FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   MilesBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/milesbuzz-370/)
-   -   MilesBuzz: Canada (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/milesbuzz/1466579-milesbuzz-canada.html)

MJ777 Jun 22, 2015 1:31 pm

Thanks Winebug - Makes sense and a good lesson to keep alert indeed. I suppose I assumed in this case they'd give a courtesy call before taking this kind of action. All good for me but I can see how this could turn into a tough situation for someone in different circumstances.

Smiley90 Jun 22, 2015 9:37 pm

Did I get this right, the only way to earn 100% miles on a deepest-discount flight is for AA?

AC is 50%, so is BA, AA appears to be 100% regardless of what airline you fly with? (AA or BA)

(well, and Delta Skymiles is a mess with 5x ticket price for lowest status members, which is basically like 50% of distance miles on the itinerary I'm looking at - even less on partners)

mahasamatman Jun 22, 2015 9:56 pm


Originally Posted by Smiley90 (Post 25012547)
Did I get this right, the only way to earn 100% miles on a deepest-discount flight is for AA?

Until they change to a revenue-based model like DL and UA.

Smiley90 Jun 22, 2015 9:59 pm


Originally Posted by mahasamatman (Post 25012611)
Until they change to a revenue-based model like DL and UA.

Is that predicted to happen? Do we know that it'll downgrade the miles earned? (e.g. will they retain roughly their value, to e.g. a 1k dollar 2k mile flight going from 1 mile earned/mile travelled to 2miles earned/1 dollar spent, or will they lose value like DL?)

mahasamatman Jun 22, 2015 10:16 pm


Originally Posted by Smiley90 (Post 25012618)
Is that predicted to happen?

Many people think it's just a matter of time.


Originally Posted by Smiley90 (Post 25012618)
Do we know that it'll downgrade the miles earned?

When was the last time any frequent flyer change was favorable to low-value flyers?

Smiley90 Jun 22, 2015 10:21 pm


Originally Posted by mahasamatman (Post 25012665)
Many people think it's just a matter of time.


When was the last time any frequent flyer change was favorable to low-value flyers?

... touche

keitherson Jun 23, 2015 2:52 pm


Originally Posted by Smiley90 (Post 25012618)
Is that predicted to happen? Do we know that it'll downgrade the miles earned? (e.g. will they retain roughly their value, to e.g. a 1k dollar 2k mile flight going from 1 mile earned/mile travelled to 2miles earned/1 dollar spent, or will they lose value like DL?)

They may not change to a revenue system, but they will at minimum drop the 100% accrual for deep discount economy I'd imagine, like BA did. No other OW carrier even comes close.

Also I think you are confused about your definition of "value". Spending $1000 to fly 2000 miles is 50cpm.

crimsona Jun 23, 2015 3:34 pm

When AA and BA aligned their fare codes a number of years ago, BA bumped all of them up to 100%. Given that BA doesn't care now and dropped to 25% as the lowest, I think AA will go there too. Alaska still gives 100% even on lowest fare buckets if credited to AS or AA.

LearningToFly Jun 23, 2015 4:13 pm


Originally Posted by akhenaton (Post 24995991)
I just booked a one-way flight from Chicago to Tokyo using Avios for AA flight. The taxes were $6, a steal.

Stealing nothing is not exactly a steal!

Smiley90 Jun 23, 2015 5:09 pm


Originally Posted by crimsona (Post 25016876)
When AA and BA aligned their fare codes a number of years ago, BA bumped all of them up to 100%. Given that BA doesn't care now and dropped to 25% as the lowest, I think AA will go there too. Alaska still gives 100% even on lowest fare buckets if credited to AS or AA.

