FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   American Airlines | AAdvantage (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/american-airlines-aadvantage-733/)
-   -   Chance of Upgrade Clearing and Availability (2023 Master Thread) (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/american-airlines-aadvantage/2106380-chance-upgrade-clearing-availability-2023-master-thread.html)

lowkeyflyer Feb 5, 2023 11:34 pm

  1. Is there any reason to check-in before you're at the airport?
  2. Can you do same-day confirmed change after checking in on the mobile app?
  3. How does the check-in time affect your upgrades?
  4. If you same day change to a flight that has more seats open in biz, do you have a better chance at upgrade?
  5. What is the reason for elites to check-in before getting to the airport? We can already select our seats for free. If we check-in then don't we lose flexibility in case something goes wrong?
  6. If we check in faster, do we get higher prio for upgrade?

JJeffrey Feb 6, 2023 5:33 am


Originally Posted by lowkeyflyer (Post 34987776)
T-24 on AA 10 and still haven't been offered a paid upgrade yet, PPro with 0 LP.


Originally Posted by lowkeyflyer (Post 34988895)
  1. Is there any reason to check-in before you're at the airport?
  2. Can you do same-day confirmed change after checking in on the mobile app?
  3. How does the check-in time affect your upgrades?
  4. If you same day change to a flight that has more seats open in biz, do you have a better chance at upgrade?
  5. What is the reason for elites to check-in before getting to the airport? We can already select our seats for free. If we check-in then don't we lose flexibility in case something goes wrong?
  6. If we check in faster, do we get higher prio for upgrade?

Just FYI I see you also posted this in the newbie thread, cross posting the same question in multiple threads is not allowed and just clutters things up.

Check-in time has no bearing on your upgrade chances. Some like to check in early, others wait till the airport. It's usually easier to change flights if you're not checked in although a phone agent can undo the check-in if necessary.

All that said, AA10 tonight is down to F1J1 (meaning one seat left for sale in F and one in J, or it could be one total in F/J combined), so your upgrade chances are slim to none as a PLT Pro with 0 LP. And all other LAX-JFK flights today are either sold out or have only 1 seat left in F/J. So I would stop stressing about this upgrade as it ain't happening and be prepared for a nice flight in coach :)

lowkeyflyer Feb 6, 2023 10:22 am


Originally Posted by JJeffrey (Post 34989346)
Just FYI I see you also posted this in the newbie thread, cross posting the same question in multiple threads is not allowed and just clutters things up.

Check-in time has no bearing on your upgrade chances. Some like to check in early, others wait till the airport. It's usually easier to change flights if you're not checked in although a phone agent can undo the check-in if necessary.

All that said, AA10 tonight is down to F1J1 (meaning one seat left for sale in F and one in J, or it could be one total in F/J combined), so your upgrade chances are slim to none as a PLT Pro with 0 LP. And all other LAX-JFK flights today are either sold out or have only 1 seat left in F/J. So I would stop stressing about this upgrade as it ain't happening and be prepared for a nice flight in coach :)

Darn! Thanks for letting me know about the crossposting.

That F1/J1 comment you made is perfect, pretty much exactly what I was looking for. I've been looking at the seatmaps for these flights for a month before I booked and they consistently flew out with many seats open in J.... Guess I got unlucky...

coleslaw Feb 6, 2023 10:46 am


Originally Posted by lowkeyflyer (Post 34990130)
Darn! Thanks for letting me know about the crossposting.

That F1/J1 comment you made is perfect, pretty much exactly what I was looking for. I've been looking at the seatmaps for these flights for a month before I booked and they consistently flew out with many seats open in J.... Guess I got unlucky...

I really doubt they ended up going with any empty J seats. They would upgrade at the gate for any gold / plat / plat pro / exp / ck (or AS elite) who wasn’t previously upgraded. I’ve never seen an A32T go out with an empty J seat.

Rhomboid Feb 6, 2023 11:39 am


Originally Posted by JJeffrey (Post 34989346)
Just FYI I see you also posted this in the newbie thread, cross posting the same question in multiple threads is not allowed and just clutters things up.
All that said, AA10 tonight is down to F1J1 (meaning one seat left for sale in F and one in J, or it could be one total in F/J combined), so your upgrade chances are slim to none as a PLT Pro with 0 LP. And all other LAX-JFK flights today are either sold out or have only 1 seat left in F/J. So I would stop stressing about this upgrade as it ain't happening and be prepared for a nice flight in coach :)

Are these information from ExpertFlyer? I'm thinking of subscribing to the service.

JJeffrey Feb 6, 2023 11:54 am


Originally Posted by Rhomboid (Post 34990372)
Are these information from ExpertFlyer? I'm thinking of subscribing to the service.

Yes.

Amil Feb 6, 2023 1:17 pm

I have too much anxiety on this upgrade so the price went low enough for me to purchase business on a transcon however I keep getting this message. my guess is maybe my upgrade is about to go through? any thoughts? ive tried a few times on desktop and phone and picked different seats as well.
https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.fly...b74cbb1bcc.jpg

EXP100 Feb 6, 2023 1:21 pm


Originally Posted by Amil (Post 34990688)
I have too much anxiety on this upgrade so the price went low enough for me to purchase business on a transcon however I keep getting this message. my guess is maybe my upgrade is about to go through? any thoughts? ive tried a few times on desktop and phone and picked different seats as well.
https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.fly...b74cbb1bcc.jpg

I'd call in. Maybe the premium cabin is oversold because someone bought the last seat seconds/minutes before you purchased it.

