(Voting Completed - Motion Failed) Should VX Have a Forum?
#16
Suspended
Join Date: May 1998
Location: Seattle
Programs: Ephesians 4:31-32
Posts: 10,690
You are right. Nothing has really changed except a few newly elected TalkBoard members.
The fact that I thought the new forum was a good idea three weeks ago, and still think it is a good idea now, is a pretty compelling reason to vote for it. ^
The fact that I thought the new forum was a good idea three weeks ago, and still think it is a good idea now, is a pretty compelling reason to vote for it. ^
#17
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Yiron, Israel
Programs: Bates Motel Plat
Posts: 68,904
Actually, I felt much more comfortable posting on this before LuckyCoins announced how he voted. Until that point, it was clear that I was discussing how important it is that TB members think their votes through and not just cast ballots lightly. I also made it a point to say that I doubt that any TB member would casually switch votes in such a short period of time without a true compelling reason.
LuckyCoins' announcement of how he voted changes that situation. It is now obvious that if all the old TB members vote the way they did three weeks ago, the motion will pass.
By my contending that they should vote the same way (and I not only think they should but have enough respect for them to believe that they will) I am, in practical terms, arguing that this motion should be passed. As I oppose it, and have said so repeatedly when it was first suggested, that puts me in a very strange position.
Therefore, I will sum up as follows and then completely bow out of this discussion:
1. It is my own belief that this forum should not be established.
2. More important than that belief, however, is the point that TB members should not sway in the wind and should give careful consideration to all of their votes.
3. There has been no serious change in the situation in the past few weeks, so if a TB member did, indeed, think carefully before voting last time, he will vote the same way this time.
LuckyCoins' announcement of how he voted changes that situation. It is now obvious that if all the old TB members vote the way they did three weeks ago, the motion will pass.
By my contending that they should vote the same way (and I not only think they should but have enough respect for them to believe that they will) I am, in practical terms, arguing that this motion should be passed. As I oppose it, and have said so repeatedly when it was first suggested, that puts me in a very strange position.
Therefore, I will sum up as follows and then completely bow out of this discussion:
1. It is my own belief that this forum should not be established.
2. More important than that belief, however, is the point that TB members should not sway in the wind and should give careful consideration to all of their votes.
3. There has been no serious change in the situation in the past few weeks, so if a TB member did, indeed, think carefully before voting last time, he will vote the same way this time.
#18
Moderator: Coupon Connection & S.P.A.M
Original Poster
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Louisville, KY
Programs: Destination Unknown, TSA Disparager Diamond (LTDD)
Posts: 57,946
For a proposed forum whose proponents keep claiming there is "buzz" or "if you build it they will come", the decrease in the rate of VX traffic is certainly a good reason for people who voted "yes" to change to "no". The rapid return of this failed motion could also be a motivating factor to change one's vote from "yes" to "no".
Other TalkBoard members may feel differently.
Last edited by Spiff; Dec 29, 2007 at 3:12 pm
#19
Suspended
Join Date: May 1998
Location: Seattle
Programs: Ephesians 4:31-32
Posts: 10,690
How can we logiclly conclude that there has been a decrease in traffic on a forum that doesn't exist?
The best that we can say is that we have checked a few random places where we assume that folks interested in VX might guess to post and there seems to be a decrease in traffic in those spots during the holiday season. We have no idea if there have been hundreds of folks who looked for a VX fora, couldn't find one and just didn't post.
Either way, I think it is a good idea and will vote for it.
The best that we can say is that we have checked a few random places where we assume that folks interested in VX might guess to post and there seems to be a decrease in traffic in those spots during the holiday season. We have no idea if there have been hundreds of folks who looked for a VX fora, couldn't find one and just didn't post.
Either way, I think it is a good idea and will vote for it.
Last edited by Punki; Dec 29, 2007 at 5:52 pm
#20
Moderator: Coupon Connection & S.P.A.M
Original Poster
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Louisville, KY
Programs: Destination Unknown, TSA Disparager Diamond (LTDD)
Posts: 57,946
I'm willing to wager some pretty safe drink coupons on this not being the case, especially considering all the discussion that has been going on here about ONSAFFP being the current place for VX. A copious absence of any "Where do I post VX items?" threads anywhere also makes me believe my drink coupon wager is a pretty safe one.
