TSA Adjusting Prohibitions/Designated "Ask Bart" Thread
#256
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 1,449
Originally Posted by MSY-MSP
That makes about as much sense as when I saw several screeners telling a mother that only one person at a time could go through the WTMD, and that she couldn't carry her baby through the WTMD with her. The folks actually had her hand the Baby through the WTMD to a screener, and then had her walk through seperately. ...
Also, can anyone clarify? -- Thread title says updated today, but I don't see any Bart updates.
#257
Suspended
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Watchlisted by the prejudiced, en route to purgatory
Programs: Just Say No to Fleecing and Blacklisting
Posts: 102,077
Originally Posted by etch5895
I'd hate to think that we are going to profile babies. I would say that I hope terrorists never sink this low, but I know that they would do it if it meant furthering their agendas.
It is sad to think that babies could (or would) be martyred against their will by some sick SOB who loads their diaper with explosives and then detonates it onboard.
The only possible way I see TSA or any airport security being able to fight this is if TSA required parents to change their babies into sterile TSA supplied diapers there at the screening area and supplying them with some for the flight. It is amazing that we are sinking this low as a society.
It is sad to think that babies could (or would) be martyred against their will by some sick SOB who loads their diaper with explosives and then detonates it onboard.
The only possible way I see TSA or any airport security being able to fight this is if TSA required parents to change their babies into sterile TSA supplied diapers there at the screening area and supplying them with some for the flight. It is amazing that we are sinking this low as a society.
#259
Join Date: Feb 2001
Posts: 325
Another odd statement from the TSA website: "Some solid or powdered cosmetics items are permitted past the checkpoint; however, this is left to the discretion of the Security Officer. To minimize delays and hassle, we recommend that you pack all cosmetics in your checked baggage."
Apparently, even if you substitute a non-liquid/gel cosmetic item for your usual brand, the TSO still has the discretion to stop you from carrying it onboard??? This makes me more worried that since shampoos and conditioners are prohibited items, apparently without regard to whether or not they are a liquid/gel, you could be prohibited from carryng them on in any form whatsoever.
Other items that seem to be prohibited without regard to the form of the substance:
Bug repellents
Make up removers or facial cleansers
Mouthwash
Nail polish removers
Maybe the theory is that, if the flying public were less attractive, we would not be such a target for terrorists.
-- Suzanne
Apparently, even if you substitute a non-liquid/gel cosmetic item for your usual brand, the TSO still has the discretion to stop you from carrying it onboard??? This makes me more worried that since shampoos and conditioners are prohibited items, apparently without regard to whether or not they are a liquid/gel, you could be prohibited from carryng them on in any form whatsoever.
Other items that seem to be prohibited without regard to the form of the substance:
Bug repellents
Make up removers or facial cleansers
Mouthwash
Nail polish removers
Maybe the theory is that, if the flying public were less attractive, we would not be such a target for terrorists.
-- Suzanne
#260
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend, In Memoriam




Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Yiron, Israel
Programs: Bates Motel Plat
Posts: 69,201
Originally Posted by Traveller
I'm not Dovster thus I'd rather brush my teeth on the plane rather than join the mile-high club.

