Keeping track of manufactured spend
#46
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: SAN
Posts: 1,396
And people wonder how Incomm makes a profit? You think the average person buying these with cash to load into their prepaid card because they don't have a bank account is this organized? How often do you think they lose cards?
#47
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Houston
Programs: UA, SWA, AA, Marriott
Posts: 22
I probably should do something to track this, but too lazy I guess. As long as I get the BB load confirmation email and see the deposit online after I load I am happy.
#48
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Finally back in Boston after escaping from New York
Posts: 13,644
Mike
#49
Join Date: Feb 2013
Posts: 16
Great discussion thread.
I used to be in finance, so pls forgive the geek speak....
I use Quicken to track all accounts - even the BB accounts. Here is an example of how I keep track:
1) buy 3 x $1K on my CC. Quicken downloads this activity (say $3030 for this example) and I make sure the charge is 'unassigned'
2) When the GCs come in - I load $1k to each of the 3 BB accounts
4) I go back into Quicken and assign the $3030 charge with $1K per BB account and $30 goes into the MF spends account.
5) Go online and reconcile the BB account to what I have in Quicken.
If my Quicken info does not match what is showing online for the CC and BB, then there is a problem.
I used to be in finance, so pls forgive the geek speak....
I use Quicken to track all accounts - even the BB accounts. Here is an example of how I keep track:
1) buy 3 x $1K on my CC. Quicken downloads this activity (say $3030 for this example) and I make sure the charge is 'unassigned'
2) When the GCs come in - I load $1k to each of the 3 BB accounts
4) I go back into Quicken and assign the $3030 charge with $1K per BB account and $30 goes into the MF spends account.
5) Go online and reconcile the BB account to what I have in Quicken.
If my Quicken info does not match what is showing online for the CC and BB, then there is a problem.
#50
Join Date: Feb 2013
Posts: 16
I thought I was doing pretty good at keeping track of the balls in the air - but I have been completely missing the utilization %. How have people been able to do this. I've been thinking of some scenarios but none of them are ideal.
1) Check my CC account each day and if I see the charge hit, pay for it with my checking account. The problem with this is that even though I'm transferring the money from the same bank - it doesn't always post on that very day.
2) I cannot pay more than what the current balance is when transferring money from my bank - so I can't 'get ahead of the charge'
The only thing I can think of is to build up my BB account and then use Bill pay to send a check to my CC before I even charge anything. But doesn't this draw attention?
BTW, I have 2 checking accounts - one online and the other is a B&M.
1) Check my CC account each day and if I see the charge hit, pay for it with my checking account. The problem with this is that even though I'm transferring the money from the same bank - it doesn't always post on that very day.
2) I cannot pay more than what the current balance is when transferring money from my bank - so I can't 'get ahead of the charge'
The only thing I can think of is to build up my BB account and then use Bill pay to send a check to my CC before I even charge anything. But doesn't this draw attention?
BTW, I have 2 checking accounts - one online and the other is a B&M.
#51
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: SFO/SJC
Programs: MR,UR, UA, BA, AA, Hotels
Posts: 581
My method for what they're worth...
In general - load as soon as purchased. i.e. Unless it is a time limited offer (like the OM GC deal) I only buy what I can unload that day or so. Once confirmed as unloaded the card gets marked with a sharpie to show empty, date and where it went.
I keep a spreadsheet with tabs for;
Prepaid: Balance for each card, last reload date and next possible reload date (tells me how much float I'm accumulating and need to cash out)
All credit cards - app date, time between apps, sign-on bonus, requirements, bonus categories and accumulated spend etc.
Prepaid load dates - for things with a rolling clock for loads so I know when I can next load.
Cashback tracking - for things like TCB / UR mall purchases
Earnings rate worksheet - to track what different methods actually cost (i.e. $3 per $1k load at Target, $3+$1.25 / $400 ATM etc.)
In general I don't like to keep a balance over $3k on any one card and will pay it off well before the due date, sometimes multiple times a month. (I get paranoid about carrying too large a float and screwing up, so I work as hard if not harder at emptying the float as I do mfg spend).
I also use Mint to track total spending. You can connect most accounts (pretty much all the AMEX prepaid variants, even Paypal - but not GoBank).
I edit the spend category to 'transfer between accounts' for things like gift cards and VR and split the transaction to assign 'frequent flyer spend' to the portion that is the actual cost. So in the Target example where the load is $1,003 this shows as $1k transfer between accounts and $3 as FF spend. Costco ATM would be $400 transfer, $3 and $1.25 as FF.
Doing it this way allows me to separate my regular spend from mfg spend and allows a running tally of what this hobby is actually costing me. The 'transfer between accounts' category doesn't track as spending which would mess up any budgets you have if you don't use this approach. When I get say a TCB payout I also apply the FF spend category which then shows as a reduction in my FF spending. Same goes if I get a payout from selling gift cards or similar.
