One columnist gets it -- take on the TSA
#31
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Colorado
Programs: TSA
Posts: 2,745
answer
Originally Posted by Wally Bird
Caught by whom ? The airlines' check-in staff (where ID is initially required) or at the TSA checkpoint ?
Were these people real, nasty terrorists
or did the TSA once more exceed its mandate by 'catching' miscreants unrelated to any aviation threat ?
Were these people real, nasty terrorists
or did the TSA once more exceed its mandate by 'catching' miscreants unrelated to any aviation threat ?
#32
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Salish Sea
Programs: DL,AC,HH,PC
Posts: 8,972
Originally Posted by eyecue
Caught at the CP. Taken away by the LEO's.
#33
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 940
Jim Smith walks up to the ticket counter and gets a ticket that he had paid for one month ago. He then meets up with Andy White in the lobby and gives him the ticket. Andy White doesnt have Jim Smiths ID. When he gets to the CP, there will be a problem. There is currently a lawsuit over this exact issue. It will be interesting to see how it is decided.
Again, checking of a ID to a BP does not provide any kind of security. It provides more of a hassle.
I seriously doubt that. We have had estimates that were off by more than 1000. I have seen the load forecasts. I know that they are for the week, not by the day!
Yeah but how big is your family?
I cant? Well the guy that wrote the article sure did!
Read what was wrote also.
False. At DTW and SMF, they make you hand the BP across the WTMD. In EUG, the BP gets confiscated before you even get a chance to dump your carry-ons into the x-ray, you get the BP back after passing through the WTMD.
BTW the SSSS system is the biggest bunch of BS I've ever seen.
#34
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 10,034
Originally Posted by screenerx
Im sorry but I don't seen many contract ticket checkers up near the equipment and on the other side. PHX checks on the side before the Walkthru, a TSA person btw and on the Walkthru side. TUS does the same. Chicago ticket checker, contract, just the tickets then directs you to a line and then the person at the walkthru takes the ticket and has you screened if your SSSS.
The examples I cited were done by TSA-uniformed people after the BP/ID check. I handed my BP to the TSA guy on the other side of the WTMD. Same thing at SMF. EUG had three different TSA people hold my boarding pass before getting it back after walking through the WTMD.
#35
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Colorado
Programs: TSA
Posts: 2,745
well
Originally Posted by Wally Bird
Are these the same people you refer to in a previous post - still under investigation ? I'd certainly be interested in knowing what if any charges are laid against them. Except for the Patriot Act excesses, I am not aware that simply carrying a false ID is a crime per se. Indicative of criminal intent perhaps. Terrorism ? Highly doubtful IMHO.
#36
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Colorado
Programs: TSA
Posts: 2,745
hmmm
Originally Posted by screenerx
Andy White should be screened and still allowed to fly. It's none of our business why the ticket was giving up to him. If he is screened and cleared by you guys, how is he a threat to aviation? We have had this dicussion in prior threads.
Again, checking of a ID to a BP does not provide any kind of security. It provides more of a hassle.
No, its fact. On average we had about 1500 passengers on my shift a day. During holidays that picked up to about 2500 passengers. You want to know something , it helped are management decide when overtime should be done and when it shouldn't.
No family but mother and father who were also in the military about 15 years ago with less salary then me could fly from overseas back home and visit family. They did it on comerical flights to. If you planned ahead, the size family wouldn't matter.
Difference between you and him, he proably flies through a lot and you only work at one. His observation might be on point for the airports he flies through.
Read what was wrote also.
Im sorry but I don't seen many contract ticket checkers up near the equipment and on the other side. PHX checks on the side before the Walkthru, a TSA person btw and on the Walkthru side. TUS does the same. Chicago ticket checker, contract, just the tickets then directs you to a line and then the person at the walkthru takes the ticket and has you screened if your SSSS.
Read what was wrote also.
Im sorry but I don't seen many contract ticket checkers up near the equipment and on the other side. PHX checks on the side before the Walkthru, a TSA person btw and on the Walkthru side. TUS does the same. Chicago ticket checker, contract, just the tickets then directs you to a line and then the person at the walkthru takes the ticket and has you screened if your SSSS.
BTW the SSSS system is the biggest bunch of BS I've ever seen.
