my primary goal is lounge access for Y flights in the region, and the Caribbean, so basically AA is useless to me.
Originally Posted by
guv1976
The fee is for an Admirals Club (lounge) membership, not for an AAdvantage program membership.
Remember that AAdvantage miles can be a lot more valuable than Avios for certain redemptions because of AA's policy of not collecting carrier surcharges on award tickets, except when flying BA/IB. So the decision is not a slam-dunk. A lot depends on what AA would charge for a particular redemption vs. what BA/IB would charge for the same redemption.