Community
Wiki Posts
Search

Undocumented immigrant with a valid state ID

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old Jul 16, 2011 | 10:30 am
  #76  
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 26
Originally Posted by catocony
For the paranoid types, ask yourself - how many times has ICE stopped you over the years while inside the US, and what forms of ID did you give, if any? I've only been stopped at highway checkpoints in TX, NM, AZ and CA and it's a verbal Q/A, if even that. They don't check even DLs.
I have been stopped several times, and not just near the TX, NM, AZ and CA border. Several times in upstate NY and like I said before, once at the Fort Lauderdale Amtrak station.

Also, a quick google search reveals that the TSA plans on teaming up with and doing more joint operations with ICE in the future and not just at the airports: http://www.presstv.ir/usdetail/185675.html Just because some random anonymous commenter on this board hasn't run across ICE at the Fort Lauderdale airport, doesn't mean it won't happen in the future. Like poster stated above, it only takes one time to be caught, deported, and banned from the USA. Also, just because you speak pure English and carry a driver's license doesn't mean that you can be worry free. The LEO will still ask you for your citizenship, and while the risks are slim that he will conduct further investigation, if you get caught lying to a federal LEO, I think you will have much bigger problems on your hands. Again, the risks are quite small, but the consequences can be quite severe. Only you can make the determination as to what you are comfortable with.
bigbird12 is offline  
Old Jul 16, 2011 | 7:44 pm
  #77  
10 Countries Visited
20 Countries Visited
30 Countries Visited
20 Years on Site
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Dulles, VA
Programs: United Airlines 1 MM, Marriott Life Titanium
Posts: 2,777
Or just go on vacation and not worry about it? I agree that the OP needs to get his situation straightened out because eventually it will bite him in the ..., but flying down to Florida is less risky than driving on the interstate and getting pulled over for speeding or something.

There are tens of thousands of Haitian and hispanic illegals floating around South Florida, on top of hundreds of thousands of quasi-legal Cubans and actual legit hispanic immigrants. They simply are not going to hassle anyone who seems at all American. The same goes at LA. You may see ICE/CBP guys floating around, but again, on a domestic flight - where they have absolutely zero authority and absolutely no interest in wasting time - they're not going to care.

There are millions of illegals in the US, and they generally function pretty well, regardless of what the paranoid types on Flyertalk seem to advise. If you only listened to the paranoid types, you would believe that there's a cop or Federal officer waiting around every corner to arrest you or strip search you. That simply is not the case. Guys who argue that if you don't declare a candy bar on your Customs form on re-entry, you'll be arrested for lying and thrown in jail. Stuff like that.

The information is incredibly wrong, or are actual corner cases but are given much higher weight on the pros and cons scale. Remember, you can theoretically be arrested and convicted for tearing the label off of a mattress, or in most states, having oral sex, especially on a mattress where you've torn off the tag. You can be arrested, tried, convicted and even incarcerated for littering, for jaywalking, for spitting on a freaking sidewalk.

This board does good work in flagging TSA abuses and everything, but in many cases, like this thread, posters come off as paranoid, scared people who anticipate the worst-possible outcome to just about any interaction with any form of TSA or law enforcement. Even if, in reality, that worst-case scenario is a once-in-many-millions chances of happening. Not to say they don't from time to time, but the odds extremely small, like 0.000001%

I think you have a higher chance of the plane crashing on the way to Florida, and a much higher chance of your car crashing on the way to the airport, than a random ICE/CBP inspection tripping you up.
catocony is offline  
Old Jul 16, 2011 | 7:54 pm
  #78  
FlyerTalk Evangelist
10 Countries Visited
20 Countries Visited
 
