FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   oneworld (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/oneworld-411/)
-   -   Changes to xONEx Rule Sheet (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/oneworld/983365-changes-xonex-rule-sheet.html)

Kiwi Flyer Apr 30, 2016 5:17 pm


Originally Posted by pandaperth (Post 26556790)
I think my post immediately above this one has addressed this question.
IMO the new rule is less restrictive, not more.

I can price up this itinerary - CPT-xLHR-DFW-HKG-oLHR-oDOH-MPM
But, again, if I change MPM to CPT then I get the error message about no flown or surface sectors between zones

Thanks for checking. I hope this bug is fixed quicker than the QF jetconnect one (which is still not fixed over a year later !@#$).

allset2travel Apr 30, 2016 7:21 pm


Originally Posted by pandaperth (Post 26556688)
Looks like the on-line tool has had the new rules implemented. I am able to price up the following itinerary:Under the previous rules those four Europe-Middle East flights were not allowed.

Edited to add:
But if I change the last flight to be DOH-CPT, then the tool flags the LHR-DOH as invalid new version of the rules, so I presume this is simply poor programming

My bold. That doesn't make any sense! Did you try DOH-JNB and see if that works?


Originally Posted by pandaperth (Post 26556688)
Will continue to investigate...

Thanks for putting in the effort ^

Viajero Millero Apr 30, 2016 8:06 pm

With the addition of MAD-JNB and HKG-MAD I'd look into a DONE4 with:

JNB-MAD-DOH-GRU-USA-ASIA-HKG-EU-DOH-CPT for maximum mileage.

Would I be able to keep both connections in each EU and DOH? Only the 2nd EU visit would be a stopover. Neither stop in DOH is over 24hr.

pandaperth May 3, 2016 5:20 am


Originally Posted by headinclouds (Post 26557933)
So, the take away is that if you want to have S.Africa as a starting point and use the backtrack exception, then you must go thru the ME hub of DOH at least 1 time. Can't do LHR/MAD both times. Correct?

Correct.

pandaperth May 3, 2016 5:33 am


Originally Posted by pandaperth (Post 26556688)
Looks like the on-line tool has had the new rules implemented.

Well I have to retract this statement.
I have been trying various itineraries in the on-line tool – and my opinion now is that the tool has not yet been updated to handle the new rule for a second transit of Europe.:(
The current situation with the on-line appears to be:
If one transit to/from Africa is via the Europe Zone
And the other transit is via the Middle East Zone
Then flights between the zones are flagged as errors (which was correct under the old rules)
Unless the flight to/from Africa from/to the Middle East Zone happens to be either QR’s DOH-MPM flight or the return flight MPM-DOH!
I tried it with the flight being DOH-NBO/WDH/CPT/JNB and got errors every time.
So I now think the tool is unchanged, as yet, and that I uncovered an existing bug that allowed intra-zone flights when there was DOH-MPM or v.v.

pandaperth May 3, 2016 6:49 am


Originally Posted by JAXBA (Post 26554697)
The ZA/Mauritius exception makes sense, at least routes to/from Asia/SWP (and soon S.America) are possible.

I beg to differ. I believe the rule makes little sense and is poorly worded

What is its purpose?
IMHO, the rule is there because BA does not want to fly pax both to SA/Mauritius and back again (or v.v. of course).
BA seems happy enough to fly you 1-way and let QR do the honours in the other direction.
Is it justified?
How do those flights compare to other flights that can be used for backtracking between continents?
We’re talking about LHR-CPT/JNB and LGW-MRU (which is the longest of the three at 6,045 miles)
The longest South America – North America backtracking flight is probably JFK-SCL at 5,097 miles and for Asia-South West Pacific AKL-HKG at 5,688 miles (though when QF flew it, its SYD-BOM flight could be used and that was 6,308 - so longer than LGW-MRU).
So, yes the BA flights are longer than the backtracking flights for other continents, but not by a really huge margin.
How effective is it?
Well yes the rule does disallow having two long-haul BA flights to/from Southern Africa
Does it have unintended consequences?
IMHO yes. (meaning that I think the following are unintended consequences.) By disallowing two transits through the Europe zone, the rule does more than prevent two flights to/from Southern Africa.
  1. What if a pax wants to start in SA, with say CPT-LHR, but end somewhere else in Africa – for example by having the last flight as MAD-DKR? No can do because both flights will be to/from the Europe Zone and the itinerary includes SA. (The same holds true for Ghana, Angola and Equatorial Guinea which are only served by European carriers – BA or IB)
  2. What if a pax visiting Africa from elsewhere wants to do something like LHR-LAD and MRU-LGW? (with a safari between the two).
Suggested Wording
If the intention is to disallow two flights between the UK and Southern Africa – then say so explicitly:

