The dreaded "X" with Global Entry
#151
Join Date: Oct 2017
Posts: 1
The way it's supposed to work is that if you have GE and prior criminal offenses, after six months of no issues the X should stop.
If you've had GE longer than six months, the flag should have been removed. If it wasn't, you need to visit a GE office and ask for "demotion." That is the correct term to remove the flag.
If you've had GE longer than six months, the flag should have been removed. If it wasn't, you need to visit a GE office and ask for "demotion." That is the correct term to remove the flag.
As others have said, this is originally for a juvy detainment that has since been sealed and destroyed. Did you notice this demotion was effective before I spend time trying to get in contact with the office? Thank you.
#152
Join Date: May 2013
Location: New York
Programs: UA Silver, Marriott LTPP, Hertz Five Star
Posts: 1,079
I was specifically told this after the 6th time of the X by a CBP who laughed and said to see a GE office and ask for this "demotion." I even went to an office in Puerto Rico previously and was told they didn't know why because "your profile is clean", the agent flipped his screen around and showed me "no issues" while shrugging his shoulders.
As others have said, this is originally for a juvy detainment that has since been sealed and destroyed. Did you notice this demotion was effective before I spend time trying to get in contact with the office? Thank you.
As others have said, this is originally for a juvy detainment that has since been sealed and destroyed. Did you notice this demotion was effective before I spend time trying to get in contact with the office? Thank you.
I would not be surprised if GE is the same way and the workings of the kiosk may be known by a few officers, but the reason that the kiosk spits out an X (on the GE system side) versus the computer systems CBP officers primarily use is different.
#153
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: ONT/FRA
Programs: AA EXP
Posts: 878
I was specifically told this after the 6th time of the X by a CBP who laughed and said to see a GE office and ask for this "demotion." I even went to an office in Puerto Rico previously and was told they didn't know why because "your profile is clean", the agent flipped his screen around and showed me "no issues" while shrugging his shoulders.
As others have said, this is originally for a juvy detainment that has since been sealed and destroyed. Did you notice this demotion was effective before I spend time trying to get in contact with the office? Thank you.
As others have said, this is originally for a juvy detainment that has since been sealed and destroyed. Did you notice this demotion was effective before I spend time trying to get in contact with the office? Thank you.
#154
Join Date: Sep 2013
Location: ORD
Programs: Once a somebody now a nobody
Posts: 518
Global Entry fail
Not sure if there is a Global Entry thread somewhere but couldn't find it. If so, mods please merge.
So I got global entry bout 1.5 years ago and have taken 4 int'l trips in that time. All 4 int'l legs have flown into ORD. All 4 times I've tried to use the kiosks the slip of paper I received had a giant X over it and said to see an agent. I could see if they randomly made people use the regular process occasionally...but 4/4 seems like there is an issue. Each trip I've had other people with me, all who had Global Entry, all who had zero issues. They were 3 transatlantic trips and 1 Mexico.
Anyone have any issues like or a good contact number/email for the Global Entry folks? I looked at their website and saw a couple contact numbers, but as ti is the gov't, it'd be nice to have some other data points before I reach out.
Thanks!
So I got global entry bout 1.5 years ago and have taken 4 int'l trips in that time. All 4 int'l legs have flown into ORD. All 4 times I've tried to use the kiosks the slip of paper I received had a giant X over it and said to see an agent. I could see if they randomly made people use the regular process occasionally...but 4/4 seems like there is an issue. Each trip I've had other people with me, all who had Global Entry, all who had zero issues. They were 3 transatlantic trips and 1 Mexico.
Anyone have any issues like or a good contact number/email for the Global Entry folks? I looked at their website and saw a couple contact numbers, but as ti is the gov't, it'd be nice to have some other data points before I reach out.
Thanks!
#155
Suspended
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: DCA
Programs: UA US CO AA DL FL
Posts: 50,262
It is possible that some of the data associated with your GE does not match your ticket or passport information. While generally not the case, the better the match the better for you. Make certain that the name match is exact (no extra periods or spaces) in all three.
