Westin Michigan Avenue, Chicago, IL [Master Thread]
#152
Suspended
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: New York, NY
Programs: Delta - Gold; Starwood - Platinum; HHonors - Diamond & Avis Preferred
Posts: 10,869
#153
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: AUS
Posts: 234
My in-laws want to stay at this property for an upcoming weekend.
Being from Chicago I haven't ever stayed at this hotel.
They have asked me to get them a room with a Lake View.
I've read the reviews and it sounds like pretty much Platinum's don't get upgrades. However it is my understanding that a better view is technically considered an upgrade (they are booked in a traditional room). Seeing as to guarantee a lake view it'd be another $58/night I don't think it would be worth that.
Knowing that the only way to get exactly what you want is to pay for it ... my question is do you think there is a good likelihood that the platinum upgrade (I'm paying) would at least be for a room with a better view?
From the people who regularly stay here on weekends what say you?
Thanks!
Being from Chicago I haven't ever stayed at this hotel.
They have asked me to get them a room with a Lake View.
I've read the reviews and it sounds like pretty much Platinum's don't get upgrades. However it is my understanding that a better view is technically considered an upgrade (they are booked in a traditional room). Seeing as to guarantee a lake view it'd be another $58/night I don't think it would be worth that.
Knowing that the only way to get exactly what you want is to pay for it ... my question is do you think there is a good likelihood that the platinum upgrade (I'm paying) would at least be for a room with a better view?
From the people who regularly stay here on weekends what say you?
Thanks!
#154
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Chicago
Programs: AA EP, UA Gold-MM, UA 1K (former), GS (former),SPG LT Platinum, Hyatt Diamond, HH Diamond
Posts: 2,299
Other than the view the room was very small (typical city hotel).
As far as the rest of the stay goes, besides having to wait for a while when checking in (there was only 1 agent) everyone was very nice and I would say nicer than I would have expected for a big city hotel. The lobby can be quite chaotic but the employees were great (especially the doorman!).
On a side note, I did have a small maintenance issue (the towel bar fell off) but when I called down within minutes someone was up to repair it and also they sent me 500 points unsolicited for the inconvenience.
#155
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: LAX
Programs: UA Gold/1MM, AA EXP, Marriott Plat
Posts: 963
Just stayed here this weekend. Stay wasn't bad and check-in staff was friendly. There was also some cookies and hot (rather scorching hot) apple cider in the lobby available. ^
I inquired about a suite upgrade and she said there was one she could give me if I waited...but coming off from a red-eye and long drive, my friend and I decided to just forgo and take the only available room -- a regular, non-deluxe, non-"lake view" room on the SPG floor. Had a decent view of Michigan Avenue, John Hancock building side, and the Water Tower.
Room wasn't super big but it was sufficient for us. The bathroom area was a bit worn but that type of thing doesn't really bug me unless I start seeing mold growing on the side or in the grout.
For the price paid and location, I'd definitely stay here again...though I think I actually prefer the room I had last trip over at the W Lakeshore.
I inquired about a suite upgrade and she said there was one she could give me if I waited...but coming off from a red-eye and long drive, my friend and I decided to just forgo and take the only available room -- a regular, non-deluxe, non-"lake view" room on the SPG floor. Had a decent view of Michigan Avenue, John Hancock building side, and the Water Tower.
Room wasn't super big but it was sufficient for us. The bathroom area was a bit worn but that type of thing doesn't really bug me unless I start seeing mold growing on the side or in the grout.
For the price paid and location, I'd definitely stay here again...though I think I actually prefer the room I had last trip over at the W Lakeshore.
#156
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Formerly HPN, but then DCA and IAD for a while, and now back to HPN!
Programs: Honestly, I've been out of the travel game so long that I'm not even sure. Maybe Marriott Gold?
Posts: 10,677
$400 a night during the Cable Show last week. Definitely no value. I thought this was a tired Westin in need of renovation. No Heavenly shower. Ran out of hot water at 6:45 am on Tuesday morning. My sink drain didn't work correctly. I reported both issues to the front desk and they resolved the issues by the next morning. Lightining in the bathrooms is poor, and left me feeling like I was showering and shaving in a cave. Took between 20 and 30 minutes to retrieve my car at the hotel parking garage. A very average stay, which, for me, was unusual at a Westin property. All of my other Westin stays were good to excellent.
#157
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: DFW -
Programs: AA EXP 5MM, DL DM, Bonvoy Titanium, Avis CHM, National VIP
Posts: 556
Stayed here two nights last week and was underwhelmed. Only stayed here because I was attending a conference down the street at the Four Seasons - otherwise would have been at one of the Ws.
Some sort of computer issue at check-in. The desk clerk serving me tried to log on, apparently had a problem, mumbled something unintelligible, then walked off to the back and never returned. After about 5 minutes, the clerk at the next position asked if I was being helped. I told her I really wasn't sure. She checked me in, but strange - and this was in the SPG Plat line. Wasn't asked about Platinum amenity choice.
No upgrade at all (although in fairness, hotel seemed pretty full). Very small room on a low floor, no view. I did receive a tray with a bottle of water and a piece of candied orange as a "welcome gift".
Six days later, no points have posted for this stay. Will send in the email when the website lets me after 7 days pass. Won't stay here again if I can avoid it - and many better options with *wood in Chicago.