4(e) Only one intercontinental departure and one intercontinental arrival permitted in each continent except as follows:
  1. Two permitted in North America when one is a transfer without stopover.
  2. Two permitted in Asia when one is a transfer without stopover or on direct single plane service between the Southwest Pacific and Europe/Middle East.
  3. Two permitted in Europe/Middle East when one is a transfer without stopover. Note: only one flight permitted between the UK and South Africa/Mauritius.

This wording is concise and does away with zones completely.

JAXBA May 3, 2016 9:04 am

Well, yes, your wording would make even more sense! I just meant I understood the reason for the exclusion, however annoying it is.

anabolism May 29, 2016 9:52 pm


Originally Posted by pandaperth (Post 26556688)

Wow, I never thought to do Europe-DOH-Europe in the middle like that! Impressive. I recently booked a 16-segment CPT-DOH...DOH-CPT DONE5 that flies 51,900 miles or so. Your suggestion would impressively expand that.

pbd456 May 30, 2016 2:27 am


Originally Posted by anabolism (Post 26699499)
Wow, I never thought to do Europe-DOH-Europe in the middle like that! Impressive. I recently booked a 16-segment CPT-DOH...DOH-CPT DONE5 that flies 51,900 miles or so. Your suggestion would impressively expand that.

i have lax doh bcn doh osl doh... vert low yq.

747-444 May 30, 2016 11:02 pm


Originally Posted by Viajero Millero (Post 26559508)
With the addition of MAD-JNB and HKG-MAD I'd look into a DONE4 with:

JNB-MAD-DOH-GRU-USA-ASIA-HKG-EU-DOH-CPT for maximum mileage.

Would I be able to keep both connections in each EU and DOH? Only the 2nd EU visit would be a stopover. Neither stop in DOH is over 24hr.


Excuse my ignorance but how is this a four continent fare?
I see Africa - Europe - South America - USA - Asia?

headinclouds May 31, 2016 10:26 am

Not a rule change, but a question of interpretation.

Cancellations and Refunds
(1) After ticket issuance - Cancellation/No Show
Forfeit 10% of ticketed fare for Economy Class fares
Forfeit 5% of ticketed fare for Business/First Class fares
What is the ticketed fare? Base fare without taxes/fees or the grand total fare?

Rebooking/Rerouting
(1) Prior to departure
(a) Changes are permitted provided ticketed points remain the same. If the first
flight coupon is being changed, and the fare level has increased since ticket
issuance, the difference between the old and new fare will be charged.

Start a xONEx in March 2017, and have segments for Apr 2017 as place holders. In Sept 2016, change the dates only for the Apr 2017 flights to July 2017. No change to the first 4 flights. To me it means just local service fee, no $125 change fee and no repricing. Correct?

JAXBA May 31, 2016 12:27 pm


Originally Posted by headinclouds (Post 26706123)
What is the ticketed fare? Base fare without taxes/fees or the grand total fare?

The base fare, before taxes, fees and charges.


Start a xONEx in March 2017, and have segments for Apr 2017 as place holders. In Sept 2016, change the dates only for the Apr 2017 flights to July 2017. No change to the first 4 flights. To me it means just local service fee, no $125 change fee and no repricing. Correct?
Correct.

Viajero Millero May 31, 2016 6:23 pm


Originally Posted by 747-444 (Post 26704083)
Excuse my ignorance but how is this a four continent fare?
I see Africa - Europe - South America - USA - Asia?

The way oneworld sees continents for RTW applications, North and South America count as two separate ones.

Himeno Jun 1, 2016 1:49 am


Originally Posted by 747-444 (Post 26704083)
Excuse my ignorance but how is this a four continent fare?
I see Africa - Europe - South America - USA - Asia?


Originally Posted by Viajero Millero (Post 26708512)
The way oneworld sees continents for RTW applications, North and South America count as two separate ones.

JNB-|MAD-DOH-|GRU-|USA-|ASIA-HKG-|EU-DOH-|CPT
That's Africa, Europe, South America, North America, Asia.
It's a DONE5, not a DONE4 as you suggested.

Viajero Millero Jun 1, 2016 6:57 am

Right! My bad.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:27 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.