2009 Program Changes -- the good, the bad and the ugly
#196


Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Always on the move
Programs: Something lifetime here and there
Posts: 1,873
Marriott Concierge
Here is my question. I ordered 3 travel package codes 0830 for Category 1-5 at 235,000 points. I was going to use them this year, but plans have changed.
Now, lets say, I want to upgrade the certificates to a cat. 6 hotel using points in the springtime. Will the additional points (to go from a cat 5 to a 6) cost me 15,000 per certificate (the old rate, 235K for cat 5 to 250K cat 6) vs the new rate, now being 65,000 per certificate. (the old rate 235K I redeemed at for cat 5 to the new rate of 300K for a cat 6 change)?
Now, lets say, I want to upgrade the certificates to a cat. 6 hotel using points in the springtime. Will the additional points (to go from a cat 5 to a 6) cost me 15,000 per certificate (the old rate, 235K for cat 5 to 250K cat 6) vs the new rate, now being 65,000 per certificate. (the old rate 235K I redeemed at for cat 5 to the new rate of 300K for a cat 6 change)?
#197

Join Date: May 2004
Programs: Marriott platinum
Posts: 296
Question for Marriott Concierge
Marriott Concierge-
I have an e-certificate from a travel package (category 5) that expires Oct. 2009. Currently it is linked to a March 2009 reservation, but I might not be able to take that trip. I know I can make reservation changes (subject to availability of course) until Jan. 14, but I'm worried my plans may change after that date. I hate to make 20 reservations now just to cover all my options, but I also don't want to have to pay additional points in 2009 to use this category 5 certificate.
Questions:
1) Prior to Jan. 15, can I extend this certificate so it is good until Jan. 14, 2010 or at least Dec. 31, 2009?
2) What happens if I find availability and want to use it at a category 5 in July 2009? Will there be an additional charge for extra points?
Thanks for your infomation. It is really helpful in determining how to use my point in the future.
I have an e-certificate from a travel package (category 5) that expires Oct. 2009. Currently it is linked to a March 2009 reservation, but I might not be able to take that trip. I know I can make reservation changes (subject to availability of course) until Jan. 14, but I'm worried my plans may change after that date. I hate to make 20 reservations now just to cover all my options, but I also don't want to have to pay additional points in 2009 to use this category 5 certificate.
Questions:
1) Prior to Jan. 15, can I extend this certificate so it is good until Jan. 14, 2010 or at least Dec. 31, 2009?
2) What happens if I find availability and want to use it at a category 5 in July 2009? Will there be an additional charge for extra points?
Thanks for your infomation. It is really helpful in determining how to use my point in the future.
#198


Join Date: Feb 2006
Programs: HH Silver, MR Plat Prem & LT Plat, Hyatt Plat,SPG Plat, Hertz PC, National EE, UA 1K
Posts: 3,437

What a STUPID response. Did you ever hear of DOUBLE DIP??? Geezus, whizkid. Think of EARNING points when referencing spending them.
#199


