Deciding on a Oneworld Frequent Flyer Program? Help is here.
#1666
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Not here; there!
Programs: AA Lifetime Gold
Posts: 34,985
I think the end result based on what I'm seeing here is that I should stay away from QR, and go to IB. I know I won't do 4 segments in BA - I really hate BA, and I don't like connecting in LHR. I often stay in no name hotels, due to the locations I go to - there's either nothing corporate, or I'm simply looking for the best value there is.
Also, note that Avios earned on IB can be transferred to BA and QR, if those programs should offer more favorable redemption options for a particular reward flight.
#1667
Join Date: May 2012
Location: YYZ
Programs: DL PM, TK Black, AA dirt
Posts: 194
since I'm too lazy to search (yeah, I know) - can I credit EY to anyone else in OW, other than AA? I've considered flying EY a few times, but didn't due to the lack of creditable mileage, and the fact that I hate AUH airport, and this whole thing requires an overnight stay in AUH.
I've done YYZ-DOH-DAC multiple times, with the first leg being on AC (so I'm getting good credit with my TK status), and the rest on QR. I've flown to YUL from DOH recently, so that's the longest haul flight I have on hand which I can credit. These are mostly D and R class fares.
I've done YYZ-DOH-DAC multiple times, with the first leg being on AC (so I'm getting good credit with my TK status), and the rest on QR. I've flown to YUL from DOH recently, so that's the longest haul flight I have on hand which I can credit. These are mostly D and R class fares.
One other thought: If you
can achieve desired status with IB without some or all of your flights to DAC, you could fly QR or EY to/from DAC, and credit to AA. Both airlines would earn you redeemable miles on AA; but only QR flights would count towards status on AA. As long as you'd be flying Business Class to/from DAC, the lack of status benefits on those flights should not affect you much -- if at all.
Also, note that Avios earned on IB can be transferred to BA and QR, if those programs should offer more favorable redemption options for a particular reward flight.
can achieve desired status with IB without some or all of your flights to DAC, you could fly QR or EY to/from DAC, and credit to AA. Both airlines would earn you redeemable miles on AA; but only QR flights would count towards status on AA. As long as you'd be flying Business Class to/from DAC, the lack of status benefits on those flights should not affect you much -- if at all.
Also, note that Avios earned on IB can be transferred to BA and QR, if those programs should offer more favorable redemption options for a particular reward flight.
#1669
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Not here; there!
Programs: AA Lifetime Gold
Posts: 34,985
https://www.etihadguest.com/en/earn-miles/flying.html
#1670
Join Date: May 2012
Location: YYZ
Programs: DL PM, TK Black, AA dirt
Posts: 194
I blew the AT status match, and MH doesn't really do it for me, location and all 

It appears that EY flights can also be credited to oneworld carriers AT and MH:
https://www.etihadguest.com/en/earn-miles/flying.html
https://www.etihadguest.com/en/earn-miles/flying.html
#1671


Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: DXB
Programs: AA EXP, A3 *G, LH SEN, SK EBG, Marriott Titanium, Hyatt Globalist, Hilton Diamond, etc. etc....
Posts: 3,349
You can credit EY to AC, I think. Which is an amazing program.
You can obviously also credit them to EY’s own program.
Both AC and EY miles can be redeemed for WY…
Yes, it’s not Oneworld, but it seems like you’re flying quite a bit, so why not use multiple programs?
You can obviously also credit them to EY’s own program.
Both AC and EY miles can be redeemed for WY…
Yes, it’s not Oneworld, but it seems like you’re flying quite a bit, so why not use multiple programs?
#1672
Join Date: May 2012
Location: YYZ
Programs: DL PM, TK Black, AA dirt
Posts: 194
I don't do AC. Terrible program. Given that I'm kind of stuck with TK, given the amount of mileage I have, and never ending status renewal, I'm just sticking with them for Star Alliance accruals.
EY's own program doesn't really make sense, since I don't see myself doing EY more than twice a year - don't like AUH (I'd rather drive from DXB, if I have business in Abu Dhabi).
Decisions, decisions... I'm taking an AA flight in the morning, so I kind of wanted to decide some thing today 🤣🤣🤣🙈🙈🙈
EY's own program doesn't really make sense, since I don't see myself doing EY more than twice a year - don't like AUH (I'd rather drive from DXB, if I have business in Abu Dhabi).
Decisions, decisions... I'm taking an AA flight in the morning, so I kind of wanted to decide some thing today 🤣🤣🤣🙈🙈🙈
You can credit EY to AC, I think. Which is an amazing program.
You can obviously also credit them to EYs own program.
Both AC and EY miles can be redeemed for WY
Yes, its not Oneworld, but it seems like youre flying quite a bit, so why not use multiple programs?
You can obviously also credit them to EYs own program.
Both AC and EY miles can be redeemed for WY
Yes, its not Oneworld, but it seems like youre flying quite a bit, so why not use multiple programs?
#1673
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Not here; there!
Programs: AA Lifetime Gold
Posts: 34,985
If you are willing to pay for an annual Admirals Club membership -- with either cash or AA miles -- then I would probably credit oneworld flights to AAdvantage. If not, then the Iberia Plus program would probably suit your needs well.
#1675
Join Date: May 2012
Location: YYZ
Programs: DL PM, TK Black, AA dirt
Posts: 194
woah, how did I miss the paying for the membership part... this obviously seals the deal as far as AA is concerned - screw that. Back to picking between QR and Iberia, simply because QR gives more avios (125% on Iberia, vs. 175% on QR, for some booking classes).
really regret, crediting a couple of flights to AA, earlier in the year...
really regret, crediting a couple of flights to AA, earlier in the year...
#1676
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Not here; there!
Programs: AA Lifetime Gold
Posts: 34,985
woah, how did I miss the paying for the membership part... this obviously seals the deal as far as AA is concerned - screw that. Back to picking between QR and Iberia, simply because QR gives more avios (125% on Iberia, vs. 175% on QR, for some booking classes).
really regret, crediting a couple of flights to AA, earlier in the year...
really regret, crediting a couple of flights to AA, earlier in the year...
Remember that AAdvantage miles can be a lot more valuable than Avios for certain redemptions because of AA's policy of not collecting carrier surcharges on award tickets, except when flying BA/IB. So the decision is not a slam-dunk. A lot depends on what AA would charge for a particular redemption vs. what BA/IB would charge for the same redemption.
#1677
Join Date: May 2012
Location: YYZ
Programs: DL PM, TK Black, AA dirt
Posts: 194
my primary goal is lounge access for Y flights in the region, and the Caribbean, so basically AA is useless to me.
The fee is for an Admirals Club (lounge) membership, not for an AAdvantage program membership.
Remember that AAdvantage miles can be a lot more valuable than Avios for certain redemptions because of AA's policy of not collecting carrier surcharges on award tickets, except when flying BA/IB. So the decision is not a slam-dunk. A lot depends on what AA would charge for a particular redemption vs. what BA/IB would charge for the same redemption.
Remember that AAdvantage miles can be a lot more valuable than Avios for certain redemptions because of AA's policy of not collecting carrier surcharges on award tickets, except when flying BA/IB. So the decision is not a slam-dunk. A lot depends on what AA would charge for a particular redemption vs. what BA/IB would charge for the same redemption.
#1678
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Not here; there!
Programs: AA Lifetime Gold
Posts: 34,985

And this is what BA (and presumably IB, too) would charge:

So not only would you have to redeem far more Avios than AAdvantage miles for the redemption, but you would also have to pay about $140 more in cash when using Avios. And that's for a one-way.
#1679
Join Date: May 2012
Location: YYZ
Programs: DL PM, TK Black, AA dirt
Posts: 194
The plot thickens... 4 of the flights I wanted to credit somewhere, are older than 90 days, meaning I can only credit them to QR or AA...3 of them aren't much to write home about - DOH-DAC return, and DOH-DXB, but one is kind of nice - DOH-FRA.
I guess I'll start by trying to credit them to QR, to see if I get the 180 day bit. Right now I'm focused on status, rather than accrual - if I got a status match somewhere, then this whole discussion would be moot, but nobody wants to do anything - AA blew me off, in writing.
I guess I'll start by trying to credit them to QR, to see if I get the 180 day bit. Right now I'm focused on status, rather than accrual - if I got a status match somewhere, then this whole discussion would be moot, but nobody wants to do anything - AA blew me off, in writing.
#1680
Original Poster
FlyerTalk Evangelist


Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: MEL CHC
Posts: 22,910
May be of interest. Has retro credit info, but check the ffp web sites--->https://www.finder.com.au/how-to-cla...t-flyer-points

