Last edit by: ChrisFlyer66
For the 2021 shutdown thread, click here: https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/manufactured-spending/2031831-2021-shutdown-thread.html
When reporting/posting here please give as many details as you can or you will be asked for it anyways. Copy and paste the text below and alter as needed.
1. SHUTdn by Bank, Credit Card info. (@m3x, chs3 ,c1t1 and brcl@y)
2. Length of account before closure and CL?
3. Average monthly account balance checking and savings?
4. Volume of ms per month and how many months?
5. Cycle CL?
6. Did you BP using both options?
- BP by issuing bank (@m3x, chs3, c1t1 and brcl@y)
- BP by Vis/MC
7. Did you spell out the bank's full name in an internet forum?
When reporting/posting here please give as many details as you can or you will be asked for it anyways. Copy and paste the text below and alter as needed.
1. SHUTdn by Bank, Credit Card info. (@m3x, chs3 ,c1t1 and brcl@y)
2. Length of account before closure and CL?
3. Average monthly account balance checking and savings?
4. Volume of ms per month and how many months?
5. Cycle CL?
6. Did you BP using both options?
- BP by issuing bank (@m3x, chs3, c1t1 and brcl@y)
- BP by Vis/MC
7. Did you spell out the bank's full name in an internet forum?
2020 Shutdown Thread
#184
Join Date: Mar 2020
Posts: 1
BofA Home Equity Loan and Walmart Bill Pay?
Greetings! I am wondering if anyone has experience using Walmart Bill Pay to pay off either:
1.) A BofA Home Equity loan, or:
2.) BofA credit cards,
and if doing this would make me likely to get shut down. Being able to clear gift cards to pay down my Home Equity loan (and then take the money out again) would be a nice way to clear an endless number of gift cards to pay a legitimate bill.
I don't want to endanger my BofA Platinum Honors status, but I am not sure how to do much MSing easily now that I banned from Walmart MOs.
I would also be interested if anyone has had good success clearing substantial numbers of gift cards with prepaid accounts, and, if so, how he/she went about doing this.
Thank you.
1.) A BofA Home Equity loan, or:
2.) BofA credit cards,
and if doing this would make me likely to get shut down. Being able to clear gift cards to pay down my Home Equity loan (and then take the money out again) would be a nice way to clear an endless number of gift cards to pay a legitimate bill.
I don't want to endanger my BofA Platinum Honors status, but I am not sure how to do much MSing easily now that I banned from Walmart MOs.
I would also be interested if anyone has had good success clearing substantial numbers of gift cards with prepaid accounts, and, if so, how he/she went about doing this.
Thank you.
#185




Join Date: Feb 2012
Posts: 4,631
You may have heard the advice "Don't s... where you eat". It's actually pretty good and applicable to your situation. If your relationship with this bank is really important, you may want to use some other bank for risky experiments.
#186




Join Date: Aug 2017
Location: Dallas, Texas
Programs: AA ExPlat. Marriott Plat, Hyatt Globalist, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 88
Data Points:
Credit Limit 21K
Monthly spend Started 4k and moved up to 16K MS. Two months ago went to straight MS as I was on vacation for 40 days and used other card for spend. Made 8K purchases prior to leaving and paid off via BP and 8K purchases when Returned and BP those.
Payment method monthly: 4x BP at 2k@
2-7 MO deposits at ATM 1k@
Cash payment at ATM 2K max
Balance paid from personal account via electronic transfer
MS type- I had made all purchases from Giftcardmall for many months, switched to Simon two months ago and then cancelled.
I was pushing it on this account as its my only BOA card and I have no other BOA accounts. I was cancelled after accruing around 225K points including 40k signup bonus.
I realize the BP has been noted as a candidate for cancelling but I'm really wondering about the combination of BP and Simon purchases that got me.
#187


