FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Checkpoints and Borders Policy Debate (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/checkpoints-borders-policy-debate-687/)
-   -   New ludicrous electronics out at TSA Checkpoint (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/checkpoints-borders-policy-debate/757578-new-ludicrous-electronics-out-tsa-checkpoint.html)

KleineFrau Nov 18, 2007 3:41 am


Originally Posted by PTravel (Post 8748389)
Going through the LAX elite line, yesterday, "barker" was saying to take out all "large" electronics -- laptops, cameras, CD players, etc.

My two carry-ons were crammed with electronics -- my laptop, two digital still cameras, a digital camcorder, and all manner of support electronics, as well as an MD recorder, my Blackberry, three cellphones and, of course, my Bose NC phones and an iPod. I wasn't about to empty my "large" electronics in the bins, particularly my cameras which get held up to my face (think about it -- shoes walk on the ground, shoes go in the bin, what was on the ground gets transferred to the bin, etc.)

I took out the laptop and left everything else in the bags. One bag got pulled for secondary. The screener was polite, as was I. I asked him to change his gloves, which he did. He did a short inspection, ran a couple of swabs and wished me a nice day, which I returned.

Because this was the elite line, I don't know what was happening with the Kettles and the Gomers.

Darnit. My flight out of LAX on the 26th will be just lovely, then. That day, will have all camera gear (considerable), plus two laptops and an iPod. The laptops I always expect, but the camera gear, I guess, is getting a secondary. No chance I am letting a brand new digital SLR and all associated lenses, lights and other gear roll around in that dirty bin. Ew.

bzbdewd Nov 18, 2007 7:50 am


Originally Posted by birdstrike (Post 8748284)
Any interaction with a security force can only have a neutral or negative outcome for the civilians immediately involved.

I believe that was the genesis of the "snake" comment. The TSA, by its own admission, is an unpredictable element in travel.

By design, I cannot tell from trip to trip what I will encounter at an airport checkpoint.

I carry more than $15K in photo gear, computer equipment, and assorted weird electronics on almost every trip.

Keeping track of this as it goes out of my sight, knowing that there are criminal pax and (far fewer) criminal screeners who would love to dip into the toys-on-parade does generate a bit of stress.

The "barkers", first time travelers, and unfortunately all-too-often incompetent screeners just add to the unpredictability of the checkpoint.

So, I like snakes. I have no fear of snakes. Even poisonous snakes are cool. However I know that every encounter with one can only have a neutral or negative outcome.

That was exactly what I was trying to say with the snake reference - thank you for saying it in a much more understandable way.

BLI-Flyer Nov 18, 2007 8:32 am

I went through ABQ yesterday afternoon and there was no additional screening of electronics.

bzbdewd Nov 18, 2007 9:52 am


Originally Posted by KleineFrau (Post 8748972)
Darnit. My flight out of LAX on the 26th will be just lovely, then. That day, will have all camera gear (considerable), plus two laptops and an iPod. The laptops I always expect, but the camera gear, I guess, is getting a secondary. No chance I am letting a brand new digital SLR and all associated lenses, lights and other gear roll around in that dirty bin. Ew.

The problem with having your camera gear go through a secondary is that they will insist on unpacking the bag themselves and may not be gentle about how they handle things. When we had this happen the TSO handled our camera gear and external hard drives like old shoes - just dumping them into the bins. We got a 'do you want to fly today' when bzbdavid freaked out about it and tried to unpack it himself.

Just wondering - if something like this happens and they break something what then?? Are you just SOL or does the TSA have to pay for it??

KleineFrau Nov 18, 2007 10:12 am


Originally Posted by bzbdewd (Post 8749904)
The problem with having your camera gear go through a secondary is that they will insist on unpacking the bag themselves and may not be gentle about how they handle things. When we had this happen the TSO handled our camera gear and external hard drives like old shoes - just dumping them into the bins. We got a 'do you want to fly today' when bzbdavid freaked out about it and tried to unpack it himself.

Just wondering - if something like this happens and they break something what then?? Are you just SOL or does the TSA have to pay for it??

