FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   DiningBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz-371/)
-   -   Best & worst Bourbon? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz/694797-best-worst-bourbon.html)

Madone59 Sep 3, 2015 10:50 am


Originally Posted by exerda (Post 25333939)
My most-local ABC store claimed (and I take this with a huge grain of salt) that Buffalo Trace is going to start becoming an "allocated" product, meaning that each store will get only a limited amount of it and thus it will be hard to find.

It's all over here in San Diego, I think it grows on the trees.

FlyingDoctorwu Sep 3, 2015 8:40 pm


Originally Posted by broadwayblue (Post 25372099)
After eluding me for years I finally found a few bottles of the 2014 Single Barrel and Small Batch Limited Editions. Cost me $100/bottle, but can't really complain considering how hard these are to find in the wild. Really looking forward to sampling these.

Wow congrats? Just recently? That's great... i haven't opened my bottle of the 2014 Single Barrel LE; but I did really like the 2014 Small Batch LE... $100 is still a great price; considering that the retail price was $80. Also, 2014 was the last year that they made a single barrel... I'm already gearing up for this year's small batch LE- it's got a great recipe with a little more age to it... In my mind 4R is really killing it these days.. that's the release I look for most... Hopefully Jim Rutledge has the pipeline stocked for the future...


Originally Posted by exerda (Post 25359075)
I do think there's very little effect of the port finishing evident on Angel's Envy. Now, their rye does definitely show off the effects of rum finishing (as I posted above, something I like--though I've subsequently also found I like good rye in general and my negative experiences had been with subpar ryes; even a cheap Rittenhouse BiB rye is very good IMHO).

The scary rumor is always that bourbon producers are considering 35 proof to attract "more ladies" away from the flavored vodka realms (shudder--like we need any more demand for bourbon?!--the real reason perhaps being cutting the limited supplies even further). I suspect very few are the real bourbons which will see a drop below 40; increasingly, "real" bourbons seem to be 90 or higher, bottled at "cask strength" in many cases even if just using marketing buzzwords.

I find the rye finish to be a bit too sweet for my taste; I'm really loving rye for my cocktails.. just replenished my Sazerac stock recently... technically if it's 35 proof it isn't bourbon (gotta be above 80 to qualify as bourbon; maybe even to qualify as whiskey)... it would be flavored liquer.. bleh...sonds gross... I tend to gravitate to higher proofed expressions; the William Larue Weller and George T Stagg are also some of my favorites and they typically are min of 125 proof...


Originally Posted by exerda (Post 25345172)
Drinking an Abraham Bowman "rare" tonight, the July release of a nearly-9-year "high rye" bourbon (estimated around 45%). I know Sazerac/Buffalo Trace supplies the distillate, and Bowman merely bottles it in VA, but I do like several of their products and like having a "local" bourbon with some age. (There are some true local bourbon distilleries in VA, but none have much age to them yet.)

This one is not bad, but at $70 a bottle, a bit richer than my everyday budget. I've had several of their other limited editions which also were solid bourbons, though probably better-priced at $50 than $70. I am somewhat annoyed that these days, any bourbon with more than, say, 4 years of age seems to run at least $50. I understand why (and yes, there are still $30-ish bargains with 8-12 years of age to them), but I don't have to like it!

I haven't actually tried any of their stuff before... I know that they are doing some interesting finishes (Gingerbread???) but since I tend to shy away from them I've shyed away from Bowman.. I like the stuff coming out of Smooth Ambler.(WV).. they are now distilling their own stuff and yes it's young but shows great promise..


Originally Posted by stimpy (Post 25356802)
OK, now I've had a bit of time to try the Angels Envy. It definitely doesn't taste like Jim Beam, I can tell you that. :) Seriously though, their marketing claims it was an experiment by their master distiller to do the Port barrel finish and I salute the experiment. And I think they got it right. It's not at all a pronounced difference in taste, but subtle and interesting. And by distilling to 86.6 proof rather than 80, it's a serious bourbon and not a slick trick club drink.

Thanks for the report.. I have a bottle of the barrel proof Angels Envy which is a just a bit off for my palette.. can't quite put a finger on it but it's seems to be a bit sweeter than I like...


Originally Posted by thelark (Post 25337586)
check fairgrounds for rock hill. I haven't seen Weller 12 anywhere.

Thanks for the tip-- I'm in there all the time and must just miss it....


I had a Manhattan tonite: Sazerac rye, Carpano Antica vermouth, barrel aged biters, and Luxardo cherries.. yum!

FDW

BamaVol Sep 4, 2015 4:49 am


Originally Posted by stimpy (Post 25356802)
OK, now I've had a bit of time to try the Angels Envy. It definitely doesn't taste like Jim Beam, I can tell you that. :) Seriously though, their marketing claims it was an experiment by their master distiller to do the Port barrel finish and I salute the experiment. And I think they got it right. It's not at all a pronounced difference in taste, but subtle and interesting. And by distilling to 86.6 proof rather than 80, it's a serious bourbon and not a slick trick club drink.