In general - load as soon as purchased. i.e. Unless it is a time limited offer (like the OM GC deal) I only buy what I can unload that day or so. Once confirmed as unloaded the card gets marked with a sharpie to show empty, date and where it went.
I keep a spreadsheet with tabs for;
Prepaid: Balance for each card, last reload date and next possible reload date (tells me how much float I'm accumulating and need to cash out)
All credit cards - app date, time between apps, sign-on bonus, requirements, bonus categories and accumulated spend etc.
Prepaid load dates - for things with a rolling clock for loads so I know when I can next load.
Cashback tracking - for things like TCB / UR mall purchases
Earnings rate worksheet - to track what different methods actually cost (i.e. $3 per $1k load at Target, $3+$1.25 / $400 ATM etc.)
In general I don't like to keep a balance over $3k on any one card and will pay it off well before the due date, sometimes multiple times a month. (I get paranoid about carrying too large a float and screwing up, so I work as hard if not harder at emptying the float as I do mfg spend).
I also use Mint to track total spending. You can connect most accounts (pretty much all the AMEX prepaid variants, even Paypal - but not GoBank).
I edit the spend category to 'transfer between accounts' for things like gift cards and VR and split the transaction to assign 'frequent flyer spend' to the portion that is the actual cost. So in the Target example where the load is $1,003 this shows as $1k transfer between accounts and $3 as FF spend. Costco ATM would be $400 transfer, $3 and $1.25 as FF.
Doing it this way allows me to separate my regular spend from mfg spend and allows a running tally of what this hobby is actually costing me. The 'transfer between accounts' category doesn't track as spending which would mess up any budgets you have if you don't use this approach. When I get say a TCB payout I also apply the FF spend category which then shows as a reduction in my FF spending. Same goes if I get a payout from selling gift cards or similar.
#52
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: SFO/SJC
Programs: MR,UR, UA, BA, AA, Hotels
Posts: 581
2) I cannot pay more than what the current balance is when transferring money from my bank - so I can't 'get ahead of the charge'
The only thing I can think of is to build up my BB account and then use Bill pay to send a check to my CC before I even charge anything. But doesn't this draw attention?
The only thing I can think of is to build up my BB account and then use Bill pay to send a check to my CC before I even charge anything. But doesn't this draw attention?
using BB or GoBank you can push a payment which will credit to your account even if there is no balance so this is paying ahead.
In general all you need to do is clear the balance before the cycle closes not on an ongoing basis (unless you have a super low credit limit on the card).
#53
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Florida
Posts: 29,767
Great discussion thread.
I used to be in finance, so pls forgive the geek speak....
I use Quicken to track all accounts - even the BB accounts. Here is an example of how I keep track:
1) buy 3 x $1K on my CC. Quicken downloads this activity (say $3030 for this example) and I make sure the charge is 'unassigned'
2) When the GCs come in - I load $1k to each of the 3 BB accounts
4) I go back into Quicken and assign the $3030 charge with $1K per BB account and $30 goes into the MF spends account.
5) Go online and reconcile the BB account to what I have in Quicken.
If my Quicken info does not match what is showing online for the CC and BB, then there is a problem.
I used to be in finance, so pls forgive the geek speak....
I use Quicken to track all accounts - even the BB accounts. Here is an example of how I keep track:
1) buy 3 x $1K on my CC. Quicken downloads this activity (say $3030 for this example) and I make sure the charge is 'unassigned'
2) When the GCs come in - I load $1k to each of the 3 BB accounts
4) I go back into Quicken and assign the $3030 charge with $1K per BB account and $30 goes into the MF spends account.
5) Go online and reconcile the BB account to what I have in Quicken.
If my Quicken info does not match what is showing online for the CC and BB, then there is a problem.
#54
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Florida
Posts: 29,767
Anyhow, a couple things occurred to me from this experience: I was only able to detect the 'lost' card because I was keeping detailed records in the first place (since otherwise I just would've been $500 poorer and not even realized it), and I was only able to recover the lost card because I kept both receipts and 'used' cards. Even then, I'd still say I got lucky in actually finding the live one in my card graveyard.
By writing on the card of the vital data, I can tell at a glance where the money has gone in case I made a mistake in doing my entries to the finance software I used to keep track of all our finances. I honestly dont know how others can manage without a finance software or at least a basic spreadsheet to keep track of things. I am so used to that (for the past decade) that I cannot do without the finance software.
#55
Suspended
Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: LAX/SNA
Programs: AA, Hilton Gold
Posts: 3,887
I also don't like spending $503 then paying off $500 immediately, seems suspicious to me, so I prefer to shuffle money around and use it to pay off other cards and use bank to pay off some of that card too.
#57
Join Date: Feb 2013
Posts: 170
I find Yodlee Moneycenter free financial software better than Mint.com.
