1 NOV 2011 HNL-GUM / GUM-NRT goes DOMESTIC 777
#76
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: ONT
Programs: AA Gold, WN A-, UA S, HH ♦, IHG Spire, Hertz Prez O, TSA Disparager
Posts: 2,159
You go through Guam Customs when you arrive so Guam can get their landing tax for goods brought in.
Guam is located outside of the US Customs zone. That's why you go through US Customs on the way back.
Guam is located outside of the US Customs zone. That's why you go through US Customs on the way back.
#77
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: PDX
Programs: UA 1K, Marriott Plat
Posts: 11,500
#78
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Japan/Thailand
Programs: AS, UA
Posts: 1,201
#79
Formerly known as CollegeFlyer
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: JRA
Programs: UA 1K MM, AA PLT, Hyatt Diamond, Marriott Gold, Hertz 5*
Posts: 6,716
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenge...ternal_borders
Other countries' "national ID cards" don't really have a US analogue, because many Americans oppose the idea of registering your identity with the federal government, on grounds of privacy and/or freedom (which is kind of silly, in light of the fact that the Feds already know a bunch of information about most people from the procedures already in place--such as filing tax returns). If an imperfect analogy had to be made, a national ID card is more functionally similar to a Driver's License, or Non-Driver ID, in the U.S.--it provides identification, and is backed by government anti-counterfeiting measures, but is not a passport ("standard" or not) and cannot be used as a substitute on any travel that actually requires a passort.
This comment is illogical, unresponsive to anything I have written, and, frankly--inappropriate. Why do this?
If anything, this is a downgrade to PMCO, not PMUA, since this route is a legacy CO route--so it doesn't have anything to do with anyone's "precious UA is changing dnt like too bad."
Again, are you just saying that it is "considered" so by you, or that you believe that UACO (or who?) considers it that way?
If this is what you believe, then please explain whether you think a flight from Frankfurt to Rome is "domestic" because you don't have to go through immigration or customs (and whether LH should be allowed to deny *G lounge access to UA/US/CO elites because it's "considered" domestic). Or whether a drive from the US to Canada prior to 2004 was a "domestic" trip.
"Do you have to go through customs or immigration" is a different question from "is the trip domestic or international," and while there is much overlap, it's just overlap. No airline that I know of (unless you can think of any) publishes a service standard or upgrade policy based on "do you have to go through customs or immigration."
The point is, if HNL-GUM is operated with a two-cabin plane in a domestic configuration, it's not unreasonable for customers to be disappointed that it's not UDU-eligible, and "it's an international flight" is not even a convincing excuse, because: (1) technically, it's not even international (which is the only point I was making until you started confusing customs with sovereignty), and (2) separately, PMCO does allow UDUs on short-haul international flights within North America and northern South America (even if you have to go through customs and immigration!!! OMG! ), which is another reason why customs/immigration is irrelevant to the question of whether UDU should be allowed on this route, given UACO's policies on UDUs in the rest of its route network.
This comment is illogical, unresponsive to anything I have written, and, frankly--inappropriate. Why do this?
If this is what you believe, then please explain whether you think a flight from Frankfurt to Rome is "domestic" because you don't have to go through immigration or customs (and whether LH should be allowed to deny *G lounge access to UA/US/CO elites because it's "considered" domestic). Or whether a drive from the US to Canada prior to 2004 was a "domestic" trip.
"Do you have to go through customs or immigration" is a different question from "is the trip domestic or international," and while there is much overlap, it's just overlap. No airline that I know of (unless you can think of any) publishes a service standard or upgrade policy based on "do you have to go through customs or immigration."
The point is, if HNL-GUM is operated with a two-cabin plane in a domestic configuration, it's not unreasonable for customers to be disappointed that it's not UDU-eligible, and "it's an international flight" is not even a convincing excuse, because: (1) technically, it's not even international (which is the only point I was making until you started confusing customs with sovereignty), and (2) separately, PMCO does allow UDUs on short-haul international flights within North America and northern South America (even if you have to go through customs and immigration!!! OMG! ), which is another reason why customs/immigration is irrelevant to the question of whether UDU should be allowed on this route, given UACO's policies on UDUs in the rest of its route network.
