FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   oneworld (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/oneworld-411/)
-   -   Oneworld booking and pricing experiences (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/oneworld/1776577-oneworld-booking-pricing-experiences.html)

PHLGovFlyer Nov 15, 2025 6:13 am


Originally Posted by izzik (Post 37428473)
It's the longhaul QF segment that's driving up your carrier fees... suggest dropping the EYW sidetrip altogether and going JL SYD-HND, overnight stopover, then JL HND-JFK.. JL has surcharges too, but not as bad as QF. It should be approx $325 total in fees with JL on those 2 segments... and you'll rack up way more LPs with a JL code.

That's exactly what I wanted to book originally, and for exactly those reasons (I'd read enough on here to be wary of longhaul QF fees). Unfortunately, there was zero JL availability on HND-JFK around any of the dates I wanted, and the first agent struggled to find AA availability on that route as well.

I rationalize paying the extra $1000 with my current booking that includes PHL-EYW-PHL because I'd be buying it regardless, and it's a surprisingly expensive route for the dates I need.

steveholt Nov 15, 2025 2:59 pm


Originally Posted by PHLGovFlyer (Post 37428381)
Any idea why the carrier imposed fees are almost $1000 higher for the second itinerary compared to the first one?

The QF longhaul leg from Oz to the US. Switch that to the AA flight from SYD-LAX-JFK and you'll save money (although I suspect run out of room for your EYW side trip)

izzik Nov 15, 2025 10:32 pm

Did you check nrt bos on jl? Or hnd ord?

pandaperth Nov 16, 2025 3:07 am


Originally Posted by nufnuf77 (Post 37404307)
very sound advice indeed!

Hi nufnuf77 - I'm trying to PM you, but your inbox is full!

LilZeppelin Nov 16, 2025 12:42 pm

Noticed competitve exCPT DONEx fares (a bit cheaper in USD then exOSL), but only on QR/BA - AA much higher. Not sure what the reason for discrepancy is, but would AA RTW price my itinerary using AA fares or the lower QR/BA fares?

skunker Nov 16, 2025 3:51 pm


Originally Posted by PHLGovFlyer (Post 37429421)
That's exactly what I wanted to book originally, and for exactly those reasons (I'd read enough on here to be wary of longhaul QF fees). Unfortunately, there was zero JL availability on HND-JFK around any of the dates I wanted, and the first agent struggled to find AA availability on that route as well.

I rationalize paying the extra $1000 with my current booking that includes PHL-EYW-PHL because I'd be buying it regardless, and it's a surprisingly expensive route for the dates I need.

What about HND-DFW on JL? Seems to generally have better availability than HND-JFK.

skunker Nov 16, 2025 3:58 pm


Originally Posted by LilZeppelin (Post 37431634)
Noticed competitve exCPT DONEx fares (a bit cheaper in USD then exOSL), but only on QR/BA - AA much higher. Not sure what the reason for discrepancy is, but would AA RTW price my itinerary using AA fares or the lower QR/BA fares?

What numbers are you seeing because I'm still seeing OSL as cheaper across the board
Code:

CPT
DONE3 QR D Round-Trip 5855.80(USD) B

--/12M

DONE3 BA D Round-Trip 5888.00(USD) B

--/12M

DGLOB34 AA D Round-Trip 6422.80(USD) B

--/12M

DGLOB34 QR D Round-Trip 6422.80(USD) B

--/12M

DONE4 AA D Round-Trip 6422.80(USD) B

--/12M

DONE4 QR D Round-Trip 6422.80(USD) B

--/12M

DGLOB34 BA D Round-Trip 6455.00(USD) B

--/12M

DONE4 BA D Round-Trip 6455.00(USD) B

--/12M

DONE5 AA D Round-Trip 7304.80(USD) B

--/12M

DONE5 QR D Round-Trip 7304.80(USD) B

--/12M

DONE5 BA D Round-Trip 7337.00(USD) B

--/12M

DONE6 AA D Round-Trip 8627.30(USD) B

--/12M

DONE6 QR D Round-Trip 8627.30(USD) B

--/12M

DONE6 BA D Round-Trip 8659.50(USD) B

--/12M

Code:

OSL
DONE3 AA D Round-Trip 5215.43(USD) B

--/12M

DONE3 QR D Round-Trip 5215.43(USD) B

--/12M

DONE3 BA D Round-Trip 5250.17(USD) B

--/12M

DGLOB34 AA D Round-Trip 5709.23(USD) B

--/12M

DGLOB34 QR D Round-Trip 5709.23(USD) B

--/12M

DGLOB34 BA D Round-Trip 5743.96(USD) B

--/12M

DONE4 AA D Round-Trip 5768.95(USD) B

--/12M

DONE4 QR D Round-Trip 5768.95(USD) B

--/12M

DONE4 BA D Round-Trip 5803.68(USD) B

--/12M

DONE5 AA D Round-Trip 6587.72(USD) B

--/12M

DONE5 QR D Round-Trip 6587.72(USD) B

--/12M

DONE5 BA D Round-Trip 6622.46(USD) B

--/12M

DONE6 AA D Round-Trip 7431.98(USD) B

--/12M

DONE6 QR D Round-Trip 7431.98(USD) B

--/12M

DONE6 BA D Round-Trip 7466.71(USD) B

--/12M


Dr. HFH Nov 16, 2025 8:12 pm


Originally Posted by skunker (Post 37431855)
What numbers are you seeing because I'm still seeing OSL as cheaper across the board

Plus, ex-South Africa adds a continent for many/most of us, so for me that changes it from a DONE3 to a DONE4. Years ago, ex-South Africa and ex-Mauritius were cheaper, even considering that it became a four continent itinerary, but no longer.

