New upgrade award on Thai and devaluation
#31
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Apr 2013
Location: PHX
Programs: AS 75K; UA 1MM; Hyatt Globalist; Marriott LTP; Hilton Diamond (Aspire)
Posts: 56,461
"The decision of these changes has been made with careful consideration as we have not adjusted the miles in our award charts for almost fifteen years ago since the beginning of our program."
This is a false justification. Any increased ticket prices will necessarily be reflected in the cost to the passenger in accruing award miles. So if (and this is a purely hypotethetical example) BKK-SYD cost $1000 10 years ago, and costs $2000 today, it will have cost the passenger twice as much to accrue those 4674 miles today as it did 10 years ago.
Because award mileage accruals already reflect changes in ticket pricing, raising award redemption rates is just a program devaluation, pure and simple.
This is a false justification. Any increased ticket prices will necessarily be reflected in the cost to the passenger in accruing award miles. So if (and this is a purely hypotethetical example) BKK-SYD cost $1000 10 years ago, and costs $2000 today, it will have cost the passenger twice as much to accrue those 4674 miles today as it did 10 years ago.
Because award mileage accruals already reflect changes in ticket pricing, raising award redemption rates is just a program devaluation, pure and simple.
Last edited by Kacee; Jun 18, 2014 at 3:44 pm
#32
Join Date: Jun 2007
Programs: ROP Gold
Posts: 1,292
What the hell is Thai Airways doing with the ROP program?
First, this stupid rolling year expiration policy and the unclear qualification rules. Now redemption miles devaluation.
Do they really think that we are really stupid customers?
I am seriously thinking about dumping this airline's frequent flyer program.
Who knows if these benefits will still last.
COuld you let us know which is a more preferable choice? TK or SQ?
First, this stupid rolling year expiration policy and the unclear qualification rules. Now redemption miles devaluation.
Do they really think that we are really stupid customers?
I am seriously thinking about dumping this airline's frequent flyer program.
COuld you let us know which is a more preferable choice? TK or SQ?
Last edited by anaidross; Jun 18, 2014 at 6:26 pm
#33
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Programs: Flying: VA; Buying: AA, AS, AV, BA, UA!
Posts: 2,349
#35
Join Date: May 2009
Location: BKK
Programs: SPG, MR, Aeroplan, UAMP, BAEC
Posts: 168
Awards on Star Alliance - unchanged or to be changed?
So, this devaluation on TG award means it is way better off to burn on *A? TG site on Air Awards on Star Alliance remains unchanged. Or, just a matter of time, perhaps by 1st Sep 2014?
http://www.thaiairways.com/frequent-...e-airlines.htm
btw, oh I find, TG will give more mile to Gold and Plat. from Aug 2014, which doesn't compensate me as I earn miles most from credit cards...
http://www.thaiairways.com/frequent-...ierBonusEN.pdf
http://www.thaiairways.com/frequent-...e-airlines.htm
btw, oh I find, TG will give more mile to Gold and Plat. from Aug 2014, which doesn't compensate me as I earn miles most from credit cards...
http://www.thaiairways.com/frequent-...ierBonusEN.pdf
#36
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Programs: Flying: VA; Buying: AA, AS, AV, BA, UA!
Posts: 2,349
http://www.thaiairways.com/frequent-...ceAirlines.htm (note that these numbers are ONEWAY)
#37
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: BKK
Posts: 6,741
Fortunately I love TG's F product, as well as J for short and medium haul out of BKK, so I will still be flying TG but most likely crediting miles to UA. It seem utterly insane that they have changed their FFP so that it offers no incentive for many of their own loyal customers.
#38
Join Date: May 2001
Location: RNO, NV, USA.
Programs: UA 2MM
Posts: 5,063
110,000 / 170,000 / 230,000.
#39
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Melbourne
Programs: Velocity Gold
Posts: 1,069
Quote:
Originally Posted by hco
BKK - LHR return flight
Before: 70,000 / 130,000 / 185,000
After 1SEP: 84,000 / 260,000 / 370,000
Wow. For real or typo? The 1SEP page doesn't actually seem to be linked from the main ROP homepage yet, or? At least I cannot find any link.
In comparison, current UA award chart shows, for *A award South Asia - Europe return:
110,000 / 170,000 / 230,000.
Originally Posted by hco
BKK - LHR return flight
Before: 70,000 / 130,000 / 185,000
After 1SEP: 84,000 / 260,000 / 370,000
Wow. For real or typo? The 1SEP page doesn't actually seem to be linked from the main ROP homepage yet, or? At least I cannot find any link.
In comparison, current UA award chart shows, for *A award South Asia - Europe return:
110,000 / 170,000 / 230,000.
#40
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: NE & SE Asia, N America
Programs: TG ROP Gold, Lifetime OZ Diamond Plus, BA Gold
Posts: 3,105
All I can say is that whoever is coming up with these ideas and making these decisions is nothing short of being a complete moron. Already ROP was the worst FFP in the industry (well pretty much tied with SQ's program which they patterned it after). The reason being, the short lifetime of miles (a mere three years). Now with this devaluation, unless you're platinum (and miles don't expire), the average flyer will never be able to save enough miles for any meaningful award. What will they do? Save up enough miles for some economy award and pay so much in taxes and not earn miles on the award ticket such that it's not really even worth it? Or use them for a hotel stay? The ROP program is now completely worthless. Certainly glad I made the decision last year to abandon ship. I'd feel total stupid if I'd stuck with them after their fraud in cheating their best customers out of the mileage validity when switching to the rolling periods. And now this. Shaking my head about how anyone could be so stupid to devise this plan.
