FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Practical Travel Safety and Security Issues (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/practical-travel-safety-security-issues-686/)
-   -   What would it take for TSA acceptance? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/practical-travel-safety-security-issues/954542-what-would-take-tsa-acceptance.html)

staceyjda May 18, 2009 7:26 pm


Originally Posted by CameraGuy (Post 11768061)
No I do not.

What did fail on 9/11 was the cooperation of the pax and crew with the hijackers. That failure is highly unlikely to be repeated.

I don't know if I agree w/this, especially w/all the sheeple willing to bend over for the naked body peep show machines. I mean, don't you think as more and more people like my husband and myself who are unwilling to be stripped of our clothing and our Constitutional rights stop flying altogether, that the sheeple left on flights are the same folks who are going to sit there on their hands if another 9/11 takes place? I'm sorry, but I think the spineless, brainless idiots who say, "Oh Golly! If it makes me safer--by all means sexually harass and assault me," are not the kind of people who are going to fight for their lives (to speak nothing of those innocent folks on the ground whom the airliner may be used against).

Stacey--first time post, btw...I already like a vast majority of the folks here, it's nice to find so few sheeple for a change ^(been reading pages and pages here in preparation for a new post on the naked body peep show scanners).

IslandBased May 18, 2009 9:41 pm


Originally Posted by HSVTSO Dean (Post 11769143)
I actually preferred the cloth insignia. The second one, anyway. The first iteration of the TSA uniform (the old DoT uniforms), the orange cloth badge looked like it came out of a Fisher-Price™ playset.

Somebody higher up on the TSA scale had a sense of reality/humor.:p

Lumpy May 18, 2009 10:34 pm

Welcome aboard, staceyjda! As more and more folks Unsheeple and quit bleating (sounds like 'bleeding', doesn't it?) on command for the TSA, there may be a dim ray of hope.

At any rate, just to get back to the seemingly forgotten original OP question: what would it take for TSA acceptance? For Lumpy, it would take waterboarding of each and every agency employee at Lumpy's hands until Lumpy was satisfied that the Dignity and Respect pledge of the TSA toward paxs had at last been truthfully met.

Talk about getting your mouth washed out with SOAP (or something...)

Nancy P. is going to teach me the new refinements of the technique as soon as she can get the true goods from the CIA, and they will be used as secondary screening techniques along with a few other SSI 'additional' techniques I am not allowed to see, they being part of the Really TRULY BIG BIG Super Secret SOP.

Hope you can accept that...

CameraGuy May 19, 2009 6:17 am


Originally Posted by TSORon (Post 11768382)
No box cutters. Next?

WRONG, again.

The box cutter ban was put in place long before (Sometime around 9/14/2001) congress created this wasteful, workfare agency.

Care to try again?

N965VJ May 19, 2009 8:01 am


Originally Posted by TSORon (Post 11767916)

9. Kill LASP dead in its tracks. There is no reason whatsoever the TSA should encroach on General Aviation. This is nothing more than a back channel way for the airlines and the Air Transport Association to make GA less of a viable alternative.
Are you of the opinion that private aircraft cannot be crashed into buildings?

Have you ever been in a corporate FBO, or aboard a GA aircraft with a MTOW greater than 12,500 lbs?

coachrowsey May 19, 2009 9:19 am


Originally Posted by staceyjda (Post 11769666)
I don't know if I agree w/this, especially w/all the sheeple willing to bend over for the naked body peep show machines. I mean, don't you think as more and more people like my husband and myself who are unwilling to be stripped of our clothing and our Constitutional rights stop flying altogether, that the sheeple left on flights are the same folks who are going to sit there on their hands if another 9/11 takes place? I'm sorry, but I think the spineless, brainless idiots who say, "Oh Golly! If it makes me safer--by all means sexually harass and assault me," are not the kind of people who are going to fight for their lives (to speak nothing of those innocent folks on the ground whom the airliner may be used against).

Stacey--first time post, btw...I already like a vast majority of the folks here, it's nice to find so few sheeple for a change ^(been reading pages and pages here in preparation for a new post on the naked body peep show scanners).



^^ & Welcome to FlyerTalk.

FWAAA May 19, 2009 9:42 am


Originally Posted by halls120 (Post 11769536)
I realize your job is to come on FT and preach company gospel. We get it. But while each of us is entitled to our own opinions, we don't get to have our own facts.

Agree completely with your post.

The propaganda machine continues to spin.

Flaflyer May 19, 2009 3:55 pm

Toy Carnivals-R-Us
 

Originally Posted by HSVTSO Dean (Post 11769143)
The first iteration of the TSA uniform (the old DoT uniforms), the orange cloth badge looked like it came out of a Fisher-Price™ playset.

