Are there any guidelines as to when to stop serving alcohol to a passenger?
#1
Original Poster




Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Bainbridge Island WA
Posts: 9,473
Are there any guidelines as to when to stop serving alcohol to a passenger?
I preference this by saying I do not drink so I have no idea of tolerance levels and quanities of consuming alcohol.....
I flew a flight this morning from MSP to SEA on NW. The passenger across the aisle from me in FC consumed 5 cans of Budweiser during the flight and 4 glasses of white wine during meal service.... he never acted intoxicated and was quiet the entire flight....I watched him de-plane and take the train to the main terminal and he never once appeared drunk or off-balance.... but isn't that a lot of alcohol to consume in a 3 hour flight and should the FA have been more attentive to the quanities served?
I flew a flight this morning from MSP to SEA on NW. The passenger across the aisle from me in FC consumed 5 cans of Budweiser during the flight and 4 glasses of white wine during meal service.... he never acted intoxicated and was quiet the entire flight....I watched him de-plane and take the train to the main terminal and he never once appeared drunk or off-balance.... but isn't that a lot of alcohol to consume in a 3 hour flight and should the FA have been more attentive to the quanities served?
#2
Join Date: May 2005
Programs: AS MVP Gold
Posts: 93
That many drinks would put most people under their seat in FC. But not someone who's addicted to alcohol and accustomed to drinking large quantities of alcohol on a fairly continual basis. They need to keep thier blood alcohol level elevated in order to operate "normally".
Alcohol servers are taught to determine whether a person is intoxicated through the drinker's behavior. Is the person staggering? Is his speech slurred? A young, inexperienced drinker will be extremely intoxicated with a BAC of .08 while there may be no indication at all that an addicted person's BAC is twice that.
Does anyone know what kind of trainings FA get for determining when to cut someone off?
Alcohol servers are taught to determine whether a person is intoxicated through the drinker's behavior. Is the person staggering? Is his speech slurred? A young, inexperienced drinker will be extremely intoxicated with a BAC of .08 while there may be no indication at all that an addicted person's BAC is twice that.
Does anyone know what kind of trainings FA get for determining when to cut someone off?
#3

Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: NYC
Programs: BAEC Silver, AA LTP 2MM
Posts: 3,358
1. I once watched two yahoos drink that much each on a 8AM flight from LIT-DFW (
).
2. See this thread.
3. On a more serious note, I have seen a few pax cut off, and in one case, I got a guy cut off before departure (he was WAY beyond hammered, and I had personally witnessed him chug no fewer than 8 Bloody Marys in the lounge before departure...he ended up being seated next to me on a transcon). The F/As managed to find me the one other seat available on this full flight, and the guy passed out right after takeoff...the purser was quite grateful for the heads up on the guy's condition. IMHO he shouldn't have been allowed to fly, but who am I to say.)
4. I was "cut off" once on Continental Express as they have a limit of 4 drinks per pax (two double scotches during a 3+ hour ERJ flight doesn't strike me as excessive, but I guess their limit is reasonable).
).2. See this thread.
3. On a more serious note, I have seen a few pax cut off, and in one case, I got a guy cut off before departure (he was WAY beyond hammered, and I had personally witnessed him chug no fewer than 8 Bloody Marys in the lounge before departure...he ended up being seated next to me on a transcon). The F/As managed to find me the one other seat available on this full flight, and the guy passed out right after takeoff...the purser was quite grateful for the heads up on the guy's condition. IMHO he shouldn't have been allowed to fly, but who am I to say.)
4. I was "cut off" once on Continental Express as they have a limit of 4 drinks per pax (two double scotches during a 3+ hour ERJ flight doesn't strike me as excessive, but I guess their limit is reasonable).
#4
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Berkeley, CA USA
Programs: Piggly Wiggly "Shop the Pig!" Preferred Shopper
Posts: 60,392
Originally Posted by david4455
I preference this by saying I do not drink...
#5
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: May 2001
Location: LAX; AA EXP, MM; HH Gold
Posts: 31,789
Originally Posted by david4455
I preference this by saying I do not drink so I have no idea of tolerance levels and quanities of consuming alcohol.....
I flew a flight this morning from MSP to SEA on NW. The passenger across the aisle from me in FC consumed 5 cans of Budweiser during the flight and 4 glasses of white wine during meal service.... he never acted intoxicated and was quiet the entire flight....I watched him de-plane and take the train to the main terminal and he never once appeared drunk or off-balance.... but isn't that a lot of alcohol to consume in a 3 hour flight and should the FA have been more attentive to the quanities served?
I flew a flight this morning from MSP to SEA on NW. The passenger across the aisle from me in FC consumed 5 cans of Budweiser during the flight and 4 glasses of white wine during meal service.... he never acted intoxicated and was quiet the entire flight....I watched him de-plane and take the train to the main terminal and he never once appeared drunk or off-balance.... but isn't that a lot of alcohol to consume in a 3 hour flight and should the FA have been more attentive to the quanities served?
As you pointed out, he seemed immune to his beer.