Last edited by iluv2fly; Sep 22, 2011 at 11:29 am Reason: merge
#80
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Ontario, Canada
Programs: AC SE, UA 1K
Posts: 83
is GUM-NRT UDU eligable?
I'm set to fly GUM-NRT-GUM on UA 777 domestic product. When reviewing my reservation on UA.com the "upgrade pending" is not listed. My ticket is issued on CO stock (ie. CO marketed, UA operated) for GUM-NRT-GUM-HNL October 30/31.
Am I out of luck for a UDU on the GUM-NRT segments as well as GUM-HNL - or is this just an anomaly of ticketing on 005 stock?
Am I out of luck for a UDU on the GUM-NRT segments as well as GUM-HNL - or is this just an anomaly of ticketing on 005 stock?
Last edited by peter.jensen; Oct 26, 2011 at 3:09 pm
#81
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Mountain Time Zone
Programs: AS Million Miler/Marriott Lifetime Titanium/ IGH Ambassador
Posts: 5,996
I'm set to fly GUM-NRT-GUM on UA 777 domestic product October 30th. When reviewing my reservation on UA.com the "upgrade pending" is not listed. My ticket is issued on CO stock (ie. CO marketed, UA operated) for GUM-NRT-GUM-HNL October 30/31.
Am I out of luck for a UDU on the GUM-NRT segments as well as GUM-HNL - or is this just an anomaly of ticketing on 005 stock?
Am I out of luck for a UDU on the GUM-NRT segments as well as GUM-HNL - or is this just an anomaly of ticketing on 005 stock?
Thanks I am dreading the downgrade in service and old dirty UA's birds.
#82
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: PSM
Posts: 69,232
I'm set to fly GUM-NRT-GUM on UA 777 domestic product October 30th. When reviewing my reservation on UA.com the "upgrade pending" is not listed. My ticket is issued on CO stock (ie. CO marketed, UA operated) for GUM-NRT-GUM-HNL October 30/31.
Am I out of luck for a UDU on the GUM-NRT segments as well as GUM-HNL - or is this just an anomaly of ticketing on 005 stock?
Am I out of luck for a UDU on the GUM-NRT segments as well as GUM-HNL - or is this just an anomaly of ticketing on 005 stock?
#83
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Ontario, Canada
Programs: AC SE, UA 1K
Posts: 83
I'm curious to see what things will be like for first day operations.
#84
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Ontario, Canada
Programs: AC SE, UA 1K
Posts: 83
In happier news, using the same new United rules I was able to UDU on the new 777 UA operated GUM-HNL flight I have scheduled to depart later today (the 2012 rules do not allow for CPU.)
We'll see if the answer I get at NRT is any different (but I suspect this will not be the case.)
#86
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Honolulu, Hawaii
Programs: UA Silver, Marriott Titanium
Posts: 97
Just took UA 201 HNL to GUM
I just completed UA 201 from HNL to Guam in Y on a domestic 772. Here is my mini trip report.
Boarding
The inbound flight from ORD was 5 minutes late. There are lots of seat movements. Cleaners and catering were late, so we did not board until 2:20 and left gate 30 minutes late. GA even said there are snack for sale on board, but that was not the case.
There was a confusion and duty free cart was not loaded.
Flight
Biggest drawback is no personal entertainment, a significant downgrade from the "state of the art" entertainment on CO 764. Heard several people making comments on that.
Meals
Still serve 2 free meals just like CO. A round of drink 45 minutes after takeoff. First meal is 1.5 hour after takeoff, lagsana or chicken + salad and bread with plastic utensils. Ice cream at 5 hours into flight (usually 3.5 to 4 hours on CO). Second meal is 1.5 hours before landing, with a ham sandwich and sliced fruit, but no utensils provided. FAs tend to me slower serving meals compared to old CO, maybe they are not used to serve free meals to everyone.
Catering screwed up so no special meals were loaded.
Baggage
Took me 55 minutes after landing to get my luggage. When I got mine, there are still half of people still waiting for theirs. Baggage people said staff are not used to 772.
Overall
GUM is a new route and new destination for UA, they are still working on various issues. Hopefully things will more smoother down the road.
