What is an "average" cost to obtain 1K
#31
Ambassador: Alaska Airlines
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: BWI
Posts: 7,390
I would say the average is $10-15K per year. It also heavily depends on where you are based... 1Ks out of IAH spends more than 1Ks out of the coasts. EWR may be the exception. Do not forget GUM based 1Ks who probably bleeds money out of their noses to fly on UA.
1Ks based outside of the USA will naturally have higher spend as well.
As for differentiaing between those who flies on higer fares and those who flies on lower fares, this is why the upgrade hierarchy is based on fare paid. I know those who flies Y/B/M fares almost never miss an upgrade, even on last minute tickets. I have a friend in IAH who buys his tickets for work only 1-3 days in advance and never misses getting an upgrade. He is a GS though.
1Ks based outside of the USA will naturally have higher spend as well.
As for differentiaing between those who flies on higer fares and those who flies on lower fares, this is why the upgrade hierarchy is based on fare paid. I know those who flies Y/B/M fares almost never miss an upgrade, even on last minute tickets. I have a friend in IAH who buys his tickets for work only 1-3 days in advance and never misses getting an upgrade. He is a GS though.
#32
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Jersey Shore/YYZ
Programs: UA 1K, Marriott Plat, Hilton Diamond, Hertz PC
Posts: 12,521
Forgive the ignorance but how in the world does someone fly 100,000 miles at 3 CPM? This implies that a 5,000 mile transcon is $150. Right?
In addition, W fares are 8-11 CPM, and what's the point of being 1K if you're not flying at 30,000 - 60,000 miles in W fares to use GPUs?
For the record, I'm shocked to hear so many people getting 1K for < $4,000. I easily spend $10-15K (minimum) and in some years, well north of $30K.
And, they've flagged me as an over-entitled elite? Their segmentation algorithms and their math are totally worthless.
In addition, W fares are 8-11 CPM, and what's the point of being 1K if you're not flying at 30,000 - 60,000 miles in W fares to use GPUs?
For the record, I'm shocked to hear so many people getting 1K for < $4,000. I easily spend $10-15K (minimum) and in some years, well north of $30K.
And, they've flagged me as an over-entitled elite? Their segmentation algorithms and their math are totally worthless.
Next year is a very very different set of numbers already.
#33
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 4,645
The LGA-IAH/ORD-PDX flights, netting close to 6K EQM, were $127. That's ~ 2 cpm. None of my flights this year (revenue that is) were international, as I used the miles earned for my honeymoon and other trips in C.
Next year is a very very different set of numbers already.
Next year is a very very different set of numbers already.
And, in the context of 1K, 6K worth of 2 CPM is nothing. We've still got to account for another 94K worth of travel.
#34
Suspended
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2012
Location: LAX
Programs: UA1K, HH Gold, Marriott Gold
Posts: 212
I appreciate everyone's responses to my question though. I think this is clearly not linear but it does seem to me that unless you're trying to MR your way to status for the sake of it, you tend to spend $10K+ if you're doing it for business travel.
I'm sure I've hit $30K or more in years with lots of international travel (this year I did no international on UA). I only counted my domestic UA, excluded a handful of US flights that I'll probably credit to UA eventually.
I'm going to spend some time reading those other threads. Didn't mean to stir a previously stirred pot. I do have a better feel for things. I'd guess that UA is making some kind of spread on you if you're at $10-15K in fare revenue, though perhaps not as much as I previously had thought.
I don't begrudge the mileage-runners as they shouldn't begrudge the airline if it finds a way to obstruct them. Meanwhile, I do appreciate the data-points. Curiosity and all.
-Mr. Market
#35
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: LAX NYC
Programs: UA 1K 3.01MM, Global Entry, RCC LIFETIME (pd $2k in '90)), HH GOLD, Pan Am Clipper Club Lifetime
Posts: 178
got 1K for $5273...was able to always firm up a schedule and stick to it. It was a fun experiment to set a goal and achieve it. The patron saint of Mileage Plus was looking out for me.
