FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Manufactured Spending (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/manufactured-spending-719/)
-   -   My Vanilla debit (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/manufactured-spending/1422892-my-vanilla-debit.html)

concordian Feb 22, 2013 10:00 am

Does anyone know what happens if we don't have balance and MVD tries to charge a dormancy fee? I requested a permanent card which did not come and used my temporary card funds completely. I want to avoid calling them for a permanent card.

liw5215 Feb 22, 2013 10:09 am


Originally Posted by rambo (Post 20295144)
I had bought a few money orders for $2K from the post office today and MVD charged $1.95 as a cash advance fee. I had used it as a debit card with PIN number. Is that a standard practice for MVD purchases in the post office? Is that why most of the FTers buy MO from Walmart?

Please let me know by PM or by responding to this thread.

Appreciate your help.

Edit: MVD charged me $1.95 and not $3.95

it must have treated USPS MO as the cash advance. I was charged $1.95 for the grocery purchase with cash back.

ORD-TGU Feb 23, 2013 9:39 am


Originally Posted by liw5215 (Post 20297395)
it must have treated USPS MO as the cash advance. I was charged $1.95 for the grocery purchase with cash back.

I have also been charged $1.95 for grocery purchase with cash back. I am not doing that again.

rambo Feb 23, 2013 9:44 am

Another data point:
Walmart - took MO for $1K, cash back for $60, charged 50cents fee by MVD
Grocery Store - Took 900$ MO, $100 CB, charged $1.95 by MVD
Post Office - Took $2K MO, no CB, charged $1.95 by MVD
So WM seems to be the cheapest use, however as another FT'er mentioned earlier( http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/manuf...ey-orders.html ), stay under the radar and take less than $3K MO in one go.

liw5215 Feb 23, 2013 9:51 am


Originally Posted by rambo (Post 20302865)
Another data point:
Walmart - took MO for $1K, cash back for $60, charged 50cents fee by MVD
Grocery Store - Took 900$ MO, $100 CB, charged $1.95 by MVD
Post Office - Took $2K MO, no CB, charged $1.95 by MVD
So WM seems to be the cheapest use, however as another FT'er mentioned earlier( http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/manuf...ey-orders.html ), stay under the radar and take less than $3K MO in one go.

WM MO confirmation: $9xx.xx MO at WM w/o CB went through, charged $0.5.

aegt123 Feb 23, 2013 11:39 am


Originally Posted by rambo (Post 20302865)
Another data point:
Walmart - took MO for $1K, cash back for $60, charged 50cents fee by MVD
Grocery Store - Took 900$ MO, $100 CB, charged $1.95 by MVD
Post Office - Took $2K MO, no CB, charged $1.95 by MVD
So WM seems to be the cheapest use, however as another FT'er mentioned earlier( http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/manuf...ey-orders.html ), stay under the radar and take less than $3K MO in one go.

the thread ( http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/manuf...ey-orders.html ) also mentions that it would be illegal to practice execution of transactions in a pattern calculated to avoid creation of certain reports. See 'Structuring'

member7777 Feb 23, 2013 11:45 am


Originally Posted by aegt123 (Post 20303461)
the thread ( http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/manuf...ey-orders.html ) also mentions that it would be illegal to practice execution of transactions in a pattern calculated to avoid creation of certain reports. See 'Structuring'

From those I know personally, not affiliated with FT, who have had problems with the IRS, they hate structuring possibly even more than evasion.
Those that think keeping <$10k in certain transactions by using $9k are in for a hurt

msp2anywhere Feb 23, 2013 4:12 pm

WM: A company with 'structure'...
 

Originally Posted by member7777 (Post 20303501)
Those that think keeping <$10k in certain transactions by using $9k are in for a hurt

Except for one key data point: the WM register will not process a transaction above $8999.99, so you couldn't 'color inside the lines' at $10,000.01 even if you wanted to; the structuring, it seems, is on the part of WM. :rolleyes:

kokonutz Feb 24, 2013 12:06 pm

Ethics of hiding VR cards?
 
When you find a stack of VR cards at your local CVS, do you grab a couple and then try to hide a few for next time?

My wife and I have found some cards 'hidden' between other gift cards when the VR card hanger is empty (and no, it didn't look like a one-off random thing...it has been a small stack stuck of them in the middle of some gas or movie gift cards).

Seems a little...unsporting. Especially since the cards are so hard to find in my neighborhood.

OTOH, we reaped the benefits of whoever was hiding them since we found cards we might not otherwise have.

