![]() |
Originally Posted by ckendall
(Post 36573886)
Recent one-night stay on points (Saturday night): NUA did not clear but we were "upgraded" to an unobstructed park view. Room was lovely and breakfast was great. Only snag was getting the Titanium breakfast benefit. Breakfast price was applied to my bill and I eventually called and got $60 taken off...as there were two of us, was I entitled to $120 off or is the benefit only $60 per room? Thanks for any help.
|
Thanks; I had heard $60 but didn't understand whether it was per person or per room.
|
Does $30 cover anything at breakfast?
|
Originally Posted by Dn10
(Post 36579985)
Does $30 cover anything at breakfast?
It seems like a setup, though, where they know that you'll end up spending $45-55 per person on breakfast. A $40 per person credit would actually coffer breakfast + juice + coffee and would seem like more of a good faith effort towards covering "breakfast" IMO, even though the T&Cs are vague enough that they could choose to just cover a meager continental and call it a day. |
Originally Posted by diesteldorf
(Post 36479492)
This is probably entirely subjective, but I wanted to burn an 85K certificate before it expired and was trying to decide between this or the Ritz Carleton. I've stayed at the Ritz in the past but this looked a little nicer and I was ready for a change.
I am just a lowly Gold, so breakfast for me, but are there any good restaurants within 1-2 blocks for breakfast or dinner?
|
Originally Posted by platbrownguy
(Post 36580038)
Covers the full american or a few other mains: https://www.mirurestaurant.com/menus/
It seems like a setup, though, where they know that you'll end up spending $45-55 per person on breakfast. A $40 per person credit would actually coffer breakfast + juice + coffee and would seem like more of a good faith effort towards covering "breakfast" IMO, even though the T&Cs are vague enough that they could choose to just cover a meager continental and call it a day. |
Have stayed at this place 3 times, and each stay has declined in quality. The first one in May 2024 was fantastic, upgrade to a caroline astor suite, champagne at check in, beautiful welcome amenity in room and was showed to our room by the associate. The second visit in January 2025 was only upgraded one level to the river view base room which had an awkward layout. No greeting at check in nor welcome amenity of any kind. The most recent visit this month has been extremely underwhelming. I've already downgraded my brilliant card and am planning on closing both my bonvoy amex. There's just too much inconsistency with the breakfast credit feeling cheap and the location is poor.
|
Won’t be surprised if and when StR has its benefits downgraded to align with R-C…only a matter of time IMO
|
Originally Posted by cjglick
(Post 36898972)
Have stayed at this place 3 times, and each stay has declined in quality. The first one in May 2024 was fantastic, upgrade to a caroline astor suite, champagne at check in, beautiful welcome amenity in room and was showed to our room by the associate. The second visit in January 2025 was only upgraded one level to the river view base room which had an awkward layout. No greeting at check in nor welcome amenity of any kind. The most recent visit this month has been extremely underwhelming. I've already downgraded my brilliant card and am planning on closing both my bonvoy amex. There's just too much inconsistency with the breakfast credit feeling cheap and the location is poor.
i will second that they used to give out sparkling wine or pink lemonade, which was a small, but really nice touch even giving us a bottle one time. This last time, there was nothing. It’s less a complaint and more just a note of subtraction by subtraction. so far, I’ve tended to favor st Regis over ritz Carlton because of exactly the fact that I do feel like the benefits are better, but agree with the other post that companies seem to be removing benefits, not adding them. |
Originally Posted by UA-NYC
(Post 36899125)
Won’t be surprised if and when StR has its benefits downgraded to align with R-C…only a matter of time IMO
|
Should note that during my stay over the weekend I ordered coffee through the butler service, and later noticed a $40 charge on my bill despite not having signed for anything. When I asked the front desk, she advised that property management made the decision to "discontinue offering butler service" a few months ago and that they've received a number of guest complaints. I asked to be transferred to manager line but was sent straight to voicemail, so I've left a message and opened a case with Marriott. I thought that complimentary coffee and tea in the mornings is a brand standard benefit? You'd think at the very least they should disclose that they don't offer that prior to charging for the drinks?
|
I stayed in a suite ten days ago (NUA) and had tea from a butler with no charge added.
|
Originally Posted by cjglick
(Post 36903399)
Should note that during my stay over the weekend I ordered coffee through the butler service, and later noticed a $40 charge on my bill despite not having signed for anything. When I asked the front desk, she advised that property management made the decision to "discontinue offering butler service" a few months ago and that they've received a number of guest complaints. I asked to be transferred to manager line but was sent straight to voicemail, so I've left a message and opened a case with Marriott. I thought that complimentary coffee and tea in the mornings is a brand standard benefit? You'd think at the very least they should disclose that they don't offer that prior to charging for the drinks?
|
Originally Posted by cjglick
(Post 36903399)
Should note that during my stay over the weekend I ordered coffee through the butler service, and later noticed a $40 charge on my bill despite not having signed for anything. When I asked the front desk, she advised that property management made the decision to "discontinue offering butler service" a few months ago and that they've received a number of guest complaints. I asked to be transferred to manager line but was sent straight to voicemail, so I've left a message and opened a case with Marriott. I thought that complimentary coffee and tea in the mornings is a brand standard benefit? You'd think at the very least they should disclose that they don't offer that prior to charging for the drinks?
|
Right - I even confirmed prior to the order on the app that all room levels include butler service so it shouldn't be the difference between whether it was a suite or not. Honestly given how limited use there is for the butler service I'm a little stunned by how cheap they're being.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 7:54 am. |
This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.