Horrible First Experience with the "New" Elevate
#16


Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: SFO/MIA/JFK
Programs: AA EXP/*wood Plat/Hilton Gold/Hyatt Discoverist
Posts: 300
So far, 3/3 on upgrades to MCS. Feels nice to finally feel some butt in the seat benefit beyond the norm as frequent user of VX.
#17
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: ORD
Programs: AA EXP,2MM, DL Gold,Starwood PLT
Posts: 3,876
Called into Elevate tonight, since I noticed that not only does my account say 0 status points (which even the rep admitted was clearly a system error, since i've had a number of flights and monthly credit card status updates), but it also doesn't reflect me as Silver Status.
She told me that even though I had both confirmation of my elevate silver card and forwarded that to her, as well as my elevate silver status email, she still stated that there was absolutely nothing her and her supervisor could do about a flight tomorrow, and that I absolutely wouldn't be placed on the upgrade list.
To make matters worse, she also mentioned that they've already changed the upgrade policy. Instead of getting automatic upgrades if you are silver or gold @ 24 / 12 hours (as their press release states clearly here - http://www.virginamerica.com/press-r...nch-tiers.html), they've instead changed it so that you are placed on a priority list and only informed @ 2 hours before .
She told me that even though I had both confirmation of my elevate silver card and forwarded that to her, as well as my elevate silver status email, she still stated that there was absolutely nothing her and her supervisor could do about a flight tomorrow, and that I absolutely wouldn't be placed on the upgrade list.
To make matters worse, she also mentioned that they've already changed the upgrade policy. Instead of getting automatic upgrades if you are silver or gold @ 24 / 12 hours (as their press release states clearly here - http://www.virginamerica.com/press-r...nch-tiers.html), they've instead changed it so that you are placed on a priority list and only informed @ 2 hours before .
The exact words on the topic were complimentary "space-available upgrades to the carriers premium Main Cabin Select service". That means they will give them if they dont think they will sell them, nothing more at the 12/24 windows. No different then any other domestic upgrade program.
#18




Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: SF Bay Area
Programs: UA GS MM, Marriott Life Plat, Hyatt Globalist, Southwest Alist pref, various others of little note
Posts: 2,873
Mike_K - Quoting Virgin's new elevate documentation:
"Opt in for free upgrades to Main Cabin Select when theres space available.
If youre flying solo, youll have the chance to opt in for an upgrade while you book your flight online, through an authorized travel agent, or when booking through the Virgin America Call Center, and well update your flight status with your new cabin (if available) up to two hours before departure."
http://www.virginamerica.com/vx/how-...it-works#seats
I know it's definitely the case, because I was able to purchase an MCS upgrade at 4 hours prior to departure (which is really what makes this benefit useless in most cases of full flights)
"Opt in for free upgrades to Main Cabin Select when theres space available.
If youre flying solo, youll have the chance to opt in for an upgrade while you book your flight online, through an authorized travel agent, or when booking through the Virgin America Call Center, and well update your flight status with your new cabin (if available) up to two hours before departure."
http://www.virginamerica.com/vx/how-...it-works#seats
I know it's definitely the case, because I was able to purchase an MCS upgrade at 4 hours prior to departure (which is really what makes this benefit useless in most cases of full flights)
Not all that different from other posts on flyertalk about other airlines and hotel chains. They're all using their newfound data crunching ability to extract more revenue, which means trying to keep loyal customers around with vague promises while selling their benefits out from under them. Get used to it, it's the "new normal" until somebody proves at the boardroom level that it costs them money. At the moment I think they're all very impressed with the sparkly new revenue sources and don't have any way (or inclination) to assess the opportunity cost from elites leaving for greener pastures (if those even exist).
#19


