AAdvantage Dining questions
#166
Join Date: Sep 2017
Location: DCA/IAD & BUF
Posts: 1,406
Although I ask myself often, if it's worth pondering to this level of detail. The accumulation of points is still paltry compared to an AAH stay or a major eShopping purchase. The delta on intermittent AA Dining doesn't move the needle much, unfortunately. If I find myself perhaps falling short on 1 Feb, I'd just do a high return stay or two. Sometimes it seems easier just to plan to do that, than the mental energy of all these small-ish purchases with lackluster returns (in comparison to AAH) .
#167
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: SFO, CLT
Programs: AA Bonsai EXP (2.9 MM), AS MVPG
Posts: 1,395
Although I ask myself often, if it's worth pondering to this level of detail. The accumulation of points is still paltry compared to an AAH stay or a major eShopping purchase. The delta on intermittent AA Dining doesn't move the needle much, unfortunately. If I find myself perhaps falling short on 1 Feb, I'd just do a high return stay or two. Sometimes it seems easier just to plan to do that, than the mental energy of all these small-ish purchases with lackluster returns (in comparison to AAH) .
#168
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Usually in SAN or Central Europe.
Programs: AA:EXP/1MM. Accor/Radisson:Silver; HH:Gold; ICH:Plt Amb.
Posts: 22,307
I don't see why people aren't particpating in this program. It doesn't take much effort to accumulate the frist 11 dines, and with minimal spend. Moreover, if one is short 1K-2K LPs in crossing over an elite status threshold come mid-February, this is an easy way to close that gap. especially with the 20%/30% LP bonus.
#169
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Oct 2014
Posts: 10,904
I don't see why people aren't particpating in this program. It doesn't take much effort to accumulate the frist 11 dines, and with minimal spend. Moreover, if one is short 1K-2K LPs in crossing over an elite status threshold come mid-February, this is an easy way to close that gap. especially with the 20%/30% LP bonus.
Now, if my local cigar place was in the program I'd be racking up the miles for sure...
#170
Join Date: Sep 2017
Location: DCA/IAD & BUF
Posts: 1,406
Good point. I decided earlier just to wait until next week, just to be sure. Taking a group of friends out who helped with a major afternoon backyard project last month. The entrees at this establishment can be pricey, and we all like our wine - alot - lol - so the 3x vice 5x difference may be relatively substantial.
Although I ask myself often, if it's worth pondering to this level of detail. The accumulation of points is still paltry compared to an AAH stay or a major eShopping purchase. The delta on intermittent AA Dining doesn't move the needle much, unfortunately. If I find myself perhaps falling short on 1 Feb, I'd just do a high return stay or two. Sometimes it seems easier just to plan to do that, than the mental energy of all these small-ish purchases with lackluster returns (in comparison to AAH) .
Although I ask myself often, if it's worth pondering to this level of detail. The accumulation of points is still paltry compared to an AAH stay or a major eShopping purchase. The delta on intermittent AA Dining doesn't move the needle much, unfortunately. If I find myself perhaps falling short on 1 Feb, I'd just do a high return stay or two. Sometimes it seems easier just to plan to do that, than the mental energy of all these small-ish purchases with lackluster returns (in comparison to AAH) .
It really depends how often you eat out at establishments that participate. When I lived in San Francisco there were a few places I went to regularly that were in the program. But in the Phoenix area there aren't too many that I'm interested in going to so I don't get too many dines. Occasionally I'll be traveling, go somewhere, and be surprised with some miles. That happened to me last week in Miami; a cigar bar there was in the program (I didn't know until I got the email later)
Now, if my local cigar place was in the program I'd be racking up the miles for sure...
Now, if my local cigar place was in the program I'd be racking up the miles for sure...
There are 3-4 other participating places I'd go to more often, one being a favorite Italian/Pizza place I'm at weekly. But for some bizarre reason those participating restaurants are all 'chownow delivery only'. Dine-in, or even takeout or the restaurants' own delivery services, don't qualify. And I refuse to give Chownow even a dime just to earn points, when tax, tip, and extra delivery fees don't count.
Actually, other than the pizza place, I probably wouldn't use Chownow often anyway, even if every $ counted. We're not in lock down anymore. If I'm doing more than standard pizza or Chinese/Asian delivery, I want the 'eating out' experience and atmosphere to go with it. Not messing around with potentially late delivery service, cold food, plastic utensils, eating from takeout containers, or transferring everything to dishes, and then the resulting clean-up.
AA Dining could be a great program. I'd participate much more often if there were more/different choices nearby.
#171
Join Date: Sep 2017
Location: DCA/IAD & BUF
Posts: 1,406
#172
Join Date: Sep 2017
Location: DCA/IAD & BUF
Posts: 1,406
I had my 10th visit this morning at a participating restaurant in AA's Dining program.
Starting with #11, the earn goes from 3 LPs/$ to 5.
If I were to have dinner at a participating restaurant tonight or tomorrow, will it qualify for the higher points? Or is this similar to the LP bonuses -- won't kick in until the 10th visit has actually posted to AA account? (at least not without additional effort & machinations).
Starting with #11, the earn goes from 3 LPs/$ to 5.
