FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   American Airlines | AAdvantage (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/american-airlines-aadvantage-733/)
-   -   AAdvantage Changes for 2016 - DISCUSSION, REACTION & POLL (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/american-airlines-aadvantage/1725574-aadvantage-changes-2016-discussion-reaction-poll.html)

TheBOSman Nov 17, 2015 1:09 pm


Originally Posted by JonNYC (Post 25729180)
And I applaud that!

I was somewhat planning to do that anyway, but in light of my most frequent redemptions increasing 30-40% (or more), the last bit of real value to me is gone. I'm clearly better off with a 2% card now.

Juanefny Nov 17, 2015 1:09 pm

I wish people took to email or Twitter to express their dissatisfaction instead of just complaining here.

callmedtop Nov 17, 2015 1:10 pm

Well, I've got about 175K miles left on my AA account. That leaves me enough for Christmas 2016 under the existing rules. I'll book both myself and my SO on different Cathay flights, both in F (since they don't release 2 F anymore), and then change the date/routing close-in (December 2016) to hopefully get in the same flight. That shouldn't change the original 67.5K per person cost, as it won't trigger a refare.

Phew. Then I'll be done with AA miles, and will refocus back to United. Like someone mentioned before, similar costs, but MUCH better availability, a easier website, etc. Will miss having free changes thanks to EXP, but the price to pay.

Dieuwer Nov 17, 2015 1:12 pm


Originally Posted by Juanefny (Post 25729230)
I wish people took to email or Twitter to express their dissatisfaction instead of just complaining here.

Complaining won't work.
This is what you get when corrupt politicians, owned by Wall Street and Big Airline stifle competition and let everyone merge with everyone else.

TheBOSman Nov 17, 2015 1:12 pm


Originally Posted by Passmethesickbag (Post 25729220)
I beg to disagree, based on my eurocentric perspective, availability with UA was always OK, even in high season — partially because options on ten European partners are a lot more than on three.

Availability has unequivocally gotten better with LH F post-deval, the cabin most affected by the pricing change. Most of the other award prices were not affected nearly as much.

Also, not all of those partners fly TATL, and BA serves more destinations with more flights in North America than LH does. But Star Alliance is simply larger than oneworld, no doubts there.

pinksalsa Nov 17, 2015 1:12 pm

Puerto Rico is out of the new Award Chart. Someone confirm it, please. Or it could be a huge glitch.

When you go to the "View region definitions", Puerto Rico does NOT appear in the Caribbean, nor in Central American nor Contiguous 48 US States.

Where is Puerto Rico????????????????????????????????????????????

I need help in here, PLEASE.

Based on aa.com regarding the official changes, Puerto Rico is out of the Award Chart. So, travel from/to Puerto Rico is out of the award game. Someone confirm me, please.

Puerto Rico is not shown in the Caribbean, South America, Central America, 48 48 US states...in no place whatsoever.
My guess is that its a glitch, but a glitch that avoid redeeming flights to SJU. CORRECT IT ASAP!!!!

badjuju Nov 17, 2015 1:14 pm

In other words, they merge airlines just to screw their members over.

1. Subtract 1 month from membership period.
2. Increase segment requirement for EXP
3. Slash SWUs by 50% and fly even more to get the additional 4 SWUs. 200K needed for 8 SWUs
4. Increase sticker requirements by 25%

... all this whilst degrading the product. Thanks AA$$hole$!

badjuju Nov 17, 2015 1:14 pm


Originally Posted by Dieuwer (Post 25729245)
Complaining won't work.
This is what you get when corrupt politicians, owned by Wall Street and Big Airline stifle competition and let everyone merge with everyone else.

I'm creating a twitter account just for that.

Dave Noble Nov 17, 2015 1:14 pm


Originally Posted by Dieuwer (Post 25729245)
Complaining won't work.
This is what you get when corrupt politicians, owned by Wall Street and Big Airline stifle competition and let everyone merge with everyone else.