I realized usefulness of Yodlee over Mint is that I can create my own categories for tracking expenses. That way separate categories track manufacturing spending and real spending in other categories.
I have 28 credit cards of which there are 14 cards which offer me catergory bonus higher than 1.25% so even at 1.19% fee gift card purchase, I donot incur loss. For vanilla with 0.79 %, many more cards qualify.
Without Yodlee, I would have to spend atleast an hour a day whereas I spend 10 minutes before start of work to plan today's activities and 10 minutes at night.
For every one manufacturing spend, I try to add 4 to 5 real transactions for each card. It can be small items like lunch or USPS or parking payment or large items e.g. reimbursed Doctor fees etc.
I realized usefulness of Yodlee over Mint is that I can create my own categories for tracking expenses. That way separate categories track manufacturing spending and real spending in other categories.
I have 28 credit cards of which there are 14 cards which offer me catergory bonus higher than 1.25% so even at 1.19% fee gift card purchase, I donot incur loss. For vanilla with 0.79 %, many more cards qualify.
Without Yodlee, I would have to spend atleast an hour a day whereas I spend 10 minutes before start of work to plan today's activities and 10 minutes at night.
For every one manufacturing spend, I try to add 4 to 5 real transactions for each card. It can be small items like lunch or USPS or parking payment or large items e.g. reimbursed Doctor fees etc.
#58
Original Poster
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: SFO/SJC
Programs: whatever comes with CCs
Posts: 1,082
great feedback everyone.. I might have to get myself a quicken license and become a quicken whiz. The concept of accounts or buckets makes it easy to track.
I also tried this app called Account Tracker and it works pretty well. I like to log transactions right away and have the history available on my phone when I'm deciding what to do. If I was more organized I would make spreadsheets and plan in the morning but I'm not. I think I'm gonna use this app going forward.
https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/acco...325834957?mt=8
I also tried this app called Account Tracker and it works pretty well. I like to log transactions right away and have the history available on my phone when I'm deciding what to do. If I was more organized I would make spreadsheets and plan in the morning but I'm not. I think I'm gonna use this app going forward.
https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/acco...325834957?mt=8
#59
Join Date: May 2013
Location: Texas
Programs: AA, AS, DL
Posts: 111
Access Database
Now you guys have inspired me to create my own tracking system. I know that this might seem like an overkill (maybe not) but I want to learn Access anyway so I created a database to keep track of my manufactured spending.
Basically, it has 3 parts. The first part is for account info, which allows me to add new cards/accounts into my portfolio in the future. The second part is the "transaction entry", which is an Access form through which I would enter my spending info. I can input the date of purchase, type of manufactured spending, from which account, to which account and in what amount. A background table would collect all these info and further analyze them. For example, $3.95 is automatically added to a $500 VR to arrive at a total outflow of $503.95 and say 504 AA points. A special category allows me to manually adjusts the amount of points/miles/cashback if need be.
Finally, the "global balance" report helps me get an overview of how many points I have accumulated and any balance on any accounts that I need to take care of. The balances are 0 by default so anything different would pop out. There is also a field showing the total cost of this game.
http://tinypic.com/view.php?pic=hstcgy&s=5
I will add more features to this database in the future when I have more time and more skills. For now, so much for 4 nights
Basically, it has 3 parts. The first part is for account info, which allows me to add new cards/accounts into my portfolio in the future. The second part is the "transaction entry", which is an Access form through which I would enter my spending info. I can input the date of purchase, type of manufactured spending, from which account, to which account and in what amount. A background table would collect all these info and further analyze them. For example, $3.95 is automatically added to a $500 VR to arrive at a total outflow of $503.95 and say 504 AA points. A special category allows me to manually adjusts the amount of points/miles/cashback if need be.
Finally, the "global balance" report helps me get an overview of how many points I have accumulated and any balance on any accounts that I need to take care of. The balances are 0 by default so anything different would pop out. There is also a field showing the total cost of this game.
http://tinypic.com/view.php?pic=hstcgy&s=5
I will add more features to this database in the future when I have more time and more skills. For now, so much for 4 nights
Last edited by myndreamland; Jun 25, 2013 at 11:23 pm
#60
Join Date: May 2013
Posts: 1,153
I use Excel...old school...
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/membe...5663-mine.html
There is one master worksheet, which is a checking, that include the balances of each CCs and other checking accounts (by referencing so that I don't have to manually enter). And, each CC (worksheet) has own madness...notes on the CC, projected rewards/cashbacks, rewards/cashbacks received, where my purchases were made, etc.
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/membe...5663-mine.html
There is one master worksheet, which is a checking, that include the balances of each CCs and other checking accounts (by referencing so that I don't have to manually enter). And, each CC (worksheet) has own madness...notes on the CC, projected rewards/cashbacks, rewards/cashbacks received, where my purchases were made, etc.
Last edited by vagrants; Jun 26, 2013 at 6:53 am