Rapid Rewards 2.0 begins March 1, 2011
#121
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Texas
Programs: Hyatt Lifetime Globalist
Posts: 454
That is a good question. I am guessing that since future CP earnings are reset to 0 as of 1/1/2011 (unless qual is before 2/28/2011) you will keep your existing CP until 12/2011 and be out of luck for next year. I would call RR CS and find out because that would be terrible if that is how it works. I am losing 40 credits for my next CP that I didn't have to qualify for until 10/2011
#123
Moderator: Southwest Airlines, Capital One
Original Poster
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: California
Programs: WN Companion Pass, A-list preferred, Hyatt Globalist; United Club Lietime (sic) Member
Posts: 21,624
I've already requalified for CP (expires 5/31/2011) so the way I read this I'll get an extra six months in 2012 on the CP. Nice.
What I can't figure out is if I'm screwed on A-list. My A-list expires 3/3/2011. I am already requalified. The way I read it my A-list will only be extended till the end of 2011, where I would have gotten it till 3/3/2012 under the "old" rules. Is that correct?
What I can't figure out is if I'm screwed on A-list. My A-list expires 3/3/2011. I am already requalified. The way I read it my A-list will only be extended till the end of 2011, where I would have gotten it till 3/3/2012 under the "old" rules. Is that correct?
#124
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: OH & NV
Programs: AA Lifetime Plat, WN CP, Latin Pass Bonus
Posts: 3,707
CP requalification
WN FAQ states:
I'm a Companion Pass Member now. What does this change mean to me and my designated Companion?
If you have a Companion Pass at the time of program launch you will retain your Companion Pass in the new program. The length of your eligibility will vary depending on the year of expiration date of your Companion Pass. At the time of launch, if your Companion Pass has an expiration date between 3/1/2011 and 12/31/2011, you will retain your Companion Pass through 12/31/2011. If your Companion Pass has an expiration date in 2012 at the time of launch, you will retain your Companion Pass until 12/31/2012. Following the launch of the new program the Companion Pass Member will be allowed to change their designated Companion 3 times during your qualification period by calling 1-800-IFLYSWA
-----------
Not too clear for me. At the time of Launch (3/1/11), I will have qualifed (100+ credits), for another year, BUT my CP at that time will still be a 4/30/11 expiration date as my New CP will not have been issued by 3/1/11. It is that "At the time of Launch" provision that concerns me.
Hopefully if at Launch you have earned enough credits to be able to extend your CP to 2012, they will extend your CP to 12/31/2012 -- but not what it says. Comment?
I'm a Companion Pass Member now. What does this change mean to me and my designated Companion?
If you have a Companion Pass at the time of program launch you will retain your Companion Pass in the new program. The length of your eligibility will vary depending on the year of expiration date of your Companion Pass. At the time of launch, if your Companion Pass has an expiration date between 3/1/2011 and 12/31/2011, you will retain your Companion Pass through 12/31/2011. If your Companion Pass has an expiration date in 2012 at the time of launch, you will retain your Companion Pass until 12/31/2012. Following the launch of the new program the Companion Pass Member will be allowed to change their designated Companion 3 times during your qualification period by calling 1-800-IFLYSWA
-----------
Not too clear for me. At the time of Launch (3/1/11), I will have qualifed (100+ credits), for another year, BUT my CP at that time will still be a 4/30/11 expiration date as my New CP will not have been issued by 3/1/11. It is that "At the time of Launch" provision that concerns me.
Hopefully if at Launch you have earned enough credits to be able to extend your CP to 2012, they will extend your CP to 12/31/2012 -- but not what it says. Comment?
#125
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: PSM
Posts: 69,232
I think they made a big mistake with the sliding scale on redemptions being this broad. B6 has a similar scale though it is a bit narrower and, from what I've seen, points are generally worth more on more expensive fares, not less. No doubt in my mind that the RR2 program is more mature and robust than TB2 but in this particular area I think WN dropped the ball.
#126
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Home
Posts: 1,910
My flights on WN are usually 2 hours or less. The fares paid range from $100 - $200 each way. I made a-list last year with 32 one ways. For me, the value of RR even with all the other declines was the CP. With flying, CC points and some partner credits (I really didnt go out of my way) I was able to get 100 credits a year. When we had the AMEX option, I was able to to get my wife a CP pass as well.
Maybe I am not the target of WN for the newRR. I will let this year play out with my current a-list and CP. If it doesnt work, that is fine.
Maybe I am not the target of WN for the newRR. I will let this year play out with my current a-list and CP. If it doesnt work, that is fine.
#127
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Oakland, CA
Programs: Southwest A; Marriott Platinum
Posts: 308
see this post
#128
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Depends on the day!