Angels Envy is going mainstream in a hurry. It got a full page in Wednesday's Winn Dixie (or was it Publix) newspaper insert. And on sale for $39.99.

stimpy Sep 4, 2015 5:08 am


Originally Posted by BamaVol (Post 25375951)
Angels Envy is going mainstream in a hurry. It got a full page in Wednesday's Winn Dixie (or was it Publix) newspaper insert. And on sale for $39.99.

For whatever it's worth, on my bottle it says Batch #2412, Bottle #480, and the numbers appear to be hand written. If it is indeed hand written and they go mainstream, someone's gonna have a sore wrist.

whackyjacky Sep 4, 2015 6:10 am

I couldn't give it away in my bar 3 years ago. I think I drank it all myself, being a team player and all. Back then all the big named aged Bourbons like Pappy, Stagg, and Parker Beam were still around though. I liked it.

exerda Sep 4, 2015 8:58 am


Originally Posted by FlyingDoctorwu (Post 25374835)
technically if it's 35 proof it isn't bourbon (gotta be above 80 to qualify as bourbon; maybe even to qualify as whiskey)... it would be flavored liquer.. bleh...sonds gross... I tend to gravitate to higher proofed expressions; the William Larue Weller and George T Stagg are also some of my favorites and they typically are min of 125 proof...

Yes, they'd probably label it something like "bourbon-flavored whiskey" or even worse. :eek:

I, too, prefer the higher proofs these days, preferably over 100.



Originally Posted by FlyingDoctorwu (Post 25374835)
I haven't actually tried any of their stuff before... I know that they are doing some interesting finishes (Gingerbread???) but since I tend to shy away from them I've shyed away from Bowman.. I like the stuff coming out of Smooth Ambler.(WV).. they are now distilling their own stuff and yes it's young but shows great promise..

I'm planning to stop by Smooth Ambler's distillery in a couple of weeks as it's along the way to where my parents live. I haven't tried anything they've distilled in-house yet but have liked their outsourced finds under the "Old Scout" labeling.

LondonElite Sep 7, 2015 12:38 pm

Found myself with a bottle of Elijah Craig this weekend (empty now ;)). I'm really impressed with the price/quality ratio, I just think it's very hard to beat for an everyday bourbon when you need the taste of a warm summer day.

broadwayblue Sep 8, 2015 9:48 pm


Originally Posted by FlyingDoctorwu (Post 25374835)
Wow congrats? Just recently? That's great... i haven't opened my bottle of the 2014 Single Barrel LE; but I did really like the 2014 Small Batch LE... $100 is still a great price; considering that the retail price was $80. Also, 2014 was the last year that they made a single barrel... I'm already gearing up for this year's small batch LE- it's got a great recipe with a little more age to it... In my mind 4R is really killing it these days.. that's the release I look for most... Hopefully Jim Rutledge has the pipeline stocked for the future...

FDW

Yeah, bought them only a couple weeks ago. It was a great surprise to find them nearly a year later, considering that they are so highly allocated and in such demand. In hindsight I probably should have bought every last bottle...but I figured I would leave some for a few (hopefully) others.

FlyingDoctorwu Sep 9, 2015 8:10 pm


Originally Posted by BamaVol (Post 25375951)
Angels Envy is going mainstream in a hurry. It got a full page in Wednesday's Winn Dixie (or was it Publix) newspaper insert. And on sale for $39.99.


Originally Posted by stimpy (Post 25375992)
For whatever it's worth, on my bottle it says Batch #2412, Bottle #480, and the numbers appear to be hand written. If it is indeed hand written and they go mainstream, someone's gonna have a sore wrist.

They were bought out by Bacardi a couple months back... maybe they will increase production... all they do is barrel finish so it would be easy for them to call up MGP, order some more whiskey and barrel finish it...


Originally Posted by whackyjacky (Post 25376129)
I couldn't give it away in my bar 3 years ago. I think I drank it all myself, being a team player and all. Back then all the big named aged Bourbons like Pappy, Stagg, and Parker Beam were still around though. I liked it.

Sigh... I passed up Eagle Rare 17, Pappy and the like on the shelf many times... still kicking myself for it...



Originally Posted by exerda (Post 25376796)
Yes, they'd probably label it something like "bourbon-flavored whiskey" or even worse. :eek:

that sounds gross


I, too, prefer the higher proofs these days, preferably over 100.
try to find Elijah Craig barrel proof; beautiful color... for the aviation geeks here if it's over 140 proof it's considered hazmat and you aren't supposed to fly with it


I'm planning to stop by Smooth Ambler's distillery in a couple of weeks as it's along the way to where my parents live. I haven't tried anything they've distilled in-house yet but have liked their outsourced finds under the "Old Scout" labeling.
Nice.. I'ld love to go there.. the guy John Little runs a nice ship... one of my buddies is a general aviation guy and flies there a couple times a year and visits...