Hm.

I guess that's what I get for living in an area where lots of other FlyerTalkers live, including mega-churners gleff and pizzaman!

freetravelguys Feb 24, 2013 12:12 pm


Originally Posted by kokonutz (Post 20308748)
When you find a stack of VR cards at your local CVS, do you grab a couple and then try to hide a few for next time?

My wife and I have found some cards 'hidden' between other gift cards when the VR card hanger is empty (and no, it didn't look like a one-off random thing...it has been a small stack stuck of them in the middle of some gas or movie gift cards).

Seems a little...unsporting. Especially since the cards are so hard to find in my neighborhood.

OTOH, we reaped the benefits of whoever was hiding them since we found cards we might not otherwise have.

Hm.

I guess that's what I get for living in an area where lots of other FlyerTalkers live, including mega-churners gleff and pizzaman!

It's selfish and very unethical in my book. No other way to describe it. "Get mine" attitude and who cares about anyone else. No different than cutting someone else in traffic or the people hoarding food at the Triumph. Yes, it goes on all the time, and it's not cool.

mizzou1 Feb 24, 2013 3:17 pm


Originally Posted by freetravelguys (Post 20308771)
It's selfish and very unethical in my book. No other way to describe it. "Get mine" attitude and who cares about anyone else. No different than cutting someone else in traffic or the people hoarding food at the Triumph. Yes, it goes on all the time, and it's not cool.

Let alone ethics (and disgust), it has even no benefit for those with "Get mine" attitude as the store will restock the item as soon as the inventory falls below the threshold.

Hiding the cards:
1) Interferes with an prevents the restocking process
2) The store would eventually find out about this kind of mess and will start disliking this product, making it willing to stop restocking it.
3) Other people will know there is a chance to find VRs behind other cards so will look for them and most likely will find them. Add this with #1 and you can see the "Get mine" attitude people is leaving the store empty-handed.
4) "Get mine" attitude people may start to find even obscurer places to hide VRs. Then others will look every single niche of the store to find VRs (possible behind those toilet papers!).

This is just something that people should stop doing! I can't see how one may not understand such a simple phenomenon!

AnitaBryant63 Feb 24, 2013 4:01 pm

I don't understand why you'd need to hide them in the first place. There's tons of CVS stores and they restock when inventory is low. Is that incorrect?

cruisr Feb 24, 2013 4:12 pm


Originally Posted by mizzou1 (Post 20309666)
Let alone ethics (and disgust), it has even no benefit for those with "Get mine" attitude as the store will restock the item as soon as the inventory falls below the threshold.

Hiding the cards:
1) Interferes with an prevents the restocking process
2) The store would eventually find out about this kind of mess and will start disliking this product, making it willing to stop restocking it.
3) Other people will know there is a chance to find VRs behind other cards so will look for them and most likely will find them. Add this with #1 and you can see the "Get mine" attitude people is leaving the store empty-handed.
4) "Get mine" attitude people may start to find even obscurer places to hide VRs. Then others will look every single niche of the store to find VRs (possible behind those toilet papers!).

This is just something that people should stop doing! I can't see how one may not understand such a simple phenomenon!

WOW. I was just thinking that people in NJ are hiding them. I went into a local CVS where they usually have plenty and I couldnt find any. I kept looking and found one at a totally random area near the movie and foor gift cards. So, I could only buy one, which I did. I didnt bother looking for more as I bought a Pay Pal reload instead of another VR.

Its sad if people are hiding them. VERY sad.

kokonutz Feb 24, 2013 4:41 pm


Originally Posted by AnitaBryant63 (Post 20309867)
I don't understand why you'd need to hide them in the first place. There's tons of CVS stores and they restock when inventory is low. Is that incorrect?

In this particular CVS (which just happens to be near my house) there are NEVER cards on the VR rack. Doesn't matter time of day nor day of week. I have only ever found them at that store in stacks hidden among the other cards. :( Of course, when I do, I take two and put the rest back on the proper rack. :D^

Never have a problem finding them at the CVS near my office, though, so this only becomes an issue on the weekends.

As I say, I think it's pretty unsporting. :td:

polandspringuy Feb 25, 2013 11:35 am

I found a couple hidden VRs at my local CVS in Brooklyn. It was pretty obvious that they were hidden deliberately... When I tried to buy them the guy mentioned a new policy that they only accept cash for amounts greater than $50. Apparently the manager of the store made up the policy to deter the use of stolen credit cards(?).


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 6:52 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.