Join Date: Mar 2005
Programs: Continental Onepass, Hilton, Marriott, USAir and now UA
Posts: 7,383
I was shut down this month by BOA using the Alaska Air personal card.
Data Points:
Credit Limit 21K
Monthly spend Started 4k and moved up to 16K MS. Two months ago went to straight MS as I was on vacation for 40 days and used other card for spend. Made 8K purchases prior to leaving and paid off via BP and 8K purchases when Returned and BP those.
Payment method monthly: 4x BP at 2k@
2-7 MO deposits at ATM 1k@
Cash payment at ATM 2K max
Balance paid from personal account via electronic transfer
MS type- I had made all purchases from Giftcardmall for many months, switched to Simon two months ago and then cancelled.
I was pushing it on this account as its my only BOA card and I have no other BOA accounts. I was cancelled after accruing around 225K points including 40k signup bonus.
I realize the BP has been noted as a candidate for cancelling but I'm really wondering about the combination of BP and Simon purchases that got me.
Data Points:
Credit Limit 21K
Monthly spend Started 4k and moved up to 16K MS. Two months ago went to straight MS as I was on vacation for 40 days and used other card for spend. Made 8K purchases prior to leaving and paid off via BP and 8K purchases when Returned and BP those.
Payment method monthly: 4x BP at 2k@
2-7 MO deposits at ATM 1k@
Cash payment at ATM 2K max
Balance paid from personal account via electronic transfer
MS type- I had made all purchases from Giftcardmall for many months, switched to Simon two months ago and then cancelled.
I was pushing it on this account as its my only BOA card and I have no other BOA accounts. I was cancelled after accruing around 225K points including 40k signup bonus.
I realize the BP has been noted as a candidate for cancelling but I'm really wondering about the combination of BP and Simon purchases that got me.
Customer with no other affiliation to bank other than credit card making multiple large deposits of cash or cash equivalents and immediately moving the deposits out of the account (by whatever means)
What they see is high velocity of cash flow into and out of the account with no logical explanation for why this is happening.
Account gets sent to Rats who don't like the smell of the cheese they are looking at and shut you down.
You describe (almost) the classic scenario of why banks will shut down an account.
#188




Join Date: Aug 2017
Location: Dallas, Texas
Programs: AA ExPlat. Marriott Plat, Hyatt Globalist, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 88
Think of what the bank was seeing.
Customer with no other affiliation to bank other than credit card making multiple large deposits of cash or cash equivalents and immediately moving the deposits out of the account (by whatever means)
What they see is high velocity of cash flow into and out of the account with no logical explanation for why this is happening.
Account gets sent to Rats who don't like the smell of the cheese they are looking at and shut you down.
You describe (almost) the classic scenario of why banks will shut down an account.
Customer with no other affiliation to bank other than credit card making multiple large deposits of cash or cash equivalents and immediately moving the deposits out of the account (by whatever means)
What they see is high velocity of cash flow into and out of the account with no logical explanation for why this is happening.
Account gets sent to Rats who don't like the smell of the cheese they are looking at and shut you down.
You describe (almost) the classic scenario of why banks will shut down an account.
#189


Join Date: Mar 2005
Programs: Continental Onepass, Hilton, Marriott, USAir and now UA
Posts: 7,383
Just wondering. Do you have a BOA account and if you do, is it still intact? There are lots of reports out there (especially with Chase) that when they can a card, they go above and beyond and can the entire banking relationship.
TIA
#190