If that isn't the case, you will find better satisfaction out at the GE station at ORD than by calling or sending a message.
If that isn't the case, you will find better satisfaction out at the GE station at ORD than by calling or sending a message.
#156
Join Date: Feb 2014
Location: PHX
Programs: AA Aluminum, WN B+
Posts: 929
Agree there's something wrong, probably a name mismatch or not reading your fingerprints. If you have dry hands rub your forehead right before you scan them to get some oil on there. When I had my interview the CBP agent said she ran into hard to read fingerprints relatively frequently. Also make sure your name is spelled exactly the same everywhere- including using middle name vs middle initial.
Also I've alerted a mod to merge this with an existing thread on the Trusted Traveler forum (The dreaded "X" with Global Entry).
Also I've alerted a mod to merge this with an existing thread on the Trusted Traveler forum (The dreaded "X" with Global Entry).
#157
Moderator: Travel Safety/Security, Travel Tools, California, Los Angeles; FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: LAX
Programs: oneword Emerald
Posts: 20,653
Also I've alerted a mod to merge this with an existing thread on the Trusted Traveler forum (The dreaded "X" with Global Entry).
#158
Original Member
Join Date: May 1998
Location: NYC
Programs: AA 2MM, Bonvoy LTT, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 14,640
I don’t see ticket mismatch being an issue. Often times GE kiosks at Preclearance in Canada don’t pick up my flight info and I had to manually select it. No issue with X.
#159
Suspended
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Watchlisted by the prejudiced, en route to purgatory
Programs: Just Say No to Fleecing and Blacklisting
Posts: 102,095
Agree there's something wrong, probably a name mismatch or not reading your fingerprints. If you have dry hands rub your forehead right before you scan them to get some oil on there. When I had my interview the CBP agent said she ran into hard to read fingerprints relatively frequently. Also make sure your name is spelled exactly the same everywhere- including using middle name vs middle initial.
Also I've alerted a mod to merge this with an existing thread on the Trusted Traveler forum (The dreaded "X" with Global Entry).
Also I've alerted a mod to merge this with an existing thread on the Trusted Traveler forum (The dreaded "X" with Global Entry).
And like seawolf, when it comes to my use of GE kiosks, my having to manually enter or otherwise confirm my flight info, has not resulted in X on my GE slips.
#160
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Washington, DC
Programs: UA 1K 1MM, AA, DL
Posts: 7,419
#161
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: SJC
Programs: AA, AS, Marriott
Posts: 6,068
No. It will show that good fingerprints have been captured, not whether they match the stored ones. I kept getting the X due to fingerprints until a CBP officer told me the trick of placing my fingers on my forehead before scanning after coming in from a long flight. I haven't had a biometrics issue since. ^
#162
Join Date: Jun 2013
Location: Roswell, GA
Programs: AA EXP 2.8m,Lifetime PLT, Hilton Diamond, IHG PlLT, SPG Gold
Posts: 3,193
Had the x once while clearing at the Dubai airport (you clear customs etc there), talked to the CBP officer there, asking why the X, she was able to do something on her computer, and since then no problems
did not tell me what she did, but it worked
did not tell me what she did, but it worked
#163
Join Date: Sep 2013
Location: CHS
Programs: UA GS, Bonvoy Amabassador, Hertz PC
Posts: 2,589
I have bad psorasis on my fingers. If it flares up and they don't get a good read on my fingers I get the X. At least that is what I attribute it to, because it is almost like the machine times out or can't verify it is me.
Based on the questions I am asked and the agent looking at my fingers, I am on my way in minutes.
Based on the questions I am asked and the agent looking at my fingers, I am on my way in minutes.