FlyingLaw Feb 6, 2023 2:19 pm

The two of us just flew DFW-YVR and back. Outbound was last Saturday morning and we left YVR yesterday. They were award tickets but since I’m EXP I was somewhat hopeful of getting an upgrade. Ended up 8 and 9 (out of 30) in the flight to YVR and ended up 5 and 6 on the return. Wouldn’t have thought there’d be that much EXP traffic in a weekend but I guess so….

the return had 3 seats for sale in first (showing 6 open on the seat map) 36 hours before departure.

FlyingLaw Feb 6, 2023 2:23 pm

The two of us just flew DFW-YVR and back. Outbound was last Saturday morning and we left YVR yesterday. They were award tickets but since I’m EXP I was somewhat hopeful of getting an upgrade. Ended up 8 and 9 (out of 30) in the flight to YVR and ended up 5 and 6 on the return. Wouldn’t have thought there’d be that much EXP traffic in a weekend but I guess so….

the return had 3 seats for sale in first (showing 6 open on the seat map) 36 hours before departure.

Amil Feb 6, 2023 2:23 pm


Originally Posted by EXP100 (Post 34990698)
I'd call in. Maybe the premium cabin is oversold because someone bought the last seat seconds/minutes before you purchased it.

apparently it went through I just got a receipt randomly

lowkeyflyer Feb 6, 2023 5:41 pm

Can't believe I never got offered a paid upgrade the entire time... Maybe it's because I booked a basic econ fare?

Either way, stuck at 3/5 on waitlist so far... 0 seats open in F (seatmap says 1 open though...)

ISUSEADSM Feb 6, 2023 6:30 pm

Interesting one Sunday evening, DFW-YYC on an A319 with 8 FC seats. When the waitlist became available I (PPro) was 5 of 15 or so for 0 available seats. At boarding, no one was crowding the gate. When they called Group 1, one person walked up. When they called Group 2, I was the only person to walk up. As boarding was nearing completion, the FA came back and upgraded several people from various MCE seats. I heard him address #4 by name and it matched the first initial of #4 on the upgrade list. I wonder if there was a late incoming flight and some missed connections to have four upgrades after boarding with 0 available, and as I noted, one person who walked up when Group 1 was called. I wasn't too bummed to miss the upgrade as I had an MCE with an empty middle and had already eaten. Plus I heard a crying baby frequently throughout the flight that I was pretty sure was coming from FC but I didn't pay close attention when deboarding.

keyw Feb 6, 2023 8:26 pm

Start of the year to now EP 220-250k LPs
1/3 EYW-MIA e175 cleared at window
MIA-CLT 772 cleared after boarding 1/42 on the list!
CLT-DTW 738 cleared at window
1/14 DTW-CLT 738 cleared at window
CLT-EYW a319 cleared 60 hours before
1/16 EYW-CLT a319 #2/13 nobody cleared
CLT-DTW 738 cleared at window
1/20
DTW-DFW 738 cleared at window
DFW-EYW a319 #1/17 nobody cleared
1/23 EYW-CLT a319 #1/8 nobody cleared
CLT-EYW 738 cleared at window
2/4 DTW-CLT a320 cleared at window
CLT-EYW e175 cleared 23 hours out
2/6 EYW-CLT a319 #1/14 nobody cleared
CLT-DTW 738 cleared 23 hours out 39 on list (Missed connection)
CLT-DTW 738 #1/21 nobody cleared (replacement flight)
2/10 DTW-CLT 378 cleared at window
2/10 CLT-PHL a321 cleared at window

FlyFreakquently Feb 6, 2023 8:30 pm


Originally Posted by keyw (Post 34991707)
Start of the year to now EP 220-250k LPs
1/3 EYW-MIA e175 cleared at window
MIA-CLT 772 cleared after boarding 1/42 on the list!
CLT-DTW 738 cleared at window
1/14 DTW-CLT 738 cleared at window
CLT-EYW a319 cleared 60 hours before
1/16 EYW-CLT a319 #2/13 nobody cleared
CLT-DTW 738 cleared at window
1/20
DTW-DFW 738 cleared at window
DFW-EYW a319 #1/17 nobody cleared
1/23 EYW-CLT a319 #1/8 nobody cleared
CLT-EYW 738 cleared at window
2/4 DTW-CLT a320 cleared at window
CLT-EYW e175 cleared 23 hours out
2/6 EYW-CLT a319 #1/14 nobody cleared
CLT-DTW 738 cleared 23 hours out 39 on list (Missed connection)
CLT-DTW 738 #1/21 nobody cleared (replacement flight)
2/10 DTW-CLT 378 cleared at window
2/10 CLT-PHL a321 cleared at window

Sounds like you need to avoid A319s


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:25 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.