I saw that, but for whatever reason AS only allows award flights to ZRH, no regular flights. Not even from SEA. I don't understand. -shrugs-

sunnyzip Jun 23, 2015 9:23 pm


Originally Posted by crimsona (Post 25016876)
When AA and BA aligned their fare codes a number of years ago, BA bumped all of them up to 100%. Given that BA doesn't care now and dropped to 25% as the lowest, I think AA will go there too. Alaska still gives 100% even on lowest fare buckets if credited to AS or AA.

i have a booking on Alaska. ..fare class R...do i get 100% mileage if crediting to AA...I cant find the fare class on aa.com mileage acrual chart for Alaska. ?

Smiley90 Jun 23, 2015 10:26 pm


Originally Posted by sunnyzip (Post 25018263)
i have a booking on Alaska. ..fare class R...do i get 100% mileage if crediting to AA...I cant find the fare class on aa.com mileage acrual chart for Alaska. ?

https://www.aa.com/i18n/AAdvantage/e...a-airlines.jsp

are you sure it's an AS fare R, operated by AS? Because there's no Business/R...

sunnyzip Jun 23, 2015 10:48 pm


Originally Posted by Smiley90 (Post 25018461)
https://www.aa.com/i18n/AAdvantage/e...a-airlines.jsp

are you sure it's an AS fare R, operated by AS? Because there's no Business/R...

Sorry...its Deep discounted economy- says fare class R.....it shows as 100% acrual on AS website, but no mention on AA website...

mahasamatman Jun 23, 2015 10:51 pm


Originally Posted by sunnyzip (Post 25018529)
Sorry...its Deep discounted economy- says fare class R.....it shows as 100% acrual on AS website, but no mention on AA website...

I'd recommend checking the American Airlines forum. They're the experts, and this really isn't the right forum for questions like this.

loun80 Jun 24, 2015 10:47 am

Hello fellow Canadian FT'ers! 1 more week until Canada Day! Hope you all have a great week until then.

I am planning a trip for Winter and I would like to get your opinion on the best use or allocation of my points. My balance of points are as follows:

Aeroplan 147,550
Asia Miles 50,209
Avios 107,478
AMEX 251,292
SPG 20,000

I am flying out of YVR and some of the cities I want to go to in priority order are:

Bangkok
Ho Chi Minh City
Berlin/Frankfurt
Barcelona/Madrid
Paris
Hong Kong
Tokyo

I don't need go to all cities but going to 3 or 4 of them would be nice.

SLC-YYZ Jun 24, 2015 10:54 am


Originally Posted by gspurr (Post 24980320)
Not that I am aware of. As someone who makes United MP 1K based on miles flown (PQM) and not spend with United (which Americans have to do) I actually hope that United never introduces a CC in Canada as I think that might end up changing United's current policy on waiving the spend requirement for Canadians and other foreigners.

+1 on that ... I am in the same situation with my UA status ... don't have to worry about the spend.

I haven't seen any churns for MP in Canada.

roastpuff Jun 24, 2015 11:04 am


Originally Posted by loun80 (Post 25020809)
Hello fellow Canadian FT'ers! 1 more week until Canada Day! Hope you all have a great week until then.

I am planning a trip for Winter and I would like to get your opinion on the best use or allocation of my points. My balance of points are as follows:

Aeroplan 147,550
Asia Miles 50,209
Avios 107,478
AMEX 251,292
SPG 20,000

I am flying out of YVR and some of the cities I want to go to in priority order are:

Bangkok
Ho Chi Minh City
Berlin/Frankfurt
Barcelona/Madrid
Paris
Hong Kong
Tokyo

I don't need go to all cities but going to 3 or 4 of them would be nice.



I would try to use Aeroplan to get to Asia on maybe EVA or Thai, in a round-trip business class ticket. You can get 2 stopovers plus destination, so you can hit up Tokyo, HKG, Bangkok, and Ho Chi Minh for sure. Might just use Avios from Tokyo-HKG on either JAL or Cathay if you want to hit up all 4.