#37
Original Poster
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: BWI
Programs: AA Gold, HH Diamond, National Emerald Executive, TSA Disparager Gold
Posts: 15,180
Originally Posted by eyecue
Wow that is really a class X airport. We run 17k to 48 k on our shift. There is a larger error probability.
As that is a pretty decent margin of error, it sounds like the incompetence isn't with the airlines.
If TSA were even remotely efficient, you'd think they'd have statisticians that could have at least figured out the numbers of pax within 3 standard deviations. Heck, there's even software that could figure out solutions like that. They'd at least be able to predict with reasonable accuracy the number of screeners needed.
Last edited by Superguy; Apr 1, 2005 at 1:51 pm
#38
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 940
Eyecue,
Yeah but like every airport in this nation, the security lanes and people staffing them to make up for the numbers. We had on average only one lane open and a selectee lane and were able to process most people through w/o a problem.
O'Hare, the busy airport of the world, has about 6 or 7 lanes in terminal two for one checkpoint and during peak times all are open and the lines aren't really that long.
Why because the airport and TSA work together to know when the most passengers are coming through and when extra flights are added so a airline doesn't get hit with huge delays because they don't inform TSA.
Ok, I'll redo that. The whole airport security system by TSA is a bunch of BS. Ive talked to people in the military since being in that were asked to test it and said how much of a joke it is. And some of these guys know more about fighting terrorists and then any Screening Manager, FSD, AFSD, Supervisor, Lead, or screener does.
I got fed up with working with TSA because it was more harassment then it was help. The x-rays that are being used to check carry-ons are bad, you'd be lucky to catch someone thats planted a explosive in there because of all the items in a bag that a person carries. Then again you don't really have to do that because you can just strap in on you and never get caught.
Airport security didn't fail America on 9/11, Government intelligence did but security has taken the fall.
This is one of your most recent posts and why I have some issue with you.
How do you know for a fact that the people sending the new procedures and stuff down to you guys are security experts? What have some of these people done that make them so.
Fact is, a lot of people here and around the world proably know better because the guys that come up with these planes to attack America are not seasoned veterns. They don't do multiply attacks and learn from mistakes. They usually do one major attack that kills everyone involved so no lesson can be learned.
If 9/11 had been done by experts, that 4th plane would have hit it's target.
How about instead of giving these people grief for their comments all the time you just see what they write and think about what it is their saying. A lot of it makes sense.
Oh and a for instance.
In the next few weeks Ill be traveling on orders overseas and I've already talked to my airport here and they said just bring my orders and the airline can remove the SSSS if I should get it.
In O'Hare they said that had been done away with and all people get screened with SSSS.
Once you start to travel you start to understand the hassel, and I've flown through only a few airports. Some of these people fly thru hundreds a year.
Wow that is really a class X airport. We run 17k to 48 k on our shift. There is a larger error probability.
O'Hare, the busy airport of the world, has about 6 or 7 lanes in terminal two for one checkpoint and during peak times all are open and the lines aren't really that long.
Why because the airport and TSA work together to know when the most passengers are coming through and when extra flights are added so a airline doesn't get hit with huge delays because they don't inform TSA.
You sure have seen a lot of b.s. in your life, each one you attest to being the biggest.
I got fed up with working with TSA because it was more harassment then it was help. The x-rays that are being used to check carry-ons are bad, you'd be lucky to catch someone thats planted a explosive in there because of all the items in a bag that a person carries. Then again you don't really have to do that because you can just strap in on you and never get caught.
Airport security didn't fail America on 9/11, Government intelligence did but security has taken the fall.
Why are you digging me?
I feel better knowing that you ran into aviation security experts in a shoe store.
Fact is, a lot of people here and around the world proably know better because the guys that come up with these planes to attack America are not seasoned veterns. They don't do multiply attacks and learn from mistakes. They usually do one major attack that kills everyone involved so no lesson can be learned.
If 9/11 had been done by experts, that 4th plane would have hit it's target.
How about instead of giving these people grief for their comments all the time you just see what they write and think about what it is their saying. A lot of it makes sense.
Oh and a for instance.
In the next few weeks Ill be traveling on orders overseas and I've already talked to my airport here and they said just bring my orders and the airline can remove the SSSS if I should get it.