Join Date: Feb 2006
Programs: HH Silver, MR Plat Prem & LT Plat, Hyatt Plat,SPG Plat, Hertz PC, National EE, UA 1K
Posts: 3,437
How about trying to ADD something to the "loyalty program"?
MC...just a suggestion-why not try to GIVE us a reason to stay. How about making SUITES BOOKABLE? Have you ever taken a look at the Hyatt program? You can BOOK SUITES ON POINTS!
MR does NOT offer suites to book on points*, and this has pushed me into Hyatt. I pay for suites a lot of the stays I have, and want to do that on points when I stay! PLEASE give us this option!
*Yes, I know MR has 5K/nt suite u/g certs, but I have NEVER found ONE property to use them on!!! (Maybe they are only good in east bumblef@#k, WI, in March?
)
MR does NOT offer suites to book on points*, and this has pushed me into Hyatt. I pay for suites a lot of the stays I have, and want to do that on points when I stay! PLEASE give us this option!
*Yes, I know MR has 5K/nt suite u/g certs, but I have NEVER found ONE property to use them on!!! (Maybe they are only good in east bumblef@#k, WI, in March?
)
#200
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Pasadena,Ca.,US.
Programs: AA, Delta, United, SPG plat, Hyatt dia
Posts: 7,140
Thanks-but no thanks Ed
Got a very nice note today from Ed French iviting me to join in a Emeeting so all of the new "enhancements"that "we""asked"for
could be explained.
Ummmm no thanks Ed-I can understand point deflation/program rot all by myself.
Next time how about asking me to have tea BEFORE the suits pull something like this.
could be explained.Ummmm no thanks Ed-I can understand point deflation/program rot all by myself.
Next time how about asking me to have tea BEFORE the suits pull something like this.
#202
Join Date: Sep 2006
Programs: Marriott Silver, Starwood Preferred Guest, Kimpton InTouch
Posts: 105
Got a very nice note today from Ed French iviting me to join in a Emeeting so all of the new "enhancements"that "we""asked"for
could be explained.
Ummmm no thanks Ed-I can understand point deflation/program rot all by myself.
Next time how about asking me to have tea BEFORE the suits pull something like this.
could be explained.Ummmm no thanks Ed-I can understand point deflation/program rot all by myself.
Next time how about asking me to have tea BEFORE the suits pull something like this.
#203
Original Poster
Company Representative - Marriott Concierge
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Salt Lake City, UT
Posts: 1,083
Many of us have unused hotel certificates that were part of a travel package and were issued BEFORE these new rules were announced. We were confidently saving those certificates for the future in the knowledge that they were (are?) extendable at any time. Those certificates may have already expired or may expire soon. So my questions are:
1. What can we do with those certificates that we thought were extendable and will expire before we are able to use them?
2. Can we keep them alive by making a reservation up to Jan 15th even if they expired before that date?
3. What will happen with a certificate that is already attached to a reservation if you need to change dates or hotel beyond its expiration date?
4. Wouldnt it make sense to establish a deadline for all certificates issued under the old T&C by January 15th, 2010 giving exactly 1 year after the start of the new program?
1. What can we do with those certificates that we thought were extendable and will expire before we are able to use them?
2. Can we keep them alive by making a reservation up to Jan 15th even if they expired before that date?
3. What will happen with a certificate that is already attached to a reservation if you need to change dates or hotel beyond its expiration date?
4. Wouldnt it make sense to establish a deadline for all certificates issued under the old T&C by January 15th, 2010 giving exactly 1 year after the start of the new program?
Question 2: You do not need to make a reservation to extend a travel package. Contact guest services and let them know you have a hotel portion of a travel package that will be expiring and ask them to reissue it for you. That will change the valid date to a year from when it is reissued. Keep in mind you need to do this before January 15th.
Question 3: If you think this may happen I recommend you call sometime in January (before the 15th) explain that you are uncertain about the dates and would like to have your hotel portion reissued so that the expiration date is a year form when you call.
Question 4: Some of the current travel packages will be issued after January 15th in order to accommodate redemption reservations made prior to the change. These certificates though will have a final expiration date of sometime around January 15th 2010, regardless of when in 2009 they were ordered.
Here is my question. I ordered 3 travel package codes 0830 for Category 1-5 at 235,000 points. I was going to use them this year, but plans have changed.
Now, lets say, I want to upgrade the certificates to a cat. 6 hotel using points in the springtime. Will the additional points (to go from a cat 5 to a 6) cost me 15,000 per certificate (the old rate, 235K for cat 5 to 250K cat 6) vs the new rate, now being 65,000 per certificate. (the old rate 235K I redeemed at for cat 5 to the new rate of 300K for a cat 6 change)?
Now, lets say, I want to upgrade the certificates to a cat. 6 hotel using points in the springtime. Will the additional points (to go from a cat 5 to a 6) cost me 15,000 per certificate (the old rate, 235K for cat 5 to 250K cat 6) vs the new rate, now being 65,000 per certificate. (the old rate 235K I redeemed at for cat 5 to the new rate of 300K for a cat 6 change)?
Marriott Concierge-
I have an e-certificate from a travel package (category 5) that expires Oct. 2009. Currently it is linked to a March 2009 reservation, but I might not be able to take that trip. I know I can make reservation changes (subject to availability of course) until Jan. 14, but I'm worried my plans may change after that date. I hate to make 20 reservations now just to cover all my options, but I also don't want to have to pay additional points in 2009 to use this category 5 certificate.
Questions:
1) Prior to Jan. 15, can I extend this certificate so it is good until Jan. 14, 2010 or at least Dec. 31, 2009?
2) What happens if I find availability and want to use it at a category 5 in July 2009? Will there be an additional charge for extra points?
I have an e-certificate from a travel package (category 5) that expires Oct. 2009. Currently it is linked to a March 2009 reservation, but I might not be able to take that trip. I know I can make reservation changes (subject to availability of course) until Jan. 14, but I'm worried my plans may change after that date. I hate to make 20 reservations now just to cover all my options, but I also don't want to have to pay additional points in 2009 to use this category 5 certificate.
Questions:
1) Prior to Jan. 15, can I extend this certificate so it is good until Jan. 14, 2010 or at least Dec. 31, 2009?
2) What happens if I find availability and want to use it at a category 5 in July 2009? Will there be an additional charge for extra points?
Question 2: As long as you have a category 5 certificate and the hotel is a category 5 at the time you booked it, you will not need to spend any additional points.
Ira
#204