As much as it angers me that they would unpack it, and that I have to choose the lesser of two evils (I shouldn't have to choose, period), how would it be good for very delicate lenses and camera gear going through on a belt, getting bumped around by other bins, rolling around in their own bin? Yeah, that thought is really scary. It is extremely sensitive equipment that will crack under such conditions.

My average gear consists of an SLR, two separate lenses, an external flash, spare batteries, CF cards, and many different types of wires that all connect to different things. The camera body, the lenses and the external flash are what scare me the most. They are in a padded carrying case for a darn good reason.

Oh, I hate this so much. I am so glad to be leaving the US!

vassilipan Nov 18, 2007 10:23 am


Originally Posted by essxjay (Post 8748774)
You must've been napping .... he's not taken the bar exam just yet. Go back to sleep. ;)

Cheap Wal-Mart glasses.

iluv2fly Nov 18, 2007 6:54 pm

Just went through screening at LAS. No nonsense. But the lines!!! Took forever and they were snaking around the terminal again! Allow enough time for your flight. Many people missed theirs at UA today. :td: :(

MojaveFlyer Nov 18, 2007 7:43 pm


Originally Posted by iluv2fly (Post 8752278)
Just went through screening at LAS. No nonsense. But the lines!!! Took forever and they were snaking around the terminal again! Allow enough time for your flight. Many people missed theirs at UA today. :td: :(

How long did you wait? I had 2 hrs + once after a CES. I don't mind checking in early, but you'd have thought that getting to the airport 2.5 hours before flight would be plenty, but no... When LAS gets hosed, it is awful!

MrAndy1369 Nov 18, 2007 9:27 pm


Originally Posted by iluv2fly (Post 8752278)
Just went through screening at LAS. No nonsense. But the lines!!! Took forever and they were snaking around the terminal again! Allow enough time for your flight. Many people missed theirs at UA today. :td: :(

Why were the lines longer? ID checkers? Or just many passengers vs. screeners?

thezipper Nov 19, 2007 7:19 am

Interesting.... I went through DCA on Sat (11/17) no issues with electronics (just laptop and kippie bag out of my carry-on) and similar experience coming back through DTW on Sun. Also out of FRA, didnt have to take off the shoes ^


Originally Posted by BLI-Flyer (Post 8749577)
I went through ABQ yesterday afternoon and there was no additional screening of electronics.


Peetah Nov 19, 2007 10:06 am

Fortunately for our TSA comrades, they didn't do this nonsense when I flew out Friday.

However, I expect FedEx, UPS and DHL's earnings to increase because I refuse to let those TSA goons handle my equipment.

N674UW Nov 19, 2007 10:12 pm

No sign of this at DEN on Saturday evening...

kkirk2 Nov 19, 2007 10:14 pm

I have had numerous flights out of LAX this month and have yet to encounter this in terminal 4.

FlyingHoustonian Nov 20, 2007 6:03 am

At CDG and MCO and IAH in the last two weeks, I took the plug and power convertor out with my laptop and in all three cases I was told "You don't need to take out the plug and cord" even though the converter is a fairly large piece of electronics.

One never knows.


Ciao,
FH

EngIceDave Nov 20, 2007 7:12 am


Originally Posted by whirledtraveler (Post 8745512)
That was a interesting way of bowing out of an argument. ;)

Seriously, you feel that checking IDs does makes us safer somehow? Would you care to explain how an ID check keeps someone from committing terror on an airplane? Do they just sit on the airplane and go "Wow, they checked my id.. maybe I shouldn't do something terrible!!"

Like I said, it's not a respectable job. Anyone with self-respect would quit due to the utter senselessness of it.

Go ahead and defend it. We're all ears.

ID check may not prevent anything from happening, but it does confirm the manifest to assist any post-event (God forbid) investigation.

and if the 3oz liquid thing is so bad and TSA so wrong for doing it, why is it being done worldwide and even in Russia?
Why would Russia do the same as the USA if it was for no reason at all?
Isn't as if Russia is really big on following the USA's lead on things


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 1:10 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.