[Report Published] BA2276 LAS-LGW B772 G-VIIO aircraft fire Las Vegas airport
#1186
Join Date: Feb 2011
Posts: 5,797
FWIW -
Just a suggestion...
Multi-select outside view cameras - pop-up screens on left and right sides of cockpit. Think the size of iPad Retina.
Screen on back side of cockpit door - shows who wants to come in and a view of the cabin. Again, think iPad Retina size for screen quality and size/depth.
Just ideas to give the pilots more information, if they want it.
(On a side note, when I was ATC, we were trained to never tell a pilot something definitively about their bird... so one day when I saw flames clearly shooting out of a smoking engine, I had to tell a jumbo pilot that it "appeared his left engine was on fire". He landed safely. )
Just a suggestion...
Multi-select outside view cameras - pop-up screens on left and right sides of cockpit. Think the size of iPad Retina.
Screen on back side of cockpit door - shows who wants to come in and a view of the cabin. Again, think iPad Retina size for screen quality and size/depth.
Just ideas to give the pilots more information, if they want it.
(On a side note, when I was ATC, we were trained to never tell a pilot something definitively about their bird... so one day when I saw flames clearly shooting out of a smoking engine, I had to tell a jumbo pilot that it "appeared his left engine was on fire". He landed safely. )
#1187
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Sussex by the Sea
Programs: BA Silver, for now at least...
Posts: 581
Whether my logic is sound or not, I will NOT book a BA flight if there is a chance of getting this aircraft post-repair - I would just not feel comfortable given the level of damage to the fuselage and wing.
I am not a nervous flyer - I just feel that Boeing are going into the unknown here.
I am sure I am not alone either.
I am not a nervous flyer - I just feel that Boeing are going into the unknown here.
I am sure I am not alone either.
#1188
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: London
Programs: Mucci. Nothing else matters.
Posts: 38,644
And by your logic, presumably you'd refuse to fly any Ethiopian Airlines flight operated by a 787, because it might be operated by the aircraft that had to have its tail chopped off and then stuck back on again as part of the completely unprecedented Boeing repair job?
#1189
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Swindon UK
Programs: BAEC, FB, QANTAS, IHG, Hilton, Marriott, AVIS Preferred, MRAeS
Posts: 813
Whether my logic is sound or not, I will NOT book a BA flight if there is a chance of getting this aircraft post-repair - I would just not feel comfortable given the level of damage to the fuselage and wing.
I am not a nervous flyer - I just feel that Boeing are going into the unknown here.
I am sure I am not alone either.
I am not a nervous flyer - I just feel that Boeing are going into the unknown here.
I am sure I am not alone either.
#1190
Join Date: Dec 2012
Posts: 3,234
FWIW -
Just a suggestion...
Multi-select outside view cameras - pop-up screens on left and right sides of cockpit. Think the size of iPad Retina.
Screen on back side of cockpit door - shows who wants to come in and a view of the cabin. Again, think iPad Retina size for screen quality and size/depth.
Just ideas to give the pilots more information, if they want it.
(On a side note, when I was ATC, we were trained to never tell a pilot something definitively about their bird... so one day when I saw flames clearly shooting out of a smoking engine, I had to tell a jumbo pilot that it "appeared his left engine was on fire". He landed safely. )
Just a suggestion...
Multi-select outside view cameras - pop-up screens on left and right sides of cockpit. Think the size of iPad Retina.
Screen on back side of cockpit door - shows who wants to come in and a view of the cabin. Again, think iPad Retina size for screen quality and size/depth.
Just ideas to give the pilots more information, if they want it.
(On a side note, when I was ATC, we were trained to never tell a pilot something definitively about their bird... so one day when I saw flames clearly shooting out of a smoking engine, I had to tell a jumbo pilot that it "appeared his left engine was on fire". He landed safely. )
But have you seen how much fuselage patching / repairing goes on as a matter of routine? You just don't know about it normally.
And by your logic, presumably you'd refuse to fly any Ethiopian Airlines flight operated by a 787, because it might be operated by the aircraft that had to have its tail chopped off and then stuck back on again as part of the completely unprecedented Boeing repair job?
And by your logic, presumably you'd refuse to fly any Ethiopian Airlines flight operated by a 787, because it might be operated by the aircraft that had to have its tail chopped off and then stuck back on again as part of the completely unprecedented Boeing repair job?
#1191
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Swindon UK
Programs: BAEC, FB, QANTAS, IHG, Hilton, Marriott, AVIS Preferred, MRAeS
Posts: 813
I would hazard that a significant proportion of aircraft worldwide would be unsuitable for Professor Yaffle to travel on. Thus inducing your own IRROPS on your travel plans. As Globailiser points out, 'ramp rash' is a fact of aviation, and other environmental damage also gets repaired meaning there are a lot of aircraft out there with patch repairs et al. The effect is most notable on brand new aircraft. New metal seems to have a strong magnetic influence on other near by metallic objects and vehicles. It is as if they attract damage.
