Best noise cancelling headphones for flying?
#273
Join Date: Aug 2004
Programs: AA (EP), Hilton (Diamond), Marriott Bonvoy (Titanium)
Posts: 8,946
I mean the two-prong to one-prong adapter that allows one to plug a one-prong headphone into a two-prong (or three-prong, where one prong is power) IFE system. Many of the nicer airplane IFE systems, including QR's Qsuite products, have two-prong (or three-prong, but only two carry sound) outlets. The airline supplies headsets that fit, but the noise cancellation is usually subpar.
Every prior Bose headset I've purchased (and there have been many over the years) has come with an airplane adapter. The NC700 is the only one that didn't, which makes me wonder if they are not intended to work with one.
Many airline IFE systems use two prongs for sound. I can plug my NC700 into either hole and get audio with noise cancellation on or off, but only one channel obviously. When I use the two-prong to one-prong adapter, I get both channels, but only when noise cancellation is off. When I turn oise cancellation on, the audio cuts out.
Sure, I assume they would work fine if connected to an IFE that uses only one prong. There's no need for an adapter then.
Every prior Bose headset I've purchased (and there have been many over the years) has come with an airplane adapter. The NC700 is the only one that didn't, which makes me wonder if they are not intended to work with one.
Sure, I assume they would work fine if connected to an IFE that uses only one prong. There's no need for an adapter then.
#274
Join Date: Jan 2015
Posts: 3,014
I mean the two-prong to one-prong adapter that allows one to plug a one-prong headphone into a two-prong (or three-prong, where one prong is power) IFE system. Many of the nicer airplane IFE systems, including QR's Qsuite products, have two-prong (or three-prong, but only two carry sound) outlets. The airline supplies headsets that fit, but the noise cancellation is usually subpar.
Every prior Bose headset I've purchased (and there have been many over the years) has come with an airplane adapter. The NC700 is the only one that didn't, which makes me wonder if they are not intended to work with one.
Many airline IFE systems use two prongs for sound. I can plug my NC700 into either hole and get audio with noise cancellation on or off, but only one channel obviously. When I use the two-prong to one-prong adapter, I get both channels, but only when noise cancellation is off. When I turn oise cancellation on, the audio cuts out.
Every prior Bose headset I've purchased (and there have been many over the years) has come with an airplane adapter. The NC700 is the only one that didn't, which makes me wonder if they are not intended to work with one.
Many airline IFE systems use two prongs for sound. I can plug my NC700 into either hole and get audio with noise cancellation on or off, but only one channel obviously. When I use the two-prong to one-prong adapter, I get both channels, but only when noise cancellation is off. When I turn oise cancellation on, the audio cuts out.
If you're using wired, I'd just take one of your old adapters and plug into that. I suspect the NC700 doesn't because it assumes you're going to be using bluetooth.more than the wired connection.
As for the noise cancelling stopping the audio, you'd have to do some experimenting... I'd recommend trying with your own adapter... but something along the lines of:
without the adapter, noise cancelling on (make sure you're plugging into the right pin)
with the adapter, noise cancelling off
with the adapter, noise cancelling on
at least two seats to make sure it's consistent.
(note, I'm pretty sure you'd test at least one seat, but trying to cover all bases)
Keep in mind that the adapter should only fit two pins in the three pin plugs. I don't remember if all three pins are unique in size but I know the two-pin adapters are unique (it will only go one way).
#275
Join Date: Aug 2004
Programs: AA (EP), Hilton (Diamond), Marriott Bonvoy (Titanium)
Posts: 8,946
You can plug in the two prong adapter and (assuming you're using wired mode) it will work. The audio requires only one pin. The second pin is to supply power to those headsets that require power (eg, noise cancelling headsets which are not powered by battery... as most airline premium headsets are not). Technically you should be able to use just a single pin since you have a battery in the headset itself.
As for the noise cancelling stopping the audio, you'd have to do some experimenting... I'd recommend trying with your own adapter... but something along the lines of:
without the adapter, noise cancelling on (make sure you're plugging into the right pin)
with the adapter, noise cancelling off
with the adapter, noise cancelling on
at least two seats to make sure it's consistent.