Join Date: Feb 2006
Programs: HH Silver, MR Plat Prem & LT Plat, Hyatt Plat,SPG Plat, Hertz PC, National EE, UA 1K
Posts: 3,437
#205
Moderator, Marriott Bonvoy & FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: McKinney, TX, USA
Programs: United Silver; AA Plat/2MM; Marriott LT Titanium; Hilton Gold
Posts: 11,775
Second, my understanding of the current 5K/night suite ug certs is that those are really used for suite upgrades at only certain chains (i.e. RIs, TPSes, MVCIs) or for non-suite upgrades (i.e. view, balcony, etc.) at certain hotels that may have those type of upgradeable rooms. That would be why you can't find any "hotels" that will let you upgrade to a suite with those today.
#206
Original Poster
Company Representative - Marriott Concierge
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Salt Lake City, UT
Posts: 1,083
The upgrade rewards are primarily there to upgrade to a two bedroom or penthouse suite at a Residence Inn or TownPlace Suites. A few other hotels, mostly resorts, use them for upgrades. Even when they are accepted at full service properties they generally only upgrade you to better view and not necessarily a suite. I am not aware of any plans to create new rewards redeemable for suites in the near future.
Ira
#207
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Houston, TX
Programs: MAR TE ... UA PS
Posts: 92
MVCI owners need to stand up on this!
Marriott Concierge
Please give us an update on MVCI owners who purchased directly from Marriott with the intent of converting to MR points every year after being told by our salesman that "first class" dream vacations could be taken every 2 years.
Is Marriott going to raise the amount of MR points we receive for our timeshares in order to stay on even kilter with the 2009 changes. With the new system, 2BR Marriott Maui owners will be able to trade there units in for enough MR points to stay in a Courtyard hotel. That's right, a $1,000/nt value will now get you only a Courtyard hotel.
Do you not think that these salespeople throughout the MVCI system were a bit misleading? Please explain this.
Please give us an update on MVCI owners who purchased directly from Marriott with the intent of converting to MR points every year after being told by our salesman that "first class" dream vacations could be taken every 2 years.
Is Marriott going to raise the amount of MR points we receive for our timeshares in order to stay on even kilter with the 2009 changes. With the new system, 2BR Marriott Maui owners will be able to trade there units in for enough MR points to stay in a Courtyard hotel. That's right, a $1,000/nt value will now get you only a Courtyard hotel.
Do you not think that these salespeople throughout the MVCI system were a bit misleading? Please explain this.
#208




Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Mesilla, NM
Programs: DL DM 4.7 MM Marriott Lifetime Titanium AA PL Not chasing status Retired!
Posts: 2,777
Marriott Concierge
I think you missed this post can you respond to this?
Marriott Concierge:How will Marriott police hotels
How will we know that hotels have release award rooms and how will this be enforced?
Will hotels still be allowed to block rooms from PL override and award rooms 2 times per year?
Marriott Concierge:How will Marriott police hotels
How will we know that hotels have release award rooms and how will this be enforced?
Will hotels still be allowed to block rooms from PL override and award rooms 2 times per year?
#209
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Madison WI, USA
Posts: 39
We own four Marriott timeshare weeks, and have been heavy users of points from our purchases, stays at Marriott hotels, and use of the Marriott credit card. I have been thinking that I would no longer buy any timeshares directly from Marriott. This change confirms that view. Certainly I will no longer be trading in my timeshares for points.
#210
Join Date: Jun 2008
Programs: AA Lifetime Platnum, Marriott Lifetime Platnum
Posts: 48
Recent MVCI Purchases
To Marriott Management: Since the "enhancements" or point increases were certainly planned for at least 12 months( direct comment by Marriott Moderator Ed French on Marriott Rewards Insider -for elite members only) here is a proposal I would like to see presented directly to Mr. Marriott and Senior management.
Any purchasers of Marriott time-shares through MCVI in the last 12 or 6 months be given either of 2 options:
1) A full and complete refund and the ability to cancel the transaction
2) The indexing of points when exchanging for Marriott Reward points. This indexing be at 30-60% of prior fixed point exchange. This matches the increases in the 7-day travel packages, award schedule and creating of new Category 8 for hotels.
The reason that good corporate governance is called for is HONESTY. The time-share sales executives did NOT disclose a material fact--THE UPCOMING Change of agreement on awards! This is not only unfair, not in the way Marriott does business but probably illegal. Certain properties were sold COMPLETELY on the process of exchanging for points and "You never will stay in the property". Deceptive at the vary least.
If you read the posts on this and other forums (Marriott Rewards Insider) it is clear that the firestorm of ill will and amount of "hatred" that has been created BY MARRIOTT is certainly not what YOU expected. Time to stand-up and do the right thing (we have seen this played out in numerous Congressional Hearings) and maybe TURN IT AROUND into a WIN/WIN. Just imagine the Good Will that this would do for Marriott.
Thank you and I look forward to seeing this issue addressed at the next Marriott Board Meeting.
Any purchasers of Marriott time-shares through MCVI in the last 12 or 6 months be given either of 2 options:
1) A full and complete refund and the ability to cancel the transaction
2) The indexing of points when exchanging for Marriott Reward points. This indexing be at 30-60% of prior fixed point exchange. This matches the increases in the 7-day travel packages, award schedule and creating of new Category 8 for hotels.
The reason that good corporate governance is called for is HONESTY. The time-share sales executives did NOT disclose a material fact--THE UPCOMING Change of agreement on awards! This is not only unfair, not in the way Marriott does business but probably illegal. Certain properties were sold COMPLETELY on the process of exchanging for points and "You never will stay in the property". Deceptive at the vary least.
If you read the posts on this and other forums (Marriott Rewards Insider) it is clear that the firestorm of ill will and amount of "hatred" that has been created BY MARRIOTT is certainly not what YOU expected. Time to stand-up and do the right thing (we have seen this played out in numerous Congressional Hearings) and maybe TURN IT AROUND into a WIN/WIN. Just imagine the Good Will that this would do for Marriott.
Thank you and I look forward to seeing this issue addressed at the next Marriott Board Meeting.
Last edited by Beach9bum; Oct 24, 2008 at 12:29 pm