#21
Original Member, Ambassador: External Miles and Points Resources
Join Date: May 1998
Location: Digital Nomad Wandering the Earth - Currently in PALMYRA, PA, USA
Posts: 58,512
By measuring the traffic on such topics in the forum where people have been told such threads belong: ONSAFFP. Sounds pretty logical to me. Other TalkBoard members may feel differently.
I'm willing to wager some pretty safe drink coupons on this not being the case, especially considering all the discussion that has been going on here about ONSAFFP being the current place for VX. A copious absence of any "Where do I post VX items?" threads anywhere also makes me believe my drink coupon wager is a pretty safe one.
I'm willing to wager some pretty safe drink coupons on this not being the case, especially considering all the discussion that has been going on here about ONSAFFP being the current place for VX. A copious absence of any "Where do I post VX items?" threads anywhere also makes me believe my drink coupon wager is a pretty safe one.
If I were a casual poster and I had a question about VX but I didnt see it in the drop-down list I might very easily conclude that FT is not the place for me.
Further I dont support this forum based on 'buzz' or thread or view counts. I support it because there is a cadre of VX flyers and folks with an interest in VX who are also passionate flyertalkers and want to have the forum. That's precisely how flyertalk itself started, with a small cadre of passionate flyers who were also passionate flyertalk posters. I believe that, just like FT itself, with that passionate cadre and so much to talk about, VX has what it take to make it as a forum here. Maybe I'm wrong. But if so, what have we lost? Nothing.
#22
Moderator: Coupon Connection & S.P.A.M
Original Poster
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Louisville, KY
Programs: Destination Unknown, TSA Disparager Diamond (LTDD)
Posts: 57,946
Other TB members feel differently.
If I were a casual poster and I had a question about VX but I didnt see it in the drop-down list I might very easily conclude that FT is not the place for me.
Further I dont support this forum based on 'buzz' or thread or view counts. I support it because there is a cadre of VX flyers and folks with an interest in VX who are also passionate flyertalkers and want to have the forum. That's precisely how flyertalk itself started, with a small cadre of passionate flyers who were also passionate flyertalk posters. I believe that, just like FT itself, with that passionate cadre and so much to talk about, VX has what it take to make it as a forum here. Maybe I'm wrong. But if so, what have we lost? Nothing.
If I were a casual poster and I had a question about VX but I didnt see it in the drop-down list I might very easily conclude that FT is not the place for me.
Further I dont support this forum based on 'buzz' or thread or view counts. I support it because there is a cadre of VX flyers and folks with an interest in VX who are also passionate flyertalkers and want to have the forum. That's precisely how flyertalk itself started, with a small cadre of passionate flyers who were also passionate flyertalk posters. I believe that, just like FT itself, with that passionate cadre and so much to talk about, VX has what it take to make it as a forum here. Maybe I'm wrong. But if so, what have we lost? Nothing.
Further fragmentation of FlyerTalk does not necessarily make it easier to find information. Rather than having a separate forum for every program that hints that a FF program is coming (or has even established one, though it may not be very good), a "miscellaneous" forum makes sense until such a program has demonstrated a demand.
While I appreciate the people who have weighed in on supporting a VX forum, the demand just isn't there yet. Obviously, other TalkBoard members may feel differently.
#23
Original Member, Ambassador: External Miles and Points Resources
Join Date: May 1998
Location: Digital Nomad Wandering the Earth - Currently in PALMYRA, PA, USA
Posts: 58,512
Well darn it, where is my forum for Bob's Pretty Good Cropduster? How about a forum for The Goodyear Blimp and Other Dirigibles?
Further fragmentation of FlyerTalk does not necessarily make it easier to find information. Rather than having a separate forum for every program that hints that a FF program is coming (or has even established one, though it may not be very good), a "miscellaneous" forum makes sense until such a program has demonstrated a demand.
While I appreciate the people who have weighed in on supporting a VX forum, the demand just isn't there yet. Obviously, other TalkBoard members may feel differently.
Further fragmentation of FlyerTalk does not necessarily make it easier to find information. Rather than having a separate forum for every program that hints that a FF program is coming (or has even established one, though it may not be very good), a "miscellaneous" forum makes sense until such a program has demonstrated a demand.