#36
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: WAS-ish
Programs: UA 1K-MM + UC, Marriott Plat, National Exec
Posts: 1,341
#37
Suspended
Join Date: Nov 1999
Posts: 24,153
Their Game is ending and costing them alot more $$ then it did in the past, they no longer find they can get into Biz on Intl or F on domestic flights and basically have to actually sit in the cabin their tkt was purchased for, heaven forbid
I dont blame COdbaUA for this and fully understand why they are doing what they are. I have many times posted that from Plat up should be Rev based besides Miles based
But they even give out GS like candy to people who havent flown the min, since they will give a company x number of GSs to give to whomever they want,a part of getting the contract
The Game isnt what it once was and it will never be the same as it once was, and many folks simply refuse to accept that and thats where the comes into play.
#38
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 4,645
Quote:
Originally Posted by aacharya
I spent $3,000 to $3,500 to become 1K. Nine of the LGA-ORD/IAH-PDX flights helped (2.7 cpm), and the rest were 4-5cpm flights, some rebookings in Y, etc.
6,000 miles at 2.7 cpm is $162
94,000 miles at 4.5 cpm is $4320
This is above the stated $3,000 to $3,500 to become 1K.
To put this into perspective, getting 94,000 miles at 4.5 cpm is the equivalent to doing 19 transcon flights at a price of $225 each.
Possible. Maybe. Probable. Not so sure.
And, my question is not answered. All of this implies nothing flown in W fare which implies no use of GPUs for > 10 hour flights. And, if that's true, then what's the point? Wouldn't it be better to stay home and have a long nap and a nice meal?
Originally Posted by aacharya
I spent $3,000 to $3,500 to become 1K. Nine of the LGA-ORD/IAH-PDX flights helped (2.7 cpm), and the rest were 4-5cpm flights, some rebookings in Y, etc.
6,000 miles at 2.7 cpm is $162
94,000 miles at 4.5 cpm is $4320
This is above the stated $3,000 to $3,500 to become 1K.
To put this into perspective, getting 94,000 miles at 4.5 cpm is the equivalent to doing 19 transcon flights at a price of $225 each.
Possible. Maybe. Probable. Not so sure.
And, my question is not answered. All of this implies nothing flown in W fare which implies no use of GPUs for > 10 hour flights. And, if that's true, then what's the point? Wouldn't it be better to stay home and have a long nap and a nice meal?
#39
Suspended
Join Date: Nov 1999
Posts: 24,153
To put this into perspective, getting 94,000 miles at 4.5 cpm is the equivalent to doing 19 transcon flights at a price of $225 each.
Possible. Maybe. Probable. Not so sure.
And, my question is not answered. All of this implies nothing flown in W fare which implies no use of GPUs for > 10 hour flights. And, if that's true, then what's the point? Wouldn't it be better to stay home and have a long nap and a nice meal?
I will be in E+ for a my Jan trip LAX-NRT-HKG-SIN-NRT-LAX my JFK-LAX-JFK on the ps will be in C. Net Net 22k EQMs,cost out of pocket $804 spending 5 nights in HKG hanging out. Returning HKG-SIN-NRT cost me $50 more then going HKG-NRT and yields a boat load of EQMs Back in April I did KIX for 3 nights walking around Kyoto
I use my RDMs for 3 trips a yr where the cheapest fare is over .10 cpeqm (most times closer to .15) and a Y award is 80k So I can chose to fly to XXX and pay $1600 and earn 11k in EQMs or do a NY-SIN trip 1 1/2 times and earn 33k or fly EC-WC 4+ time and earn 25k a No-Brainer to me
Im heading to MIA next week for 3 days, its not a rev tkt nor on UA. Im using my BA miles on AA and it cost 15k!EWR-MIA-EWR I could have paid $380 and earned 2k eqm. But that same 380 could get me EC-WC and 6100+ eqms. So its basically how to get the most out of the $$$ you spend
#40
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: WAS-ish
Programs: UA 1K-MM + UC, Marriott Plat, National Exec
Posts: 1,341
Quote:
Originally Posted by aacharya
I spent $3,000 to $3,500 to become 1K. Nine of the LGA-ORD/IAH-PDX flights helped (2.7 cpm), and the rest were 4-5cpm flights, some rebookings in Y, etc.