As for the wine - airline wine glasses (at least on AA where I fly) tend to be very small and only hold about 3 ounces. Most restaurant wine glasses tend to hold at least twice that much (and some hold much more). Bottom line: He only had a couple "glasses" of wine, together with a meal. Not all that much for many wine drinkers. Obviously not too much for this beer-swilling pax.

Again, body weight, food consumption, tolerance to alcohol (whether he's a drunkard) all matter in determining whether his alcohol consumption made him intoxicated or whether he's able to drink that much without hitting intoxication.
On a dinner transcon, I often have a couple of pre-dinner cocktails, followed by a few glasses of wine with dinner, followed by a couple of after-dinner drinks. Together with a couple bottles of water and a coke or two. In decades of flying, I've never been cut off by a flight attendant and have never been involved in alcohol-related on-board incidents.
I guess there's always a first time, however.

Like the ads say: "Know your limits." Sounds like this guy may have pushed toward his limit on a mere 3 hour flight.
#7
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: The Motor City
Posts: 232
To respond to the question regarding training received: At NWA, the answer is absolutely none. As a matter of fact, the service aspect of the job is something that we barely even touch on in training. During the six week initial training class, one Saturday afternoon was set aside for service (and related) training. I suppose that assume we will receive the necessary skills on the job.
We are told to be cognizant of intoxicated passengers upon boarding, but that is about as far as it goes. It generally isn't a big problem. In my 10 years, I've never cut anyone off, and have been serving liquor for about double that length of time. Maybe I'm just lucky, but I just don't hear of it happening a whole lot.
To the OP- MSP-SEA is longer than three hours. You don't say the size of the passenger, this makes a world of difference. Also, since you don't drink, you probably arent' aware, but the wine glasses are tiny glasses. Really, I don't think an ice cube would fit inside of it. Besides all of this, I am curious-what caused you to focus on his beverage habits so intently? You say he was quiet, so that can't be it. Was he rude? Slovenly?
We are told to be cognizant of intoxicated passengers upon boarding, but that is about as far as it goes. It generally isn't a big problem. In my 10 years, I've never cut anyone off, and have been serving liquor for about double that length of time. Maybe I'm just lucky, but I just don't hear of it happening a whole lot.
To the OP- MSP-SEA is longer than three hours. You don't say the size of the passenger, this makes a world of difference. Also, since you don't drink, you probably arent' aware, but the wine glasses are tiny glasses. Really, I don't think an ice cube would fit inside of it. Besides all of this, I am curious-what caused you to focus on his beverage habits so intently? You say he was quiet, so that can't be it. Was he rude? Slovenly?
#8
In Memoriam




Join Date: Jun 2000
Programs: Honors Diamond, Hertz Presidents Circle, National Exec Elite
Posts: 36,111
#9
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Northern VA
Programs: UA 1KMM, HH Diamond
Posts: 172
Originally Posted by nwaflygirl
To respond to the question regarding training received: At NWA, the answer is absolutely none. As a matter of fact, the service aspect of the job is something that we barely even touch on in training. During the six week initial training class, one Saturday afternoon was set aside for service (and related) training. I suppose that assume we will receive the necessary skills on the job.
We are told to be cognizant of intoxicated passengers upon boarding, but that is about as far as it goes. It generally isn't a big problem. In my 10 years, I've never cut anyone off, and have been serving liquor for about double that length of time. Maybe I'm just lucky, but I just don't hear of it happening a whole lot.
To the OP- MSP-SEA is longer than three hours. You don't say the size of the passenger, this makes a world of difference. Also, since you don't drink, you probably arent' aware, but the wine glasses are tiny glasses. Really, I don't think an ice cube would fit inside of it. Besides all of this, I am curious-what caused you to focus on his beverage habits so intently? You say he was quiet, so that can't be it. Was he rude? Slovenly?
We are told to be cognizant of intoxicated passengers upon boarding, but that is about as far as it goes. It generally isn't a big problem. In my 10 years, I've never cut anyone off, and have been serving liquor for about double that length of time. Maybe I'm just lucky, but I just don't hear of it happening a whole lot.
To the OP- MSP-SEA is longer than three hours. You don't say the size of the passenger, this makes a world of difference. Also, since you don't drink, you probably arent' aware, but the wine glasses are tiny glasses. Really, I don't think an ice cube would fit inside of it. Besides all of this, I am curious-what caused you to focus on his beverage habits so intently? You say he was quiet, so that can't be it. Was he rude? Slovenly?
#10
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: GEG
Posts: 217
I'm going to chime in and agree with nwaflygirl here. Half a day, if that, was spent on service. We are told not to serve anyone that 'appears to be intoxicated'. I've had to cut a few people off (We're talking had 10+ drinks) and we're handling it so well.
On a random note, and I don't know if this is rumour or not, but someone told me why AirTran no longer has a 2 comp drink limit in BC. The story goes that Joe Leonard was traveling, and asked for a third diet coke and rum, and the f/a politely told him that he was only allowed the two. Shortly after that the limit was compleatly lifted.
On a random note, and I don't know if this is rumour or not, but someone told me why AirTran no longer has a 2 comp drink limit in BC. The story goes that Joe Leonard was traveling, and asked for a third diet coke and rum, and the f/a politely told him that he was only allowed the two. Shortly after that the limit was compleatly lifted.
#11
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 28
It's a common problem that all airline crews face, but most often in the premium cabins where the booze is comped. Very seldom do we encounter the passenger that drinks to excess in the economy cabin unless they have brought their own, a violation of FAR's.
We have a little game we play in the "upgrade" cabins where, without referring to the paperwork, we guess the upgraded passengers, and the "real" paying folks. The standard we use, that is far more accurate than you would think, is observing alcoholic intake. There is a strong propensity for upgrades to knock back a few pre-dinner pops, then guzzle wine as if they were 18 again, as many apertifs as time permits, and then keep drinking until they are cut off or pass out.
What is amazing, is that these are people that hold responsible positions, and should be smart enough to understand that water and juice are the only beverages one should drink at all when flying. Having said that I know that scenerio is unrealistic. On the other hand the real pro's are the premium passengers who (international flights) get on, refuse the food, ask for water, and go to sleep immediately after take off. They understand what is important. I realize there are exceptions, but believe me when I say that my comments are more rule than exception.
We have a little game we play in the "upgrade" cabins where, without referring to the paperwork, we guess the upgraded passengers, and the "real" paying folks. The standard we use, that is far more accurate than you would think, is observing alcoholic intake. There is a strong propensity for upgrades to knock back a few pre-dinner pops, then guzzle wine as if they were 18 again, as many apertifs as time permits, and then keep drinking until they are cut off or pass out.
What is amazing, is that these are people that hold responsible positions, and should be smart enough to understand that water and juice are the only beverages one should drink at all when flying. Having said that I know that scenerio is unrealistic. On the other hand the real pro's are the premium passengers who (international flights) get on, refuse the food, ask for water, and go to sleep immediately after take off. They understand what is important. I realize there are exceptions, but believe me when I say that my comments are more rule than exception.
#12
Original Poster




Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Bainbridge Island WA
Posts: 9,473
Originally Posted by nwaflygirl
To the OP- MSP-SEA is longer than three hours. You don't say the size of the passenger, this makes a world of difference. Also, since you don't drink, you probably arent' aware, but the wine glasses are tiny glasses. Really, I don't think an ice cube would fit inside of it. Besides all of this, I am curious-what caused you to focus on his beverage habits so intently? You say he was quiet, so that can't be it. Was he rude? Slovenly?
#13

Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: RDU
Programs: Marriott PLT, Starwood, American Gold, Delta
Posts: 448
Pax in Exit Row
I was on flight one time and FA continued to serve female pax in exit row. I guess I saw pax drink about 6 beers, to point she was standing up, singing, starting taking her top off. I was across aisle. I tend to take the exit row stuff seriously and there was no way in the world she could "follow commands, issue instructions" in her state. I was disappointed in FA for continuing to serve someone they had delegated responsibilities to.
#14
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Boston, MA
Programs: AA EXP, UA Global Services , Marriott Platinum
Posts: 301
I have once seen a flight attendant cut off a passenger for intoxication (in Coach even! But it was on the way to Vegas). However, there is a period prior to being completely outwardly intoxicated where they are "talkative". So they may not be beligerant and a general problem to the rest of the cabin, but they are an annoyance to the person sitting next to them. I sat next to a guy recently who drank maybe 6 (I'm estimating) doubles of whiskey/Coke during a flight from DFW-SAN which is a bit over two hours of actual in-flight time. If his drink didn't taste strong enough, he would ring the call button and request a top-up. While he wasn't outwardly intoxicated, he was certainly an annoyance to me. He actually physically took my headphone out at one point when I was trying to ignore his repeated attempts at chatting. And it's not even just insisting on having a conversation; when one is a little drunk, they have a greater tendency to talk about inappropriate things! I don't need to hear about your divorce and what a jerk your ex is and I certainly don't need to hear about the strip clubs you prefer in San Diego. I'm a girl. (Sorry, minor vent there!)
Either way, I would support an upper limit based on the flight time. While it is true that everyone can safely consume varying amounts, limiting everyone to a reasonable amount based on flight time would likely alleviate some problems.
Either way, I would support an upper limit based on the flight time. While it is true that everyone can safely consume varying amounts, limiting everyone to a reasonable amount based on flight time would likely alleviate some problems.
#15
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Asia/Europe
Programs: CX, OZ, MU (+AY, DL), Shangri-La, Hilton
Posts: 7,233
I've had one experience when a seatmate on a European flight started to make threats after I politely refused to partake in his brandy excess. Switched seats and the "gent" in question was escorted for a night at the airport police facilities by two officers at the gate. Declined to press charges as anonymity was not breached but I guess he would have been in deep trouble on a US flight.


