FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   oneworld (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/oneworld-411/)
-   -   Oneworld booking and pricing experiences (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/oneworld/1776577-oneworld-booking-pricing-experiences.html)

kayzng Jun 20, 2024 5:20 am


Originally Posted by pandaperth (Post 36317412)
That's all nonsense by the QF team.

Assuming your itinerary conforms to all the other rules:
  • There is no restriction on multiple stopovers at the same place
  • There is no requirement to end in CAI (can be anywhere in the Middle East)
  • You have already flown the first segment, therefore the base fare in effect when you purchased the ticket is now fixed, and you are not adding, or subtracting, continents, so there is no re-price for that. Therefore the AUD4.9k charge is unwarranted
  • The cancellation refund of AUD3.9 is believable! Adding the 'D' class 1-way fares of the flights already flown would likely eat up what you paid for the whole ticket.
So what to do? My suggestions:
  • Ask for a full, written, breakdown of the components of the $4.9K charge
  • Armed with that, argue you case for it being unwarranted
  • If getting nowhere, even after speaking to a supervisor, then ask for the supervisor's details - say it's for when you make your complaint to the ACCC (Australian Competition and Consumer Commission) - this will demonstrate that you know at least a little about your rights and may cause them to look more closely at your situation.

Good luck, and please let us know how it works out (I am interested, because I start my ex-CAI DONE5 next Tuesday and might want to re-route some segments at the end on my itinerary)

I definitely going to escalate this, thanks for sharing on ACCC, I will cc Airline Customer Advocate (ACA) in Australia too. Probably next week after my travel.
I somehow has a feeling that I am being "blacklisted" or "marked". I made a call this morning for a flight change, from morning to evening flight. The agent after checking system, first response was, oh, seems like you made changes before, now you can no longer make any more changes.
I push back. Then only she proceed to check availability, and informed no seats available.

dvs7310 Jun 20, 2024 5:33 am


Originally Posted by Dr. HFH (Post 36317407)
For comparison I just ticketed my next DONE3 ex-NRT through the AA RTW desk. Base fare $4,180 (they told me that that's the JPY fare converted to USD -- the dollar has been particularly strong over the past few weeks). "Taxes and fees" -- $358.90 "Carrier-imposed fees" -- $363.80 TOTAL: $4,902.70

That's quite strong, not much more than the ex-CAIs most people were booking post-devaluation. I think my DONE5 ex-CAI was $4700-ish. I don't think I'm going to buy another one this year myself since I'll already be over 250k AA LPs with my ex-CAI once it's finished. Might get tempted if there's another strong swing somewhere though and just book for next spring / summer, my primary reluctance in booking too far out is that I will have to use QF and they only allow changes to a year from ticketing vs. the correct 1 year from first departure. Will probably speak to one of the travel agents who have come out on the board for next time since I can't use AA (too much hit to LPs)


Originally Posted by zoombee (Post 36317442)
I'm similarly keen to know what changes are possible after the first segment is flown without a reprice of the base fare.
​​​​
I booked with AA and more than one agent said that if a change involves a $125 fee then the base fare would be reviewed as well as taxes and surcharges. I'm hoping in the end that's not how it will work and am keen to hear of recent experiences (especially for anyone dealing with AA)

I wouldn't be worried about AA, they'll follow the correct rules and manually price them anyway. QF tries to autoprice which doesn't seem to work most of the time, if ever.

danger Jun 20, 2024 5:41 am


Originally Posted by kayzng (Post 36317323)
Sharing updates on my attempts to add stops with ex-CAI DONE3 issued by QF.
Background
Initial ticket price was around AUD3980 ticket + AUD1290 for YQ/YR
Initial segment was 13 air segments, and 2 surface segment, open jaw at DOH
4 segment flown (3 inter Europe, 1 from Europe to Asia)

I tried to change my balance itinerary by removing 2 surface (replace with inter US) and add final segment to DOH-DXB

Was told by QF team that for ex-CAI ticket, they cant calculate the change cost, unless,
1. Remove cities that stop multiple times (I have 2x KUL and 2x DFW)
2. End it with DOH-CAI

...

I, too, was told by Qantas I had to end in CAI on a planned itinerary that began in CAI. It's obviously wrong, but Qantas didn't seem to care.


Originally Posted by pandaperth (Post 36317412)
...
  • If getting nowhere, even after speaking to a supervisor, then ask for the supervisor's details - say it's for when you make your complaint to the ACCC (Australian Competition and Consumer Commission) - this will demonstrate that you know at least a little about your rights and may cause them to look more closely at your situation.

The ACCC largely wouldn't care less. As an organisation, it only seems to act when there's a multitude of complaints along the same lines. And it won't mediate or act on an individual's behalf.


Originally Posted by kayzng (Post 36317689)
I definitely going to escalate this, thanks for sharing on ACCC, I will cc Airline Customer Advocate (ACA) in Australia too. Probably next week after my travel.
I somehow has a feeling that I am being "blacklisted" or "marked". I made a call this morning for a flight change, from morning to evening flight. The agent after checking system, first response was, oh, seems like you made changes before, now you can no longer make any more changes.
I push back. Then only she proceed to check availability, and informed no seats available.