Programs: Marriott/Lifetime Titanium Hyatt/Explorist, Hilton/Silver, IHG Spire,UA Gold
Posts: 17,832
My flights on WN are usually 2 hours or less. The fares paid range from $100 - $200 each way. I made a-list last year with 32 one ways. For me, the value of RR even with all the other declines was the CP. With flying, CC points and some partner credits (I really didnt go out of my way) I was able to get 100 credits a year. When we had the AMEX option, I was able to to get my wife a CP pass as well.
Maybe I am not the target of WN for the newRR. I will let this year play out with my current a-list and CP. If it doesnt work, that is fine.
Maybe I am not the target of WN for the newRR. I will let this year play out with my current a-list and CP. If it doesnt work, that is fine.
#129
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Chicagoland, IL, USA
Programs: WN CP, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 14,192
I think you wouldn't find 10% of FTers who would consider a nonstop DL RT award ticket ATL-PDX "worth $1100," if you could get my routing for $254 (and get back well over 4000 US miles with your paid ticket).
We can all pick and choose specific routes on specific airlines on specific days to make a point. I am sure there are great redemptions available on every airline.
In general, though, knowledgeable people (lucky, gleff, ingy...) consider Skymiles to be bottom-of-the-barrel.
With this WN change, people in the middle of the country (MDW in my case) may do better than they used to with RR. If I watch carefully with reasonable notice, I can usually find a RT WGA fare many places for $250 or less. That's going to cost me 15,000 new WN points, which I'll get for $15,000 spend on the CC. Previously, I'd have to spend $19,200. And those $69 flights will be really cheap in points terms.
Unless I am misunderstanding something.
#130
Moderator: Southwest Airlines, Capital One
Original Poster
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: California
Programs: WN Companion Pass, A-list preferred, Hyatt Globalist; United Club Lietime (sic) Member
Posts: 21,624
1. Login to your account at the top right.
2. Look for a red vertical bar near the right of the page (it might say "Loading" and it might require more than one click). Click on it and the simulator will slide into place from the right.
3. Click the import account info button near the top right of the simulator pane.
2. Look for a red vertical bar near the right of the page (it might say "Loading" and it might require more than one click). Click on it and the simulator will slide into place from the right.
3. Click the import account info button near the top right of the simulator pane.
#131
Join Date: Feb 2010
Posts: 19
On the RR2.0 website, they list their hotel partners. I do not see the Intercontinental Group/Priority Club (Holiday Inn, HIE, Candlewood, Staybridge, etc.) on the new list. They were on the RR1.0. Is this an oversight or will PC not be participating in the new program?
#132
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Phoenix, AZ
Programs: WN CP
Posts: 6,360
No details, yet. This estimate came in response to a question during yesterday's webinar. Ryan Green of SWA said that international redemptions will be priced similar to domestic Anytime redemptions which are 100 points/dollar.
#133
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Danville, CA, USA;
Programs: UA 1MM, WN CP, Marriott LT Plat, Hilton Gold, IC Plat
Posts: 15,722
Well we all knew this was coming but that doesn't make it any less painful.
My initial take is that there will be some pluses and minuses, as may no doubt be true for many.
On the minus side, the value of RR for my short haul flights will see a huge devaluation.
Example #1:
16 low-fare one-ways @ $59 = $944 spend x 6 points = 5664 RR points
Under RR 1.0, I'd receive a RR ticket that I could generally leverage for a $200-300 ticket (just used one to book a trip that would have cost $350).
Under RR 2.0, 5664 RR points only generates $94 in reward airfare Conclusion: Low value short-haul travelers get shafted by RR 2.0
On the plus side:
(1) I won't have to worry about expiration of credit for my dependents, who often accumulate only 2-4 RR credits per year.
Example #2
Mrs. B + 2 children fly 2 roundtrips at total cost of $500 total per person. Under RR 1.0 all credits continuously expire and therefore effectively = $0.
Under RR 2.0, each person receives $500 x 6 pts = 3000 points. The value of these points (which will never expire) is 3000/60 = $50.
Conclusion: Infrequent travelers will be far happier with RR 2.0
(2) I will be well compensated for occasional business travel and high priced leisure tickets.
Example #3
A roundtrip ticket for a typical domestic business trip (infrequent as most of my trips are international) runs $1000 on WN, slightly more on the competition.
Under RR 1.0, I was heavily disincentivized from using WN as I would only receive 2 RR credits which I valued at around $30-40 total v. 8000 miles on competing legacy carrier (includes 100% elite bonus) plus EQM and potential upgrade to F.
Under RR 2.0, I will receive 10k points (anytime fare) = $166 RR credit, which is roughly equivalent to 8 RR credits.