#1192
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Nottingham, England
Programs: BA Silver
Posts: 968
Re: repairs to aircraft. I have a friend that works for a subcontractor of RR in Derby. He repairs engine turbine fan blades.
When they get chipped or indeed broken they don't just fit new ones, they splice a new piece onto the existing blade.
He does them in a vacume environment and each one gets x-rayed after repair and the serial number recorded. He says he has worked on several blades numberious times.
When they get chipped or indeed broken they don't just fit new ones, they splice a new piece onto the existing blade.
He does them in a vacume environment and each one gets x-rayed after repair and the serial number recorded. He says he has worked on several blades numberious times.
#1193
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: London, England.
Programs: BA
Posts: 8,482
Whether my logic is sound or not, I will NOT book a BA flight if there is a chance of getting this aircraft post-repair - I would just not feel comfortable given the level of damage to the fuselage and wing.
I am not a nervous flyer - I just feel that Boeing are going into the unknown here.
I am sure I am not alone either.
I am not a nervous flyer - I just feel that Boeing are going into the unknown here.
I am sure I am not alone either.
#1194
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 2,071
I would hazard that a significant proportion of aircraft worldwide would be unsuitable for Professor Yaffle to travel on. Thus inducing your own IRROPS on your travel plans. As Globailiser points out, 'ramp rash' is a fact of aviation, and other environmental damage also gets repaired meaning there are a lot of aircraft out there with patch repairs et al. The effect is most notable on brand new aircraft. New metal seems to have a strong magnetic influence on other near by metallic objects and vehicles. It is as if they attract damage.
#1195
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: London, England.
Programs: BA
Posts: 8,482
One BEA Trident G-ARPI was in the hangar when a Comet 4B outside on an engine test suddenly overrode its chocks and crashed forward into the hangar doors, bringing them down on the tail of the aircraft. It was repaired. Shortly afterwards it was parked at Heathrow when an out-of-control landing aircraft crashed into it, completely severing the tail. It was repaired again. It had a further subsequent accident and there was a check that the repairs were nothing to do with it, but they had been fine and the third issue was a piloting one.
#1196
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Glasgow
Programs: BA Executive Club
Posts: 448
One BEA Trident G-ARPI was in the hangar when a Comet 4B outside on an engine test suddenly overrode its chocks and crashed forward into the hangar doors, bringing them down on the tail of the aircraft. It was repaired. Shortly afterwards it was parked at Heathrow when an out-of-control landing aircraft crashed into it, completely severing the tail. It was repaired again. It had a further subsequent accident and there was a check that the repairs were nothing to do with it, but they had been fine and the third issue was a piloting one.
#1197
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Global
Posts: 6,008
Most (all?) newer aircraft already have cameras integrated to the cockpit displays to aid ground movements, including the 77W. You may not be able to zoom in on a postage stamp but you could certainly see if something was on fire or no longer there. Perhaps after BA2276 this is something Boeing will work on for the 777X.
A nice idea for future aircraft designs but a retro fit to existing airframes would present enormous costs for only a very small chance that cost will be in anyway useful. Design, installation and certifications costs are just the start of it. Submitting type design changes to the relevant aircraft certification bodies is a whole other cost all together. The costs to some airlines for retrofitting iPad type EFBs with aircraft powered charging capability has been staggering, but this technology is used on every flight, thus justifiable. ...
#1198
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Swindon UK
Programs: BAEC, FB, QANTAS, IHG, Hilton, Marriott, AVIS Preferred, MRAeS
Posts: 813
An Airworthiness Directive, relating to the engine, has now been issued. AD Number- US-2015-27-01 Effective 27 Jan 16.
http://ad.easa.europa.eu/ad/US-2015-27-01
http://ad.easa.europa.eu/ad/US-2015-27-01
Last edited by vibrex; Jan 14, 2016 at 1:59 pm Reason: Insert Web Page
#1199
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2013
Location: London
Posts: 17,007
An Airworthiness Directive, relating to the engine, has now been issued. AD Number- US-2015-27-01 Effective 27 Jan 16.
http://ad.easa.europa.eu/ad/US-2015-27-01
http://ad.easa.europa.eu/ad/US-2015-27-01
#1200
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: City of Kingston Upon Hull
Programs: BAEC Gold
Posts: 4,940
The AD states:
Costs of Compliance
We estimate that this AD affects 1 engine installed on an airplane of U.S. registry.
I find this hard to believe (though I have to accept it at face value) unless I have misunderstood what this means.
Costs of Compliance
We estimate that this AD affects 1 engine installed on an airplane of U.S. registry.
I find this hard to believe (though I have to accept it at face value) unless I have misunderstood what this means.