FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   bmi | Diamond Club (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/bmi-diamond-club-486/)
-   -   Redemption Help: The DC redemption "Is this Route Allowed ?" Master Thread (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/bmi-diamond-club/1043560-dc-redemption-route-allowed-master-thread.html)

jbfield Mar 9, 2012 2:09 pm

If NZ don't charge YQ out of AKL, why not break the journey in AKL and try to get NZ AKL-HKG/LAX-LHR?? Or do you mean there's no availability on them?

I think OZ has comparatively low YQ, so you might want to try routing via ICN, or do you need to specifically visit AKL?
4 hour transit in IST shouldn't make a difference as it's not a Z1-Z2 journey

YorkieFlyer Mar 9, 2012 2:46 pm


Originally Posted by erik123 (Post 18167697)
Would this work? LHR-EWR(stop)-SIN (Z1-Z8 via Z3).

ual.com shows it as a valid route.

Err...No!

trf0412 Mar 9, 2012 3:55 pm

Any way I would get away with the following route?

MAN - BJS // HKG - TYO // OSA - MAN

I know the open-jaw between TYO and OSA will be find, but how about the surface sector from BJS-HKG? Any chance the ICC will treat it as MAN-TYO with a stopover in China?

h15t0r1an Mar 9, 2012 5:34 pm

.....Going all the way to HKG in a z1-z2 is a new one on me, though... from barnstaple and orudge



I love it !! do you think the ICC would notice, if we all phoned up and asked for this one?:D

FlyerTalker7654 Mar 9, 2012 11:41 pm


Originally Posted by jbfield (Post 18168979)
If NZ don't charge YQ out of AKL, why not break the journey in AKL and try to get NZ AKL-HKG/LAX-LHR?? Or do you mean there's no availability on them?

I think OZ has comparatively low YQ, so you might want to try routing via ICN, or do you need to specifically visit AKL?
4 hour transit in IST shouldn't make a difference as it's not a Z1-Z2 journey

The first idea was to go AKL -NRT-ICN -LHR ....but now there are no seats with OZ due to a black out period during Jan! Gutted.

As a result, that is why I am now looking at AKL-PVG with NZ and then home with TK with IST. We did have AKL-BKK-SIN-LHR and with tax and cash it was over £600 each...which would not normally be a problem but as we are on a strict budget the Mrs is saying we can't afford that :roll eyes:

Regarding coming back via HGK or LAX...no chance, checked and nothing. Those seats do not normally open up till last minute.

demue Mar 10, 2012 12:10 am


Originally Posted by erik123 (Post 18167697)
Would this work? LHR-EWR(stop)-SIN (Z1-Z8 via Z3).

ual.com shows it as a valid route.

Hilariuos :) But then I guess you were serious so definitely a big fat NO. This is really taking the "p*ss" by trying to route LHR-SIN via EWR. MPM is exploding on this one. You can do two redemptions LHR-EWR & EWR-SIN but not as 1 one-way.

erik123 Mar 10, 2012 6:05 am


Originally Posted by demue (Post 18171594)
Hilariuos :) But then I guess you were serious so definitely a big fat NO. This is really taking the "p*ss" by trying to route LHR-SIN via EWR. MPM is exploding on this one. You can do two redemptions LHR-EWR & EWR-SIN but not as 1 one-way.


Off course these are ridiculous - but stranger things have happened! Some of the routings allowed defy belief.

planestupid Mar 11, 2012 5:34 am


Originally Posted by YorkieFlyer (Post 18166214)
Historically, some have said yes, but I tried in Jan and HUACed and got a very firm no on three occasions when there was availability on SAA via JNB but not on the direct LH. Then tried IST-JNB-EZE and no again. Yet via IAH is fine!
So no harm in trying...let us know

Thanks, YorkieFlyer! I called the ICC and they said no, pointing at the available JJ routing via GRU (the direct LH flight wasn't available). When I asked "why not" the agent clearly wasn't going to engage in any sort of discussion and repeated her "computer says no" line until I gave up. Do you think it's a MPM issue? If only the ICC would tell me WHY something's not permitted ....

holtju2 Mar 11, 2012 6:05 am


Originally Posted by planestupid (Post 18177391)
Thanks, YorkieFlyer! I called the ICC and they said no, pointing at the available JJ routing via GRU (the direct LH flight wasn't available). When I asked "why not" the agent clearly wasn't going to engage in any sort of discussion and repeated her "computer says no" line until I gave up. Do you think it's a MPM issue? If only the ICC would tell me WHY something's not permitted ....

They no longer care about the MPM. They apparently only care if the route comes up as eligible one on staralliance.com. Yes. I know. Totally crazy.

onlysuites Mar 11, 2012 7:40 am


Originally Posted by holtju2 (Post 18177459)
They no longer care about the MPM. They apparently only care if the route comes up as eligible one on staralliance.com. Yes. I know. Totally crazy.

It seems that they have been trained on how to use the MPM excuse quite badly now. I was denied a PHL-MCO add on to a MAN-PHL ticket as it exceeded the MPM! :p

A simple call later and it was ticketed.

Like holtju2 says if its on the *A timetable then they normally allow it.

demue Mar 11, 2012 10:02 pm


Originally Posted by lallyr (Post 18177709)
It seems that they have been trained on how to use the MPM excuse quite badly now. I was denied a PHL-MCO add on to a MAN-PHL ticket as it exceeded the MPM! :p

A simple call later and it was ticketed.

Like holtju2 says if its on the *A timetable then they normally allow it.

Haha, yes that is "funny" to deny that and has nothing to do with MPM. Oh well, BD DC is going down the drain anyways so I guess it is back to trying to be super creative and maximize.

Air Rarotonga Mar 12, 2012 2:01 pm

ZRH OS VIE OS JFK (LGA) AC YUL (no Stopovers)

Valid routing Z1-Z3, OW 18750mi + £105 ?

ICC quotes some 30000mi with over £200 co-pay, each segment charged as single award. Reason: not the most direct routing...

Doable or not? HUACA? Thanks for your inputs!

caz312 Mar 12, 2012 2:18 pm


Originally Posted by Air Rarotonga (Post 18186169)
ZRH OS VIE OS JFK (LGA) AC YUL (no Stopovers)

Valid routing Z1-Z3, OW 18750mi + £105 ?

ICC quotes some 30000mi with over £200 co-pay, each segment charged as single award. Reason: not the most direct routing...

Doable or not? HUACA? Thanks for your inputs!

this was in another thread http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/18185106-post9.html
...you also have some backtracking in there. Seems to be ok if the route appears on staralliance.com
Unfortunately picking a different route because there is no availability on more direct routes does not wash
maybe worth another call if these are the only flights with availability....I would start with VIE to NYC then add the next flight, if that is ok you could try and ask for the ZRH part but don't be surprised if that is a no due to the backtracking and maybe think about a separate booking or revenue ticket for that part

Air Rarotonga Mar 12, 2012 2:36 pm

Thanks! Thats the same I thought... I will try it again ;)

Concerto Mar 12, 2012 6:01 pm

Don't agree: I booked (and have just flown) a complex routing with apparent backtracking, mixing 4 different carriers and with one stopover:

DUS-VIE (LH)
VIE-IAD (OS)
IAD-LGA (US)
Stopover
EWR-PBI (CO/UA)

There was no trouble with the routing (the backtracking is hardly noticeable on the map compared to the longer sectors).

It was a brilliant trip, by the way, every sector punctual with lovely service.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 9:44 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.