Join Date: Nov 1999
Programs: FB PLT again afater a decade as plebian
Posts: 22,938
Originally Posted by thunderbringer
Not to be racist or anything but I'm white, and look american-ish. My English is perfect. I finished high school and college here so I don't think just by looking at me anyone would suspect that I'm an immigrant.
You're not being racist, but merely realistic. I always wondered how that AZ anti-illegal law can be enforced or even be acted upon without hassling everyone, rather than only people who aren't lily white (or who once were but are now leathered).
YVR Cockroach is offline  
Old Jul 18, 2011 | 3:38 pm
  #79  
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: PDX
Posts: 908
Originally Posted by catocony
You may see ICE/CBP guys floating around, but again, on a domestic flight - where they have absolutely zero authority...
I agree with you on everything else you've said but this one. The CBP may set up a random immigration check anywhere within 100 miles of the border. The OP will be departing and arriving in the places that are less than 100 miles from the border. But like you said, the chances of encountering such a checkpoint are very slim.
Knig is offline  
Old Jul 18, 2011 | 3:56 pm
  #80  
Suspended
 
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: DCA
Programs: UA US CO AA DL FL
Posts: 50,253
We're talking about a person who has lived almost his whole life in the USA and has graduated from college here. Slim chance or not, it's reckless to take any chance, particularly because these situations can be sorted out. But, not after an unfortunate incident.
Often1 is offline  
Old Jul 18, 2011 | 4:37 pm
  #81  
20 Nights
50 Countries Visited
5M
15 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: DCA
Programs: FB Gold Privilege
Posts: 419
I am also an imigrant and I have gone to vacations with three of my friends several times. All three of them are illegal and have the said IL driver's license. Go for it, no problem.
fjord is offline  
Old Jul 18, 2011 | 5:11 pm
  #82  
Ari
FlyerTalk Evangelist
10 Countries Visited
20 Countries Visited
30 Countries Visited
20 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Chicago
Posts: 11,667
Originally Posted by ToniCounter
IL and FL are both not safe. I have seen border patrol agent at Ft. Lauderdale Amtrak station as well... which means they probably work anywhere in FL.
That is a VIPR operation which is completely different from CBP/BP/ICE operations at airports. VIPR operations are when the TSA (BDOs/FAMs) go out somewhere, usually to a train or bus station, with the stated goal of preventing and detrrring terrorism by being random and visible. But that would produce no tangible results since they are extremely unlikely to catch any terrorists, so they bring along the local law and some other federal alphabet soup (DEA/ICE/BP) depending on the operation. The operation then becomes about finding and arresting criminals and unlawfully present aliens with terrorism as as the excuse and BDOs end up looking for 'suspicious' brown people while drug dogs sniff away. In other words, the temptation of running a dragnet under the excuse of (and possibly with the funding for) preventing terrorism is unsurpassable.

Compare this with BP checkpoints set up in airports-- these are unrelated to VIPR. These can work one of two ways: The first way is a BP officer standing behind the TSA TDC looking at the documents presented to the TDC and stopping passengers whose documents indicate that they are potentially aliens and then verifying status-- another variation of this is a BP officer in the same location asking everyone if they are US citizens and verifying the status of those who aren't. The second way is to station a team of BP officers in the jetway of a flight and ask boarding passengers if they are US citizens and verifying the status of those who say they aren't; each way has its pros and cons.

The chances of encountering a BP officer at ORD doing an immigration checkpoint are extremely slim due to allocation of resources; not only is ORD a huge airport with numerous checkpoints and flights, but Chicago is not a common origin for air travel by unlawfully present aliens as compared with other airports. The same cannot be said of FLL. Airports near borders (including maritime borders) are good target airports since those airports yield a steady influx of unlawfully present aliens making the trip North to settle at their final destinations. SJU is probably the most popular airport for these types of checks; other popular ones include LAX, SAN, BUF, PHX, MIA and similar. It is possible for FLL to have this type of check though it is not something I've seen there.

Originally Posted by Often1
Don't get your legal advice on FT.
Always a good idea.

Originally Posted by Often1
Go to a good and trustworthy immigration lawyer and get your status adjusted.
Not always an option.