#164
Join Date: Oct 2018
Posts: 1
This might not be best thread but had an unusual experience with Global Entry at EWR today. Arrived on UA961 from FRA and went to GE kiosk. Answered questions and a gpbig "X" appeared on screen and kiosk spit out a receipt with a big "X". Agent escorted me then to a holding area where another agent scrutinized my PP AND THEN X-rayed my bag. Then I was left to leave. I asked but they would not say
Has anyone lose experienced this? Shed light on it? Thanks
Has anyone lose experienced this? Shed light on it? Thanks
I am a dual citizen (Italy and USA) and just got GE a few months ago. Flew into LAX from LHR last week and got the same treatment. They took me to a holding area and interrogated me for a half hour. Apparently they knew I had travelled to Pakistan (for a friends wedding) on my Italian passport and wanted to know more. Asked for grooms name address and phone number... as well as my social media handles, job, etc. When I asked if this was going to happen every time I come to America they answered with a half smile and a “maybe yes maybe no”.... and when they told me to leave they said jokingly l, see you next time. <redacted>!
Last edited by TWA884; Oct 17, 2018 at 11:08 pm Reason: Opinion/commentary better left for the policy debate forum.
#165
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: DEN
Programs: UA GS, Marriott Gold
Posts: 174
I am getting the "X" 100% of the time now - getting very frustrating. Always sent to talk to a person, but have never been subjected to any additional security because of it.
I travel a fair amount, so my memory is a bit fuzzy on exact details, but it started sometime in the last year. Sometime after, but not immediately after, I renewed my GE and got a new passport at the same time. So it could be related, but strange that it didn't start occurring right away.
I noticed when I use the GE Kiosk, the process (fingerprints & questions) is the same except that doesn't show me my inbound flight.
At first I just took the X to a person in a special line, they looked at my passport and didn't say anything. I think this happened at SFO and LAX. Then I came into EWR, and then they took me to the holding pen. In this case, the person was more helpful and said that it appeared to be a problem with my fingerprints and that I was still vetted by GE. So thinking that was great info, I started to look into fixing my fingerprints. I was amazed that nothing on the GE website showed how to fix any problem, let alone a specific problem. So I pressed it coming into DEN, got ejected again, went to talk to the guy and tried to ask him how to fix it. I was a little frustrated and something to the tune of "this is worthless now because of the X", and he responded with a terse "you are at the front of the line aren't you?". Needless to say it ended there. He did ask if I had been arrested, which made me doubt if everyone is reading off the same sheet of music.
2 weeks ago, IAD this time, same thing. Person asked me a few questions and let me in. I didn't even bother to ask what he thought I should do.
Anyway - any opinions on how to attack this problem? It seems the airport CBP strategy is failing. I could try to talk to the GE folks at DEN, but their interview schedule is packed until 8 months out, and that's only for new and renewals.
Appreciate any help.
I travel a fair amount, so my memory is a bit fuzzy on exact details, but it started sometime in the last year. Sometime after, but not immediately after, I renewed my GE and got a new passport at the same time. So it could be related, but strange that it didn't start occurring right away.
I noticed when I use the GE Kiosk, the process (fingerprints & questions) is the same except that doesn't show me my inbound flight.
At first I just took the X to a person in a special line, they looked at my passport and didn't say anything. I think this happened at SFO and LAX. Then I came into EWR, and then they took me to the holding pen. In this case, the person was more helpful and said that it appeared to be a problem with my fingerprints and that I was still vetted by GE. So thinking that was great info, I started to look into fixing my fingerprints. I was amazed that nothing on the GE website showed how to fix any problem, let alone a specific problem. So I pressed it coming into DEN, got ejected again, went to talk to the guy and tried to ask him how to fix it. I was a little frustrated and something to the tune of "this is worthless now because of the X", and he responded with a terse "you are at the front of the line aren't you?". Needless to say it ended there. He did ask if I had been arrested, which made me doubt if everyone is reading off the same sheet of music.
2 weeks ago, IAD this time, same thing. Person asked me a few questions and let me in. I didn't even bother to ask what he thought I should do.
Anyway - any opinions on how to attack this problem? It seems the airport CBP strategy is failing. I could try to talk to the GE folks at DEN, but their interview schedule is packed until 8 months out, and that's only for new and renewals.
Appreciate any help.