Consolidated "Champagne - Questions/Suggestions/Recommendations" thread
#766
Suspended
Join Date: May 2013
Posts: 738
Interestingly, Laetitia took over the California operation, including winery, mature vineyards, and tasting room, of Deutz - a French Champagne house.
#768
Suspended
Join Date: May 2013
Posts: 738
#770
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: AU
Programs: former Olympic Airways Gold (yeah - still proud of that!)
Posts: 14,541
A few years ago, we hosted a blind champagne tasting, with champagnes ranging in price from the 20s to Dom. No one knew which champagnes were which, because all were in brown paper bags. Each participant was given a rating form, and they gave numerical values. After the tasting, the ratings were compiled and the clear winner was Piper Heidsieck Brut. You can't go wrong. About $40, but YMMV.
#772
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Snooky
Posts: 2,507
#773




Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: Hawai'i Nei
Programs: Au: HA, UA, Marriott, Hilton; GE
Posts: 7,814
Welcome back into the club. We like Charles Heidieck too!^
#774




Join Date: Jun 2012
Programs: AA EXP, Hyatt Globalist, AF Silver
Posts: 5,018
So I ended up picking up a bottle of Moet, and then went on the day of Thanksgiving and got a bottle of Veuve-Clicquot. I like the Moet more, it tasted less acidic than the Veuve-Clicquot. How does Dom Perignon compare?
#775




Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Finland
Programs: Almost anything with six to twelve steps...
Posts: 1,034
Cheers,
T.
#776
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Snooky
Posts: 2,507
I rarely find vintage champagne to be worth the $$, since the grey market in the US dried up 25 years ago. I'm still happily given the opportunity more than occasionally, but not on my dime. You're paying 5X the price for something that's 10% better than NV, IMO.
#777
Suspended
Join Date: May 2013
Posts: 738
Personally, I find the worst jump in price relative to quality comes from stepping from the various French Houses' best wines produced in other regions around the world to their basic NV Brut genuine Champagne cuvee.
For example, Domaine Chandon Reserve costs less than Moet NV Brut - and IMHO, is a superior wine. Similarly, I find that the California Roederer Estate L'Ermitage is well superior to Roederer's Brut NV Champagne. (IMHO, even Roederer's base California Estate wine is superior to their base Champagne Cuvee, at half the price.)
In other words, the biggest tax paid relative to quality is to buy authentic Champagne compared to sparklers produced elsewhere by the same firms that know best how to make the stuff.
#778
FlyerTalk Evangelist

Join Date: Feb 1999
Location: Seat 1A, Juice pretty much everywhere, Mucci des Coins Exotiques
Posts: 34,337
I attended a blind tasting of small Champagne producers this week. Most all retail around 20 or 30 per bottle and several stood up to the top name brands such as Krug, Bollinger, Tattinger, etc. I tried 13 whites and 4 ross. My top 3...
1. Benot Lahaye, Naturessence, extra-brut http://champagne-benoit-lahaye.ardoneo.com/
2. Maurice Vesselle, Millsime 2000, grand cru, brut http://champagnemauricevesselle.com/en/
3. Daniel Savart, L'Overture, Blanc de Noirs, brut http://www.champagne-savart.com/
Not sure if you can get these easily outside of France, but they are well worth the price it you can.
1. Benot Lahaye, Naturessence, extra-brut http://champagne-benoit-lahaye.ardoneo.com/
2. Maurice Vesselle, Millsime 2000, grand cru, brut http://champagnemauricevesselle.com/en/
3. Daniel Savart, L'Overture, Blanc de Noirs, brut http://www.champagne-savart.com/
Not sure if you can get these easily outside of France, but they are well worth the price it you can.
#779




Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: In the air
Programs: Finnair Platinum, Bonvoy LT Plat, GHA Tit, Turkish Elite
Posts: 9,177
Did a lot of wine tasting (ok, drinking) as part of my trip to Bangkok yesterday. I thought I should offer a summary. My palette may have gotten less sensitive over time. In order of consumption:
Piper Heidseick at the St Pancras Champagne Bar - Perfectly adequate, quite light taste. 6/10
Gosset NV at the St Pancras Champagne Bar - More flavour and a lovely balance. 7.5/10
Pol Roger 2002 Vintage in the LHR Qatar lounge - A very nice champagne. Simultaneously light and bubbly as well as having some of the depth you'd expect of a champagne of this age. 8/10
Moet Rose 2004 Vintage in the LHR Qatar Lounge - Either something was wrong with the bottle (not corked) or this was really an acquired taste. Strong nose, slightly acrid on the tongue. 2/10
Krug in Qatar F - Lovely champagne and unusually fine bubbles with a strong sense of butter really coming out after all the others. 9/10
Billecart-Salmon Brut Reserve - Very solid mid-priced champagne with a very slight taste of fruit on the tongue. For the price, you can't go far wrong - it would have just been even nicer to have the Blanc de Blancs. 8/10
And yes, add a glass of vodka with the caviar and a couple of glasses of a fantastic dessert wine and I did feel awful when I woke up, thanks.
Piper Heidseick at the St Pancras Champagne Bar - Perfectly adequate, quite light taste. 6/10
Gosset NV at the St Pancras Champagne Bar - More flavour and a lovely balance. 7.5/10
Pol Roger 2002 Vintage in the LHR Qatar lounge - A very nice champagne. Simultaneously light and bubbly as well as having some of the depth you'd expect of a champagne of this age. 8/10
Moet Rose 2004 Vintage in the LHR Qatar Lounge - Either something was wrong with the bottle (not corked) or this was really an acquired taste. Strong nose, slightly acrid on the tongue. 2/10
Krug in Qatar F - Lovely champagne and unusually fine bubbles with a strong sense of butter really coming out after all the others. 9/10
Billecart-Salmon Brut Reserve - Very solid mid-priced champagne with a very slight taste of fruit on the tongue. For the price, you can't go far wrong - it would have just been even nicer to have the Blanc de Blancs. 8/10
And yes, add a glass of vodka with the caviar and a couple of glasses of a fantastic dessert wine and I did feel awful when I woke up, thanks.
Last edited by EuropeanPete; Dec 5, 2013 at 2:08 pm
#780
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Snooky
Posts: 2,507
"And yes, add a glass of vodka with the caviar and a couple of glasses of a fantastic dessert wine and I did feel awful when I woke up, thanks". - Well worth it in my estimation. I've been known to utter the phrase "go big or go home". Bravo Sir, you were able to do both simultaneously.