I wouldn't waste my time with the ACCC and the ACA seems to only be marginally better. Reports on Australian Frequent Flyer suggest taking legal action through an appropriate tribunal in Australia (such as the New South Wales Civil and Administration Tribunal) is more likely to get traction. It's not an easy process, though and not without costs. I assume you're not based in Australia and that makes it more tricky. If you reside in a country where Qantas has a registered office, you may explore legal avenues there.

Perhaps a better option still is to lodge a complaint with the US Department of Transportation. It's my understanding that airlines are required to respond to consumers in a certain timeframe following lodgement of a complaint.

kayzng Jun 20, 2024 6:05 am


Originally Posted by danger (Post 36317722)
I, too, was told by Qantas I had to end in CAI on a planned itinerary that began in CAI. It's obviously wrong, but Qantas didn't seem to care.



The ACCC largely wouldn't care less. As an organisation, it only seems to act when there's a multitude of complaints along the same lines. And it won't mediate or act on an individual's behalf.



I wouldn't waste my time with the ACCC and the ACA seems to only be marginally better. Reports on Australian Frequent Flyer suggest taking legal action through an appropriate tribunal in Australia (such as the New South Wales Civil and Administration Tribunal) is more likely to get traction. It's not an easy process, though and not without costs. I assume you're not based in Australia and that makes it more tricky. If you reside in a country where Qantas has a registered office, you may explore legal avenues there.

Perhaps a better option still is to lodge a complaint with the US Department of Transportation. It's my understanding that airlines are required to respond to consumers in a certain timeframe following lodgement of a complaint.

Thanks for sharing on AFF (I had a peek, cant find much on RTW thread, will check out in details later).
Will definitely at US DOT in cc

ironmanjt Jun 20, 2024 8:27 am

LOL so making a quick 16 hr date change to one segment having already flown five of an Explorer ticket.

"I just need to let you know these tickets from Cairo were all underpriced by over $10,000 and there will be a substantial charge if you change anything. I see you've already snuck it by several agents so I'll be documenting the record so you can't do that again."

Funniest part? I got the Australia call center and she was even more aggressive and incorrect than Fiji. Will be interesting to see what happens after she gets back from "consulting a supervisor."

edited: for typo

Dr. HFH Jun 20, 2024 9:05 am


Originally Posted by dvs7310 (Post 36317710)
I don't think I'm going to buy another one this year myself since I'll already be over 250k AA LPs with my ex-CAI once it's finished.

I credit to QRPC, where you can keep accumulating QPoints after you hit QRPC PLT (OneWorld EMD), and earn PLT for two years instead of one. Plus, I fly between Thailand and the U.S. typically three roundtrips per year, and a DONE3 is usually less expensive than a straight roundtrip.



Originally Posted by dvs7310 (Post 36317710)
I wouldn't be worried about AA, they'll follow the correct rules and manually price them anyway.

Agreed. Their superior knowledge, willingness to follow the rules, accept being corrected if they're wrong about a rule and being consistently friendly are the major reasons I've always used the AA RTW desk since South Africa stopped being the bargain that it used to be and we were all using Mindpearl in JNB.

LilZeppelin Jun 20, 2024 10:27 am


Originally Posted by Dr. HFH (Post 36317407)
For comparison I just ticketed my next DONE3 ex-NRT through the AA RTW desk. Base fare $4,180 (they told me that that's the JPY fare converted to USD -- the dollar has been particularly strong over the past few weeks). "Taxes and fees" -- $358.90 "Carrier-imposed fees" -- $363.80 TOTAL: $4,902.70

Yes, the two ex-CAI I have are 1500$ and 1200$ cheaper than this. Worthwhile premium to avoid dealing with QF or BA for sure!

dvs7310 Jun 20, 2024 12:28 pm


Originally Posted by ironmanjt (Post 36318076)
LOL so making a quick 16 hr date change to one segment having already flown five of an Explorer ticket.

"I just need to let you know these tickets from Cairo were all underpriced by over $10,000 and there will be a substantial charge if you change anything. I see you've already snuck it by several agents so I'll be documenting the record so you can't do that again."

Funniest part? I got the Australia call center and she was even more aggressive and incorrect than Fiji. Will be interesting to see what happens after she gets back from "consulting a supervisor."

edited: for typo

LOL, underpriced by what standard? Even post-EGP deval they weren't that much cheaper than ex-Japan and Norway. Certainly not by AUD10k, that's nonsense. I think they just got overwhelmed by ex-CAI bookings this spring because for whatever reason they became the ticketing carrier for most itineraries booked in the OW tool. Who knows if that was by design of by accident, but reports this year of even itineraires that should have been ticketed by BA getting sent to QF for ticketing via the OW tool, that's not a good thing for us, and seems they don't want to be dealing with them either. I really want a warning flag in the OW tool to say who the ticketing carrier is about to be on the payment page. Then you can make your own choice if you really want it or not.


