What is an "average" cost to obtain 1K
#46
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 4,645
Fair question. I can't answer for aacharya, but it wouldn't be the first time somebody's done it -- I think lucky9876coins flew roughly 100K of domestic mileage runs a few years ago. And it's not economically illogical. W fares are expensive, and if you can get 1K for $3500, you're earning almost enough RDM for a couple of trips in international F that would cost $15K each -- plus between CPU priority and strategic domestic use of GPUs, you might never have to sit in coach.
I don't doubt that these things are possible, but I question the point of it. Does this lead to happiness? To health? To anything valuable?
CPU priority is a red herring. Those days are over.
You can always burn the GPUs for domestic travel. The RDM and the fee waivers for being a 1K might justify the "investment" by themselves.
FT is a strongly biased sample. Most people (even on FT) do not do mileage runs.
I am a 4-figure 1K on my own spend. I don't take mileage runs, but I tend to fly on competitive routes.
FT is a strongly biased sample. Most people (even on FT) do not do mileage runs.
I am a 4-figure 1K on my own spend. I don't take mileage runs, but I tend to fly on competitive routes.
And, as for you, "4 figure" means anything from 1,000 to 9,999. That's a big range. I'm questioning some of these $3-4K numbers. If you told me you were at $8-9K, it would be easier to for me to comprehend.
Last edited by iluv2fly; Nov 7, 2012 at 11:36 pm Reason: merge
#47
Moderator: United Airlines
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: SFO
Programs: UA LT Plat 2MM, Hyatt Discoverist, Marriott Plat/LT Gold, Hilton Silver, IHG Plat
Posts: 67,002
personally, I try to minimze my time in a airplane others enjoy --- each to their won.
Yes it can be done but I can understand you not understanding why any sane person would do this --- I would not.
#48
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Jersey Shore/YYZ
Programs: UA 1K, Marriott Plat, Hilton Diamond, Hertz PC
Posts: 12,521
Why...well thats my own business. And the spend is accuarate with 10k from Y irrops. I answered the ops question. I wasnt boasting.
#50
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Los Angeles, CA, USA
Programs: United, Delta, AA, southwest
Posts: 150
My next trip this month will push me over to 1K. I had 3 TATL trips and the rest domestic. Spent about $11K. First time I ever got this high in status. Business has been good this year. I usually only hit gold.
#51
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: WAS-ish
Programs: UA 1K-MM + UC, Marriott Plat, National Exec
Posts: 1,341
Nope! 85K EQM last year, 100,300 this year (cross fingers). Roughly half domestic. However, all of my international flights are in Y, whereas most of the domestic is upgraded. So, frankly, domestic is substantially more comfortable for me -- the only advantage to international is that the EQM/hours-on-plane ratio is better.
I think you have to just plain enjoy flying. Seat2A is a great exemplar of this -- afaict, he just loves being up in the air.
As for the redeye thing -- I spend far more time searching for MR fares (purely for the fun of it) than I do flying them, and most of the ones I find are in the middle of the day. They just tend to be mid-week, which is a problem if you work a regular job. But if I had weekdays free, I could have flown back and forth on ABQ-IAH-SFO-LAS all year for 2.3cpm and slept in a bed every night.
Health? Definitely not. Value? Depends on what you value. Happiness? Well, that depends on what makes you happy. I think it's 100% clear that you have to be a little weird to hang out on FT, and a lot weird to engage in serious mileage running!
Personally, I probably wouldn't do 100K of mileage runs now, but... I want to. I just can't because I have a family.
The things I've done for fun in the past include marathons, competitive swimming, mountaineering, long-distance hiking, and triathlon. It's not precisely that I enjoy pain, but at some level the idea that enlightenment and success come from brutal self-abuse is ingrained in me. To me, the mileage game is an charmingly stupid and pointless hobby (sort of like video games, but more destructive to the environment). I'm sure I'll get over it at some point, but as long as I'm having fun, the whole MR thing is weirdly compelling.
I'm not sure what you mean here, but I'm assuming you mean "Even as a 1K, you won't clear CPUs". As a Plat this year, I've cleared 32 out of 37 eligible flights. I assume my odds won't go down if I hit 1K.
Who, in their right mind, would actually *want* to take a "few" international trips after having endured 100K on domestic flights? Also, to get these 2 cpm flights, wouldn't you have to be doing red-eye flights more often than not? Doesn't that just add to the pain and suffering of the 100K at 2 cpm domestic only proposition?
As for the redeye thing -- I spend far more time searching for MR fares (purely for the fun of it) than I do flying them, and most of the ones I find are in the middle of the day. They just tend to be mid-week, which is a problem if you work a regular job. But if I had weekdays free, I could have flown back and forth on ABQ-IAH-SFO-LAS all year for 2.3cpm and slept in a bed every night.
Personally, I probably wouldn't do 100K of mileage runs now, but... I want to. I just can't because I have a family.
The things I've done for fun in the past include marathons, competitive swimming, mountaineering, long-distance hiking, and triathlon. It's not precisely that I enjoy pain, but at some level the idea that enlightenment and success come from brutal self-abuse is ingrained in me. To me, the mileage game is an charmingly stupid and pointless hobby (sort of like video games, but more destructive to the environment). I'm sure I'll get over it at some point, but as long as I'm having fun, the whole MR thing is weirdly compelling.