Otherwise, Europe using Aeroplan again, with two stopovers and Avios on BA/Iberia for the intra-Europe short trips. Maybe YVR-Frankfurt-Paris-YVR with Paris-Barcelona on Avios (Iberia).

grandgourmand Jun 24, 2015 11:18 am


Originally Posted by loun80 (Post 25020809)
Hello fellow Canadian FT'ers! 1 more week until Canada Day! Hope you all have a great week until then.

I am planning a trip for Winter and I would like to get your opinion on the best use or allocation of my points. My balance of points are as follows:

Aeroplan 147,550
Asia Miles 50,209
Avios 107,478
AMEX 251,292
SPG 20,000

I am flying out of YVR and some of the cities I want to go to in priority order are:

Bangkok
Ho Chi Minh City
Berlin/Frankfurt
Barcelona/Madrid
Paris
Hong Kong
Tokyo

I don't need go to all cities but going to 3 or 4 of them would be nice.


How many people are travelling with you? If it's just you, and with that amount of points you should be able to do everything in two trips. In business class or First.

As opposed to designing your itinerary, which takes a lot of time, I suggest you look at routings on your own out of Vancouver and out of nearby airports like SEA, SFO and LAX. Keep your options open to include these cities as it improves your flexiblity and allows you to test out some better products (e.g. ANA out of YVR has old angled seating in business, but SEA/SFO/LAX all have the new seating).

Probably the best (or at least simplest) course of action is to convert your Amex points to Aeroplan (as many as you need, no more) and fly Star Alliance airlines to do your Asia trips. Air Canada, but also EVA (low fees), ANA, Thai, Singapore (the latter only within the region, long haul premium cabins from NA not available using Aeroplan).

I don't know much about using Asia Miles, but you could potentially use those to book side trips within Asia if you were to use Hong Kong as a base (e.g. fly Cathay to Ho Chi Minh or Bangkok from HKG).

Avios pretty much sucks for long haul flights (although you have enough for YVR-HKG one-way on Cathay for 90k points). It's very limiting, charges you points per leg of trip. But it's useful for short haul flights. So if you can't find space from YVR to SFO for a "positioning flight" for instance you may be able to use Avios.

As far as Europe goes, Jerry Hung started a useful thread in the Air CAnada/Aeroplan section that talks about how to get to Europe using Aeroplan while minimizing fuel surcharges (YQ is the acronym you'll see). You should get some routing ideas on that for the European stuff.

There's also a big discussion on mini-round-the-world (RTW) trips using Aeroplan. Something I know nothing about, but could be useful to read.

Your request is wide open, and can go in many directions as you can tell from this respose. You should do a lot of research (figuring out routes and which carriers serve them is a big part of that). Then come back with some specific questions.

loun80 Jun 24, 2015 2:55 pm

OK. What do you think of this plan?

- Convert 40,000 AMEX points to receive 30,000 Asia Miles to top up my Asia Miles balance to 80,000. Use this 80,000 for YVR-NRT RT on JAL business class.

- NRT-BKK RT with a layover in SGN for 30,000 Aeroplan miles with Asiana and Thai Air in J.

- While in BKK, do a BKK-HKG RT from for 30,000 Avios with Cathay in J.

onlycat Jun 24, 2015 6:01 pm


Originally Posted by roastpuff (Post 25020895)
I would try to use Aeroplan to get to Asia on maybe EVA or Thai, in a round-trip business class ticket. You can get 2 stopovers plus destination, so you can hit up Tokyo, HKG, Bangkok, and Ho Chi Minh for sure. Might just use Avios from Tokyo-HKG on either JAL or Cathay if you want to hit up all 4.

Otherwise, Europe using Aeroplan again, with two stopovers and Avios on BA/Iberia for the intra-Europe short trips. Maybe YVR-Frankfurt-Paris-YVR with Paris-Barcelona on Avios (Iberia).

Hi, I am new here. Just wonder how to use Aeroplan on Eva or Thai?

Also when I try to book stopover YVR-Paris, it only allowed LHR and cost more than don't select own stopover. (on BA website)

Thanks

loun80 Jun 24, 2015 6:05 pm


Originally Posted by onlycat (Post 25022879)
Hi, I am new here. Just wonder how to use Aeroplan on Eva or Thai?