While I appreciate the people who have weighed in on supporting a VX forum, the demand just isn't there yet. Obviously, other TalkBoard members may feel differently.
The airline itself will either grow or die. Either way the forum will serve a useful purpose (either as a vibrant forum or as a fascinating archive of a failed airline/frequent flyer program).
Grrrrrrr...if we were allowed to open the TB debate forum on a read only basis I wouldnt have to make these same points in two different places! @:-)
#24
Moderator: Coupon Connection & S.P.A.M
Original Poster
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Louisville, KY
Programs: Destination Unknown, TSA Disparager Diamond (LTDD)
Posts: 57,946
No point in getting worked up over that which we currently cannot change. @:-)
#25
Suspended
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: The Pointy End
Posts: 3,565
If a person were to do this for the reason you've listed, it would indicate that the interest and wishes of the members who elected them is not what is being considered when they make their vote.
#26
Moderator: Coupon Connection & S.P.A.M
Original Poster
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Louisville, KY
Programs: Destination Unknown, TSA Disparager Diamond (LTDD)
Posts: 57,946
Or perhaps in the greater sense of an advisory board, some people, both board members and their supporters, might object to failed proposals being revisited so quickly, whether they are proponents of the proposal or not. @:-) Other TalkBoard members may feel differently.
#27
Moderator Hilton Honors, Travel News, West, The Suggestion Box, Smoking Lounge & DiningBuzz
Join Date: Jun 2000
Programs: Honors Diamond, Hertz Presidents Circle, National Exec Elite
Posts: 35,993
I didn't vote for those whom I did because I expect them to "represent" my views, I voted for them because I had learned to trust their judgment and therefore expected them to continue using that independent judgment to make FlyerTalk a better place through the implementation of good ideas and the blocking of silly ones.
And, after all, it isn't your interest or mine that matters, it's what's in the best interest of FlyerTalk. I would hope that those for whom I voted would have that as their goal and motivation, not simply trying in some way to ascertain my point of view and then vote "my" way. That would be more like pandering than anything else, imo.
Last edited by cblaisd; Dec 29, 2007 at 5:19 pm Reason: Typo
#28
Moderator: Southwest Airlines, Capital One
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: California
Programs: WN Companion Pass, A-list preferred, Hyatt Globalist; United Club Lietime (sic) Member
Posts: 21,585
This motion puts TB members who favor the new forum in the difficult position of choosing between the new forum and respect for the prior Talk Board. IMHO, respect for the prior TalkBoard is more important for FT than is the VX forum. For this reason, had I been elected I would have chosen to support the integrity of TalkBoard decisions by voting against the VX proposal at this time.
#29
Suspended
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: The Pointy End
Posts: 3,565
{Discussion of moderation removed per FT rules}
Last edited by Moderator2; Dec 29, 2007 at 11:29 pm
#30
Moderator Hilton Honors, Travel News, West, The Suggestion Box, Smoking Lounge & DiningBuzz
Join Date: Jun 2000
Programs: Honors Diamond, Hertz Presidents Circle, National Exec Elite
Posts: 35,993
That's a much better explanation of the kinds of things I had in mind with my stare decisis analogy than I offered. Thank you.
I was and am in favor of a VX forum, but I am saddened that the new TB members did not have enough respect for the prior TB to let more time pass before making this motion. This is not what I call getting off on the right foot. Not to put a fine point on it, it's antisocial. Public forums have to deal with a wide variety of antisocial behavior, but the Talk Board should be better.
This motion puts TB members who favor the new forum in the difficult position of choosing between the new forum and respect for the prior Talk Board. IMHO, respect for the prior TalkBoard is more important for FT than is the VX forum. For this reason, had I been elected I would have chosen to support the integrity of TalkBoard decisions by voting against the VX proposal at this time.
This motion puts TB members who favor the new forum in the difficult position of choosing between the new forum and respect for the prior Talk Board. IMHO, respect for the prior TalkBoard is more important for FT than is the VX forum. For this reason, had I been elected I would have chosen to support the integrity of TalkBoard decisions by voting against the VX proposal at this time.