First Bag Fees & 2009 OnePass Program Changes
#256
Join Date: Jan 2008
Programs: Conti Plat/1K, SPG Plat, Hyatt Diamond
Posts: 60
larry, maybe you and your thousands of co-workers should value platinums as we spend hundreds of hours on your planes and thousands of dollars paying your salaries
#257


Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Orlando
Programs: DL 4MM/DM, UA 1MM/Gold, AA Paper
Posts: 1,386
It was interesting that CO Insider, the OP, said that this change could not be rolled out in August with the other changes. My question is WHY????? All sorts of answers come to mind.
#258
FlyerTalk Evangelist


Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: A menace to everything in the sky. Yes. Even birds.
Programs: Eh+ Rapid Rolleyes
Posts: 14,522
I guess I thought CO was above the stupidity of taking a big fat dump on their best customers.
I guess I was wrong.
Why airlines think saving nickels per flight (which is what we're talking when we're talking miles) is going to do anything when they could be offering some sort of value added service that people will pay for is beyond me.
Airlines created the mess that they're in. And, apparently, they're not smart enough to get themselves out of it.
Dig up CO. Dig up.
I guess I was wrong.
Why airlines think saving nickels per flight (which is what we're talking when we're talking miles) is going to do anything when they could be offering some sort of value added service that people will pay for is beyond me.
Airlines created the mess that they're in. And, apparently, they're not smart enough to get themselves out of it.
Dig up CO. Dig up.
#259
Original Poster
Company Representative, United Airlines
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Chicago, Houston, or somewhere in between
Posts: 2,176
Originally Posted by nycnnj
I personally think that the benefits and services in place when a ticket is purchased should be delivered; changes should be applied to tickets "purchased after a certain date" and not to previously-purchased tickets "flown after a certain date". For example, I purchased a ticket for non-elites a while back based on a number of factors, including no bag fee for them, and now the terms of the "contract" have changed. I think that's bad.
Actually, craz, for now we are (and at least we didn't call them "enhancements" this time). I can't say that we won't make minor adjustments over the next year (for better and for worse in the eyes of our customers). Such is the nature of this volatile business. I will say that based on the current environment, we have no further major program changes anticipated in the near future.
This is the reason I left US Airways and got status matched to CO.
So my questions to CO Insider, are:
The drop of the 500 minimum mile is inline w/ UA and apparently being changed due to the pending *A membership. Does this mean that CO will:
A) Change the elite levels to 25k, 50k, 100k like UA and US?
B) Be modifying the elite upgrades?
C) Change the way elite is earned, i.e. get rid of the "50%" earning on the cheaper economy fairs so that elites always earn at least 100% and "1" segment per flight (even if it is not booked on co.com) -- especially if the threshold to earning Plat changes.
The elite percentage change (i.e 25 / 100 /100 ) is inline w/ UA.
Thanks....
So my questions to CO Insider, are:
The drop of the 500 minimum mile is inline w/ UA and apparently being changed due to the pending *A membership. Does this mean that CO will:
A) Change the elite levels to 25k, 50k, 100k like UA and US?
B) Be modifying the elite upgrades?
C) Change the way elite is earned, i.e. get rid of the "50%" earning on the cheaper economy fairs so that elites always earn at least 100% and "1" segment per flight (even if it is not booked on co.com) -- especially if the threshold to earning Plat changes.
The elite percentage change (i.e 25 / 100 /100 ) is inline w/ UA.
Thanks....
First Checked Bag Fee. For travel within the U.S. and between the U.S. and Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin Islands and Canada, customers will be charged $15 for the first checked bag. OnePass Elite members, SkyTeam Elite members, anyone else eligible for EliteAccess (including full-fare Y class and Chase Presidential Plus cardmembers), and avtive military personnel traveling on orders will be exempt.
A quick question. Does this mean that if someone in my family traveling with me on the same PRN and therefore having my status will not be charged for a bag? Somehow, I don't think so but I have to ask.
A quick question. Does this mean that if someone in my family traveling with me on the same PRN and therefore having my status will not be charged for a bag? Somehow, I don't think so but I have to ask.
Scott as a "former" CO plat, who is now 1K on UA and only Silver for this year on CO, two big questions....
(Its nice to cut benifits to UA levels re miles but...)
(1) Will CO adjust its award availability so that the seat availability on its own metal (and other *A carriers) is similar to or better than UA? Put another way is CO going to increase its currently almost humourous level of regular (not "premium") level award availability to at least that of UA?
(2) Will CO offer a similar benifit to SWUs on UA?
(Its nice to cut benifits to UA levels re miles but...)
(1) Will CO adjust its award availability so that the seat availability on its own metal (and other *A carriers) is similar to or better than UA? Put another way is CO going to increase its currently almost humourous level of regular (not "premium") level award availability to at least that of UA?
(2) Will CO offer a similar benifit to SWUs on UA?
As for systemwide upgrades (SWUs), we have no current plans. Nor do we have any current plans to discontinue unlimited free upgrades for all Elite tiers or raise our top Elite tier to 100,000 Elite Qualifying Miles.
Last edited by UA Insider; Sep 6, 2008 at 7:54 am Reason: typo in response to CopperSteve
#260
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: NJ
Programs: MM - GOLD, HH, Mariott
Posts: 291
I for one am VERY DISAPPOINTED with CO's decision to reduce the bonus for Plat's to 100%. There were already very few differnces between Gold and Plat, and this just blurs the line more.
Why penalize your best customers? This is a business, and so is my decision as to where I spend my airline dollars! This one rates right up there with zero EQP's when you purchase a ticket anywhere except CO.com.
Bunches of folks on this board with defend this decision, but I can assure you that the masses of flyers that don't even know this site exists are also disappointed.
It's not too late to reverse this horrible decision and give Plats our well-deserved 125% bonus!!!!
Why penalize your best customers? This is a business, and so is my decision as to where I spend my airline dollars! This one rates right up there with zero EQP's when you purchase a ticket anywhere except CO.com.
Bunches of folks on this board with defend this decision, but I can assure you that the masses of flyers that don't even know this site exists are also disappointed.
It's not too late to reverse this horrible decision and give Plats our well-deserved 125% bonus!!!!
As I sit at the IAH PC and read this doing a MR to ensure Plat status next year, I have the same question, just go for gold. Actually, I think it does'nt matter what airline you fly because in the end they will all be the same. CO had a great product that standed out but now they are like every other airline and being faithful doesn't matter.
#261
FlyerTalk Evangelist


Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: A menace to everything in the sky. Yes. Even birds.
Programs: Eh+ Rapid Rolleyes
Posts: 14,522
CO - why not charge these fees to folks buying only the lowest fares? It's insulting to pay $700 to fly between EWR and DCA and then have to pay $15 to check my bag.
Then people would, maybe, purchase higher fares instead of always choosing the lowest fare. @:-)
Same with mileage bonuses and minimums. CO does this to an extent to drive bookings directly through CO - why not take it a slight step further?
Or, offer a JK like model. I know they're not a great example when it comes to a profitable airline, but they're onto something.
And, by the way, brilliant timing, announcing this on a day when oil is down 8% for the week. You guys must have really bad hedges.
Then people would, maybe, purchase higher fares instead of always choosing the lowest fare. @:-)
Same with mileage bonuses and minimums. CO does this to an extent to drive bookings directly through CO - why not take it a slight step further?
Or, offer a JK like model. I know they're not a great example when it comes to a profitable airline, but they're onto something.
And, by the way, brilliant timing, announcing this on a day when oil is down 8% for the week. You guys must have really bad hedges.
#262
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Philadelphia,PA
Programs: United 1K,Marriott Platinum Premier,IHC Platinum Ambassador,Hilton Gold
Posts: 1,898
Larry seems like a cool guy to me..Larry is having to make some hard choices and its not allways popular,but I think he is doing what he has to do to stay in business..Larry,if your reading this..I support your choices even though change can be hard to accept,I think your making prudent choices given what you have to work with..
#263
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Perth
Programs: QFF SG
Posts: 30
Would have been nice to get at least one days notice before the changes came into effect so you could have planned your travel around it. Would be extremely poor form if you had someone book a ticket at 7am this morning for a flight in November and then find out 3 hours later they will be getting stung a $15 fee as well on the day they fly.
#264
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: CLE
Programs: CO Gold - 1MM, IC Plat, Hertz PC
Posts: 1,644
While I do not support the changes, especially the mileage bonus without adjusting for the golds. This could end up causing a thinning of the herd of plats. Since I am CLE based I am stuck, so I will look forward to more opportunities at EUAs in 2009 and 2010 from this.
#265




Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: NYC
Programs: DL Plat, 1 MM; SPG LT Plat (RIP); Marriott LT Titanium; Fairmont Plat (RIP), DL Kryptonium Medallion
Posts: 1,859
I'm trying to come up with reasons, at the margin, to bother reaching Plat and only come up with 2:
1. Higher priority for upgrades. Might matter for:
a. Routes that are super elite-heavy
b. People who buy tickets between the Plat and Gold upgrade windows
2. No change fees on award tickets (I think) and some minor things. Matters for people who need to make a lot of dummy or frequently-changing award bookings.
In all seriousness, I think there are a few people who would benefit from the above, but not that many.
1. Higher priority for upgrades. Might matter for:
a. Routes that are super elite-heavy
b. People who buy tickets between the Plat and Gold upgrade windows
2. No change fees on award tickets (I think) and some minor things. Matters for people who need to make a lot of dummy or frequently-changing award bookings.
In all seriousness, I think there are a few people who would benefit from the above, but not that many.
#266


Join Date: Mar 2005
Programs: Continental Onepass, Hilton, Marriott, USAir and now UA
Posts: 7,389
Hi radonc1, if you're eligible for the exemption, then everyone in your reservation will be given the exemption as well.
Thank you Scott for the quick response
Radonc1
Thank you Scott for the quick response
Radonc1
#267
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 32
Let the Fed'Exing to Larry Begin!!!!!
We certainly know Scott reads this forum (and perhaps Larry). While that's great, here's my challenge to everyone who has voiced their displeasue today--
Send a letter via courier to Larry's attention. We'll get more traction from a courier based letter campaign than simply posting here.
#268
Join Date: Jan 2008
Programs: Conti Plat/1K, SPG Plat, Hyatt Diamond
Posts: 60
larry is a good guy, thats why i am baffled by the kick to plats. It is just a bad decision to lower the 125% bonus to 100% for platinums. I have no problem paying higher fares or fuel surcharges. However, to keep your best customers loyal it is a bad decision to give minimal benefits for achieving platinum status over gold. As you can see above many platinums are questioning the advantage of going for platinum vs. gold. my 2 cents
#269

Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: TPA & MCO
Programs: DL Diamond, AA EXP & UA Gold
Posts: 3,051
As annoyed I am by these changes, there are more changes that CO could have implemented but thankfully didn't. (maybe they will in the future!
)
-eliminate meals at meal time for the Y cabin (I haven't seen many ads lately boasting this feature)
-eliminate pillows and blankets in Y;
-eliminate free booze and free wireless in the PC;
-increase redeposit fees to $100;
-eliminate mixing and matching of awards (saver Y award going out, EasyPass J coming home, for example). Lots of airlines currently don't allow this;
-eliminate elite bonuses when flying partners;
-reduce BF catering (one less main course choice maybe, downsize the cheese course, drop the grand marnier, for example);
So, although today's actions really left a bad taste in my mouth, I'm trying to keep things in perspective. They did, after all, throw us a few bones recently:
--Flyertalk DO
--PDA feature
--Million Miler program
--upcoming inflight internet access
--elimination of the dreaded BF 24 hour rule.
)-eliminate meals at meal time for the Y cabin (I haven't seen many ads lately boasting this feature)
-eliminate pillows and blankets in Y;
-eliminate free booze and free wireless in the PC;
-increase redeposit fees to $100;
-eliminate mixing and matching of awards (saver Y award going out, EasyPass J coming home, for example). Lots of airlines currently don't allow this;
-eliminate elite bonuses when flying partners;
-reduce BF catering (one less main course choice maybe, downsize the cheese course, drop the grand marnier, for example);
So, although today's actions really left a bad taste in my mouth, I'm trying to keep things in perspective. They did, after all, throw us a few bones recently:
--Flyertalk DO
--PDA feature
--Million Miler program
--upcoming inflight internet access
--elimination of the dreaded BF 24 hour rule.
#270
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: ewr,swf,fll
Posts: 835
Would have been nice to get at least one days notice before the changes came into effect so you could have planned your travel around it. Would be extremely poor form if you had someone book a ticket at 7am this morning for a flight in November and then find out 3 hours later they will be getting stung a $15 fee as well on the day they fly.