6,000 miles at 2.7 cpm is $162
94,000 miles at 4.5 cpm is $4320
This is above the stated $3,000 to $3,500 to become 1K.
To put this into perspective, getting 94,000 miles at 4.5 cpm is the equivalent to doing 19 transcon flights at a price of $225 each.
Originally Posted by aacharya
I spent $3,000 to $3,500 to become 1K. Nine of the LGA-ORD/IAH-PDX flights helped (2.7 cpm), and the rest were 4-5cpm flights, some rebookings in Y, etc.
6,000 miles at 2.7 cpm is $162
94,000 miles at 4.5 cpm is $4320
This is above the stated $3,000 to $3,500 to become 1K.
To put this into perspective, getting 94,000 miles at 4.5 cpm is the equivalent to doing 19 transcon flights at a price of $225 each.
Speaking for myself, almost all of my international travel is work-related, and my employer's lowest-economy-fare + 2-week-advance-purchase policy means I'm unlikely to be able to use GPUs next year -- but I'm shooting for 1K anyway. Just because, y'know?
#42
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: ORD
Programs: Hertz Presidents, UA Plat, IHG Plat, MR Plat, HH Gold
Posts: 423
I'm barely going to make platinum with 90 segments this year for about $15k. I usually fly between ORD and IAD. If I flew out of MKE, I would have hit 1k months ago due to increased connections. Somehow, I guess, that would make me a more loyal customer. Makes lots of sense to me...
#43
Join Date: Apr 2008
Programs: UA1k 3mm, HH-LifeDiamond, Mar-LifePlatElite
Posts: 351
So I am on the opposite end of the scale. Those 1k's who pay waaay too much and never get the GS invite, because of company policies.
146575 eqm, and spend is 33,456 = 22.8cpm
I do have probably have another 19,500 eqm's to fly before the year end, and the cost is apx 7500~8000, so I may be on the cusp of GS spending, but only 1 C/D fare international this yr 1 - Z, and a bunch of domestic M/U/E and lower fares.
Lesson is, don't try and get to 1k the way that I have!
146575 eqm, and spend is 33,456 = 22.8cpm
I do have probably have another 19,500 eqm's to fly before the year end, and the cost is apx 7500~8000, so I may be on the cusp of GS spending, but only 1 C/D fare international this yr 1 - Z, and a bunch of domestic M/U/E and lower fares.
Lesson is, don't try and get to 1k the way that I have!
#45
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: NYC
Programs: AA EXP, Hilton GLD, Marriott Plat, NEXUS/GE
Posts: 2,872
Forgive the ignorance but how in the world does someone fly 100,000 miles at 3 CPM? This implies that a 5,000 mile transcon is $150. Right?
In addition, W fares are 8-11 CPM, and what's the point of being 1K if you're not flying at 30,000 - 60,000 miles in W fares to use GPUs?
For the record, I'm shocked to hear so many people getting 1K for < $4,000. I easily spend $10-15K (minimum) and in some years, well north of $30K.
In addition, W fares are 8-11 CPM, and what's the point of being 1K if you're not flying at 30,000 - 60,000 miles in W fares to use GPUs?
For the record, I'm shocked to hear so many people getting 1K for < $4,000. I easily spend $10-15K (minimum) and in some years, well north of $30K.
FT is a strongly biased sample. Most people (even on FT) do not do mileage runs.
I am a 4-figure 1K on my own spend. I don't take mileage runs, but I tend to fly on competitive routes.
Nearly any revenue scheme will be gameable in some way (or annoy employers). Set a revenue threshold in absolute terms? Pure MRs with a bit more disposable income will triple their flying, hit the revenue target, and walk off with even more miles to burn. Set a CPM threshold? Employers will frown on employees picking fares to hit that CPM target.