PHLGovFlyer Nov 17, 2025 11:29 am


Originally Posted by steveholt (Post 37430202)
The QF longhaul leg from Oz to the US. Switch that to the AA flight from SYD-LAX-JFK and you'll save money (although I suspect run out of room for your EYW side trip)

I had considered that option, however, it substantially reduces LP earnings on AA, and yes, the added segment would have collapsed the rest of the trip structure.


Originally Posted by skunker (Post 37431846)
What about HND-DFW on JL? Seems to generally have better availability than HND-JFK.

Thanks. I'll toss that one into the mix next time. I did check ORD and BOS on JL, and also considered using NRT originating flights. They showed even worse availability than JFK on my dates.

dvs7310 Nov 17, 2025 1:02 pm


Originally Posted by PHLGovFlyer (Post 37433327)
I had considered that option, however, it substantially reduces LP earnings on AA, and yes, the added segment would have collapsed the rest of the trip structure.



Thanks. I'll toss that one into the mix next time. I did check ORD and BOS on JL, and also considered using NRT originating flights. They showed even worse availability than JFK on my dates.

If you're stuck with the QF coded segment because of LP's (I am in the same boat sometimes) then you'll want to change your ticketing carrier. This means going through a travel agent. Most likely if you ticket with QR or JL you won't have much in YQ/YR on that segment, also JL coded segments (if this applies to you) have very minimal YQ/YR when on QR or JL stock.

LilZeppelin Nov 18, 2025 12:04 pm

AA no DONE3 and the numbers I see on expertflyer:
ExCPT QR AA
DONE3 QR D Round-Trip 5092.00(USD) na
DGLOB34QRD Round-Trip 5585.00(USD) 6422.80(USD)
DONE4 QR D Round-Trip 5585.00(USD) 6422.80(USD)
DONE5 QR D Round-Trip 6352.00(USD) 7304.80(USD)
DONE6 QR D Round-Trip 7502.00(USD) 8627.30(USD)

ExOSL
DONE3 QR D Round-Trip 5194.00(USD)
DGLOB34 QR D Round-Trip 5686.00(USD)
DONE4 QR D Round-Trip 5745.00(USD)
DONE5 QR D Round-Trip 6561.00(USD)
DONE6 QR D Round-Trip 7402.00(USD)

link2 Nov 18, 2025 12:09 pm


Originally Posted by LilZeppelin (Post 37435428)
AA no DONE3 and the numbers I see on expertflyer:
ExCPT QR AA
DONE3 QR D Round-Trip 5092.00(USD) na
DGLOB34QRD Round-Trip 5585.00(USD) 6422.80(USD)
DONE4 QR D Round-Trip 5585.00(USD) 6422.80(USD)
DONE5 QR D Round-Trip 6352.00(USD) 7304.80(USD)
DONE6 QR D Round-Trip 7502.00(USD) 8627.30(USD)

ExOSL
DONE3 QR D Round-Trip 5194.00(USD)
DGLOB34 QR D Round-Trip 5686.00(USD)
DONE4 QR D Round-Trip 5745.00(USD)
DONE5 QR D Round-Trip 6561.00(USD)
DONE6 QR D Round-Trip 7402.00(USD)

My ex-OSL fares match yours (apart from rounding) but not the ex-CPT ones.

DONE3 QR D Round-Trip 5855.80(USD)
DGLOB34 QR D Round-Trip 6422.80(USD)
DONE4 QR D Round-Trip 6422.80(USD)

Bizarre.

link2 Nov 18, 2025 12:15 pm

Okay, I managed to get your numbers to show up by explicitly searching for QR fares. Cabin is listed as "C" instead of "B". I'm tempted to say this is an ExpertFlyer glitch. (Caching?)

PHLGovFlyer Nov 18, 2025 10:06 pm

date change prior to first departure
 
I've booked a DONE6 starting from OSL in March which includes:

JFK-GRU (AA)
stopover
GRU-MIA-PHL (AA)

With all three legs in mid September.

I need to change the dates of those flights and stopover to early September. The routings wouldn't change at all. If I make the date change now (before the first flight of the booking in March) will it cause the entire trip to be repriced?

I also noticed that the JFK-GRU leg is sold as a JL codeshare on AA metal. Would changing to the JL codeshare cause a reprice of the whole trip?

danger Nov 18, 2025 10:28 pm


Originally Posted by PHLGovFlyer (Post 37436308)
I've booked a DONE6 starting from OSL in March which includes:

JFK-GRU (AA)
stopover
GRU-MIA-PHL (AA)

With all three legs in mid September.

I need to change the dates of those flights and stopover to early September. The routings wouldn't change at all. If I make the date change now (before the first flight of the booking in March) will it cause the entire trip to be repriced?
...

Some disagree with me but my view is the rules are silent on whether a reprice results in your situation. In reality I think you'll be fine without a reprice, particularly if ticketed with AA.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 1:15 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.