Bank of America Alaska Airlines card (2017 - 2024)

Subscribe
Apr 13, 2017 | 7:18 pm
  #226  
Quote: My last AS personal card was approved in Nov 16, I am ready to apply another one. Should I keep old card open or reduce the limit and close account before applying new one. I already have chekcing/saving/other no fee card and AS business card with BofA.
You are not ready to apply for another if you haven't reduced the credit limit yet. You should reduce the credit limit as soon as possible after opening a BofA card, as opposed to waiting until you're ready to apply for another card.

Many people lately are getting denied for another personal card if they have even one open. I would think that should tell you whether you should close after reducing credit limit.

But people who have too much credit "tied up" with BofA may only get approved for a Platinum card (5k bonus) instead of signature. And credit can get "tied up" at BofA if you don't reduce credit limit before cancelling or if you don't wait long enough after reducing credit limit before applying for another card.

So reduce your credit limit immediately. But I'm not sure how long you need to wait after that to close and apply again (with low risk).
Apr 13, 2017 | 10:39 pm
  #227  
Quote: Just wanted to share I got a targeted mailer ...
Spend $250, get $75 credit towards my next Alaska flight.
Can that credit be used in conjunction with using the discount code for a companion fare?
Apr 13, 2017 | 11:23 pm
  #228  
Quote: You are not ready to apply for another if you haven't reduced the credit limit yet. You should reduce the credit limit as soon as possible after opening a BofA card, as opposed to waiting until you're ready to apply for another card.

Many people lately are getting denied for another personal card if they have even one open. I would think that should tell you whether you should close after reducing credit limit.

But people who have too much credit "tied up" with BofA may only get approved for a Platinum card (5k bonus) instead of signature. And credit can get "tied up" at BofA if you don't reduce credit limit before cancelling or if you don't wait long enough after reducing credit limit before applying for another card.

So reduce your credit limit immediately. But I'm not sure how long you need to wait after that to close and apply again (with low risk).
I have a AS personal card and have already gotten the 2.5k retention offer for it last month (opened for more than 4 months ago). If I don't want to pay the annual fee by month 12, is there any benefit for me to wait and not close the account now (e.g. another retention offer before month 12 perhaps?)
Apr 14, 2017 | 8:59 am
  #229  
Quote: My last AS personal card was approved in Nov 16, I am ready to apply another one. Should I keep old card open or reduce the limit and close account before applying new one. I already have chekcing/saving/other no fee card and AS business card with BofA.
My first AS personal was instantly approved in Dec 2016. I have never lowered my credit limit and after reading posts here, I decided to apply for the Business version instead of another personal. I got approved for 2 AS Business cards on the same day earlier this month.
Apr 14, 2017 | 12:08 pm
  #230  
Quote: My first AS personal was instantly approved in Dec 2016. I have never lowered my credit limit and after reading posts here, I decided to apply for the Business version instead of another personal. I got approved for 2 AS Business cards on the same day earlier this month.
So I guess they really like you.

Or you got really lucky.

I suggest not encouraging others to try the same thing though. Especially since we don't know why you managed to pull that off. A/S cards have been YMMV for years....
Apr 14, 2017 | 12:21 pm
  #231  
Quote: You are not ready to apply for another if you haven't reduced the credit limit yet. You should reduce the credit limit as soon as possible after opening a BofA card, as opposed to waiting until you're ready to apply for another card.

Many people lately are getting denied for another personal card if they have even one open. I would think that should tell you whether you should close after reducing credit limit.

But people who have too much credit "tied up" with BofA may only get approved for a Platinum card (5k bonus) instead of signature. And credit can get "tied up" at BofA if you don't reduce credit limit before cancelling or if you don't wait long enough after reducing credit limit before applying for another card.

So reduce your credit limit immediately. But I'm not sure how long you need to wait after that to close and apply again (with low risk).
Yeah I should have don it long back but got lazy but anyway I am calling now and requesting to reduce it and may be I will apply after 3/4 weeks. Should I cancel the first card before applying new one?