What? airlines being profitable?

rwoman Nov 17, 2015 1:14 pm

Being London-based and often flying BA in economy just got a lot more painful.

crimsona Nov 17, 2015 1:15 pm


Originally Posted by TheBOSman (Post 25729247)
Availability has unequivocally gotten better with LH F post-deval, the cabin most affected by the pricing change. Most of the other award prices were not affected nearly as much.

CX F availability might get better too for the exact same reason!

tonytifao Nov 17, 2015 1:15 pm

New Disadvantage program will no longer win the FT award :) LOL

JonNYC Nov 17, 2015 1:16 pm


Originally Posted by Dave Noble (Post 25729275)
What? airlines being profitable?

Must we?

Dieuwer Nov 17, 2015 1:16 pm


Originally Posted by Dave Noble (Post 25729275)
What? airlines being profitable?

Red herring.
Maybe we should let Microsoft and Apple merge too... iPC. :rolleyes:
Cry cry: computer makers being profitable? Sure: pay $100,000 for you next pad.

scubadu Nov 17, 2015 1:16 pm


Originally Posted by pinksalsa (Post 25729251)
Puerto Rico is out of the new Award Chart. Someone confirm it, please. Or it could be a huge glitch.

When you go to the "View region definitions", Puerto Rico does NOT appear in the Caribbean, nor in Central American nor Contiguous 48 US States.

Where is Puerto Rico????????????????????????????????????????????

I need help in here, PLEASE.

Based on aa.com regarding the official changes, Puerto Rico is out of the Award Chart. So, travel from/to Puerto Rico is out of the award game. Someone confirm me, please.

Puerto Rico is not shown in the Caribbean, South America, Central America, 48 48 US states...in no place whatsoever.
My guess is that its a glitch, but a glitch that avoid redeeming flights to SJU. CORRECT IT ASAP!!!!

Good grief, would you take a breath and step in off the ledge. Nobody is bleeding and nobody is dying. Posting the same thing over and over, in multiple threads doesn't get the answer sooner.

This is an emerging topic and everyone is figuring things out as quickly as they can. Most of the people in these threads don't have much more information than you do. Everyone is looking at the same public info.

Regards

delerium Nov 17, 2015 1:18 pm

Just renewed my AA PLT for next year, but I'm gone. Going to redeem my miles now and look for new options.

Superguy Nov 17, 2015 1:18 pm


Originally Posted by Dave Noble (Post 25729275)
What? airlines being profitable?

Merging and shafting customers is the only way the airlines can be profitable?

Gee, I would have thought innovative concepts like treating customers and employees well, and offering products people are willing to pay more for were the ways to becoming profitable. Silly me. :rolleyes:

pinksalsa Nov 17, 2015 1:19 pm

Off-peak Saver availability to EUROPE was dramatically and negatively reduced.

Bad bad bad bad news!!!!

Superguy Nov 17, 2015 1:21 pm


Originally Posted by pinksalsa (Post 25729307)
Off-peak Saver availability to EUROPE was dramatically and negatively reduced.

Bad bad bad bad news!!!!

Also no business off peak fares too. That was a nice little thing US used to offer. :(

Juanefny Nov 17, 2015 1:21 pm


Originally Posted by scubadu (Post 25729292)
Good grief, would you take a breath and step in off the ledge. Nobody is bleeding and nobody is dying. Posting the same thing over and over, in multiple threads doesn't get the answer sooner.

This is an emerging topic and everyone is figuring things out as quickly as they can. Most of the people in these threads don't have much more information than you do. Everyone is looking at the same public info.

Regards

This is making me want to go to Puerto Rico.

tonytifao Nov 17, 2015 1:21 pm


Originally Posted by badjuju (Post 25729268)
In other words, they merge airlines just to screw their members over.