Here it happens again, another TSO misinforming the flying public. ;)

SSI research clearly shows the original* TSA Organization Manual was not made by Fisher-Price. It was from Playmobil. :p

*Which has Evolved into the "Mission Creep International Airport" version where 75% of the floor space is taken up by TSA, for proper indoctrination of next generation sheeple.

TSORon Sep 25, 2009 9:53 am


Originally Posted by N965VJ (Post 11759810)

What to do with the TSA short term-

1. Full accountability of TSA employees, with levels of discipline up to and including termination. Fail a Red Team test? You’re fired. A pattern of complaints from PAX and not following the SOP? You’re fired.

So, if we apply your standard to the general public, or even the police or the military, one mistake and your history. No possibility of retraining, no possibility of errors on the part of either the red team members or the passengers, just out the door! Real humane, to bad your solution here would violate several federal labor laws.


2. Initiate a focus on customer service training instead of barking and asking “Do you want to fly today?” The fact that the TSA has publically stated that customer service is not a priority in its Engage! training is appalling. Ditch the LEO look-alike uniform and tin badge ($14 million waste of taxpayer money). TSOs are not law enforcement.
You really should attend the Engage training. You might actually then know what you are talking about. As for the uniforms, we know we are not LEO’s, but you seem to have issues in this area.


3. End the War on Liquids. The exemptions make it pointless, and even if there was such a Magic Liquid™ that could be used to create a bomb if you just had enough of it, just send ten guys through the checkpoint with their Kippie Bags and combine it airside.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/7536167.stm


4. End the Shoe Carnival. The X-Ray machine cannot detect explosives, period.
The X-ray machines have never been able to detect anything, the operators can, and do.


5. Eliminate the gate screenings. The fact that this is being done in MCI, where each gate area pretty much has its own checkpoint to start with, is proof that this is nothing more than security theatre and workfare.
http://www.skatingonstilts.com/skating-on-stilts/


6. Get rid of the No Fly List. There’s no effective means of redress or oversight how the list is managed. If the people on these lists are so dangerous, arrest them.
So, we should allow known terrorists to fly on our nations commercial aircraft? Hmmm, well they can fly with you, but I would rather they not fly with me. Any of them.


7. Stop the ID checks. The TSA has no need to know who I am or where I’m flying. This is nothing more than revenue protection on behalf of the airlines. The thought that I must “present my papers” to travel within the border of my own country is disgusting.
There are many places and conditions on which you might be required to “present my papers”, and I don’t hear you complaining about them.


8. Stop using the checkpoint as a dragnet. I’m tired of the TSA patting itself on the back every time it catches a college kid with a fake ID, illegal alien going home, or some common criminal wanted on a drug charge somewhere. These actions are not the mission of the TSA; we have other government agencies tasked for this.
Better to say “Stop breaking the law and then trying to fly”. I’m fairly sure that many folks who have warrants out for them fly every day, it’s just the idiots who make a scene or who break the law ON the checkpoints that get caught.


9. Kill LASP dead in its tracks. There is no reason whatsoever the TSA should encroach on General Aviation. This is nothing more than a back channel way for the airlines and the Air Transport Association to make GA less of a viable alternative.
Sure, there must be something on board all those private aircraft that make it impossible for them to be used as weapons. Some transponder, radar, terrain avoidance system, magic wand or force field…


10. End the mission creep. What on earth was the mayor of TPA thinking when he asked the TSA to provide BDOs at the Super Bowl? What do sporting events have to do with transportation?
I have worked some of the types of events that you complain about. The paychecks for those who work the events come directly from the event organizers. Its not mission creep to do some part time work. TSO’s have specialized skills that the event organizers wanted to use, why not allow them to use those skills?


What to do with the TSA long term-

The TSA should become a part of the DOT. Actual screening should be done by private contractors with oversight by the DOT or FAA. Funny how we never heard the constant stories of mistreatment and harassment of PAX, organized rings of theft and general thuggery when this was being done by private sector firms.
You were not listening. That’s how. Just as you wont listen to what I have written, because it does not meet your political agenda, personal perception of your importance in the universe, or it contradicts your opinions. How sad for you.

NoClu Sep 25, 2009 9:56 am

Why go through the trouble of reviving a dead thread if all you are going to do is take offense and argue about statements from months ago?:rolleyes:

FlyingHoustonian Sep 25, 2009 10:15 am


Originally Posted by NoClu (Post 12437002)
Why go through the trouble of reviving a dead thread if all you are going to do is take offense and argue about statements from months ago?:rolleyes:

That is part of the "cut and paste" agenda. Posting vague tangential "arguments" with no facts for back up and presuming ones own non-factual post is fact by saying it over and over a few times; then refusing to answer direct questions about it. That is the standard M.O. here.