If I were to have dinner at a participating restaurant tonight or tomorrow, will it qualify for the higher points? Or is this similar to the LP bonuses -- won't kick in until the 10th visit has actually posted to AA account? (at least not without additional effort & machinations).
So there's another breakfast outing this morning to make the magic number. I'm just relieved I didn't jump the gun prematurely on a bigger expenditure.
On a happier note, noticed TGIF is added now in the DMV region, including Dine-In. Like them better than most similar chain restaurants. Hopefully they stay on the list for awhile. Fairly surprised to see them added.
#173
Join Date: Apr 2011
Programs: Marriott Ambassador, AA ExecPlat, Amtrak Select Exec, former WN apologist
Posts: 1,429
There are 3-4 other participating places I'd go to more often, one being a favorite Italian/Pizza place I'm at weekly. But for some bizarre reason those participating restaurants are all 'chownow delivery only'. Dine-in, or even takeout or the restaurants' own delivery services, don't qualify. And I refuse to give Chownow even a dime just to earn points, when tax, tip, and extra delivery fees don't count.
#174
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Houston, TX, USA
Programs: UA 1K, AA Lifetime Platinum, DL Platinum, Honors Diamond, Bonvoy Titanium, Hertz Platinum
Posts: 7,970
#175
Join Date: Sep 2017
Location: DCA/IAD & BUF
Posts: 1,406
Anyone else experiencing recent delays in posting times?
The breakfast place I've been going to to hit VIP status, previously posted to AA in 3-4 days. Like clockwork.
Now however I'm waiting on 3 postings at the 8, 7, and 4 day marks, respectively. The first two (last week) should have pushed me over to VIP by now. There's been no acknowledgment/ movement on the Dining site.
I know it's states to allow 10 days, and I will wait the full 10 days before submitting the current charges from my AA card, but the sudden, notable time difference is kind of frustrating.
The breakfast place I've been going to to hit VIP status, previously posted to AA in 3-4 days. Like clockwork.
Now however I'm waiting on 3 postings at the 8, 7, and 4 day marks, respectively. The first two (last week) should have pushed me over to VIP by now. There's been no acknowledgment/ movement on the Dining site.
I know it's states to allow 10 days, and I will wait the full 10 days before submitting the current charges from my AA card, but the sudden, notable time difference is kind of frustrating.
#176
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Oct 2014
Posts: 10,904
No. I recently (10/27) did a little experiment to see if I could double dip SimplyMiles and Dining. I got the tracking email from Dining immediately, and and it posted 3 days later. SimplyMiles took longer (as it always does) but I got the tracking email a couple of days ago and they posted overnight last night.
So, double dip successful and everything posted on schedule (3 days for dining and 5 days for SimplyMiles)
So, double dip successful and everything posted on schedule (3 days for dining and 5 days for SimplyMiles)
#179
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Pacific Northwest
Programs: UA Gold 1MM, AS 75k, AA Plat, Bonvoyed Gold, Honors Dia, Hyatt Explorer, IHG Plat, ...
Posts: 16,859
It’s even worse than this. A lot of the 'chownow delivery only' places charge higher menu prices if you click through the AAdvantage dining link vs ordering online directly. The difference in price more than outweighs the value of miles. It’s more than a little disingenuous imo.
Bagel sandwich, ordered directly from them: $9
Ordered via AA Dining/Chownow: $12
30% surcharge to earn some miles? No thanks.
As for dining in, there are exactly two restaurants in my area. One is a Jersey Mike’s sub shop, and one is a local Mexican restaurant that isn’t particularly convenient for me to get to. In the past when one of the Dining Rewards programs had a significant signup bonus, I did pick up takeout food at the Mexican place a couple of times (ordered directly). Occasionally, when traveling I receive miles or points from a random restaurant, but I rarely even check nowadays when I am traveling before we pick a restaurant.
#180
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: PHX and LIH
Programs: AA: 2 MM
Posts: 85,576
Taking a look at a local place that I like and might order from:
Bagel sandwich, ordered directly from them: $9
Ordered via AA Dining/Chownow: $12
30% surcharge to earn some miles? No thanks.
As for dining in, there are exactly two restaurants in my area. One is a Jersey Mike’s sub shop, and one is a local Mexican restaurant that isn’t particularly convenient for me to get to. In the past when one of the Dining Rewards programs had a significant signup bonus, I did pick up takeout food at the Mexican place a couple of times (ordered directly). Occasionally, when traveling I receive miles or points from a random restaurant, but I rarely even check nowadays when I am traveling before we pick a restaurant.
Bagel sandwich, ordered directly from them: $9
Ordered via AA Dining/Chownow: $12
30% surcharge to earn some miles? No thanks.
As for dining in, there are exactly two restaurants in my area. One is a Jersey Mike’s sub shop, and one is a local Mexican restaurant that isn’t particularly convenient for me to get to. In the past when one of the Dining Rewards programs had a significant signup bonus, I did pick up takeout food at the Mexican place a couple of times (ordered directly). Occasionally, when traveling I receive miles or points from a random restaurant, but I rarely even check nowadays when I am traveling before we pick a restaurant.