(note, I'm pretty sure you'd test at least one seat, but trying to cover all bases)
without the adapter, noise cancelling on (make sure you're plugging into the right pin)
with the adapter, noise cancelling off
with the adapter, noise cancelling on
at least two seats to make sure it's consistent.
(note, I'm pretty sure you'd test at least one seat, but trying to cover all bases)
Yes, one jack (pin) is for power for the airline-supplied headsets. The other two jacks are for audio, one is the right channel and the other is the left. The two jacks are identical as they are standard; the airplane adapter can be inserted with either prong in either hole (i.e., rotated 180 degrees), although doing so swaps the channels in the headset (usually not discernible). I can plug the NC700 cable into either jack and hear mono audio with noise cancellation on or off. Using the airplane adapter allows the NC700 to hear both channels (stereo audio) but only when noise cancellation is off.
#276
Ambassador: Emirates Airlines
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Manchester, UK
Posts: 18,801
#277
Join Date: Aug 2004
Programs: AA (EP), Hilton (Diamond), Marriott Bonvoy (Titanium)
Posts: 8,946
#278
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Menlo Park, CA, USA
Programs: UA 1MM 0P, AA, DL, *wood, Lifetime FPC Plat., IHG, HHD
Posts: 6,925
Slightly off topic but related to “prongs”. I recently did my first flight in the United Polaris product. I was SHOCKED that there was no place for a typical single prong audio jack to be plugged in. It required the typical bose two prong adaptor which frankly. I have not flown with for nearly two decades. Of course even the large IFE had no Bluetooth option (which I could have used my APP with) and the airline of course had no two prong adaptors. It was pretty crazy, had to use the provided headphones which were NOT NC at all and the flight was from a sound perspective, exhausting.
#279
Join Date: Jan 2015
Posts: 3,014
Slightly off topic but related to “prongs”. I recently did my first flight in the United Polaris product. I was SHOCKED that there was no place for a typical single prong audio jack to be plugged in. It required the typical bose two prong adaptor which frankly. I have not flown with for nearly two decades. Of course even the large IFE had no Bluetooth option (which I could have used my APP with) and the airline of course had no two prong adaptors. It was pretty crazy, had to use the provided headphones which were NOT NC at all and the flight was from a sound perspective, exhausting.
#280
Join Date: Aug 2004
Programs: AA (EP), Hilton (Diamond), Marriott Bonvoy (Titanium)
Posts: 8,946
Slightly off topic but related to “prongs”. I recently did my first flight in the United Polaris product. I was SHOCKED that there was no place for a typical single prong audio jack to be plugged in. It required the typical bose two prong adaptor which frankly. I have not flown with for nearly two decades. Of course even the large IFE had no Bluetooth option (which I could have used my APP with) and the airline of course had no two prong adaptors. It was pretty crazy, had to use the provided headphones which were NOT NC at all and the flight was from a sound perspective, exhausting.
I really appreciate that those cases have a pocket for the airplane adapter, as well as a pocket for spare batteries and such. It's really annoying that the NC700s don't have any place to put an adapter. One can just put it in between the ear cups, but then it inevitably falls out when getting the headphones.
#281
Join Date: Jan 2015
Posts: 3,014
I really appreciate that those cases have a pocket for the airplane adapter, as well as a pocket for spare batteries and such. It's really annoying that the NC700s don't have any place to put an adapter. One can just put it in between the ear cups, but then it inevitably falls out when getting the headphones.
I would also be a bit weary about putting one of those adapters between the cups without being secured. There'd be a good chance that a sudden jerk and you could damage the headset. I don't know about you, but $400 headsets are kinda painful to replace (which is why I use a much cheaper headset for EDC stuff.
#282
Join Date: Aug 2004
Programs: AA (EP), Hilton (Diamond), Marriott Bonvoy (Titanium)
Posts: 8,946
Yeah, same here. I only bought the NC700s because I finally upgraded my six-year-old phone, and the new one has no headphone jack. But, what's EDC?
#283
Join Date: Jan 2015
Posts: 3,014
#284
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: SAN
Programs: Nothing, nowhere!
Posts: 23,819
Can you point me in the right direction for an adapter kit please?
ETA: ignore me. I found the 2.5mm to 3.5mm jack in the case!
Last edited by USA_flyer; Apr 21, 2022 at 5:37 am