1. Subtract 1 month from membership period.
2. Increase segment requirement for EXP
3. Slash SWUs by 50% and fly even more to get the additional 4 SWUs. 200K needed for 8 SWUs
4. Increase sticker requirements by 25%

... all this whilst degrading the product. Thanks AA$$hole$!

I'm with you :)


Originally Posted by badjuju (Post 25729274)
I'm creating a twitter account just for that.

LOL

DWFI Nov 17, 2015 1:22 pm


Originally Posted by Oformula (Post 25729221)
But at first glance, still seems slightly better than Delta and United. They did their homework.

Well Delta is on a different level.

The award chart is perhaps marginally cheaper than United. However, United I think makes up for it in not having YQ to Europe, as well as FAR more generous routing rules. AA has painfully restrictive routing rules that cause substantial issues.

I'd say AA and UA award charts are about a wash at this point.

TheBOSman Nov 17, 2015 1:24 pm


Originally Posted by prw555 (Post 25729335)
I like the new EQM earning. Just 3 trips to HKG in paid J and at EXP. Given go there every month, and else where also, would be Uber Exec Plat, if only such a program existed :-( Wonder if the "over achieving exec plat" extra SWU program will continue?

If you're flying monthly to HKG in paid J, and other trips elsewhere, I'm sure AA will take care of you (are you CK?).

zabes64 Nov 17, 2015 1:26 pm

GUTTING of partner EQM earning after Jan 1st
 
So we all know AA gutted BA earning, but for flights on BA from Jan 1-31, 2016, you will also now earn 50% EQM G, Q, S, N, O, K, L, M, V, H while still earning 100% RDMs.

Nice to see AA giving a full 44 days notice on that gutting.

Alaska earns 50% EQM starting Jan 1st on B, H, M, Q, U, G, K, L, T, V

Finnair earns 50% EQM A, H, K, L, M, P, V, G, N, O, Q, R, S, T, W, Z

BASICALLY all partners earn 50% EQM unless you buy a Y/B fare.

Really is no reason to fly AA anymore

200nites Nov 17, 2015 1:27 pm


Originally Posted by badjuju (Post 25729268)
In other words, they merge airlines just to screw their members over.

1. Subtract 1 month from membership period.
2. Increase segment requirement for EXP
3. Slash SWUs by 50% and fly even more to get the additional 4 SWUs. 200K needed for 8 SWUs
4. Increase sticker requirements by 25%

... all this whilst degrading the product. Thanks!

Never expected anything different from this Parker led Mgt. team...just about everything is being degraded (although I do give them credit for purchasing new aircraft) including # of First seats, private label snacks in first, etc.

Thank goodness I hit the 2M mark and have reduced my flying (of course who knows if million miler program will continue)

CApreppie Nov 17, 2015 1:27 pm

It was inevitable that once the merger was going smoothly, AA would follow the likes of DL and UA in devaluing the FF program. I'm just surprised there is no minimum $ spend yet - I suppose you have to save something for 2017!

TheBOSman Nov 17, 2015 1:28 pm


Originally Posted by JonNYC (Post 25729363)
Only marginally related, I thought there was a -chance- they'd make some changes/improvements to CK at this point, kinda think it's a mistake that they didn't, personally.

Considering Concierge Key doesn't even have its own specific webpage on AA.com, wouldn't any of those be made quietly? I know you would know if they occurred anyway, but might be something they'll be changing later after putting all of their focus into this much larger overall program change.

Schultzois Nov 17, 2015 1:39 pm

So, partner earnings even on normal economy tickets gutted.
No improvement in partner earnings for premium cabins (unless I've missed something).
And a major devaluation on redemption levels... my usual two awards move from 62,500 to 85,000 o/w and 32,500 to 50,000 o/w - so 36-54% more miles needed for my usual redemptions.

I suppose it could have been worse, but this is pretty bad as far as I'm concerned.

If subsequent changes to tickets issued between now and March 21 are honored under current rates, I'm tempted to book some of my usual routes at current rates.

