FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Manufactured Spending (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/manufactured-spending-719/)
-   -   giftcards.com master thread(up to 2017) (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/manufactured-spending/1698857-giftcards-com-master-thread-up-2017-a.html)

polishdan Sep 3, 2015 2:49 pm

1. Are creditcard.com VGCs issued by MetaBank like the kind you find at Staples/OfficeMax? (if yes, ignore next question)
2. Can you unload creditcard.com VGCs onto BB at Walmart KATEs without any fees? Anyone successfully do this? Or is it a Bancorp/Vanilla situation where I'd have to find other means of liquidation?

I've been getting my $200 VGCs at Staples but am thinking if I can get $500 ones off giftcards.com, I'll save $22.86 for $1,000 in MS

$1000 VGC @Staples using Amex Plat: 5x(200 + 6.95) = 1034.75 + [gas to store]
$1000 VGC @CC.com using Amex Plat: 2x(500 + 4.95) + 1.99 [shipping] = 1011.89

khochurn Sep 3, 2015 5:40 pm

I loaded 3/4 to my redbird today. One of the cards kept giving me "unable" to read error after entering the PIN and selecting no cash back. Came back and the balance is still $500.

Anyone experience something similar? Should I just request a new card?

chakrabortyDuo Sep 4, 2015 9:57 am

Well it seems we've both been banned by giftcards.com. After his first or second cancellation last month, husband called in to get more details and was told that there is a 10k per month limit, based on first order not calendar month. I attempted a smaller amount than the usual 2k order since it would have brought me under the 10k limit for the month but was still cancelled. Annoyed but determined, I decided to continue to lay low. Husband's new month started earlier this week and he tried to put through an order and was cancelled, twice.

As fate would have it giftcards.com sent me a customer service survey and I politely gave a piece of my mind concerning their lack of concrete information and overall terrible customer. The Vendor Relationship Manager emailed me in return basically repeating the same message I'd been hearing all along:

I'm sorry that your orders were not able to be processed due to our security screening and that the response to your inquiry was unsatisfactory. We consider online security, which protects both our customers as well as our company, to be a top priority. I understand that it is frustrating that you are not being given any specific details as to why the orders are cancelled. While we are comfortable with the accuracy of our process we do realize that no screening process is perfect and, unfortunately, sometimes good people are impacted.
After another reply from me voicing my dissatifaction with their lack of transparency, I got this message from her:

I’m sorry that we are not able to share the specific details from the security screening. At this point, GiftCards.com has chosen to no longer do business with you.
So thats that. I was able to get 8k out of them so I'm not too broken up about it. For anyone else ordering, enjoy it while you can but make sure you line up a plan B for when giftcards.com arbitrarily bans you for no reason.

Happy MS'ing!

CockyDoc16 Sep 4, 2015 10:11 am


Originally Posted by chakrabortyDuo (Post 25377100)
Well it seems we've both been banned by giftcards.com. After his first or second cancellation last month, husband called in to get more details and was told that there is a 10k per month limit, based on first order not calendar month. I attempted a smaller amount than the usual 2k order since it would have brought me under the 10k limit for the month but was still cancelled. Annoyed but determined, I decided to continue to lay low. Husband's new month started earlier this week and he tried to put through an order and was cancelled, twice.

As fate would have it giftcards.com sent me a customer service survey and I politely gave a piece of my mind concerning their lack of concrete information and overall terrible customer. The Vendor Relationship Manager emailed me in return basically repeating the same message I'd been hearing all along:


After another reply from me voicing my dissatifaction with their lack of transparency, I got this message from her:


So thats that. I was able to get 8k out of them so I'm not too broken up about it. For anyone else ordering, enjoy it while you can but make sure you line up a plan B for when giftcards.com arbitrarily bans you for no reason.

Happy MS'ing!

Were you using the same credit card for all of your orders or did you change them out frequently?

BussingIt Sep 4, 2015 10:14 am

I was banned also. I had no doubt this would happen.

chakrabortyDuo Sep 4, 2015 10:29 am


Originally Posted by CockyDoc16 (Post 25377184)
Were you using the same credit card for all of your orders or did you change them out frequently?

Nope different cards.


Originally Posted by BussingIt (Post 25377199)
I was banned also. I had no doubt this would happen.

Any reason given?

Amex For Children Of Africa Sep 4, 2015 10:44 am

From the start of using this site I knew it was going to only be good for complementing my MS, and never thought to use it as my main source. I'll continue to do my $1k a week and just have it save me $40-50 a month in fees. Let's hope staying low keeps working, as I just had another order confirmed this morning.

Btw new free shipping code is:
FREEUSPS915

Guessing it only goes to 9/15...

cdog999 Sep 4, 2015 1:01 pm


Originally Posted by Amex For Children Of Africa (Post 25377360)
From the start of using this site I knew it was going to only be good for complementing my MS, and never thought to use it as my main source. I'll continue to do my $1k a week and just have it save me $40-50 a month in fees. Let's hope staying low keeps working, as I just had another order confirmed this morning.

Btw new free shipping code is:
FREEUSPS915

Guessing it only goes to 9/15...

Thanks gave it another try. This time only for 1 card since my 3 card purcahse was declined. If this doesn't work I'm done with this site.

cdog999 Sep 4, 2015 8:08 pm


Originally Posted by cdog999 (Post 25378025)
Thanks gave it another try. This time only for 1 card since my 3 card purcahse was declined. If this doesn't work I'm done with this site.

Update: Just got my cancellation notice 5 hours later. Only tried to purchase one card so I know its not an issue with my credit card. Screw these jackholes.

CockyDoc16 Sep 4, 2015 9:21 pm


Originally Posted by cdog999 (Post 25379466)
Update: Just got my cancellation notice 5 hours later. Only tried to purchase one card so I know its not an issue with my credit card. Screw these jackholes.

:td::td::td: Ridiculous. Can't believe these guys even stay in business. What else would anyone buy on that site...

Phantom707 Sep 5, 2015 12:38 am


Originally Posted by CockyDoc16 (Post 25379629)
:td::td::td: Ridiculous. Can't believe these guys even stay in business. What else would anyone buy on that site...

... Other gift cards.

I've also sold some store gift cards to them, before I got into churning.

CockyDoc16 Sep 5, 2015 9:16 am


Originally Posted by Phantom707 (Post 25379949)
... Other gift cards.

I've also sold some store gift cards to them, before I got into churning.

There's not much else to buy there anymore. I used to buy a good amount of discounted store gift cards from them but they've since moved that to another site. Now it's just Visa/MC and full-priced store gift cards...and there are far better places to buy store gift cards.

toby16custom Sep 5, 2015 9:38 am

Question for folks using GCM do any of you use Citi cards? I want to make sure they don't charge as a Ca$h Adv

kyroadrunner Sep 5, 2015 10:50 am


Originally Posted by toby16custom (Post 25381068)
Question for folks using GCM do any of you use Citi cards? I want to make sure they don't charge as a Ca$h Adv

I have my citi cards cash advance limit set zero, I have 6 orders placed so far with no issues.

Amex For Children Of Africa Sep 5, 2015 12:41 pm


Originally Posted by toby16custom (Post 25381068)
Question for folks using GCM do any of you use Citi cards? I want to make sure they don't charge as a Ca$h Adv

I did not change my CA limit and it goes through as a charge. No fees on multiple citi cards.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:48 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.