Some sort of computer issue at check-in. The desk clerk serving me tried to log on, apparently had a problem, mumbled something unintelligible, then walked off to the back and never returned. After about 5 minutes, the clerk at the next position asked if I was being helped. I told her I really wasn't sure. She checked me in, but strange - and this was in the SPG Plat line. Wasn't asked about Platinum amenity choice.
No upgrade at all (although in fairness, hotel seemed pretty full). Very small room on a low floor, no view. I did receive a tray with a bottle of water and a piece of candied orange as a "welcome gift".
Six days later, no points have posted for this stay. Will send in the email when the website lets me after 7 days pass. Won't stay here again if I can avoid it - and many better options with *wood in Chicago.
#158
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: MSP
Programs: Delta PM, Marriott Plat, Hertz Pres
Posts: 3,649
Posted this as its own thread but figured i should have it here....
so around 3 AM yesterday me and a friend booked a last min trip to Chicago, cheap flight which we were both upgraded on, and the traditional room at the Westin Michigan ave on the prepay rate of $127 a night (notice there are deluxe rooms and a crown suite open also). Valet the rental at the hotel ($59 ugh) and get to desk where i realize i left my wallet in the car, while its being retrieved we make small talk with the desk agent. He finds our reservation, notes my Gold is on there, i make a off hand comment about the Crown room (ok maybe a did a bit of the puppy eye thing also....) to which he replies "well i do have one for you....." punches a few keys and gives us the suite!!
Never gotten such a good upgrade as a lowly Gold :P
Love the room, huge wrap around/corner room over Michigan ave on the 12th floor
so around 3 AM yesterday me and a friend booked a last min trip to Chicago, cheap flight which we were both upgraded on, and the traditional room at the Westin Michigan ave on the prepay rate of $127 a night (notice there are deluxe rooms and a crown suite open also). Valet the rental at the hotel ($59 ugh) and get to desk where i realize i left my wallet in the car, while its being retrieved we make small talk with the desk agent. He finds our reservation, notes my Gold is on there, i make a off hand comment about the Crown room (ok maybe a did a bit of the puppy eye thing also....) to which he replies "well i do have one for you....." punches a few keys and gives us the suite!!
Never gotten such a good upgrade as a lowly Gold :P
Love the room, huge wrap around/corner room over Michigan ave on the 12th floor
#159
Suspended
Join Date: Dec 2009
Posts: 3,816
#161
Original Member
Join Date: May 1998
Location: nyc, ny, usa
Posts: 364
Customer Service at FD an issue
I have already filed a complaint with the hotel, will let u know outcome. Here are the details of my last 5 stays:
Check-in Process:
1. NEVER enough people at the counters.
2. The Starwood counter never properly taken care of and people constantly cutting in line.
3. I literally waited while someone filled in an application for the Starwood Preferred program this week.
Check-out Process
1. Never received a final bill under my door or emailed to me.
2. At 7 am, only one man at the counter. He was checking bags plus checking out people. People cutting in line, and he serviced them. This included taking checked baggage, leaving the counter unmanned and storing it. This is not isolated; I observed the same problems yesterday when I left the hotel in the morning.
3. I finally gave up waiting, as did another gentlemen and left.
4. No doorman at the front door. Had to flag my own cab, carry my luggage and got into an argument with the same woman who cut into line in front of me who tried to take my cab.
Check-in Process:
1. NEVER enough people at the counters.
2. The Starwood counter never properly taken care of and people constantly cutting in line.
3. I literally waited while someone filled in an application for the Starwood Preferred program this week.
Check-out Process
1. Never received a final bill under my door or emailed to me.
2. At 7 am, only one man at the counter. He was checking bags plus checking out people. People cutting in line, and he serviced them. This included taking checked baggage, leaving the counter unmanned and storing it. This is not isolated; I observed the same problems yesterday when I left the hotel in the morning.
3. I finally gave up waiting, as did another gentlemen and left.
4. No doorman at the front door. Had to flag my own cab, carry my luggage and got into an argument with the same woman who cut into line in front of me who tried to take my cab.
#162
Join Date: Feb 2007
Programs: SPG
Posts: 22
Ditto on everything negative
This is my least favorite Starwood property in Chicago. The staff are not helpful, the rooms are tired, the bathrooms are even worse, and room service is painfully slow. If it was not so well located, I doubt it could hold on to the Westin flag. My advice, just stay away unless you have no choice (unfortunately like I did - three times now).
#163
Moderator: GLBT travelers, India-based Airlines and India; FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Asia
Programs: Yes!
Posts: 15,512
Wow. And as a counterpoint I absolutely loved this hotel and the way they looked after me. The staff in particular were outstanding, and the recognition was excellent too.
I would be delighted to return!
I would be delighted to return!
#165
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: LGA/JFK/EWR
Programs: UA 1K1.75MM, Hyatt Globalist, abandoned Marriott LTT (RIP SPG), Hertz PC
Posts: 21,172
Good for shopping - but the Westin River North IMO is much superior for El access, closer to nice restaurants, Plat treatment, etc.
Unfortunately have a stay at the Mich. Ave next week as the River North is painfully high right now for my SET codes and the W Lakeshore has been sold out for two weeks.
Unfortunately have a stay at the Mich. Ave next week as the River North is painfully high right now for my SET codes and the W Lakeshore has been sold out for two weeks.