I'm not sure what you mean here, but I'm assuming you mean "Even as a 1K, you won't clear CPUs". As a Plat this year, I've cleared 32 out of 37 eligible flights. I assume my odds won't go down if I hit 1K.
#52
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Vancouver, Houston
Programs: UA-Perma Plat, Hyatt-Sucks, HHonors - Dia., Marriott - Gold
Posts: 438
I'll contribute a data point... I'm at 175K so far and $42k so I average out at $24k (too many GPUs used this year)
Last year I was 240k for $74k or about $31k.
Year before that 238k for $40k so $17k for 1K
Over the three years it is about $23k
Last year I was 240k for $74k or about $31k.
Year before that 238k for $40k so $17k for 1K
Over the three years it is about $23k
#53
Suspended
Join Date: Nov 1999
Posts: 24,153
My argument is that 1K is only worth having for GPUs that get you out of hell on long flights. These days, with TODs and HODs and X-UPs, there are plenty of cheap and easy ways to get into F. And, fee waivers are given to all tiers, so assuming one would naturally be at the 50K or 75K level, I'm not sure how much incremental value there is from the fee waivers compared with the cost of acquiring the status to get the waivers in the first place.
And, as for you, "4 figure" means anything from 1,000 to 9,999. That's a big range. I'm questioning some of these $3-4K numbers. If you told me you were at $8-9K, it would be easier to for me to comprehend.
And, as for you, "4 figure" means anything from 1,000 to 9,999. That's a big range. I'm questioning some of these $3-4K numbers. If you told me you were at $8-9K, it would be easier to for me to comprehend.
Thats besides getting to visit many places.
But I can even understand a MRer who turns right around. eg NY-ONT was $160 say you do 10 of them so you spent $1600 earned (the way I fly) 123000 RDMs and now fly to my reg destination in C , while $1600 may just cover an ElCheapo tkt in Y and earn 22k RDMs and are 62% of the way to 1K instead of 11% That C tkt is usually $4500+
Each person has their own reasons . Ideally COdbaUA would love it if we simply purchased Refundable tkts at top $$$, and is well aware what goes on, they need to walk a fine line where they dont turn off everyone who isnt a Full Fare person. BA did that when they started giving only 25% EQMs & RDMs to those on ElCheapos they switched back. Every Carrier needs both types of flyers.
Maybe CO should start giving out more GPUs and RPUs as a persons spend hits certain amounts. I do agree they should be giving more to those with the good spend, how to do that w/o turning off the others is the hard part
#55
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: SFO and OAK
Programs: FAF, Hyatt <>, SPG PLT
Posts: 2,240
But, have you ever flown 100K domestically? Who, in their right mind, would actually *want* to take a "few" international trips after having endured 100K on domestic flights? Also, to get these 2 cpm flights, wouldn't you have to be doing red-eye flights more often than not? Doesn't that just add to the pain and suffering of the 100K at 2 cpm domestic only proposition?
I don't doubt that these things are possible, but I question the point of it. Does this lead to happiness? To health? To anything valuable?
CPU priority is a red herring. Those days are over.
I don't doubt that these things are possible, but I question the point of it. Does this lead to happiness? To health? To anything valuable?
CPU priority is a red herring. Those days are over.
#56
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
Programs: UA-1k, 1mm, Marriott-LT Platinum, Hertz-Presidents Circle
Posts: 6,355
So you can spend more time posting on FT no doubt!
#57
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: BWI, SEA 1/month
Programs: UA Platinum
Posts: 487
These days, flights aren't exactly going out with lots of empty seats (except in Essential Air Service airports, naturally); the pricing algorithms are too sophisticated. So it's not "UA wouldn't have my revenue at all if I didn't buy" but "how much lower would UA have to have priced this to get someone who didn't have loyalty and book UA to earn or use his elite benefits."
Under any system, people are going to find a way to beat the system. But really, UA isn't trying to reward you for being "loyal," they're rewarding elites because they think it's profitable to do so.
#59
Suspended
Join Date: Nov 1999
Posts: 24,153
What I meant was alot of folks who had been with PMUA for yrs and yrs all of a sudden woke up and found a new set of facts on the ground , which meant they would no longer be able to play the Game as they were used to playing it and now it was a very good chance if they still purchased a Coach tkt thats exactly where they will end up sitting. And that meant War! and take Jeff down.
I saw it as a new owner and if you dont like the way things are then move on. I honestly believe if most of those who curse Jeff were the CEO they would most likely have done pretty much what Jeff has.
For myself I said I will be too close to 1MM to switch now, after 12/26 I will need apx 76k. After I hit that I will revisit where things stand and decide what if anything Id do, and posted many a time this is what each and every person needs to do. If COdbaUA doesnt work for you any longer move onto to which ever Carrier does, its very simple.
#60
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: WAS-ish
Programs: UA 1K-MM + UC, Marriott Plat, National Exec
Posts: 1,341
...let me get my calculator...
...41666.67cpm! Folks, we have a winner!
(Update: I think that is possible. SBA-LAX one-way in full Y/F is 88 miles, or 132EQM with the bonus. And if you started with no status, and managed to find a mistake fare that charged $55K, then you could end up with 132 EQM and GS. Doing it with only 120 EQM on UA metal would be harder -- I'm sure there's an 80-mile route out there, but then you'd have to get the other 12 EQM on a partner, and that's tough).