Two stopovers, two transits or one openjaw
#1
Suspended
Original Poster
Join Date: May 2006
Location: HKG
Programs: A3, TK *G; JL JGC; SPG,Hilton Gold
Posts: 9,952
Two stopovers, two transits or one openjaw
Right, i know this had been discussed.
I want hkg-ongo-octs-kix//ngo-hkg... But
I just got cut off by AM after a 30 minute discussion. Anyone had a precedent case of 2 stopovers and an open jaw en-route? I think its pretty clear in the TnC, but still got rejected and cut off by the agent!!! (she insisted that because of 2 stopovers i had, i cant take another openjaw.)
I want hkg-ongo-octs-kix//ngo-hkg... But
I just got cut off by AM after a 30 minute discussion. Anyone had a precedent case of 2 stopovers and an open jaw en-route? I think its pretty clear in the TnC, but still got rejected and cut off by the agent!!! (she insisted that because of 2 stopovers i had, i cant take another openjaw.)
#3
Join Date: Mar 2012
Programs: Marriott & SPG Plat, HH Diamond, Accor Plat, ex-Fairmont Plat, ex-Swissotel Eleva
Posts: 710
Right, i know this had been discussed.
I want hkg-ongo-octs-kix//ngo-hkg... But
I just got cut off by AM after a 30 minute discussion. Anyone had a precedent case of 2 stopovers and an open jaw en-route? I think its pretty clear in the TnC, but still got rejected and cut off by the agent!!! (she insisted that because of 2 stopovers i had, i cant take another openjaw.)
I want hkg-ongo-octs-kix//ngo-hkg... But
I just got cut off by AM after a 30 minute discussion. Anyone had a precedent case of 2 stopovers and an open jaw en-route? I think its pretty clear in the TnC, but still got rejected and cut off by the agent!!! (she insisted that because of 2 stopovers i had, i cant take another openjaw.)
Is the rule a "2 stopovers + 2 transits" or "2 stopovers or 2 transits" (i.e. if you used 2 stopovers, you cannot transit in a 3rd or 4th location) in a return ticket?
#4
Suspended
Original Poster
Join Date: May 2006
Location: HKG
Programs: A3, TK *G; JL JGC; SPG,Hilton Gold
Posts: 9,952
2 stopovers and 1 transit is defo ok. I've never tried 2 stopover and 2 transits tho. (with the limitations of CX+1 airline it's not so easy... Maybe HKG-oTPE-xHND-oCTS-xHND-HKG or HKG-xHND-oCTS-oMMB-xHND-HKG
PS. I've just found out the agent who denied me 2 stopovers and an open jaw is downright wrong - the rule i need to challenge is 2 stopovers and 2 transit! (in the english T&C, it says what i stated on the topic. so i'd take it the transits and openjaw is connected by an "or" clause.
However, how would it suggest if i want to do a HKG-xHND-CTS//HKD-xHND-HKG!?! and in chinese they are all connected with an "and"! have anyone tried to challenge that!?
Last edited by kaka; Nov 9, 2012 at 5:33 pm
#6
Join Date: Jan 2000
Posts: 3,208
Right, i know this had been discussed.
I want hkg-ongo-octs-kix//ngo-hkg... But
I just got cut off by AM after a 30 minute discussion. Anyone had a precedent case of 2 stopovers and an open jaw en-route? I think its pretty clear in the TnC, but still got rejected and cut off by the agent!!! (she insisted that because of 2 stopovers i had, i cant take another openjaw.)
I want hkg-ongo-octs-kix//ngo-hkg... But
I just got cut off by AM after a 30 minute discussion. Anyone had a precedent case of 2 stopovers and an open jaw en-route? I think its pretty clear in the TnC, but still got rejected and cut off by the agent!!! (she insisted that because of 2 stopovers i had, i cant take another openjaw.)
two stopovers in addition to the destination plus the open jaw on the return? Was this a matter of CX to/from NGO, then JL to CTS and KIX
All for 30k miles? thanks
for some reason, I recall an old CX thread where the turnaround point was considered the second stopover, so I guess that was just bad info.