More seriously: Aren't we all getting a little carried away here?
I don't like these new rules any more than the next guy, but given the fact that I have little choice in the matter, I can live with them.
Take off my shoes? Yes, I can do that -- I am not even particularly worried about catching some disease through my socks. Since about age 3 or so, I have been taking off my shoes every time I went into a store to buy a new pair and have not suffered from any malady as a result.
Toothpaste, deodorant, et al? I'll put them in my checked baggage. If it doesn't arrive when I do, I will stop in at a pharmacy or supermarket and pick some up. Today, I shelled out $1300 for an upcoming itinerary -- an extra $10 or so for this stuff is not going to make much of a difference.
Do I think I am getting better security for this? No.
Do I believe that a trained terrorist will be able to work around these regulations? Yes.
Do I wish that a more logical system of security were in effect? Of course.
But I am not about to let this put me into a panic.
Last edited by Dovster; Aug 22, 2006 at 12:39 pm
#261
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 250
I would NEVER let a stranger who had been touching hundreds of different people and their belongings TOUCH MY baby and deposit the germs from a whole city full of strangers on him. Not unless that screener put on FRESH NEW RUBBER GLOVES.
#262
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Lahaina, Hawai'i
Programs: HA Pua. Platinum WP, PR, QF, UA, AA, DL, NW Prince Preferred
Posts: 4,786
Originally Posted by Dovster
Actually, Traveller, there is no conflict between the two. In fact, I think you will find that if you brush your teeth on the plane you will have a better shot at joining the Mile High Club.
More seriously: Aren't we all getting a little carried away here?
I don't like these new rules any more than the next guy, but given the fact that I have little choice in the matter, I can live with them.
Take off my shoes? Yes, I can do that -- I am not even particularly worried about catching some disease through my socks. Since about age 3 or so, I have been taking off my shoes every time I went into a store to buy a new pair and have not suffered from any malady as a result.
Toothpaste, deodorant, et al? I'll put them in my checked baggage. If it doesn't arrive when I do, I will stop in at a pharmacy or supermarket and pick some up. Today, I shelled out $1300 for an upcoming itinerary -- an extra $10 or so for his stuff is not going to make much of a difference.
Do I think I am getting better security for this? No.
Do I believe that a trained terrorist will be able to work around these regulations? Yes.
Do I wish that a more logical system of security were in effect? Of course.
But I am not about to let this put me into a panic.
More seriously: Aren't we all getting a little carried away here?
I don't like these new rules any more than the next guy, but given the fact that I have little choice in the matter, I can live with them.
Take off my shoes? Yes, I can do that -- I am not even particularly worried about catching some disease through my socks. Since about age 3 or so, I have been taking off my shoes every time I went into a store to buy a new pair and have not suffered from any malady as a result.
Toothpaste, deodorant, et al? I'll put them in my checked baggage. If it doesn't arrive when I do, I will stop in at a pharmacy or supermarket and pick some up. Today, I shelled out $1300 for an upcoming itinerary -- an extra $10 or so for his stuff is not going to make much of a difference.
Do I think I am getting better security for this? No.
Do I believe that a trained terrorist will be able to work around these regulations? Yes.
Do I wish that a more logical system of security were in effect? Of course.
But I am not about to let this put me into a panic.
Sh'Aloha, Dovster! I like the way you think. Shows good sechel. Gut gezucht, Zai gezunt, Having fun, wish you were here! Shalom + Aloha = Sh'Aloha from Maui!
#263
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Greater DC
Programs: UA plus
Posts: 12,947
Originally Posted by Dovster
Actually, Traveller, there is no conflict between the two. In fact, I think you will find that if you brush your teeth on the plane you will have a better shot at joining the Mile High Club.
More seriously: Aren't we all getting a little carried away here?
I don't like these new rules any more than the next guy, but given the fact that I have little choice in the matter, I can live with them.
Take off my shoes? Yes, I can do that -- I am not even particularly worried about catching some disease through my socks. Since about age 3 or so, I have been taking off my shoes every time I went into a store to buy a new pair and have not suffered from any malady as a result.
Toothpaste, deodorant, et al? I'll put them in my checked baggage. If it doesn't arrive when I do, I will stop in at a pharmacy or supermarket and pick some up. Today, I shelled out $1300 for an upcoming itinerary -- an extra $10 or so for this stuff is not going to make much of a difference.
Do I think I am getting better security for this? No.
Do I believe that a trained terrorist will be able to work around these regulations? Yes.
Do I wish that a more logical system of security were in effect? Of course.
But I am not about to let this put me into a panic.
More seriously: Aren't we all getting a little carried away here?
I don't like these new rules any more than the next guy, but given the fact that I have little choice in the matter, I can live with them.
Take off my shoes? Yes, I can do that -- I am not even particularly worried about catching some disease through my socks. Since about age 3 or so, I have been taking off my shoes every time I went into a store to buy a new pair and have not suffered from any malady as a result.
Toothpaste, deodorant, et al? I'll put them in my checked baggage. If it doesn't arrive when I do, I will stop in at a pharmacy or supermarket and pick some up. Today, I shelled out $1300 for an upcoming itinerary -- an extra $10 or so for this stuff is not going to make much of a difference.
Do I think I am getting better security for this? No.
Do I believe that a trained terrorist will be able to work around these regulations? Yes.
Do I wish that a more logical system of security were in effect? Of course.
But I am not about to let this put me into a panic.
As far as the feet go -- I really don't know where you shop, but the places I shop vaccuum the floor frequently, only have a few hundred not thousand people through on a daily basis and in general pick up after themselves. Aside from all that, my (bare or socked) feet rarely touch that floor - period. I don't go walking around in socked/bare feet except within my own home, that includes public places, hotels, pools, beaches, etc. I also have a parent with diabetes and major foot related issues - yes, I'm concerned, no I don't think its something acceptable. Sorry if myself or others are not as calm or accepting of these new regs as you seem to be.
#264
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Salish Sea
Programs: DL,AC,HH,PC
Posts: 8,972
Originally Posted by GoingAway
Replacements of those products, temporary or otherwise will cost well over $200...

