Best card for foreign exchange?
#511
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Atlanta
Programs: POS, Delta Skymiles, IC Plat Amb., Hilton Gold, SPG gold
Posts: 1,619
fyi, my schwab visa still charges no fee and all my charges for this upcoming trip - the rates are better than whats on xe.com.
#512


Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: NYC
Posts: 8,691
Originally Posted by allen074
Natalie - welcome to the scam of all scams -- yes, you probably were charged a currency ripoff fee even though the purchase was in US$. The merchant located overseas and therefore they charged you a fee. Ain't that great.
#513
Join Date: Oct 2005
Programs: AA, SPG
Posts: 108
I have a Bank Direct online checking with interest account (AA miles for opening and on interest - thanks FT!) and it has the best deal out of all my cards and banks (I don't have a Capital One) - the ATM fee is only for whatever the foreign ATM fee is (they reimburse up to 4 for US transactions), and their Visa debit card just passes along the Visa 1 percent. If I wanted another CC I would get the Fidelity MBNA, but I don't.
I'm imagining that foreign ATM fees aren't going to be over $10 US, so at worst I would be charged 1 percent for $100. Oh, that's not right. That would be 10 %! I wouldn't get just $100, but I wouldn't get $1000 either, which would get it down to 1%. Maybe not such a good deal. But my other ATM card (Chase) charges $3 plus 3%, which just seems exorbitant.
Can someone tell me the range of ATM fees I might encounter?
I'm imagining that foreign ATM fees aren't going to be over $10 US, so at worst I would be charged 1 percent for $100. Oh, that's not right. That would be 10 %! I wouldn't get just $100, but I wouldn't get $1000 either, which would get it down to 1%. Maybe not such a good deal. But my other ATM card (Chase) charges $3 plus 3%, which just seems exorbitant.
Can someone tell me the range of ATM fees I might encounter?
#514
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Midlothian, VA
Programs: DoD
Posts: 10
Originally Posted by fun888
Just returned from Japan.. did some charges on the CitiBank cards.
Exchange rate is about 1% surcharge... there is another column showing the 4% charges making a total cost of 4 % to me.
another interesting things is, some local bank charges 1 % while other charges 2 or 3 % in the exchange rate, in addition to the CitiBank 3 %. The total cost of using your credit card can be as high as 6%.
From the ATM, Citibank ATM is 1.2% and Bank of America ATM is about 1.5% in getting cash.
There is no way out from the greedy banks.
Exchange rate is about 1% surcharge... there is another column showing the 4% charges making a total cost of 4 % to me.
another interesting things is, some local bank charges 1 % while other charges 2 or 3 % in the exchange rate, in addition to the CitiBank 3 %. The total cost of using your credit card can be as high as 6%.
From the ATM, Citibank ATM is 1.2% and Bank of America ATM is about 1.5% in getting cash.
There is no way out from the greedy banks.
#515


Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: NYC
Posts: 8,691
Originally Posted by susaboo
Can someone tell me the range of ATM fees I might encounter?
#517
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: MCI
Programs: AA Gold 1MM, AS MVP, UA Silver, WN A-List, Marriott LT Titanium, HH Diamond
Posts: 53,012
Both of the popular new Juniper cards - US Airways and Midwest Airlines - follow the typical 1+2% method.
I use SPG Amex as my primary and my credit union's debit card as my backup while abroad.
I figure I'm still coming out a smidge ahead buying Starpoints for 2 cents, and my credit union debit card doesn't seem to pass through any charges that I can tell (vs. that day's interbank rates). I also get three free ATM hits per month worldwide with the debit card, which is plenty unless I'm hitting a lot of different countries.
I use SPG Amex as my primary and my credit union's debit card as my backup while abroad.
I figure I'm still coming out a smidge ahead buying Starpoints for 2 cents, and my credit union debit card doesn't seem to pass through any charges that I can tell (vs. that day's interbank rates). I also get three free ATM hits per month worldwide with the debit card, which is plenty unless I'm hitting a lot of different countries.
#518
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 69
Originally Posted by fun888
I did two experiments in hong Kong with my b of a ATM card and the citi ATM at their respective bank owned ATM machine... both without any aTM fee charge.
the exchange rate for HK$500 at each terminal on the same day, within 2 minutes (3/2 and 3/13 twice). BofA has the best rate of $7.76 (at the official exchange rate published by the Asia Wall Street Journal) while citi is only $7.68 which is 1% less than the official rate.
If you need Chinese YMB$, the best way is to get it from the bofA ATM in hong kong, the exhange rate is at the official rate too... Y$8.02. I can only get $7.9 inside China using cash. ATM rate are usually lower at Y$7.8 Citi has ATM at all major cities within China.
As to credit card, I get the offical rate of Y$8.02 and HK$7.76 using my charless Schwab credit card without any surcharge.
the exchange rate for HK$500 at each terminal on the same day, within 2 minutes (3/2 and 3/13 twice). BofA has the best rate of $7.76 (at the official exchange rate published by the Asia Wall Street Journal) while citi is only $7.68 which is 1% less than the official rate.
If you need Chinese YMB$, the best way is to get it from the bofA ATM in hong kong, the exhange rate is at the official rate too... Y$8.02. I can only get $7.9 inside China using cash. ATM rate are usually lower at Y$7.8 Citi has ATM at all major cities within China.
As to credit card, I get the offical rate of Y$8.02 and HK$7.76 using my charless Schwab credit card without any surcharge.
Just returned from China and used the citi ATM at the PVG AIRPORT TO GET CASH. When I returned, I found out that there is a surcharge of $5, or 1%, on my statement. The exhange rate is about 0.7% less than the official exchange rate as listed on the Asia Wall street Journal.
Call to Citibank, the lady answered cannot give me an answer. talked to a supervisor: It is Citi new policy to charge 1% on all foreign aTM transactions. If you use a non-Citi ATM, there will be another $5 to 7 surcharge per transaction.
Bank of America has a better exchange rate than Citi and they do not charge the extra 1% on their own aTM machines.
the moral of the story is ; stop using an citi credit card and ATM oversea.
#519

Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 812
Originally Posted by pinniped
I use SPG Amex as my primary and my credit union's debit card as my backup while abroad.
I figure I'm still coming out a smidge ahead buying Starpoints for 2 cents, and my credit union debit card doesn't seem to pass through any charges that I can tell (vs. that day's interbank rates). I also get three free ATM hits per month worldwide with the debit card, which is plenty unless I'm hitting a lot of different countries.
I figure I'm still coming out a smidge ahead buying Starpoints for 2 cents, and my credit union debit card doesn't seem to pass through any charges that I can tell (vs. that day's interbank rates). I also get three free ATM hits per month worldwide with the debit card, which is plenty unless I'm hitting a lot of different countries.
I guess I'm also leery of using AMEX for foreign transactions given the class action lawsuit (from which I got all of 3 cents). For some countries, they apparently had terrible conversions, and I don't want to waste the time calling up customer service to dispute the conversion rate. In this case, I think the class action lawsuit settlement probably had the opposite effect of what AMEX hoped for--I'm now very unlikely to use them for overseas transactions except under special circumstances.
#520
Original Member
Join Date: May 1998
Location: Kirkland, WA
Posts: 6,932
Bank of America has informed me that they no longer waive the forex fees for Premier Banking Customers, so it's back to the Harvard Alumni Association MasterCard.
QL
QL
#521
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: LAX/SNA
Programs: AA PLT/1.9MM
Posts: 500
The free ride on the Fidelity Investments Rewards MC has come to an end. Just got a notice that, effective June 30, 2006, a 3% 'transaction fee" will be added to all foreign transactions.
#522




Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: Palm Beach/ New England
Programs: AA EXP 3MM, DL GM, Marriott Platinum
Posts: 4,459
Capital One MasterCard still has 0% foreign currency transaction fees.
#523


Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: NYC
Posts: 8,691
Originally Posted by fastflyer
Capital One MasterCard still has 0% foreign currency transaction fees.
http://www.flyertalk.com/wiki/index....hange#The_List
Otherwise, let me know the details by PM and I'll do it for you.
#524

Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: SF, NYC (Upper WS), Europe
Posts: 309
For all of you that want to test out you card for foreign fee transactions before your next trip, try:
www.allofmp3.com
Buy $10 worth of downloadable MP3s (the current minimum), the bill is in Rubles so you can check your credit card bill online after 2 days to see if there is an extra charge......(BTW, allofmp3.com is the cheapest place on the net to get songs and it's very reliable, so it's at least a good investment for the ole' Ipod.)
I recently did this with my MBNA Amtrak MC only to find out that it's now 3%.
www.allofmp3.com
Buy $10 worth of downloadable MP3s (the current minimum), the bill is in Rubles so you can check your credit card bill online after 2 days to see if there is an extra charge......(BTW, allofmp3.com is the cheapest place on the net to get songs and it's very reliable, so it's at least a good investment for the ole' Ipod.)
I recently did this with my MBNA Amtrak MC only to find out that it's now 3%.
#525

Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: SF, NYC (Upper WS), Europe
Posts: 309
Originally Posted by fastflyer
Capital One MasterCard still has 0% foreign currency transaction fees.

