Hotels going cashless (i.e., refusing cash payment) & implications of refusing cash
#16
Suspended
Join Date: Dec 2013
Posts: 1,271
LOL, you write as if it is only poor people who don't use cards and as if staying at a Hilton or Marriott means you do have money. My Brother does not use cards because of a lack of funds, he does not use cards because of a belief that using them gives too many government agencies and just plain hackers, access to too much information about you. And in that regard he is of course correct. But if he wants to stay in a Hilton type mid-market hotel or an upmarket hotel, he still pays cash. I suppose he can just call his banker and have them transfer the money to the hotel's account.
I find your asssumptions about who uses cash and who doesn't amusing. Oh and by the way, he doesn't own a cellphone either. For much the same reasons. Big Brother is watching.
As for someone paying it on their card and earning points, well I suppose that would be a benefit to someone who doesn't have enough money to not care about points. Maybe my Brother would hand you cash and let you get points from the hotel. A form of charitable contribution on his part. LOL
#17
Suspended
Join Date: Dec 2013
Posts: 1,271
Yes
That can sometimes work, but sometimes it doesn’t work.
I am just waiting to see what a place does when the final bill charges are such that the card used at check-in doesn’t cover the final bill in full and yet the only remaining form of payment available to the person is cash. Will courts defend the hotel ban on cash, or will courts defend the right to use local cash to pay expenses incurred in local cash denominations?
In Germany, for example, nearly 80% of all purchase transactions were done using cash. In Sweden, however, don’t be surprised if the majority of purchase transactions are settled without using cash.
That can sometimes work, but sometimes it doesn’t work.
I am just waiting to see what a place does when the final bill charges are such that the card used at check-in doesn’t cover the final bill in full and yet the only remaining form of payment available to the person is cash. Will courts defend the hotel ban on cash, or will courts defend the right to use local cash to pay expenses incurred in local cash denominations?
In Germany, for example, nearly 80% of all purchase transactions were done using cash. In Sweden, however, don’t be surprised if the majority of purchase transactions are settled without using cash.
Interesting that Germany still does 80% of all transactions in cash. I wonder why? Perhaps just a cultural thing. Or perhaps wiser than we realize.
When the power fails and the computers are down, our world today comes to a sudden and total halt. Even my Brother using cash can't pay for groceries at the supermarket if their computerized cash register won't add up the purchases and the drawer with the cash won't even open to make change. Imagine some of the younger people today trying to add up a column of a couple of dozen figures with a pencil and piece of paper. They actually couldn't do it in many cases. But my Brother can walk up to the check-out with a steak marked, '$16.50 on the plastic wrapped package, hand the clerk a $20 bill and say, 'keep the change.'
Try to imagine how long you could survive an extended power outage. Do a Google for 'Black Sky event' and see what you find. Makes for interesting reading. Even a weather induced event that last for more than a few days wreaks havoc. Computers have brought us many good things but they have also bought us potential unintended consequences as well. The more we move towards a 'cashless society' the more vulnerable we become to those consequences.
#18
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Pittsburgh
Programs: MR/SPG LT Titanium, AA LT PLT, UA SLV, Avis PreferredPlus
Posts: 31,010
Did you wake up on the "I am God" side of the bed today?
btw, it's 74% of transactions. You're entitled to you own opinion but not your own facts.
btw, it's 74% of transactions. You're entitled to you own opinion but not your own facts.
#19
Suspended
Original Poster
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Watchlisted by the prejudiced, en route to purgatory
Programs: Just Say No to Fleecing and Blacklisting
Posts: 102,095
+-/- 8% (or less ), the point is the same: the vast majority of transactions in Germany are still in cash, but Sweden has more rapidly become a different story. Either way the trend toward going cash free is increasing and impacting those staying at hotels during trips abroad.
Sometimes ancient innovations (like that of coinage/cash as a unit of value/measurement, a store of wealth and medium of exchange) don’t create the same kind of problems that an extreme dependency on modern technologies can create when things go seriously wrong and stay offline “for too long”.
A mixed system of old school and new school operating in conjunction is my idea of the “best of al worlds” when it comes to travel. Declining cash acceptance does have some consequences, realized or not as of yet..
Last edited by GUWonder; Mar 3, 2018 at 10:53 am
#20
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: San Diego, CA
Programs: GE, Marriott Platinum
Posts: 15,508
In the US, the only flights that I've noticed that accept cash involve the smaller regional jets (CRJs, Embraers, etc); the mainline aircraft from the major airlines are card only in my experience. The distance theory may still come into play as well since the former tend to operate shorter routes compared to the latter, but it could also come down to other factors. Of course, it could very well be different elsewhere.
#21
Join Date: Sep 2012
Location: NW London and NW Sydney
Programs: BA Diamond, Hilton Bronze, A3 Diamond, IHG *G
Posts: 6,347
I don't have a problem with this, if it is made clear at the time of booking that cash is not accepted.
