How Different Credit Card companies handle MS ?
#17
Join Date: Feb 2017
Posts: 40
#20
Original Poster
Join Date: Jan 2013
Posts: 1,438
#21
Join Date: May 2017
Posts: 59
#22
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: South Florida, USA
Posts: 184
If the MO was not made out to yourself, how would you deposit it into your account? I suppose if it was endorsed to you on the back. But do banks generally accept endorsed checks?
#23
Join Date: May 2017
Posts: 59
should've been more clear...by made out to yourself, i meant putting yourself down as both sender and receiver of the mo.
#24
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: South Florida, USA
Posts: 184
#25
Join Date: May 2017
Posts: 59
no questioning from the banks for depositing mo's with an anonymous sender? what volume are you depositing, if you don't mind answering?
#26
Join Date: Feb 2015
Posts: 14
What? I think he said it. I MSed almost my entire 110k in 4 months. Of course there has been about 1-3k/mo biz use on this card for years, so maybe that makes my usage less suspicious.
I agree with the person who said that many shutdowns may be reported with less than the whole story. I know a guy who got shut down by Am3x for only 10k/mo. He was floored and dumbfounded. After a detailed discussion, it turns out he was depositing MO's in 8-10 banks and CU's and paying the card with 8-10 billpays from different institutions. Now, that's suspicious.
Addressing the OP, maybe it's the type of card. WF was touchy about their 5B grocery because it was their cash. Same with BB&T's 4.05% everything card. I got shutdowns on both of those, cycling. But I can cycle a points card as often as I want. Consider the biz model. More usage gets them a better deal on buying the points from whomever. Imagine Am3x at a Hilton or Starwood meeting. "We bought umpteen billion points last year. Give us a better deal this year..." As long as they're making money on every transaction, I imagine they don't care. But if they're losing money... Same goes for casinos. My first time in Vegas, I was obviously counting cards and they knew it. But they didn't throw me out when they were making money from me. Only when they were losing.
I agree with the person who said that many shutdowns may be reported with less than the whole story. I know a guy who got shut down by Am3x for only 10k/mo. He was floored and dumbfounded. After a detailed discussion, it turns out he was depositing MO's in 8-10 banks and CU's and paying the card with 8-10 billpays from different institutions. Now, that's suspicious.
Addressing the OP, maybe it's the type of card. WF was touchy about their 5B grocery because it was their cash. Same with BB&T's 4.05% everything card. I got shutdowns on both of those, cycling. But I can cycle a points card as often as I want. Consider the biz model. More usage gets them a better deal on buying the points from whomever. Imagine Am3x at a Hilton or Starwood meeting. "We bought umpteen billion points last year. Give us a better deal this year..." As long as they're making money on every transaction, I imagine they don't care. But if they're losing money... Same goes for casinos. My first time in Vegas, I was obviously counting cards and they knew it. But they didn't throw me out when they were making money from me. Only when they were losing.
#27
Original Poster
Join Date: Jan 2013
Posts: 1,438
To the bank, it's the same scenario as depositing a check. That is why I am baffled by Flyertalkers who mention they are leery to deposit money orders or their bank gives them a hard time.
If they ask "Why are you the buyer and the recipient?," then you should be able to say "none of your business" but probably better to say "It's like writing myself a check for business purposes."
#28
Join Date: Feb 2015
Posts: 14
Well, I'm skeptical too about believing all these posts, but sometimes you do have to believe and be careful. I read how strict Chase was, for example. I bought a gift card, and I got flagged immediately, first time right out of the gate. So I for one DO believe those posts as true. Or at least half true like you said!
Last edited by TyroneSchulase; Jun 16, 2017 at 11:29 am
#29
Join Date: May 2017
Posts: 59
I usually get mine blank at the PO for $495. I go to bank immediately after. Scribble my own name as the recipient, sign it, deposit it. Sometimes 3 or 4 at a time for a total deposit of $1,980. Personally, I always deposit and never cash them.
To the bank, it's the same scenario as depositing a check. That is why I am baffled by Flyertalkers who mention they are leery to deposit money orders or their bank gives them a hard time.
If they ask "Why are you the buyer and the recipient?," then you should be able to say "none of your business" but probably better to say "It's like writing myself a check for business purposes."
To the bank, it's the same scenario as depositing a check. That is why I am baffled by Flyertalkers who mention they are leery to deposit money orders or their bank gives them a hard time.
If they ask "Why are you the buyer and the recipient?," then you should be able to say "none of your business" but probably better to say "It's like writing myself a check for business purposes."
For Chase, when I'm training a new card, I always call and notify them of an upcoming large purchase. Their automated system is great for that, and it works every time. I start small, maybe 3k first purchase, then 6, then 10. After the third purchase, I don't need to call anymore. And I'm careful not to mix in too many small purchases. I suspect it throws their model off. (i.e. Are you a big spender or not?) What they find suspicious is 100's of $4 purchases for months, then $500. I would definitely warn them on that, just like you tell them when you're leaving the state.
#30
Join Date: Feb 2015
Posts: 910
But I can cycle a points card as often as I want. Consider the biz model. More usage gets them a better deal on buying the points from whomever. Imagine Am3x at a Hilton or Starwood meeting. "We bought umpteen billion points last year. Give us a better deal this year..." As long as they're making money on every transaction, I imagine they don't care.
We largely all play by ear I'd imagine and when a review and or shutdown happens we ourselves might not be aware of all the deciding factors, or how far back an analyst decided to look to make a decision. But, I wouldn't venture to say that just because one of us has done X activity with no blow-back so far, that X activity doesn't result in a shutdown. My guess is that that most shutdowns happen for a combination of risks factors, and/or repeat of activities that the bank sees as risky or suspicious, not just doing one of these things once.