Join Date: Sep 2017
Location: SFO/LAX/SAN/LAS/DFW/JFK/LGA/EWR/MIA
Posts: 1,560
really sorry for the super late responses to your comments.
thank you for the details. glad your auto loan was approved. any other issues from them after you had proactively closed your accounts? that was a smart move after the obvious shutdown phone call. no way you would've survived that given your obvious MS. volume wasnt necessarily "excessive" but still definitely noticeable. especially after the auto loan app.
curious if you plan to app for cap1 soon. haha. that would be an interesting test.
yea. i dont think 5k/mo MS on one BofA CC is excessive, but im hoping its "safe enough". ive had BofA for 20+ years. Plat Honors. but no loans of any kind. so no interest from me, but i do have funds with MEdge. and i use BofA as one of my primary banks so i stay away from WMBP or cycling. i do sometimes depo MO, but very rarely.
i do much more MS with chase, amex, citi and obviously none with US Bank. however, i stay away from cash rewards. i believe its been shown for many years that there is a strong correlation between risk alerts, reviews, and shutdowns when financial institutions are losing actual cash vs monopoly money. eg Citi DC vs Citi AA. but when volume is "excessive", currency doesnt matter.
thank you for the details. any updates on your situation? i feel like you had a chance for reinstatement. ive found your story to be super interesting because you didnt MS or do MO. but legit business spend for 20x CL cycle totally raised a flag and manual review. i think it took 14 months because it was legit spend, but prolonged periods of cycling is always one key factor for shutdown.
thank you for the details. so you got shutdown in 6 months? from JUL to DEC? in your case, its clear MS 20k/mo CL + going over CL + WMBP all contributed to the shutdown. also sounds like you did a few brokerage bonuses too. with brokerage firms, they have a much lower degree of risk tolerance due to the business nature, and flags get raised easily. same with deposit accounts that have "excessive" cash volume. banks hate cash going in and out quickly. any MO or cash transactions at all?
The auto loan was approved. I churned 4 of those cards from 2017 to the present. I started MS on my second latest one in august 2018 cycling the card twice for three months after which I would MS ABOUT 10-12K per month which went on until about may this year. Beginning in March I got a second card of the same kind and would divide the same amount of MS across the two accounts. After that I only did as needed to cover travel purchases which amounted to about 10k over 2 months. A "Sr Account Manager who monitors account activity" left a couple voicemails saying he had some questions for me. That's what prompted me to close the accounts. The MS was online from simon the first couple months then just GCM.
curious if you plan to app for cap1 soon. haha. that would be an interesting test.
I don't think that $5K/month is an excessive amount of MSing in one account but, and this is a big but, what is your overall relationship with BOA. Are you a long term valuable customer i.e do you make them money by getting loans, having large balances in other accounts, etc. OR....
Are you sucking them dry with a credit card and bill pay with no other business. I have had a 30 year relationship with my regional bank which has been beneficial for both the bank and me.
I do about $5K/mo in MSing (mostly depositing MOs) into an active checking account which has been going on for at least 8 years without a peep. In truth, I wouldn't expect one.
Are you sucking them dry with a credit card and bill pay with no other business. I have had a 30 year relationship with my regional bank which has been beneficial for both the bank and me.
I do about $5K/mo in MSing (mostly depositing MOs) into an active checking account which has been going on for at least 8 years without a peep. In truth, I wouldn't expect one.
i do much more MS with chase, amex, citi and obviously none with US Bank. however, i stay away from cash rewards. i believe its been shown for many years that there is a strong correlation between risk alerts, reviews, and shutdowns when financial institutions are losing actual cash vs monopoly money. eg Citi DC vs Citi AA. but when volume is "excessive", currency doesnt matter.
When the simon $1k cards came out (July??), the following months I would MS at least 20k a month on my premium rewards card up until November/December (after Walmart implemented their $8k/month for WMBP). I would pretty much max out the BP limits each month (5 on Visa and 5 on BofA rolling 30 days). I did cycle 2-3 times but maybe going to 25k (in total) at most each time on a 20k limit. As you can see, I was much more active than you. I think doing 5k a month will be just fine.
Last edited by GundamWing01; Mar 29, 2020 at 10:43 pm
#191




Join Date: Aug 2017
Location: Dallas, Texas
Programs: AA ExPlat. Marriott Plat, Hyatt Globalist, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 88
No in my original posting I stated I had no other BOA accounts.
#192


Join Date: Apr 2002
Posts: 3,229
Is there any recent history regarding recycling credit limits with Citi? Is this doable, or a no-no?
#193

Join Date: Jul 2014
Posts: 369
I cycle my Citi DC 2-4x monthly without issue. I do have very high limits on other citi cards +30K on 3 cards. Only about 9k on my DC. They will let me transfer CL but require a hard pull so I dont do it. Not sure if its because of my overall limit that they let me or if its standard. I also regularly go over my CL on the DC card without issue but I am constantly paying it.
#194


Join Date: Apr 2002
Posts: 3,229
I cycle my Citi DC 2-4x monthly without issue. I do have very high limits on other citi cards +30K on 3 cards. Only about 9k on my DC. They will let me transfer CL but require a hard pull so I dont do it. Not sure if its because of my overall limit that they let me or if its standard. I also regularly go over my CL on the DC card without issue but I am constantly paying it.
#195




Join Date: Oct 2014
Programs: All of them
Posts: 1,717
I cycle my Citi DC 2-4x monthly without issue. I do have very high limits on other citi cards +30K on 3 cards. Only about 9k on my DC. They will let me transfer CL but require a hard pull so I dont do it. Not sure if its because of my overall limit that they let me or if its standard. I also regularly go over my CL on the DC card without issue but I am constantly paying it.