Boarding
The inbound flight from ORD was 5 minutes late. There are lots of seat movements. Cleaners and catering were late, so we did not board until 2:20 and left gate 30 minutes late. GA even said there are snack for sale on board, but that was not the case.
There was a confusion and duty free cart was not loaded.
Flight
Biggest drawback is no personal entertainment, a significant downgrade from the "state of the art" entertainment on CO 764. Heard several people making comments on that.
Meals
Still serve 2 free meals just like CO. A round of drink 45 minutes after takeoff. First meal is 1.5 hour after takeoff, lagsana or chicken + salad and bread with plastic utensils. Ice cream at 5 hours into flight (usually 3.5 to 4 hours on CO). Second meal is 1.5 hours before landing, with a ham sandwich and sliced fruit, but no utensils provided. FAs tend to me slower serving meals compared to old CO, maybe they are not used to serve free meals to everyone.
Catering screwed up so no special meals were loaded.
Baggage
Took me 55 minutes after landing to get my luggage. When I got mine, there are still half of people still waiting for theirs. Baggage people said staff are not used to 772.
Overall
GUM is a new route and new destination for UA, they are still working on various issues. Hopefully things will more smoother down the road.
#88
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Mountain Time Zone
Programs: AS Million Miler/Marriott Lifetime Titanium/ IGH Ambassador
Posts: 5,996
I just completed UA 201 from HNL to Guam in Y on a domestic 772. Here is my mini trip report.
Boarding
The inbound flight from ORD was 5 minutes late. There are lots of seat movements. Cleaners and catering were late, so we did not board until 2:20 and left gate 30 minutes late. GA even said there are snack for sale on board, but that was not the case.
There was a confusion and duty free cart was not loaded.
Flight
Biggest drawback is no personal entertainment, a significant downgrade from the "state of the art" entertainment on CO 764. Heard several people making comments on that.
Meals
Still serve 2 free meals just like CO. A round of drink 45 minutes after takeoff. First meal is 1.5 hour after takeoff, lagsana or chicken + salad and bread with plastic utensils. Ice cream at 5 hours into flight (usually 3.5 to 4 hours on CO). Second meal is 1.5 hours before landing, with a ham sandwich and sliced fruit, but no utensils provided. FAs tend to me slower serving meals compared to old CO, maybe they are not used to serve free meals to everyone.
Catering screwed up so no special meals were loaded.
Baggage
Took me 55 minutes after landing to get my luggage. When I got mine, there are still half of people still waiting for theirs. Baggage people said staff are not used to 772.
Overall
GUM is a new route and new destination for UA, they are still working on various issues. Hopefully things will more smoother down the road.
Boarding
The inbound flight from ORD was 5 minutes late. There are lots of seat movements. Cleaners and catering were late, so we did not board until 2:20 and left gate 30 minutes late. GA even said there are snack for sale on board, but that was not the case.
There was a confusion and duty free cart was not loaded.
Flight
Biggest drawback is no personal entertainment, a significant downgrade from the "state of the art" entertainment on CO 764. Heard several people making comments on that.
Meals
Still serve 2 free meals just like CO. A round of drink 45 minutes after takeoff. First meal is 1.5 hour after takeoff, lagsana or chicken + salad and bread with plastic utensils. Ice cream at 5 hours into flight (usually 3.5 to 4 hours on CO). Second meal is 1.5 hours before landing, with a ham sandwich and sliced fruit, but no utensils provided. FAs tend to me slower serving meals compared to old CO, maybe they are not used to serve free meals to everyone.
Catering screwed up so no special meals were loaded.
Baggage
Took me 55 minutes after landing to get my luggage. When I got mine, there are still half of people still waiting for theirs. Baggage people said staff are not used to 772.
Overall
GUM is a new route and new destination for UA, they are still working on various issues. Hopefully things will more smoother down the road.
Last edited by iluv2fly; Nov 1, 2011 at 8:28 pm Reason: fixed
#89
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: LHR
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 14
Congrats! Does anyone know if GUM-HNL will have UDU for the rest of 2011? I was bummed that my CO SWU is useless for this leg of my trip (travelling in December 2011, booked in L class), but if there's a chance that it's UDU-able, that'd be pretty awesome!