Originally Posted by Often1
Sooner or later, if not on this trip, you will bump into the system. Your bigger risk is not from TSA but from SecureFlight which may kick you out of its system for review by DHS/ICE (or not).
SecureFlight is part of the TSA; it does not run things through the USCIS/CBP database.

Originally Posted by Often1
For what it's worth, CBP was out in force at LAX on Weds PM, doing spot checks on UA flights so don't count on the fact that somebody else has flown 1000 times without a problem. You only need one mess-up.
Were they checking IDs or just asking citizenship, or both?

Originally Posted by bigbird12
I have been stopped several times, and not just near the TX, NM, AZ and CA border. Several times in upstate NY and like I said before, once at the Fort Lauderdale Amtrak station.

Also, a quick google search reveals that the TSA plans on teaming up with and doing more joint operations with ICE in the future and not just at the airports: http://www.presstv.ir/usdetail/185675.html
Again, note the difference between VIPR and airport BP operations. (There are also plenty of stand-alone BP operations).

Originally Posted by bigbird12
Just because some random anonymous commenter on this board hasn't run across ICE at the Fort Lauderdale airport, doesn't mean it won't happen in the future. Like poster stated above, it only takes one time to be caught, deported, and banned from the USA. Also, just because you speak pure English and carry a driver's license doesn't mean that you can be worry free. The LEO will still ask you for your citizenship, and while the risks are slim that he will conduct further investigation, if you get caught lying to a federal LEO, I think you will have much bigger problems on your hands. Again, the risks are quite small, but the consequences can be quite severe. Only you can make the determination as to what you are comfortable with.
Making a false claim of citizenship is a big deal; having a valid DL, perfect English and white skin makes getting caught very unlikely. Nervousness would be the only thing to worry about-- and any BP officer worth his salt knows that IL is one of a few states that doesn't verify status when issuing DLs so additional investigation would be done.

Originally Posted by Often1
We're talking about a person who has lived almost his whole life in the USA and has graduated from college here. Slim chance or not, it's reckless to take any chance, particularly because these situations can be sorted out. But, not after an unfortunate incident.
This can be sorted out before or after an "unfortunate incident" in point of fact; sometimes it can only be sorted out after the fact as a practical matter. An alien who entered with inspection is at a signifigant advantage.
Ari is offline  
Old Sep 25, 2011 | 9:23 pm
  #83  
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Posts: 1
Trip to hawaii

Hey everyone, i had a question for all of you if you dont mind...
Im planning on taking a trip to hawaii but i am "illegal" no papers no anything all i really have is a "matricula" and i was wondering if it was possible for me to take a plane there safely?
alondra021793 is offline  
Old Sep 25, 2011 | 9:32 pm
  #84  
 
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: YYZ
Programs: AC Aeroplan - Elite Status. DL Skymiles - Regular Status
Posts: 509
Originally Posted by alondra021793
Hey everyone, i had a question for all of you if you dont mind...
Im planning on taking a trip to hawaii but i am "illegal" no papers no anything all i really have is a "matricula" and i was wondering if it was possible for me to take a plane there safely?
You need identification to board an airplane.. I have no idea what a "matricula" is, but I'm pretty sure that its not an acceptable form of ID for the TSA..

Do you have a passport from your country? That will work.. The TSA won't check your legal status.
alexb133 is offline  
Old Sep 26, 2011 | 9:16 am
  #85  
mkt
10 Countries Visited
20 Countries Visited
30 Countries Visited
20 Years on Site
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: MIA/SJU/MCO
Programs: AA LT PLT; DL GLD, UA nothing, B6 Mosaic; Emerald Club Executive
Posts: 3,333
Originally Posted by alondra021793
Hey everyone, i had a question for all of you if you dont mind...
Im planning on taking a trip to hawaii but i am "illegal" no papers no anything all i really have is a "matricula" and i was wondering if it was possible for me to take a plane there safely?
Matricula Consular... it's not a recognized ID by the TSA.