#7
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: TPE / HSZ
Programs: CX GO (=SPH), IHG Diamond Amb, Hertz 5*, Accor, Hilton, National
Posts: 6,437
English T&C have "or" but Chinese T&C have "and." Our experiences have been that the Chinese version is correct, and you can have 2 stopovers + 2 transits + 1 open-jaw.
#8
Ambassador, Hong Kong and Macau
Join Date: May 2009
Location: HKG
Programs: Non-top tier Asia Miles member
Posts: 19,836
Yesterday I tried ticketing this as a 120,000AM J return Asia Miles award:
HKG-xMXP-oMAD-oMXP-HKG
At first, Beijing centre told me they can't do xMXP, because MXP-MAD-MXP is done on Iberia and they cited the following:
http://www.asiamiles.com/am/en/site/terms
"2. The member or the Nominee may make two stopovers, two transfers or one open-jaw at either the origin, en route or turnaround point on all airline partners except Air China and Iberia where no stopovers or open-jaws are permitted."
I had Tsuen Wan centre repeat the query. If need be, I will convert to OW award tho that makes my routing even harder to organise. To my surprise, I got straight through at about 11:45am.
Tsuen Wan said the rule posed no problem and proceeded to ticket. Beijing centre called me back after to say after reconsideration they don't think it's a problem either but they already see Tsuen Wan's centre's booking.
Tsuen Wan released e-tickets to me this morning. So I guess the rule is truly not applicable to me. I don't fault Beijing for acting in accordance with rules, tho of course I appreciate Tsuen Wan can break it.
HKG-xMXP-oMAD-oMXP-HKG
At first, Beijing centre told me they can't do xMXP, because MXP-MAD-MXP is done on Iberia and they cited the following:
http://www.asiamiles.com/am/en/site/terms
"2. The member or the Nominee may make two stopovers, two transfers or one open-jaw at either the origin, en route or turnaround point on all airline partners except Air China and Iberia where no stopovers or open-jaws are permitted."
I had Tsuen Wan centre repeat the query. If need be, I will convert to OW award tho that makes my routing even harder to organise. To my surprise, I got straight through at about 11:45am.
Tsuen Wan said the rule posed no problem and proceeded to ticket. Beijing centre called me back after to say after reconsideration they don't think it's a problem either but they already see Tsuen Wan's centre's booking.
Tsuen Wan released e-tickets to me this morning. So I guess the rule is truly not applicable to me. I don't fault Beijing for acting in accordance with rules, tho of course I appreciate Tsuen Wan can break it.
#9
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Singapore
Programs: SQ PPS, OZ Gold, Marriott Titanium & lifetime Platinum, IHG Diamond
Posts: 174
1. PVG-oHKG-xTPE-KIX//NGO-xTPE-oHKG-PVG; (30,000 miles in Y)
2. SIN-xBKK-oHKG-TPE//KHH-oHKG-xBKK-SIN (30,000 miles in Y)
#10
Ambassador, Hong Kong and Macau
Join Date: May 2009
Location: HKG
Programs: Non-top tier Asia Miles member
Posts: 19,836
I just asked Tsuen Wan Centre to check legality of LAX-LIM//EZE-oSCL-oLIM-LAX (all on LA)
Beijing Centre asserted no, 3 stopover
Tsuen Wan said OK and ready to ticket (I searched all the dates on ba.com, 60,000AM and $1,312 YQ).
Beijing Centre asserted no, 3 stopover
Tsuen Wan said OK and ready to ticket (I searched all the dates on ba.com, 60,000AM and $1,312 YQ).
Last edited by percysmith; Jan 8, 2013 at 3:53 am
#12
Ambassador, Hong Kong and Macau
Join Date: May 2009
Location: HKG
Programs: Non-top tier Asia Miles member
Posts: 19,836
30,000 appears right
Ticket/Upgrade : Round-trip Ticket
Class : Economy
From To Airline
Taipei/Taoyuan Hong Kong Cathay Pacific Airways #
Hong Kong Busan Dragonair #
Incheon Hong Kong Cathay Pacific Airways #
Hong Kong Taipei/Taoyuan Cathay Pacific Airways #
Asia Miles Required 30,000
# You may not be able to redeem Asia Miles on some codeshare flights. To confirm eligibility, please call Asia Miles Service Hotline.