Originally Posted by LondonElite (Post 25389074)
Found myself with a bottle of Elijah Craig this weekend (empty now ;)). I'm really impressed with the price/quality ratio, I just think it's very hard to beat for an everyday bourbon when you need the taste of a warm summer day.

The stuff is so good, especially for the money.. They used to make an 18 yr version that was like $40... so tasty.. my current value leader is Old Weller Antique.. $22.99; same mash bill as the Van Winkle...


Originally Posted by broadwayblue (Post 25397034)
Yeah, bought them only a couple weeks ago. It was a great surprise to find them nearly a year later, considering that they are so highly allocated and in such demand. In hindsight I probably should have bought every last bottle...but I figured I would leave some for a few (hopefully) others.

Let me know where you left it.. I'll go running...

but seriously it's great stuff and that's great find.. the new small batch should hit any day now... nice of you to leave some for the next guy... my local only got 2 bottles of the limited small batch last year...

FDW

thelark Sep 18, 2015 9:23 am

went to fairgrounds today to browse the selection and grab something for the shelf. asked about the waiting list for the fall releases and Paul was a douche about it - stated that MD's allocation was cut by ~70% and their allocation would be little to none...fair enough. I mentioned that I'd been lucky for the past few years to grab a few bottles there and asked if he would take my name just in case.

"Have you been on our list in the past?"
"Yes, so are you just carrying it over?"
"I guess, maybe" and he walked away.

I've had good experiences with them in the past with bourbons and wine special orders so I've continued to go out of my way to purchase there. My wife noted a similarly poor experience a few months back and I chalked it up to her being overly sensitive. Now I don't think I'll be back.

BamaVol Sep 18, 2015 12:56 pm


Originally Posted by thelark (Post 25444417)
went to fairgrounds today to browse the selection and grab something for the shelf. asked about the waiting list for the fall releases and Paul was a douche about it - stated that MD's allocation was cut by ~70% and their allocation would be little to none...fair enough. I mentioned that I'd been lucky for the past few years to grab a few bottles there and asked if he would take my name just in case.

"Have you been on our list in the past?"
"Yes, so are you just carrying it over?"
"I guess, maybe" and he walked away.

I've had good experiences with them in the past with bourbons and wine special orders so I've continued to go out of my way to purchase there. My wife noted a similarly poor experience a few months back and I chalked it up to her being overly sensitive. Now I don't think I'll be back.

Any recent increase in competition? We had a great little local shop but the grocery chains got into liquor in a big way - no selection, just better prices. The guy couldn't make a go of it selling top shelf to a small customer list. You need the hordes buying 1.75L Jack to make a profit. So he got crabby the last 3-4 months before he decided to go out of business. I hope that's not the case here.

thelark Sep 18, 2015 1:54 pm

doubt that's the case - it's a decently-sized, high volume store. No new competition that I know of. I'd be really surprised if it were the case.

edcaya Sep 28, 2015 2:48 pm

Our regular supply train of Kentucky expats just dropped off three bottles of Ancient Ancient Age 10-year for the bunker.

The good doctor also managed to acquire a couple of bottles of Jos. A Magnus's inaugural distillation. It has a wonderful aroma, but it requires a bit of water or ice to bring out its best.

DaveBlaine Sep 28, 2015 2:51 pm


Originally Posted by edcaya (Post 25490343)
Our regular supply train of Kentucky expats just dropped off three bottles of Ancient Ancient Age 10-year for the bunker.

I'm guessing that's of a higher proof than the regular Ancient Age. Not sure if I've seen it. I see the regular Ancient Age for sale and it looks very moderately priced.

exerda Sep 28, 2015 4:10 pm


Originally Posted by DaveBlaine (Post 25490361)
I'm guessing that's of a higher proof than the regular Ancient Age. Not sure if I've seen it. I see the regular Ancient Age for sale and it looks very moderately priced.

The 10 year Ancient Ancient Age is decent drinking, particularly considering the value. Unfortunately, I don't think Buffalo Trace puts it out any longer.

There is also a 10 Star Ancient Ancient Age (no age statement, but supposedly around 6 years old, and 90 proof), which is... well, at least it's not swill. It's drinkable, and super-cheap. I think around here it goes for $19 for 1.75L. I keep some on hand for the much-less-discerning bourbon drinkers who stop by our home. I could see it being OK as a mixer for a cocktail where the bourbon isn't the predominant element.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 4:09 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.