If you have your country's passport, you should be ok- it's not their job to check immigration status. If you have a driver's license or other non-driver ID, even better.
mkt is offline  
Old Sep 26, 2011 | 12:37 pm
  #86  
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 3,702
Originally Posted by alexb133
You need identification to board an airplane.. I have no idea what a "matricula" is, but I'm pretty sure that its not an acceptable form of ID for the TSA..

Do you have a passport from your country? That will work.. The TSA won't check your legal status.
My friendly advice is NOT to use a Matricula card. Never use it for TSA. ICE will be called, and that will ruin your trip. In fact, leave that card at home, just in case you are searched.

As another noted, if you have your passport, use that, but if your worried that the Visa may be checked, do you have any credit cards, school identification, work ID? If so use those.

Have fun in Hawaii!
SATTSO is offline  
Old Sep 26, 2011 | 12:56 pm
  #87  
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 3,702
Originally Posted by alexb133
I have no idea what a "matricula" is, but I'm pretty sure that its not an acceptable form of ID for the TSA..
A Matricula Consular Identification, to put bluntly, is an ID that a foreign government gives to its citizens who plan on living in another country illegally, so that they can get basic services, such as utilities, banking accounts, and so on. If the immigrant is living in another country legally, they have no need for this ID, as they will have "official" identifications.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matr%C3%ADcula_Consular

http://www.theamericanresistance.com...a_id_card.html
SATTSO is offline  
Old Sep 26, 2011 | 1:31 pm
  #88  
Ari
FlyerTalk Evangelist
10 Countries Visited
20 Countries Visited
30 Countries Visited
20 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Chicago
Posts: 11,667
Originally Posted by SATTSO
As another noted, if you have your passport, use that, but if your worried that the Visa may be checked, do you have any credit cards, school identification, work ID? If so use those.
But what if they want to do the call-in thing?

That is not the type of website I would cite as authority on this (or any other) topic.
Ari is offline  
Old Sep 26, 2011 | 2:16 pm
  #89  
 
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: YYZ
Programs: AC Aeroplan - Elite Status. DL Skymiles - Regular Status
Posts: 509
Originally Posted by Ari
But what if they want to do the call-in thing?
Then the individual in question would be questioned by CBP.

As far as the article the poster above mentioned, I totally agree with the quote "Specifically, a state or local government official or employee who provides any benefit or service to such a presenter possesses the criminal intent (mens rea) necessary for a felony indictment under Section 274 of the Immigration and Nationality Act"

No agency should accept that card. People can argue all day long, but there's nothing legal about being illegal.
alexb133 is offline  
Old Sep 26, 2011 | 9:35 pm
  #90  
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 3,702
Originally Posted by Ari
But what if they want to do the call-in thing?



That is not the type of website I would cite as authority on this (or any other) topic.

First, regarding your last comment, neither web-site is an "authority". One, I would argue, is more reliable than the other, but both neither are authorities. But I was in a rush for time, and it provided the information to convey what those identifications are. If you are really interested, you can actually find a web-site from our national Congress discussing that particular card, and I would say that site is an authority. But I did not want to spend the time looking for it, as what I needed was on those 2 sites.

Second, regarding your question, the call-in thing would be tricky for an illegal immigrant and perhaps end with a trip with some ICE agents. I would not suggest it. If someone is here illegally, the more questions they are asked, the more likely they are to get caught in a lie.

If you remember, some time ago at SAT a student was taken away by ICE for trying to use the Matricula Consular Identification to gain entry through the TDC. He was and is currently a student at Harvard (it appeared Harvard knew he was illegal, but accepted him anyway). There was a thread about it here on FT. And nationally there was anger on both so-called sides of the issue. Eventually, our government decided he could stay, since his family brought him here illegally when he was a toddler or infant. But I am sure for this particular man it was a major hassle, even though he prevailed.
SATTSO is offline  


Contact Us - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service -

This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.