Thanks.
Apr 15, 2017 | 8:40 am
  #232  
Quote: Should I cancel the first card before applying new one?
Please re-read the second paragraph of what you just quoted and you should have your answer.
Apr 15, 2017 | 7:53 pm
  #233  
deleted
Apr 15, 2017 | 11:03 pm
  #234  
Quote: You are not ready to apply for another if you haven't reduced the credit limit yet. You should reduce the credit limit as soon as possible after opening a BofA card, as opposed to waiting until you're ready to apply for another card.

Many people lately are getting denied for another personal card if they have even one open. I would think that should tell you whether you should close after reducing credit limit.

But people who have too much credit "tied up" with BofA may only get approved for a Platinum card (5k bonus) instead of signature. And credit can get "tied up" at BofA if you don't reduce credit limit before cancelling or if you don't wait long enough after reducing credit limit before applying for another card.

So reduce your credit limit immediately. But I'm not sure how long you need to wait after that to close and apply again (with low risk).
Is it truly a YMMV situation anymore with these cards? I have 1 Biz and 1 personal AS card (that's all I have with BoA) and I really do want to apply for another of each. But based on all of the data out there, I really am having trouble predicting how that will shake out (I do have a lot of new accounts in the last 24 months).
Apr 16, 2017 | 8:48 am
  #235  
Quote: So how long should someone wait to close an account, after lowering the credit limit?
I've usually waited at least a week (after verifying that the new lower credit limit was showing online).

But that does not mean you can apply two days after and have a good chance of being approved with a decent credit limit on the new card. It's probably better to wait a month or more between lowering credit limit and applying for the next card.
Apr 16, 2017 | 8:56 am
  #236  
Quote: Is it truly a YMMV situation anymore with these cards? I have 1 Biz and 1 personal AS card (that's all I have with BoA) and I really do want to apply for another of each. But based on all of the data out there, I really am having trouble predicting how that will shake out (I do have a lot of new accounts in the last 24 months).
I suggest you do one at a time.

I don't know about YMMV, and I'm not sure why it should matter.

Most people are denied if they apply for another personal card while still having one open. Do you really care whether it's "all" people or "most" people, if you can't predict which camp you'll fall into? Just assume it's "all" people.

I don't know whether we have enough data points on business cards. I assume the same might apply for business card, because I'm risk averse.

But other datapoints suggest BofA is paying more attention perhaps to inquiry counts than before.

So I would suggest a couple things:

1. End up with a BofA card which you'll "never' cancel. You might want to therefore convert your personal Alaska card to a no-AF BofA card (it doesn't much matter which one, just use it once every year or so for something small to make sure they don't close it for "inactivity"). I don't think you can convert the business card, only the personal card probably.

2. Don't close both cards at the same time. Keep one card open while you close the other card, and then try applying for the other card. If you succeed on the other card, then sometime later repeat with the first card.

3. Remember, with a business card application you'll be either approved or denied. With a personal card application, you can be approved for Signature at 30k bonus, or approved for Platinum with the dreaded 5k bonus (more likely than being denied outright).

4. And, of course, remember to lower your credit limit right away (if you haven't already), no matter when you plan to cancel (or convert) each card.
Apr 16, 2017 | 9:47 am
  #237  
Quote: So how long should someone wait to close an account, after lowering the credit limit?
Wrong question. What you should do is lower the cl as soon as you meet the min spnd. Then when you want to cancel/reapply later you don't have to worry about "how long".

I understand in your current situation you now have to worry about "how long". And since I do the above I don't know the answer to that. But my advice above is for your next app.
Apr 16, 2017 | 12:04 pm
  #238  
Quote: I suggest you do one at a time.

I don't know about YMMV, and I'm not sure why it should matter.

Most people are denied if they apply for another personal card while still having one open. Do you really care whether it's "all" people or "most" people, if you can't predict which camp you'll fall into? Just assume it's "all" people.

I don't know whether we have enough data points on business cards. I assume the same might apply for business card, because I'm risk averse.

But other datapoints suggest BofA is paying more attention perhaps to inquiry counts than before.