Let's see, what have they done to devalue the program recently:
1) This devaluation of miles.
2) Reduced the lifetime of miles by a year
3) Added on bogus additional surcharges for premium awards
4) Increased fuel surcharges
And to top it off, they have the gall to lie to their customers in such a weak attempt at pawning off this outrage as being something that's warranted and overdue, when they've in actuality been raising the miles needed all along.
Absolutely ridiculous. Your continued adding on insult after insult to your best customer really makes me to totally despise you as an airline. I was once one of your biggest fans. Now I have nothing but contempt for your despicable behavior.
Let's see, what have they done to devalue the program recently:
1) This devaluation of miles.
2) Reduced the lifetime of miles by a year
3) Added on bogus additional surcharges for premium awards
4) Increased fuel surcharges
And to top it off, they have the gall to lie to their customers in such a weak attempt at pawning off this outrage as being something that's warranted and overdue, when they've in actuality been raising the miles needed all along.
Absolutely ridiculous. Your continued adding on insult after insult to your best customer really makes me to totally despise you as an airline. I was once one of your biggest fans. Now I have nothing but contempt for your despicable behavior.
#41
Join Date: Jul 2010
Programs: HHon Diamond, IHG Plat, SPG Gold, TG Gold, QR Plat, OZ Gold, AF Silver, Hertz #1 Gold, Priority Pass
Posts: 447
Can someone post one of their complaint letters or PM, I will be happy to send it through as well (with some limited mods, of course)...
too busy at the moment to draft something new.
too busy at the moment to draft something new.
#42
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: VZ
Programs: M&M, ROP, KrisFlyer
Posts: 1,028
All I can say is that whoever is coming up with these ideas and making these decisions is nothing short of being a complete moron. Already ROP was the worst FFP in the industry (well pretty much tied with SQ's program which they patterned it after). The reason being, the short lifetime of miles (a mere three years). Now with this devaluation, unless you're platinum (and miles don't expire), the average flyer will never be able to save enough miles for any meaningful award. What will they do? Save up enough miles for some economy award and pay so much in taxes and not earn miles on the award ticket such that it's not really even worth it? Or use them for a hotel stay? The ROP program is now completely worthless. .....
....(rest quote is all pers-/emotional)
....(rest quote is all pers-/emotional)
the hotel vouchers which you mention are not so bad - while I prefer chasing for miles to use them for upgrades (even though now more expensive, but they still work), my friends are using them for hotel vouchers (and have never complained).
Also the new introduction of oneway award tickets is not only bad (because they do now cost the same as a return ticket used to cost) but a fairer way for those who want/need them (not everybody likes flying back and forth the same routing/airline....)
#43
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: CGN
Programs: Thai reborn Platinum , EY Platinum ,Annie's Preferred Guest , Knauber Hobbymarkt Rabattkarte
Posts: 337
What they are certainly targeting at is reducing the number of non-ROP award flyers . Though increasing earned ROP miles between 30 %and 60 % makes no sense against doubling the " price " for their award tickets . There is a different aspect to consider assuming that Thai intends to run the company by selling tickets for cash .
I gave up using them late ast year because it had become impossible to get seats on my preferred flights ( FRA>BKK only ) let alone choose my preferred seats . Thai probaby thinks ( or thought ) maybe 1600 € are better than 4600 € for an F seat . It has been my first letter I ever sent to an airline carefully expaining them what I think about all this and that they can throw my next Platinum card due in July into the nearest dustbin . I am not sure if they have other ways of regulating their award business but this is a sign of hope although upsetting their ROP miles-collectors .
Respectfully .
For the record : Currently (!) using Etihad .
I gave up using them late ast year because it had become impossible to get seats on my preferred flights ( FRA>BKK only ) let alone choose my preferred seats . Thai probaby thinks ( or thought ) maybe 1600 € are better than 4600 € for an F seat . It has been my first letter I ever sent to an airline carefully expaining them what I think about all this and that they can throw my next Platinum card due in July into the nearest dustbin . I am not sure if they have other ways of regulating their award business but this is a sign of hope although upsetting their ROP miles-collectors .
Respectfully .
For the record : Currently (!) using Etihad .
#44
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Melbourne
Programs: Velocity Gold
Posts: 1,069
How does these changes do that somkiat? I think if anything this will increase not reduce the number of non-ROP award flyers as their current ROP flyers will credit their miles to other programs and then redeem miles from those programs on Thai flights. How do the current changes stop other *A carriers booking award flights on Thai where the value is multiple times better?
#45
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Generally PHX
Programs: UA 1K, AA EXP, TG Gold, Starwood Gold, Marriott Gold
Posts: 413
Already burned large number of miles last year after they started the rolling expiration of miles. Now I think I will try to empty it before September. I have already moved bulk of my miles collection to UA (as I end up flying them more often), I will probably renew Gold for the last time this year and I am already looking at other carriers. seems like Emirates or Qatar may be good idea.