New Calculation
#13
Join Date: Feb 2013
Programs: CXSL
Posts: 35
Hello, recently I am looking at how should I use the 60,000 miles
I have think of the following routing
ICN-oHKG-LHR//MXP-oHKG-ICN
I called the agent and was told that there are 3 stopovers.
They consider the open jaw between LHR//MXP as stopovers, as I arrive in London 25 June, leaving MXP 28 June (>24 hrs). I argue that this is a open jaw, not stopover. But the agent said, if your open jaw is >24hr it would be considered as stopovers. Is that true?
Alternatively, I asked about -
ICN-oHKG-BKK-oHKG-ICN
The agent insists 3 stopovers, I argue BKK is a destination, not stopovers, but was not successful...
I have think of the following routing
ICN-oHKG-LHR//MXP-oHKG-ICN
I called the agent and was told that there are 3 stopovers.
They consider the open jaw between LHR//MXP as stopovers, as I arrive in London 25 June, leaving MXP 28 June (>24 hrs). I argue that this is a open jaw, not stopover. But the agent said, if your open jaw is >24hr it would be considered as stopovers. Is that true?
Alternatively, I asked about -
ICN-oHKG-BKK-oHKG-ICN
The agent insists 3 stopovers, I argue BKK is a destination, not stopovers, but was not successful...
#14
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Hong Kong
Programs: CX Diamond / SQ Gold / Bonvoy Platinum / Hyatt Globalist / Hilton Gold
Posts: 1,098
From what I know, having done around many of these:
ICN-oHKG-LHR//MXP-oHKG-ICN
- two stopovers
- one openjaw
- within the rules.
ICN-oHKG-BKK-oHKG-ICN
- three stopovers
- violates the rules
- "destination" is not a category - a city is either the origin, a stopover, a transfer, or an open jaw.
so, with your example above, ICN-oHKG-LHR//MXP-oHKG-ICN is allowed but ICN-oHKG-LHR-oHKG-ICN is not allowed.
hope this makes sense.
ICN-oHKG-LHR//MXP-oHKG-ICN
- two stopovers
- one openjaw
- within the rules.
ICN-oHKG-BKK-oHKG-ICN
- three stopovers
- violates the rules
- "destination" is not a category - a city is either the origin, a stopover, a transfer, or an open jaw.
so, with your example above, ICN-oHKG-LHR//MXP-oHKG-ICN is allowed but ICN-oHKG-LHR-oHKG-ICN is not allowed.
hope this makes sense.
#15
Suspended
Original Poster
Join Date: May 2006
Location: HKG
Programs: A3, TK *G; JL JGC; SPG,Hilton Gold
Posts: 9,952
I second the bkk one is out of rules whilst lhr//mxp shud b ok...
From what I know, having done around many of these:
ICN-oHKG-LHR//MXP-oHKG-ICN
- two stopovers
- one openjaw
- within the rules.
ICN-oHKG-BKK-oHKG-ICN
- three stopovers
- violates the rules
- "destination" is not a category - a city is either the origin, a stopover, a transfer, or an open jaw.
so, with your example above, ICN-oHKG-LHR//MXP-oHKG-ICN is allowed but ICN-oHKG-LHR-oHKG-ICN is not allowed.
hope this makes sense.
ICN-oHKG-LHR//MXP-oHKG-ICN
- two stopovers
- one openjaw
- within the rules.
ICN-oHKG-BKK-oHKG-ICN
- three stopovers
- violates the rules
- "destination" is not a category - a city is either the origin, a stopover, a transfer, or an open jaw.
so, with your example above, ICN-oHKG-LHR//MXP-oHKG-ICN is allowed but ICN-oHKG-LHR-oHKG-ICN is not allowed.
hope this makes sense.