So I would suggest a couple things:

1. End up with a BofA card which you'll "never' cancel. You might want to therefore convert your personal Alaska card to a no-AF BofA card (it doesn't much matter which one, just use it once every year or so for something small to make sure they don't close it for "inactivity"). I don't think you can convert the business card, only the personal card probably.

2. Don't close both cards at the same time. Keep one card open while you close the other card, and then try applying for the other card. If you succeed on the other card, then sometime later repeat with the first card.

3. Remember, with a business card application you'll be either approved or denied. With a personal card application, you can be approved for Signature at 30k bonus, or approved for Platinum with the dreaded 5k bonus (more likely than being denied outright).

4. And, of course, remember to lower your credit limit right away (if you haven't already), no matter when you plan to cancel (or convert) each card.
Good advice, thank you for that. Obviously, no one likes applying for cards and being denied. I have other cards I could apply for that I think my success rate would be higher with, but I also don't want them as much as the AS cards. So that's my dilemma is all I meant. That and BoA seems very unpredictable these days.

I do have some interest for sure in the Merrill+ (if I can still get the 50K offer), but I'd put that behind the AS card(s) in fear of either being turned down or not getting the personal signature card like you suggested. Do you think applying for the Merrill+ first and keeping that then slowly closing the other AS cards is the way to go? Thanks again for your insights.
Apr 16, 2017 | 7:21 pm
  #239  
Quote: I do have some interest for sure in the Merrill+ (if I can still get the 50K offer), but I'd put that behind the AS card(s) in fear of either being turned down or not getting the personal signature card like you suggested. Do you think applying for the Merrill+ first and keeping that then slowly closing the other AS cards is the way to go? Thanks again for your insights.
I don't personally see the point of Merrill+ cards (they're just cashback so that's just $500, isn't it) compared to AS cards. Zillions of banks have cashback cards, but only BofA has AS cards*. And it seems far riskier to first apply for another card with BofA than to convert a card you already have. What if they're only going to approve you for one more card in the next 6 months, then what? You'll have lowest priority card and 0 new AS cards (and be out at least one old AS card), is that worth $500?

Plus, converting the card you already have will give BofA a card with more "age and history" than applying for a new card will. It's the closest thing possible to "going back in time" and opening your BofA "keeper" card account "in the past". The point is not just to get a BofA "keeper" card account, it's to have one with the longest history possible.

*Well, that's not 100% true, in that merger partner Virgin America still has a separate program and is with another bank (Comenity), but the signup bonus there is not so good
Apr 16, 2017 | 7:56 pm
  #240  
Quote: I don't personally see the point of Merrill+ cards (they're just cashback so that's just $500, isn't it) compared to AS cards. Zillions of banks have cashback cards, but only BofA has AS cards*. And it seems far riskier to first apply for another card with BofA than to convert a card you already have. What if they're only going to approve you for one more card in the next 6 months, then what? You'll have lowest priority card and 0 new AS cards (and be out at least one old AS card), is that worth $500?

Plus, converting the card you already have will give BofA a card with more "age and history" than applying for a new card will. It's the closest thing possible to "going back in time" and opening your BofA "keeper" card account "in the past". The point is not just to get a BofA "keeper" card account, it's to have one with the longest history possible.

*Well, that's not 100% true, in that merger partner Virgin America still has a separate program and is with another bank (Comenity), but the signup bonus there is not so good
What's great about the Merrill+ is no annual fee and if you redeem for flights, you can redeem for 2 flights up to $500 each. And if the flights are over $500, you can pay the difference. With how cheap economy tickets are to Europe right now, that could add up to two roundtrippers or if there is a last minute/holiday booking domestically (which often runs pricey), you could also get tickets free that way or heavily discounted. It's quite a good deal.

It's true, I prefer AS to Merrill+, but it's not like the Merrill+ is a bad card to pick up. I misunderstood your original suggestion though. It sounds like you favored downgrading one of the AS cards and keeping that one, yes? If so, is there any time frame you'd suggest on that? I think I opened my cards in August of last year. Do you think they'd let me convert it to Merrill+?

Anyway, truly, thanks for your suggestions. I greatly appreciate it.
6  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  26  66  116