If a hotel decides to go cashless, it should continue to accept cash for all bookings that were made prior to announcing this.
The Quality Hotel View at Malmö Hyllie is also cashless. I booked this via a 3rd party site which indicated that cash was accepted as a payment method, so I got an unpleasant surprise when I noticed the sign by the front entrance stating that it is "cash-free", and the hotel's own website is clear on that fact too. The staff were sympathetic to the fact that there was an error on their listing on that 3rd party site, but the only thing that could be done was to complain to that booking site, since the hotel's computer system was no longer able to record that payment had been made in cash, and would not allow check-in until payment was made by card.
When I was in New Zealand recently, I noticed that all my hotels had a sign at their front desk, stating that credit card payments incur a 2% fee, and if one wished to avoid this fee, to change the payment method to cash, and indeed I paid for all my hotel stays in cash (as I don't have a New Zealand debit card, otherwise I would have preferred to use that, obviously).
I guess cheap motels and hostels will continue to accept cash for some time (though maybe not in Sweden), but actually I would think that Hiltons and Marriotts would be among the last hotels to stop accepting cash.
With regards to cash on board airlines, I notice that flight attendants of low-cost carriers are very efficient at handling cash and giving change, and airlines such as BA which decided to never accept cash from the start (ostensibly with one reason being to save time) can be extremely inefficient.
Most problems with change can be eliminated by pricing items sensibly.
If a hotel decides to go cashless, it should continue to accept cash for all bookings that were made prior to announcing this.
The Quality Hotel View at Malmö Hyllie is also cashless. I booked this via a 3rd party site which indicated that cash was accepted as a payment method, so I got an unpleasant surprise when I noticed the sign by the front entrance stating that it is "cash-free", and the hotel's own website is clear on that fact too. The staff were sympathetic to the fact that there was an error on their listing on that 3rd party site, but the only thing that could be done was to complain to that booking site, since the hotel's computer system was no longer able to record that payment had been made in cash, and would not allow check-in until payment was made by card.
When I was in New Zealand recently, I noticed that all my hotels had a sign at their front desk, stating that credit card payments incur a 2% fee, and if one wished to avoid this fee, to change the payment method to cash, and indeed I paid for all my hotel stays in cash (as I don't have a New Zealand debit card, otherwise I would have preferred to use that, obviously).
With regards to cash on board airlines, I notice that flight attendants of low-cost carriers are very efficient at handling cash and giving change, and airlines such as BA which decided to never accept cash from the start (ostensibly with one reason being to save time) can be extremely inefficient.
Most problems with change can be eliminated by pricing items sensibly.
#22
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 9,307
Just as you and some others gave examples of where booking direct was the best option, there were also many, many examples of where that wasn't true. Shame you missed them.
#23
Moderator: Manufactured Spending
Join Date: Jul 2011
Posts: 6,580
LOL, you write as if it is only poor people who don't use cards and as if staying at a Hilton or Marriott means you do have money. My Brother does not use cards because of a lack of funds, he does not use cards because of a belief that using them gives too many government agencies and just plain hackers, access to too much information about you. And in that regard he is of course correct. But if he wants to stay in a Hilton type mid-market hotel or an upmarket hotel, he still pays cash. I suppose he can just call his banker and have them transfer the money to the hotel's account.
I find your asssumptions about who uses cash and who doesn't amusing. Oh and by the way, he doesn't own a cellphone either. For much the same reasons. Big Brother is watching.
I find your asssumptions about who uses cash and who doesn't amusing. Oh and by the way, he doesn't own a cellphone either. For much the same reasons. Big Brother is watching.
Because he sounds like some nutcase conspiracy theorist.
If he has a bank account, the government and hackers can already do what they need to do, but he clearly hasn't thought that through.
In the US, the only flights that I've noticed that accept cash involve the smaller regional jets (CRJs, Embraers, etc); the mainline aircraft from the major airlines are card only in my experience. The distance theory may still come into play as well since the former tend to operate shorter routes compared to the latter, but it could also come down to other factors. Of course, it could very well be different elsewhere.
With regards to cash on board airlines, I notice that flight attendants of low-cost carriers are very efficient at handling cash and giving change, and airlines such as BA which decided to never accept cash from the start (ostensibly with one reason being to save time) can be extremely inefficient.
Most problems with change can be eliminated by pricing items sensibly.
Most problems with change can be eliminated by pricing items sensibly.
#24
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: GLA
Programs: BA Silver
Posts: 2,963
I agree with your latter point, but I don’t really understand why you think card transactions take lower - the retailer presses “card” instead of opening the till, you hold your card over the machine; it’s done in 3-4 seconds!