In O'Hare they said that had been done away with and all people get screened with SSSS.
Once you start to travel you start to understand the hassel, and I've flown through only a few airports. Some of these people fly thru hundreds a year.
#39
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Colorado
Programs: TSA
Posts: 2,745
oh
Originally Posted by screenerx
Eyecue,
Yeah but like every airport in this nation, the security lanes and people staffing them to make up for the numbers. We had on average only one lane open and a selectee lane and were able to process most people through w/o a problem.
O'Hare, the busy airport of the world, has about 6 or 7 lanes in terminal two for one checkpoint and during peak times all are open and the lines aren't really that long.
Why because the airport and TSA work together to know when the most passengers are coming through and when extra flights are added so a airline doesn't get hit with huge delays because they don't inform TSA.
Ok, I'll redo that. The whole airport security system by TSA is a bunch of BS. Ive talked to people in the military since being in that were asked to test it and said how much of a joke it is. And some of these guys know more about fighting terrorists and then any Screening Manager, FSD, AFSD, Supervisor, Lead, or screener does.
I got fed up with working with TSA because it was more harassment then it was help. The x-rays that are being used to check carry-ons are bad, you'd be lucky to catch someone thats planted a explosive in there because of all the items in a bag that a person carries. Then again you don't really have to do that because you can just strap in on you and never get caught.
Airport security didn't fail America on 9/11, Government intelligence did but security has taken the fall.
This is one of your most recent posts and why I have some issue with you.
How do you know for a fact that the people sending the new procedures and stuff down to you guys are security experts? What have some of these people done that make them so.
Fact is, a lot of people here and around the world proably know better because the guys that come up with these planes to attack America are not seasoned veterns. They don't do multiply attacks and learn from mistakes. They usually do one major attack that kills everyone involved so no lesson can be learned.
If 9/11 had been done by experts, that 4th plane would have hit it's target.
How about instead of giving these people grief for their comments all the time you just see what they write and think about what it is their saying. A lot of it makes sense.
Oh and a for instance.
In the next few weeks Ill be traveling on orders overseas and I've already talked to my airport here and they said just bring my orders and the airline can remove the SSSS if I should get it.
In O'Hare they said that had been done away with and all people get screened with SSSS.
Once you start to travel you start to understand the hassel, and I've flown through only a few airports. Some of these people fly thru hundreds a year.
Yeah but like every airport in this nation, the security lanes and people staffing them to make up for the numbers. We had on average only one lane open and a selectee lane and were able to process most people through w/o a problem.
O'Hare, the busy airport of the world, has about 6 or 7 lanes in terminal two for one checkpoint and during peak times all are open and the lines aren't really that long.
Why because the airport and TSA work together to know when the most passengers are coming through and when extra flights are added so a airline doesn't get hit with huge delays because they don't inform TSA.
Ok, I'll redo that. The whole airport security system by TSA is a bunch of BS. Ive talked to people in the military since being in that were asked to test it and said how much of a joke it is. And some of these guys know more about fighting terrorists and then any Screening Manager, FSD, AFSD, Supervisor, Lead, or screener does.
I got fed up with working with TSA because it was more harassment then it was help. The x-rays that are being used to check carry-ons are bad, you'd be lucky to catch someone thats planted a explosive in there because of all the items in a bag that a person carries. Then again you don't really have to do that because you can just strap in on you and never get caught.
Airport security didn't fail America on 9/11, Government intelligence did but security has taken the fall.
This is one of your most recent posts and why I have some issue with you.
How do you know for a fact that the people sending the new procedures and stuff down to you guys are security experts? What have some of these people done that make them so.
Fact is, a lot of people here and around the world proably know better because the guys that come up with these planes to attack America are not seasoned veterns. They don't do multiply attacks and learn from mistakes. They usually do one major attack that kills everyone involved so no lesson can be learned.
If 9/11 had been done by experts, that 4th plane would have hit it's target.
How about instead of giving these people grief for their comments all the time you just see what they write and think about what it is their saying. A lot of it makes sense.
Oh and a for instance.
In the next few weeks Ill be traveling on orders overseas and I've already talked to my airport here and they said just bring my orders and the airline can remove the SSSS if I should get it.
In O'Hare they said that had been done away with and all people get screened with SSSS.