How the hell does one spend $200 in a drugstore ?
#265
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend, In Memoriam




Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Yiron, Israel
Programs: Bates Motel Plat
Posts: 69,201
GoingAway, you might want to look in airport shops -- landside. If they haven't already started stocking small toiletries I am certain they will soon. There are a lot of people in your situation and they know they will be able to pick up some $$$ this way.
For you, it will be a lot cheaper than Fedex.
Also, if you are going to the same places repeatedly, you might want to consider leaving a set of toiletries there. (In addition to what I have in my house, I have one set in Tel Aviv, one in Milano, and one in Lugano -- simply to save me lugging them around.)
As far as where I buy my shoes is concerned, I have bought them all over the world -- and have no idea of how often the stores are vacuumed.
My son -- definitely not a chip off the old block -- is a health nut. He is a vegetarian (prefers the organic stuff), a certified fitness instructor, brown belt in karate, and is currently studying Chinese medicine at Israel's top institution for this field.
He lives in Tel Aviv and only puts on shoes between April and October when a restaurant requires it. The rest of the time he walks around barefoot. He is 26 and has never had any problems with his feet -- and if you have ever been in Tel Aviv, you know it makes New York City look spotless.
For you, it will be a lot cheaper than Fedex.
Also, if you are going to the same places repeatedly, you might want to consider leaving a set of toiletries there. (In addition to what I have in my house, I have one set in Tel Aviv, one in Milano, and one in Lugano -- simply to save me lugging them around.)
As far as where I buy my shoes is concerned, I have bought them all over the world -- and have no idea of how often the stores are vacuumed.
My son -- definitely not a chip off the old block -- is a health nut. He is a vegetarian (prefers the organic stuff), a certified fitness instructor, brown belt in karate, and is currently studying Chinese medicine at Israel's top institution for this field.
He lives in Tel Aviv and only puts on shoes between April and October when a restaurant requires it. The rest of the time he walks around barefoot. He is 26 and has never had any problems with his feet -- and if you have ever been in Tel Aviv, you know it makes New York City look spotless.
#266
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Lahaina, Hawai'i
Programs: HA Pua. Platinum WP, PR, QF, UA, AA, DL, NW Prince Preferred
Posts: 4,786
Originally Posted by Wally Bird
Well I for one am suitably impressed 
How the hell does one spend $200 in a drugstore ?

How the hell does one spend $200 in a drugstore ?
#267
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: United States
Programs: UA, AA, DL, Amtrak
Posts: 4,647
Originally Posted by Dovster
GoingAway, you might want to look in airport shops -- landside. If they haven't already started stocking small toiletries I am certain they will soon. There are a lot of people in your situation and they know they will be able to pick up some $$$ this way.
How many land-side airport shops are there? Even at a large airport like ORD, aside from the int'l terminal, there's very little landside. In the United terminal...a Starbucks cart, maybe? (Coffee, Scones, and Shampoo!)
In fact, I can hardly think of any land-side shops at most of the airports I use. As you point out, this may change. But I hardly think there are going to be any Walgreens setting up shop by the luggage returns in most places.
#268
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Salish Sea
Programs: DL,AC,HH,PC
Posts: 8,972
Originally Posted by kaukau
Wally, it's easy. Anyway, the deal is, I totally appreciate both Dovster's calming sensibility and GoingAway's very real and very frequent business flyer needs. You convince a female business flyer to travel carry-on with the current restrictions. I think it's tougher on the women. Just ask Mrs. kaukau.
Do I see a business opportunity for cosmetic carts in terminals ?
#270
FlyerTalk Evangelist


Join Date: Jun 1999
Location: MIA
Programs: Retired :)
Posts: 10,943
Originally Posted by Dovster
More seriously: Aren't we all getting a little carried away here?
If I decide to just buy new stuff each week I think I can get by on about $10 a week, and that's buying the cheapest items available. That's another $400 I now have to spend in the name of security. Of course there's also that additional 1/2 hour a week spent in the drugstore, so now I'm up to 100 hours of wasted time a year.
I don't travel to the same place everyweek, but do go to a client site about 8 to 10 times in a one year period. I have about 6 more trips to this client and asked the hotel if I could store some things here until I come back. I bought cosmetics/hair products, etc. yesterday and will try this method, I spent about $25. If it's not here next month, oh well, it was only a loss of $25. If it is here, then this may be the way I go until they hopefully lift some of these liquid/gel bans.
BTW, I could care less about the shoe ban, I hate it, but it's not really costing me much in terms of hours/dollars. I'm barefoot as much as I can be anyway and haven't yet caught any diseases/infections.
My friends who travel once a year also don't understand why I'm irate about all this. Checking luggage once a year is very different than having to check it 40 times a year.
And yes, I do think there is a big need for a landside drugstore that sells travel size toiletries/cosmetics. I'd pay a premium for them at the airport so that I didn't have to make an extra trip to a drugstore after I get to the hotel.