CDKing Nov 17, 2015 1:43 pm

Now everyone will be looking for EY F apartment awards. I guess I need to just find something, book and go.

klymen Nov 17, 2015 1:44 pm

Feeling rather glad I just drained my account with a J return Europe-Australia. 25K extra each way from next year. Old J redemption rate is the new Y rate.

I predict a rush to redeem, and corresponding dearth of award availability, especially in J/F.

TheBOSman Nov 17, 2015 1:45 pm


Originally Posted by CDKing (Post 25729495)
Now everyone will be looking for EY F apartment awards. I guess I need to just find something, book and go.

I have zero regrets about all of the wonderful tickets I booked in the last 12-13 months :D :D :D.

GUWonder Nov 17, 2015 1:46 pm

The earning changes aren't an improvement for me as a very mixed class flyer.

The redemption chart changes and the reduction of elite benefits for me are rather brutal.

This basically marks the end of an era of me going out of my way to fly AA and Oneworld carriers. Also what is history: AA getting top spot when it comes to crediting my non-flight activity to a partner airline program (in this case AA).

AA is hiking the cost of most of my mileage ticket redemptions by well over 30% -- even as my cost to acquire miles has not dropped.

kalendil Nov 17, 2015 1:47 pm


Originally Posted by CDKing (Post 25729495)
Now everyone will be looking for EY F apartment awards. I guess I need to just find something, book and go.

Yup. Glad I booked mine weeks ago after the BA earning announcement.

prw555 Nov 17, 2015 1:47 pm


Originally Posted by TheBOSman (Post 25729353)
If you're flying monthly to HKG in paid J, and other trips elsewhere, I'm sure AA will take care of you (are you CK?).

Not CK, lowly EXP. This year over 300k EQP, and last month CS gave me 6 extra SWU's. 50% of my OW spend is on CX, so although total spend over $60k, only 50% is on AA metal, so they won't give me CK.

lobo411 Nov 17, 2015 1:50 pm

Thanksgiving is next week...close enough to call this the Thanksgiving Massacre?

GEO22Olsen Nov 17, 2015 1:51 pm

So depressing but makes sense
 
I don't know you all, but I'm 99.99% sure I'm the saddest of all. I had such a good thing going, but I do understand. AA was losing so much $ on me and my status benefits. Sigh. I guess I'll consider using up my miles and going rogue.

Austin787 Nov 17, 2015 1:53 pm


Originally Posted by callmedtop (Post 25729235)
Phew. Then I'll be done with AA miles, and will refocus back to United. Like someone mentioned before, similar costs, but MUCH better availability, a easier website, etc. Will miss having free changes thanks to EXP, but the price to pay.

+1. Also, on award bookings to Europe UA does not add on fuel surcharges.

badjuju Nov 17, 2015 1:53 pm

delete.

flyingmusicianlax Nov 17, 2015 1:54 pm

Email I just sent to AAdvantage:

"Wow, AAdvantage, from first to worst in 2016. So now you have a frequent flyer program that mirrors Delta and United but your operational efficiency is at the bottom, it routinely takes 45 minutes to an hour to receive bags (with no guarantee), your premium cabin food has been downgraded, your US Airways planes have no power, no AVOD, no MCE etc, etc.

"Tell me: why on God's green earth should I choose to fly with you? Understand that, based on increased mileage requirements for awards and massively decreased mileage earning, I will be looking very hard at switching carriers and will strongly encourage friends and business partners to book away from AA. After all, if AAdvantage is the same as all the others, then we might as well book with the much better airline - which, for the past several years, has been Delta."

Forgot to mention that, with a greater number of partners, availability is generally better when redeeming on UA and DL. Very dumb move by AAdvantage - no competitive edge remaining.

jlb3 Nov 17, 2015 1:55 pm

[Deleted for duplication]


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 8:56 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.