Also when I try to book stopover YVR-Paris, it only allowed LHR and cost more than don't select own stopover. (on BA website)

Thanks

When you book on the Aeroplan site from YVR to TPE or BKK, it will give you Eva Air and Thai Airways options.

Yes, stopovers cost more with BA. If you want to stop in Paris to go to LHR, then try booking with Aeroplan.

grandgourmand Jun 24, 2015 6:44 pm


Originally Posted by loun80 (Post 25022094)
OK. What do you think of this plan?

- Convert 40,000 AMEX points to receive 30,000 Asia Miles to top up my Asia Miles balance to 80,000. Use this 80,000 for YVR-NRT RT on JAL business class.

- NRT-BKK RT with a layover in SGN for 30,000 Aeroplan miles with Asiana and Thai Air in J.

- While in BKK, do a BKK-HKG RT from for 30,000 Avios with Cathay in J.

Sounds like you have it figured out already. The intra-Asia Aeroplan J award is amazing value.

I had to do a double check....is it only 80k Asia Miles RT in J YVR-NRT? That's amazing value. Is there a catch?

Edit: Just did a quick check on the Asia Miles award chart. Looks like the one world partner chart is showing points required for total miles flown, not just the distance between cities. YVR and NRT are ~4700 miles apart = 9400 miles distance flown. that bumps you up to award zone 7 which requires 95k Asia Miles for a RT ticket. Better than Aeroplan for J. So you'd need to transfer 60k Amex points. Which brings you to a total of 110k "points" vs. 150k Aeroplan requirement for the same flight. BUT....you may to loop in a few of those other cities you plan on visiting on one Aeroplan award rather than having to spend the extra 30k Avios and 30k Aeroplan for those side trips.

Before I go further, though, this discussion shouldn't be on the Milesbuzz board (mainly to talk about credit card offers in Canada).

mahasamatman Jun 24, 2015 8:38 pm


Originally Posted by gspurr (Post 24980320)
As someone who makes United MP 1K based on miles flown (PQM) and not spend with United (which Americans have to do)

People with a U.S. address need to do both.

onlycat Jun 24, 2015 10:42 pm


Originally Posted by loun80 (Post 25022890)
When you book on the Aeroplan site from YVR to TPE or BKK, it will give you Eva Air and Thai Airways options.

Yes, stopovers cost more with BA. If you want to stop in Paris to go to LHR, then try booking with Aeroplan.

Thanks^

matthieugd Jun 25, 2015 3:08 am


Originally Posted by loun80 (Post 25020809)

I am flying out of YVR and some of the cities I want to go to in priority order are:

Bangkok
Ho Chi Minh City
Berlin/Frankfurt
Barcelona/Madrid
Paris
Hong Kong
Tokyo

I don't need go to all cities but going to 3 or 4 of them would be nice.

Hello,

I'm currently doing a trip in Asia visiting 3 cities on the same ticket : Bangkok, Shanghai and Seoul. I used 150k Aeroplan for a ticket in Business. The routing is YUL-BKK (via IST with TK), BKK-PVG with TG, PVG-ICT with OZ and finally ICT-YUL via LAX with OZ and AC

I'm not an expert so I used the service of http://canadiankilometers.boardingar...an-kilometers/ very professional. I gave him the cities I wanted to visit with the approx. dates and he build an routing.

Hyacinthe Jun 25, 2015 2:37 pm

$100 Gift Card for TD First Class Travel Visa Infinite via https://www.ratesupermarket.ca/deals/td/100/ (apply before July 31st)

mkjr Jun 25, 2015 2:56 pm


Originally Posted by winebug (Post 24992500)
Tried it, doesn't work.

Apparently they check in your BA account:
- country needs to be Canada
- name needs to be the same
- birthdate needs to be the same.

Create a family BA Avios account and move them around.