Conclusion: I will have a tough choice between my legacy EQMs and RR 2.0 for business travel, but maybe lean towards WN.
One final note: The credit card program was always disappointing (beyond the initial bonus) and remain so under RR 2.0. However WN always has the opportunity to easily tweak this with bonus offers, etc.
My initial take is that there will be some pluses and minuses, as may no doubt be true for many.
On the minus side, the value of RR for my short haul flights will see a huge devaluation.
Example #1:
16 low-fare one-ways @ $59 = $944 spend x 6 points = 5664 RR points
Under RR 1.0, I'd receive a RR ticket that I could generally leverage for a $200-300 ticket (just used one to book a trip that would have cost $350).
Under RR 2.0, 5664 RR points only generates $94 in reward airfare Conclusion: Low value short-haul travelers get shafted by RR 2.0
On the plus side:
(1) I won't have to worry about expiration of credit for my dependents, who often accumulate only 2-4 RR credits per year.
Example #2
Mrs. B + 2 children fly 2 roundtrips at total cost of $500 total per person. Under RR 1.0 all credits continuously expire and therefore effectively = $0.
Under RR 2.0, each person receives $500 x 6 pts = 3000 points. The value of these points (which will never expire) is 3000/60 = $50.
Conclusion: Infrequent travelers will be far happier with RR 2.0
(2) I will be well compensated for occasional business travel and high priced leisure tickets.
Example #3
A roundtrip ticket for a typical domestic business trip (infrequent as most of my trips are international) runs $1000 on WN, slightly more on the competition.
Under RR 1.0, I was heavily disincentivized from using WN as I would only receive 2 RR credits which I valued at around $30-40 total v. 8000 miles on competing legacy carrier (includes 100% elite bonus) plus EQM and potential upgrade to F.
Under RR 2.0, I will receive 10k points (anytime fare) = $166 RR credit, which is roughly equivalent to 8 RR credits.
Conclusion: I will have a tough choice between my legacy EQMs and RR 2.0 for business travel, but maybe lean towards WN.
One final note: The credit card program was always disappointing (beyond the initial bonus) and remain so under RR 2.0. However WN always has the opportunity to easily tweak this with bonus offers, etc.
#134
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: May 2000
Location: RDU
Programs: AA LT Gold, DL SM, HY Disc, Marriott LT Gold
Posts: 12,507
I ran the math this morning using their calculator. Excluding promos (which I'm sure they'll still run in the new scheme), I would have earned $640 worth of RR2 credit in 2010 using the new scheme, compared to 46 credits under RR1. So my credits were worth $14 each in the new scheme, compared to my actual redemption range of $16-$22/credit, for a roughly 30% devaluation.
But compared to a legacy carrier... on United or American (my non-stop options on Chicago), I would have had 34 segments between work and leisure and about 20k base points. Only two paid segments would have been barely greater than 1000 miles, a half dozen were in the 700-900 mile range, and the rest were all 350-600 miles and would have relegated to 50-seat regional jets.
So while I'm not thrilled - mostly not thrilled about not being able to change fiddle with my return flight time on an award at the last minute - I can now qualify for A-List with only 25 paid flights and be pretty much guaranteed my seat 17D the entire year. Instead of redeeming for MDW-SEA/PDX/SAN/LAS, I'll use them for traveling companions on shorter vacation trips.
My main intrigue now is with the new 50 trip plateau. Right now, I've flown 30-35 flights on WN each of the last three years. Getting to 50 might be tough, but a 15*$59 = $900 investment would earn me a 75% bonus in points for 2012.
But compared to a legacy carrier... on United or American (my non-stop options on Chicago), I would have had 34 segments between work and leisure and about 20k base points. Only two paid segments would have been barely greater than 1000 miles, a half dozen were in the 700-900 mile range, and the rest were all 350-600 miles and would have relegated to 50-seat regional jets.
So while I'm not thrilled - mostly not thrilled about not being able to change fiddle with my return flight time on an award at the last minute - I can now qualify for A-List with only 25 paid flights and be pretty much guaranteed my seat 17D the entire year. Instead of redeeming for MDW-SEA/PDX/SAN/LAS, I'll use them for traveling companions on shorter vacation trips.
My main intrigue now is with the new 50 trip plateau. Right now, I've flown 30-35 flights on WN each of the last three years. Getting to 50 might be tough, but a 15*$59 = $900 investment would earn me a 75% bonus in points for 2012.
#135
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: HOU
Programs: WN CP, A+, UA Sil, MR Amb LTP, Hyatt Plat, HH Dia, National EE
Posts: 466
Not a mistake. Ending their affiliation on 2/24/11. Which is why I'm now taking my business to HHonors.