hubs
- Traffic tends to be low yielding aside from sporadic trade show demand (and even with tradeshows for a more mundane tradeshow I wonder how many attendees originate CLE... and I've avoided the red-eye in favor of a connection coming back from LAS trade shows)
- UA MX is a limited presence (UA lists Cleveland and Orlando as "major" maintenance locations in addition to the hubs... nothing for LAS)
#2097
Join Date: Jun 2014
Programs: UA MM
Posts: 4,126
I go to LAS two or maybe three times per year for various business reasons. One of the times earlier this year or maybe late 2018, a ticket agent checking me in and tagging my bag mentioned, out of the blue, that they can't believe they no longer have a nonstop flight to CLE. She mentioned they are always checking in quite a few people bound for CLE.
#2098
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: CLE, DCA, and 30k feet
Programs: Honors LT Diamond; United 1K; Hertz PC
Posts: 4,165
I go to LAS two or maybe three times per year for various business reasons. One of the times earlier this year or maybe late 2018, a ticket agent checking me in and tagging my bag mentioned, out of the blue, that they can't believe they no longer have a nonstop flight to CLE. She mentioned they are always checking in quite a few people bound for CLE.
And with Frontier offering $100 round trip on a random set of dates in January (8p departure from CLE, 6a arrival back to CLE) it doesn't seem UA is leaving money on the table. Assuming none of that was taxes/government fees that yields $0.0274/per mile. Based on the latest number I could quickly Google UA's domestic yield per RPM is $0.1404 -- or around 5-6 times what CLE-LAS seems to yield. Without significant strategic advantages to offset either end (e.g. no onward connections to sell, business subsiding the route, aircraft/crew/maintenance rotation considerations etc.) I don't think its that surprising.
#2099
Join Date: Jun 2014
Programs: UA MM
Posts: 4,126
One possibility is for lack of a better term, temporal adjacency. It's one thing to have quite a few people to CLE but if you have 100 people a day but 25 of them want to go early morning, 25 noon, 25 afternoon, and 25 late evening combined with the typical nonstop premium it's going to be hard to sell 75 of them "Fly nonstop at midnight and pay 15% more" vs "Fly when you want and lose 45 minutes in a connection" -- and 25 people generally don't make for a profitable flight... [Or maybe I'm just too old and curmudgeony to accept a red eye flight if I don't have to]
And with Frontier offering $100 round trip on a random set of dates in January (8p departure from CLE, 6a arrival back to CLE) it doesn't seem UA is leaving money on the table. Assuming none of that was taxes/government fees that yields $0.0274/per mile. Based on the latest number I could quickly Google UA's domestic yield per RPM is $0.1404 -- or around 5-6 times what CLE-LAS seems to yield. Without significant strategic advantages to offset either end (e.g. no onward connections to sell, business subsiding the route, aircraft/crew/maintenance rotation considerations etc.) I don't think its that surprising.
And with Frontier offering $100 round trip on a random set of dates in January (8p departure from CLE, 6a arrival back to CLE) it doesn't seem UA is leaving money on the table. Assuming none of that was taxes/government fees that yields $0.0274/per mile. Based on the latest number I could quickly Google UA's domestic yield per RPM is $0.1404 -- or around 5-6 times what CLE-LAS seems to yield. Without significant strategic advantages to offset either end (e.g. no onward connections to sell, business subsiding the route, aircraft/crew/maintenance rotation considerations etc.) I don't think its that surprising.
Maybe UA and other airlines simply think of LAS as a cheap tourist destination and leave it at that.
#2100
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: CLE/RSW
Programs: Marriot Lifetime Plat
Posts: 206
I understand what you're saying and the flight time question is a good one. I will say, though, that despite whatever Frontier might be charging on any given day, this UA agent says they're still checking in a lot of people bound for CLE and I know I've never paid less than a several hundred bucks. Now maybe everyone else is paying quite a bit less than me but I kind of doubt that.
Maybe UA and other airlines simply think of LAS as a cheap tourist destination and leave it at that.
Maybe UA and other airlines simply think of LAS as a cheap tourist destination and leave it at that.