Originally Posted by Dr. HFH (Post 36318172)
I credit to QRPC, where you can keep accumulating QPoints after you hit QRPC PLT (OneWorld EMD), and earn PLT for two years instead of one. Plus, I fly between Thailand and the U.S. typically three roundtrips per year, and a DONE3 is usually less expensive than a straight roundtrip.

Similarly I could make QRPC Platinum very easily with my travel patterns, but have a slight favor to AA status for the once or twice a year TPAC I take with my partner when we just buy the cheapest ticket and use SWUs for upgrades (they have always cleared even if just a few days before). That plus Avios long haul redemption cost is brutal in comparison to AAdvantage, and an EXP would likely earn 2-3x total miles per year vs QRPC Plat due to partner multipliers AA elites have that other OW programs don't offer, assuming the AA EXP is avoiding most AA, BA, and IB coded flights. It's not one size fits all, I know, but works extremely well for me in today's environment. I definitely though would appreciate the QRPC Plat Al Safwa access on paid J tickets on QR as I have a lot of those, but the new Al Mourjan Garden works well enough, much better than the original 'south' one.

ironmanjt Jun 20, 2024 1:43 pm


Originally Posted by dvs7310 (Post 36318702)
LOL, underpriced by what standard? Even post-EGP deval they weren't that much cheaper than ex-Japan and Norway. Certainly not by AUD10k, that's nonsense. I think they just got overwhelmed by ex-CAI bookings

In fairness, after the warning/scolding she went away to work on it, made the change and advised "only the $125 change fee" and I'll take a credit card when ready.

I asked her nicely to pull up the rules, directed to her about the date changes part...and she not only admitted she was wrong, but thanked me for explaining it to her. Quite refreshing in customer service these days to see someone willing to learn and admit their mistakes instead of digging in. My sense was she's seen so many of these with people arguing about massive price increases when making changes before departure that she wasn't willing to invest the time making changes if I wasn't warned ahead....

Dr. HFH Jun 20, 2024 7:44 pm


Originally Posted by dvs7310 (Post 36318702)
I definitely though would appreciate the QRPC Plat Al Safwa access on paid J tickets on QR as I have a lot of those, but the new Al Mourjan Garden works well enough, much better than the original 'south' one.

The food and champagne have gone downhill a bit at Al Safwa, but I still like it for the sleeping rooms. I've had incredible success getting one when I wanted/needed it. Only been denied once. I must say, I also enjoy the small exhibits of pieces from the collection of the Museum of Islamic Art.

kayzng Jun 20, 2024 8:09 pm


Originally Posted by ironmanjt (Post 36318866)
In fairness, after the warning/scolding she went away to work on it, made the change and advised "only the $125 change fee" and I'll take a credit card when ready.

I asked her nicely to pull up the rules, directed to her about the date changes part...and she not only admitted she was wrong, but thanked me for explaining it to her. Quite refreshing in customer service these days to see someone willing to learn and admit their mistakes instead of digging in. My sense was she's seen so many of these with people arguing about massive price increases when making changes before departure that she wasn't willing to invest the time making changes if I wasn't warned ahead....

Hi, what are the changes you made? Isn't date change suppose to be free?

ironmanjt Jun 20, 2024 8:11 pm


Originally Posted by kayzng (Post 36319462)
Hi, what are the changes you made? Isn't date change suppose to be free?

Maybe my post was unclear. It was a date change. She was wrong in thinking she should charge a fee. When I guided her through the rules she figured that out.

edited to clarify: free AFTER the first segment is flown. Before that any change is a refare.

wandering_fred Jun 20, 2024 10:24 pm

A DONE3 planning question. Note the earlier reference by DR.HFH was for a DONE3.....ex Japan
Also my plan...
Madrid to Singapore in October....
Choices:
MAD-LHR to QF 2
MAD-DOH-SIN on QR.
What is the likely difference in "additional charges" resulting from selecting QF from LHR(connection so no UK departure tax)
I would credit to QF so a substantial difference in points awarded.

Note: for a DONE4 LHR to PER QF has zero mid week D class available either direct or via SIN
Once again think about wandering
Fred

Dr. HFH Jun 20, 2024 10:47 pm


Originally Posted by wandering_fred (Post 36319651)
A DONE3 planning question. Note the earlier reference by DR.HFH was for a DONE3.....ex Japan
Also my plan...
Madrid to Singapore in October....
Choices:
MAD-LHR to QF 2
MAD-DOH-SIN on QR.
What is the likely difference in "additional charges" resulting from selecting QF from LHR(connection so no UK departure tax)
I would credit to QF so a substantial difference in points awarded.

Note: for a DONE4 LHR to PER QF has zero mid week D class available either direct or via SIN
Once again think about wandering
Fred

Hi, Fred,

You can get a breakdown of the fees and other charges using ITA Matrix. Even though it's now owned by Google, it still gives a complete breakdown of these other charges.

Cynicor Jun 20, 2024 10:54 pm

I didn’t think ITA gave good info for fees and charges when a fare is part of a xONE, though?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 7:54 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.