Once you start to travel you start to understand the hassel, and I've flown through only a few airports. Some of these people fly thru hundreds a year.
#40
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 940
I get it now! You are an Xscreener Just posting sour grapes! I dont dish out half the grief to the FF as they do to TSA. You logic is flawed as is your sense of patriotism and devotion to an employer. Its probably a good thing that you joined the military as they can certainly show you how to get things done. If your theory on terrorists is correct, nothing would have come out of the investigation of the PAN AM flight in Scotland.
My theory on terrorists is pretty much on key. Their all rookies pretty much when it comes to what happens, with a few expections. Great amounts of planning may go into the stuff but in the end planning don't mean nothing unless you successfully pull it off.
I'm enjoying the hell out of the military so far. I really want to get out there and finally start doing my rate. As for showing me how to get things done, I've already learned how to do that before joining the military, or my arse would still be stuck in the TSA and maybe believing I was doing something good for the flying public.
BTW your logic is flawed, if I was a xscreener here to pour sour grapes I would do so to all screeners here. Big difference between you and the others that post here, you feel this people don't know a damn thing and the stories they post have to be lies because it just can't happen in your eyes, such as the poster in the other thread that had a screwdriver and something else in her purse but it was never caught.
#42
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Miami, FL
Programs: AA EXP/Marriott Plat/Hertz PC
Posts: 12,724
Originally Posted by eyecue
Since a false ID was presented and the is a requirement to present ID at airports, this is an example of impersonation. Attempting to gain a benefit by by assuming a false identity.
#43
Suspended
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Desert city where Venice, Paris and NY are within walking distance
Programs: Delta and Hilton make a lot of $$ off me
Posts: 671
Back off the TSA
I am amazed sometimes to hear the anti-TSA rantings of some flyers?
First off don;t blame the front line agents for stupid policies. They are told to enforce certain rules and do it whether the rules make sense or not. Your Joe Blow police officer enforces the laws written by politicans, he doesn't pick and choose what to enforce (or at least shouldn't).
2. In any organization there will be good employees and bad ones. Don't pick one incident that happened to you and based on that one incident paint all TSA employees as being the same.
3. Were you happier with the pre-TSA $7 an hour security we had? I know I wasn't.
I have personally never had any problems with the TSA and I fly every week. Some TSA employees are friendlier but that's about it. I follow the rules, don't try to be a jackass and all works well. If you are a jerk, are beligerent, have a me vs them attitude to start with, you will cause trouble.
So in short, chill out, take your shoes off, take your belt off, go through the machine and get on with your life.
First off don;t blame the front line agents for stupid policies. They are told to enforce certain rules and do it whether the rules make sense or not. Your Joe Blow police officer enforces the laws written by politicans, he doesn't pick and choose what to enforce (or at least shouldn't).
2. In any organization there will be good employees and bad ones. Don't pick one incident that happened to you and based on that one incident paint all TSA employees as being the same.
3. Were you happier with the pre-TSA $7 an hour security we had? I know I wasn't.
I have personally never had any problems with the TSA and I fly every week. Some TSA employees are friendlier but that's about it. I follow the rules, don't try to be a jackass and all works well. If you are a jerk, are beligerent, have a me vs them attitude to start with, you will cause trouble.
So in short, chill out, take your shoes off, take your belt off, go through the machine and get on with your life.
#44
FlyerTalk Evangelist

Join Date: Feb 1999
Location: Seat 1A, Juice pretty much everywhere, Mucci des Coins Exotiques
Posts: 34,337
Originally Posted by da_guy
3. Were you happier with the pre-TSA $7 an hour security we had? I know I wasn't.
So in short, chill out, take your shoes off, take your belt off, go through the machine and get on with your life.
#45
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 940
3. Were you happier with the pre-TSA $7 an hour security we had? I know I wasn't.
The government and airlines made the list of things allowed on and off a plane before TSA. The government made the procedures for how a hijacking will be handled.
Sure box cutters were used to take control of the flight crew, but then again it was procedure to work with terrorists in a hijack situation rather then fight them before pre Tsa.
2. In any organization there will be good employees and bad ones. Don't pick one incident that happened to you and based on that one incident paint all TSA employees as being the same.