Points will automatically return to your account within 24 hours, at least it did in my case.

if both have an avion, move RBC to pooled joint esso account then since both persons can use the esso points, move to second persons RBC avion then to BA.

martyYYZ Jun 26, 2015 4:35 am

Canada Amex MR has a 25% bonus on transfers to Avios

http://catalogue.membershiprewards.c...r_participants

erwintok Jun 26, 2015 7:01 am


Originally Posted by martyYYZ (Post 25029624)
Canada Amex MR has a 25% bonus on transfers to Avios

http://catalogue.membershiprewards.c...r_participants

Is this a promo? Or is this the new going rate?

alc Jun 26, 2015 8:27 am


Originally Posted by martyYYZ (Post 25029624)
Canada Amex MR has a 25% bonus on transfers to Avios

http://catalogue.membershiprewards.c...r_participants


Originally Posted by erwintok (Post 25029967)
Is this a promo? Or is this the new going rate?

Here is the thread that talk about this:

http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/ameri...25-2015-a.html

loun80 Jun 26, 2015 9:00 am


Originally Posted by martyYYZ (Post 25029624)
Canada Amex MR has a 25% bonus on transfers to Avios

http://catalogue.membershiprewards.c...r_participants

YES! The day has finally come! I've been waiting about 2 years. :D

onlycat Jun 26, 2015 12:07 pm


Originally Posted by loun80 (Post 25030601)
YES! The day has finally come! I've been waiting about 2 years. :D

So it must be a good deal then?! I am just planning to transfer some points to get a one way BA tik.^

loun80 Jun 26, 2015 1:49 pm


Originally Posted by onlycat (Post 25031531)
So it must be a good deal then?! I am just planning to transfer some points to get a one way BA tik.^

Well, the deal isn't go great anymore unless you only travel in economy class as the BA devalued their Avios in April 2015.

DealAddict Jun 27, 2015 8:30 am


Originally Posted by winebug (Post 24963815)
Has anyone been declined on the CIBC business aeroplan? Does anyone know how much time it needs without credit check and minimum score?

Mine is just below 700, and I got approved...Applied, called the next day, was asked about the kind of business I have. Done deal.More free points ^

DealAddict Jun 27, 2015 8:31 am

Avios transfers don't excite me... for Europe , Avios are kind of useless.But great for short haul.

peacestar Jun 27, 2015 9:16 am


Originally Posted by DealAddict (Post 25034910)
Mine is just below 700, and I got approved...Applied, called the next day, was asked about the kind of business I have. Done deal.More free points ^

I made the mistake of applying over the phone. I had to fax T4 and NOA for 2 yeas. It took 2weeks but approved . They also checked my credit twice in the last two weeks.

DealAddict Jun 27, 2015 9:37 am


Originally Posted by peacestar (Post 25035044)
I made the mistake of applying over the phone. I had to fax T4 and NOA for 2 yeas. It took 2weeks but approved . They also checked my credit twice in the last two weeks.

Yikes.I wonder why there is a difference between applying online vs on the phone. Glad I applied online... it was painless.

mikeycanuk Jun 28, 2015 7:53 am

Can't remember if this has been posted before but the CIBC Aerobiz 20,000 bonus is distinction eligible. My wife applied online with no issues. I will apply in Aug as I only cancelled it in Feb.

jerryhung Jun 28, 2015 10:53 am


Originally Posted by mikeycanuk (Post 25038256)
Can't remember if this has been posted before but the CIBC Aerobiz 20,000 bonus is distinction eligible. My wife applied online with no issues. I will apply in Aug as I only cancelled it in Feb.

Yep, many can confirm the 20K is dDistinction eligible
not that dStatus are that useful

loun80 Jun 28, 2015 11:11 am

Has anyone had the experience of entering the wrong Aeroplan number during the CIBC Aeroplan Visa Business application and had the bonus points deposited to someone else' account? I just did that and I'm trying to get my 20k back. =(


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 8:07 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.