Ciao,
FH

jkhuggins Sep 25, 2009 10:31 am


Originally Posted by N965VJ (Post 11759810)

What to do with the TSA short term-


1. Full accountability of TSA employees, with levels of discipline up to and including termination. Fail a Red Team test? You’re fired. A pattern of complaints from PAX and not following the SOP? You’re fired.


Originally Posted by TSORon (Post 12436978)
So, if we apply your standard to the general public, or even the police or the military, one mistake and your history. No possibility of retraining, no possibility of errors on the part of either the red team members or the passengers, just out the door! Real humane, to bad your solution here would violate several federal labor laws.

Ron, with respect ... that's not what N965VJ said. "Up to and including termination" doesn't mean "one mistake and you're history". "A pattern of complaints" doesn't mean "one mistake and you're history".

Look, I have a job with substantial job security protections, and I'm happy for them. But those protections aren't absolute. There are certain things at my job that if I did them, I'd be escorted to the door instantly. There are other things at my job that if I made a regular habit of doing them, I'd be warned, disciplined, and eventually escorted to the door. And I know this is true because I've seen people disappear from the office for precisely those reasons.

Does this happen with TSA? I don't know ... because even though TSA is a taxpayer-funded agency, TSA doesn't reveal personnel actions to the public. (And, yes, I understand that TSA contends that federal law forbids them from disclosing such actions.)

Is TSA held accountable for its performance? I honestly don't know. If it is held accountable, it's certainly not publicly accountable.


Originally Posted by N965VJ (Post 11759810)
6. Get rid of the No Fly List. There’s no effective means of redress or oversight how the list is managed. If the people on these lists are so dangerous, arrest them.


Originally Posted by TSORon (Post 12436978)
So, we should allow known terrorists to fly on our nations commercial aircraft? Hmmm, well they can fly with you, but I would rather they not fly with me. Any of them.

If they're that dangerous, then get a court order forbidding them from flying. Then everyone will know who is, and isn't, on the no-fly list. Furthermore, the court proceedings will give defendants due-process rights to ensure that only truly dangerous people are on the list. Right now, there are no due-process rights; no-one knows how a name gets on the list, and no-one knows how to get a name off the list. (Heck, there's no way to even confirm if a name is on the list.)


Originally Posted by TSORon (Post 12436978)
7. Stop the ID checks. The TSA has no need to know who I am or where I’m flying. This is nothing more than revenue protection on behalf of the airlines. The thought that I must “present my papers” to travel within the border of my own country is disgusting.


Originally Posted by TSORon (Post 12436978)
There are many places and conditions on which you might be required to “present my papers”, and I don’t hear you complaining about them.

And most of those places and conditions are actually checking things other than identity, even though one presents an identity document to confirm them.

N965VJ Sep 25, 2009 11:35 am


Originally Posted by TSORon (Post 12436978)
Sure, there must be something on board all those private aircraft that make it impossible for them to be used as weapons. Some transponder, radar, terrain avoidance system, magic wand or force field…


I’m not sure where you’re going here. Are you saying all GA aircraft with MTOW greater than 12500 lbs should be mandated to only fly in controlled airspace?



Originally Posted by TSORon (Post 12436978)
I have worked some of the types of events that you complain about. The paychecks for those who work the events come directly from the event organizers. Its not mission creep to do some part time work. TSO’s have specialized skills that the event organizers wanted to use, why not allow them to use those skills?

A TSO can moonlight off-duty in uniform?

wildcatlh Sep 25, 2009 11:55 am


Originally Posted by TSORon (Post 12436978)

Sure, there must be something on board all those private aircraft that make it impossible for them to be used as weapons. Some transponder, radar, terrain avoidance system, magic wand or force field…


Even in the rare occurrence that something does happen with a private plane -- exactly how much damage are you going to have?

Because... if you remember, it happened. Didn't do much at all, actually. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/1744923.stm

N965VJ Sep 25, 2009 12:10 pm


Originally Posted by wildcatlh (Post 12437621)
Even in the rare occurrence that something does happen with a private plane -- exactly how much damage are you going to have?

Because... if you remember, it happened. Didn't do much at all, actually. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/1744923.stm

I should point out that LASP will not directly affect light GA aircraft*. However, towards the end of WWII a B-25 bomber crashed into the Empire State Building due to bad WX. Although unfortunate, there were only about a dozen fatalities.

*The hobbling of our GA infrastructure would certainly trickle down with a negative effect on owners of light GA aircraft.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:33 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.