Which Hotel Credit Cards are worth MSing?
#61
Original Poster
Join Date: Feb 2014
Posts: 908
Good info. Club Carlson has nice hotel in europe but since I wasn't approved for the card I opted for park hyatt. Fairmont. And hilton for my europe Trip. I stayed at a Radisson in richmond. Canada it was nice. Not 5 stars. But will do if it was just a regular vac.
I lowered my chase hyatt CL to 5k. I don't think I will be msing with it. I already have a few cards with amex. Don't want to have amother pull applying for the surpass. My CL for my spg is 2k
I'll probably ms about 40-80k a year with the hilton Reserve at simon.
Once I get my ihg card. I would ms a little with it also for stays at the intercontinental hotels.
I lowered my chase hyatt CL to 5k. I don't think I will be msing with it. I already have a few cards with amex. Don't want to have amother pull applying for the surpass. My CL for my spg is 2k
I'll probably ms about 40-80k a year with the hilton Reserve at simon.
Once I get my ihg card. I would ms a little with it also for stays at the intercontinental hotels.
#62
Original Poster
Join Date: Feb 2014
Posts: 908
Good info. Club Carlson has nice hotel in europe but since I wasn't approved for the card I opted for park hyatt. Fairmont. And hilton for my europe Trip. I stayed at a Radisson in richmond. Canada it was nice. Not 5 stars. But will do if it was just a regular vac.
I lowered my chase hyatt CL to 5k. I don't think I will be msing with it. I already have a few cards with amex. Don't want to have amother pull applying for the surpass. My CL for my spg is 2k
I'll probably ms about 40-80k a year with the hilton Reserve at simon.
Once I get my ihg card. I would ms a little with it also for stays at the intercontinental hotels.
I lowered my chase hyatt CL to 5k. I don't think I will be msing with it. I already have a few cards with amex. Don't want to have amother pull applying for the surpass. My CL for my spg is 2k
I'll probably ms about 40-80k a year with the hilton Reserve at simon.
Once I get my ihg card. I would ms a little with it also for stays at the intercontinental hotels.
Last edited by sosamo; Mar 21, 2015 at 10:50 am
#63
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 1,710
That is true but they do have some interesting gaps even there. There are near as I can tell three CC properties in all of Italy. One in Rome (with mixed reviews, mostly about location), one in Milan and one some distance from Venice (probably far enough away you wouldn't want to stay there if going to Venice).
#64
Join Date: May 2012
Location: NYC
Programs: AA PLT
Posts: 223
That is true but they do have some interesting gaps even there. There are near as I can tell three CC properties in all of Italy. One in Rome (with mixed reviews, mostly about location), one in Milan and one some distance from Venice (probably far enough away you wouldn't want to stay there if going to Venice).
I've had my eye on the CC card for a little while. Will likely pull the trigger sometime this year (because, why not...) But most of the comments I read about it being a great card for Europe seem to always call out the same 2 or 3 properties... scandinavian countries seem to get a lot of mentions. What are some of the other prime Europe CC properties? Good location, and all the rest?
#65
Join Date: Oct 2014
Programs: All of them
Posts: 1,664
I've had my eye on the CC card for a little while. Will likely pull the trigger sometime this year (because, why not...) But most of the comments I read about it being a great card for Europe seem to always call out the same 2 or 3 properties... scandinavian countries seem to get a lot of mentions. What are some of the other prime Europe CC properties? Good location, and all the rest?
#66
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Chicago, IL
Programs: AA EP; WN CP;UA SILVER; MARRIOTT TITANIUM; HH DIAMOND; IHG PLAT; RADISSON PLAT; HYATT GLOBAL
Posts: 1,938
Discussed earlier, and another option. Hold multiple cards that have free annual night benefits.
My SO and I have the IHG, HH Reserve, Hyatt and Club Carl Personal and Business.
Yes, that is 10 cards total, with 10 annual fees. But it is easy, no need to MS.
And I have been successful to get some really good retention offers that offset the annual cost.
I use these points/free nights for high end properties, expensive cities or peak travel time (ie, Sporting Events, XMAS & NYE) to maximize return.
Of course I mix in everyday spend.
I also do buy points when there are good sales. To some this is not worth, but for me it is, easy. I also participate in the structured offers, like stay X, get X.
I also hit MS pretty hard on my airline cards.
Just like a good investment portfolio, I diversify.
Goal is to get "free" travel, but I am also very pleased to get "highly discounted" travel.
My SO and I have the IHG, HH Reserve, Hyatt and Club Carl Personal and Business.
Yes, that is 10 cards total, with 10 annual fees. But it is easy, no need to MS.
And I have been successful to get some really good retention offers that offset the annual cost.
I use these points/free nights for high end properties, expensive cities or peak travel time (ie, Sporting Events, XMAS & NYE) to maximize return.
Of course I mix in everyday spend.
I also do buy points when there are good sales. To some this is not worth, but for me it is, easy. I also participate in the structured offers, like stay X, get X.
I also hit MS pretty hard on my airline cards.
Just like a good investment portfolio, I diversify.
Goal is to get "free" travel, but I am also very pleased to get "highly discounted" travel.
#68
Join Date: May 2012
Location: NYC
Programs: AA PLT
Posts: 223
that's the Valhalla, right? multiple cards, multiple free nights, string them together for a vacation we couldn't afford otherwise.
#69
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 1,710
The "problem" with some hotel cards is they aren't a whole lot better (and some are worse) than just MSing on a 2% or 2.2% cashback card. Just because you get a hotel stay for half price (accounting for cost of MS) doesn't mean it is a good deal as compared to 2% cashback and booking the same hotel via Hotwire at a discount. Also there are a number of ways to to get discounted lodgings beyond just hotels. I do MS some hotel cards for hotel stays but you really need to run the numbers and compare to other options you have for lodging/discount lodging.
And of course the math can change a lot based on what your cost of MS is, what other options you have to MS and your volume.
And of course the math can change a lot based on what your cost of MS is, what other options you have to MS and your volume.
#71
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 1,207
The "problem" with some hotel cards is they aren't a whole lot better (and some are worse) than just MSing on a 2% or 2.2% cashback card. Just because you get a hotel stay for half price (accounting for cost of MS) doesn't mean it is a good deal as compared to 2% cashback and booking the same hotel via Hotwire at a discount. Also there are a number of ways to to get discounted lodgings beyond just hotels. I do MS some hotel cards for hotel stays but you really need to run the numbers and compare to other options you have for lodging/discount lodging.
And of course the math can change a lot based on what your cost of MS is, what other options you have to MS and your volume.
And of course the math can change a lot based on what your cost of MS is, what other options you have to MS and your volume.
#72
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 1,710
Yes humans are remarkably good at making poor economic decisions (not pointing the finger at you as I too can fall prey to the thought process you outline). That said just because one makes that decision doesn't necessarily make it right in a strictly logical sense. Still in reality this is a hobby as much as a business to most folks and if they are happy with what they get from it, that is all that matters.
#73
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Madison, WI, USA
Posts: 14,162
The "problem" with some hotel cards is they aren't a whole lot better (and some are worse) than just MSing on a 2% or 2.2% cashback card. Just because you get a hotel stay for half price (accounting for cost of MS) doesn't mean it is a good deal as compared to 2% cashback and booking the same hotel via Hotwire at a discount...
#74
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 688
IHG gives a free annual night and CC gives 40k points/yr so it can be redeemed for free night.
#75
Join Date: Sep 2008
Posts: 63
Hyatt gives a free night every year you pay AF too. Hilton Reserve gives you a free night after $10K spend.