#25
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: San Diego, CA
Programs: GE, Marriott Platinum
Posts: 15,508
Honestly, I'm surprised that businesses aren't doing more to discourage their use considering how much some dislike the whole concept.
#26
Join Date: Sep 2012
Location: NW London and NW Sydney
Programs: BA Diamond, Hilton Bronze, A3 Diamond, IHG *G
Posts: 6,347
I visited some Christmas markets in Scandinavia a few months ago, and I observed that cash payments were far more frequent than one might be led to believe.
For my own transactions a lot of the time using cash was much faster than card would have been, as I always try to have the correct amount ready, unlike some slow people who always seemed to have coins of multiple currencies in their purses and had trouble adding up. So the merchant handed me the item, and I handed over the cash, done. Alternatively, they hand me the item, then they fumble around for the card reader, enter the amount, then I have to put my card in (while holding the item), type the PIN, then wait for a connection and a receipt.
Of course, contactless is great.
#27
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Minneapolis: DL DM charter 2.3MM
Programs: A3*Gold, SPG Plat, HyattDiamond, MarriottPP, LHW exAccess, ICI, Raffles Amb, NW PE MM, TWA Gold MM
Posts: 100,417
Another reason to pay with cash is to avoid dynamic currency conversion and/or foreign transaction fees. Normally you can pay with a credit card that doesn't have such practices, but it can be a problem if the hotel or other merchannt in a foreign country doesn't accept all major credit cards.
Until recently, In Argentina, one got better foreign exchange rates for cash, so it made sense to avoid using credit cards, even for major expenditures such as hotel bills. Everyone seemed to be doing this.
Somewhat similarly, during periods of rapid changes in foreign exchange rates (such as very severe inflation in the destination country), it can make sense to avoid using credit cards that will be eventually billed in your home currency. Posting delays can be expensive in asuch cases.
Until recently, In Argentina, one got better foreign exchange rates for cash, so it made sense to avoid using credit cards, even for major expenditures such as hotel bills. Everyone seemed to be doing this.
Somewhat similarly, during periods of rapid changes in foreign exchange rates (such as very severe inflation in the destination country), it can make sense to avoid using credit cards that will be eventually billed in your home currency. Posting delays can be expensive in asuch cases.
#28
Join Date: Jul 2013
Location: SJC
Programs: DL DM, F9 100k, Hilton Diamond, Marriott Plat
Posts: 98
I've always found cash acceptance interesting. I've found it doesn't necessarily always correlate to the caliber of hotel here in the US, including deposit policies.
I've been to Full-Service Marriott properties that will take cash with a reasonable incidental deposit (in cash), but yet seen RIs that won't take cash at all (or they'll take cash for payment, but still want a CC to hold room + incidentals on)
I've also been to low-end properties that won't take cash, or require an absurd (Read: $300) deposit for those paying cash.
The only chain I've found to consistently accept cash (with no insane incidental deposit) is, unsurprisingly, Motel 6.
I've been to Full-Service Marriott properties that will take cash with a reasonable incidental deposit (in cash), but yet seen RIs that won't take cash at all (or they'll take cash for payment, but still want a CC to hold room + incidentals on)
I've also been to low-end properties that won't take cash, or require an absurd (Read: $300) deposit for those paying cash.
The only chain I've found to consistently accept cash (with no insane incidental deposit) is, unsurprisingly, Motel 6.
#29
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: ICN / 평택
Programs: AA, DL Gold, UA Gold, HHonors Gold
Posts: 8,714
There are middle class people who don't use cards, but they are probably too few to be worth the hotel's consideration. Perhaps they can be directed to get a money order from the closest CVS or 7-Eleven, or maybe the Flyertalker in line behind them would be happy to take the cash and use his/her credit card to pay the bill and earn some points
#30
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: OH
Programs: AA Lifetime Plat, Marriot Lifetime Gold
Posts: 9,539
Does he also wear a tin foil hat to stop the government from sending radio waves into his brain?
Because he sounds like some nutcase conspiracy theorist.
If he has a bank account, the government and hackers can already do what they need to do, but he clearly hasn't thought that through.
I've noticed that too. Maybe people don't buy much on short flights so it's not worthwhile to set up the machines?
Why would you think that?
I don't think card payments generally save time, especially for small amounts. It can take longer to run a credit card transaction than to accept a note and give change. My guess is that airlines don't want to bother storing and transporting cash.
Because he sounds like some nutcase conspiracy theorist.
If he has a bank account, the government and hackers can already do what they need to do, but he clearly hasn't thought that through.
I've noticed that too. Maybe people don't buy much on short flights so it's not worthwhile to set up the machines?
Why would you think that?
I don't think card payments generally save time, especially for small amounts. It can take longer to run a credit card transaction than to accept a note and give change. My guess is that airlines don't want to bother storing and transporting cash.