Join Date: Dec 2007
Programs: Enough to travel better
Posts: 2,023
#20
Join Date: Aug 2012
Posts: 1
Question about the New Elevate
I'm a little confused. When Virgin's new Elevate program went live on August 8th I had 56k elevate points as well as the Virgin Visa card. Yet my account says I have 0 status points. I originally thought when the program started that all the points I had already earned would automatically bump me to Gold but nothing! Is this a system error or are they really making me start from scratch to get status points?
#22
Original Poster
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: San Francisco, CA
Programs: VX Silver
Posts: 29
That's not what the press release said at all. Space available, not that you automatically confirm at the windows.
The exact words on the topic were complimentary "space-available upgrades to the carriers premium Main Cabin Select service". That means they will give them if they dont think they will sell them, nothing more at the 12/24 windows. No different then any other domestic upgrade program.
The exact words on the topic were complimentary "space-available upgrades to the carriers premium Main Cabin Select service". That means they will give them if they dont think they will sell them, nothing more at the 12/24 windows. No different then any other domestic upgrade program.
See the table from the press release. Even if it's space pending, that sure looks like you get upgraded at 12 or 24 hours to me....:
#23
Join Date: May 2012
Posts: 68
For the first 6 months I flew with VX I never once got anyone with anything even close to an American accent. This was a complaint echoed by others as well.
Perhaps it's changed since then. I should hope it has.
D'oh!
Perhaps it's changed since then. I should hope it has.
FYI: Mike_K If you spend $10k this year with VA, your points go to Virgin Australia.
Virgin America's code is VX.
Virgin America's code is VX.
#24
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: ORD
Programs: AA EXP,2MM, DL Gold,Starwood PLT
Posts: 3,876
While I respect your opinion, I completely disagree with you. When you look at the table, it specifically mentions that the upgrades to MCS are at 24 hours and 12 hours.
See the table from the press release. Even if it's space pending, that sure looks like you get upgraded at 12 or 24 hours to me....:

See the table from the press release. Even if it's space pending, that sure looks like you get upgraded at 12 or 24 hours to me....:

#25


Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: LAX
Posts: 230
I absolutely read that as you will be upgraded at 24 hours or at 12 hours, not be made eligible pending availability.
Just like advance purchase window opens up at 24 hours or at 12 hours. Imagine purchasing an upgrade at 24 hours to first class, and then 3 hours before the flight someone buys a full fare ticket and VX has to downgrade you and refund your money.
Also, if you're green lighted at T24 as a gold member to a MCS upgrade, you would pay less for your upgrade to F, right?
With the current system in place, that MCS upgrade only really kicks in at T2?
I feel like everything is still in the works, so I can't criticize too much, but it READS a lot better than it is.
With such a small MCS and F offering, it seems like those will no longer be so accessible.
Just like advance purchase window opens up at 24 hours or at 12 hours. Imagine purchasing an upgrade at 24 hours to first class, and then 3 hours before the flight someone buys a full fare ticket and VX has to downgrade you and refund your money.
Also, if you're green lighted at T24 as a gold member to a MCS upgrade, you would pay less for your upgrade to F, right?
With the current system in place, that MCS upgrade only really kicks in at T2?
I feel like everything is still in the works, so I can't criticize too much, but it READS a lot better than it is.
With such a small MCS and F offering, it seems like those will no longer be so accessible.
#26
Join Date: May 2009
Posts: 460
While I respect your opinion, I completely disagree with you. When you look at the table, it specifically mentions that the upgrades to MCS are at 24 hours and 12 hours.
See the table from the press release. Even if it's space pending, that sure looks like you get upgraded at 12 or 24 hours to me....:

See the table from the press release. Even if it's space pending, that sure looks like you get upgraded at 12 or 24 hours to me....:

Opt in for free upgrades to Main Cabin Select when theres space available.
If youre flying solo, youll have the chance to opt in for an upgrade while you book your flight online, through an authorized travel agent, or when booking through the Virgin America Call Center, and well update your flight status with your new cabin (if available) up to two hours before departure.
If youre traveling with companions, you can opt in to upgrade your seat by calling your exclusive Elevate Silver or Elevate Gold reservations line.
Since the upgrades are automatic, we cant guarantee availability of any previously selected Main Cabin seats once youve been assigned a spot in Main Cabin Select.
If youre upgraded to Main Cabin Select when you have already checked in for your flight, youll need to check in again online or at the airport to select your new seat in Main Cabin Select.
#27


Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: LAX
Posts: 230
It's pretty clearly spelled out in more detail on the adjacent "How it Works" page. It isn't guaranteed:
Opt in for free upgrades to Main Cabin Select when theres space available.
If youre flying solo, youll have the chance to opt in for an upgrade while you book your flight online, through an authorized travel agent, or when booking through the Virgin America Call Center, and well update your flight status with your new cabin (if available) up to two hours before departure.
If youre traveling with companions, you can opt in to upgrade your seat by calling your exclusive Elevate Silver or Elevate Gold reservations line.
Since the upgrades are automatic, we cant guarantee availability of any previously selected Main Cabin seats once youve been assigned a spot in Main Cabin Select.
If youre upgraded to Main Cabin Select when you have already checked in for your flight, youll need to check in again online or at the airport to select your new seat in Main Cabin Select.
Opt in for free upgrades to Main Cabin Select when theres space available.
If youre flying solo, youll have the chance to opt in for an upgrade while you book your flight online, through an authorized travel agent, or when booking through the Virgin America Call Center, and well update your flight status with your new cabin (if available) up to two hours before departure.
If youre traveling with companions, you can opt in to upgrade your seat by calling your exclusive Elevate Silver or Elevate Gold reservations line.
Since the upgrades are automatic, we cant guarantee availability of any previously selected Main Cabin seats once youve been assigned a spot in Main Cabin Select.
If youre upgraded to Main Cabin Select when you have already checked in for your flight, youll need to check in again online or at the airport to select your new seat in Main Cabin Select.
The -12 and -24 hours still has nothing to do with the upgrades.
#28


Join Date: Dec 2007
Programs: Enough to travel better
Posts: 2,023

I'd like to see how VX calculates the beginning of 2012 as the beginning of the "calendar" status year.
#29


Join Date: Dec 2007
Programs: Enough to travel better
Posts: 2,023
Real Ambiguous Explanation of Policy
Does this make sense to you?
https://virginamerica.com/frequent-f...ber-guide.html
Membership Benefit Year
The Elevate Status Benefit Year runs from January 1st to February 28th.
Your Benefit year runs from the time you qualify during the initial qualification year, and through to the end of the following full calendar year.
If you do not re-qualify for Elevate Status in a subsequent Membership Qualification Year, your Elevate Status Benefits will expire on February 28th after the end of the Elevate Status Benefit year.
For example, if you earn 20,000 Status Points between August 8 and December 31 2012, you will earn Elevate Silver Status for the remainder of 2012 as well as for the full 2013 Membership Benefit Year. If you do not re-qualify for the 2014 Membership Benefit Year, your Elevate Silver Status will expire on February 28. 2014.
https://virginamerica.com/frequent-f...ber-guide.html
Membership Benefit Year
The Elevate Status Benefit Year runs from January 1st to February 28th.
Your Benefit year runs from the time you qualify during the initial qualification year, and through to the end of the following full calendar year.
If you do not re-qualify for Elevate Status in a subsequent Membership Qualification Year, your Elevate Status Benefits will expire on February 28th after the end of the Elevate Status Benefit year.
For example, if you earn 20,000 Status Points between August 8 and December 31 2012, you will earn Elevate Silver Status for the remainder of 2012 as well as for the full 2013 Membership Benefit Year. If you do not re-qualify for the 2014 Membership Benefit Year, your Elevate Silver Status will expire on February 28. 2014.
#30
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: ORD
Programs: AA EXP,2MM, DL Gold,Starwood PLT
Posts: 3,876
I absolutely read that as you will be upgraded at 24 hours or at 12 hours, not be made eligible pending availability.
Just like advance purchase window opens up at 24 hours or at 12 hours. Imagine purchasing an upgrade at 24 hours to first class, and then 3 hours before the flight someone buys a full fare ticket and VX has to downgrade you and refund your money.
Also, if you're green lighted at T24 as a gold member to a MCS upgrade, you would pay less for your upgrade to F, right?
With the current system in place, that MCS upgrade only really kicks in at T2?
I feel like everything is still in the works, so I can't criticize too much, but it READS a lot better than it is.
With such a small MCS and F offering, it seems like those will no longer be so accessible.
Just like advance purchase window opens up at 24 hours or at 12 hours. Imagine purchasing an upgrade at 24 hours to first class, and then 3 hours before the flight someone buys a full fare ticket and VX has to downgrade you and refund your money.
Also, if you're green lighted at T24 as a gold member to a MCS upgrade, you would pay less for your upgrade to F, right?
With the current system in place, that MCS upgrade only really kicks in at T2?
I feel like everything is still in the works, so I can't criticize too much, but it READS a lot better than it is.
With such a small MCS and F offering, it seems like those will no longer be so accessible.


