Does anyone in US offer EMV (Chip & PIN)? [Practical discussion]
#1
Original Poster

Join Date: Oct 2008
Programs: NWA Tears
Posts: 986
Does anyone in US offer EMV (Chip & PIN)? [Practical discussion]
Maybe I'm just picking the really wrong places to buy stuff but I've had problems at 4 places with my US cards in the past 24 hrs. One of them about had a bird when he couldn't figure out how to do a swipe and I said I would go down the street to an ATM and get cash. He wouldn't let me leave and called the cops. Fortunately the cop was level headed and told the guy he'd escort shifty old me down to the ATM and back.
I'd love to find someone that will give me a cash-back w/ chip & PIN that works in Europe.
I'd love to find someone that will give me a cash-back w/ chip & PIN that works in Europe.
#2




Join Date: Aug 2004
Programs: Delta SkyMiles, Hertz #1, HHonors
Posts: 105
Oh, I'm afraid the problem is only going to get worse. Almost every major financially mature country, except the USA has chip and pin plans for their credit card infrastructures. Yet as far as I can tell, it is impossible to get anything with a Visa/MC/Amex logo in the USA that has a chip and pin - even sites like Travelex.com will sell you a reloadable VISA travel card denominated in Euros, intended specifically for USA travellers, but it will not have a chip and pin.
Some contributors here will argue that:
My response is that:
It is indeed ironic that the places where mag only cards have been rejected are those that:
Credit card companies are quick to point out that to outfit the USA with chip and pin readers is a very costly task. I would agree. But the cost to add the chip and pin support software at the card issuer back-end, and the cost of the chip on a card itself is, in my mind, minimal. This way USA cards could use chip and pin if taken abroad, while still using conventional mag swipe here.
Anyway, this is my $.02.
-Alex
Some contributors here will argue that:
- They've never had problems, despite having traveled extensively through Europe or that they've never encountered a retail situation in which their mag only card was not accepted.
- That the various merchant agreements absolutely mandate that mag only cards still be accepted.
- That after some patient explanation and a "learning session" they've imparted to an ignorant cashier, their card was accepted.
My response is that:
- I've encountered situations in which a magnetic card facility did not exist, but chip and pin cards, bearing a credit card logo were accepted. Specifically at the pay at the pump at gas stations in Scandinavia, and Switzerland.
- Apparently the card companies need to do some further education, focusing particularly on small independent merchants and restaurants.
- As a card holder, I should NEVER have to do this.
It is indeed ironic that the places where mag only cards have been rejected are those that:
- Focus on situations of travel convenience (pay at the pump, self-service train kiosks, mobile phone vendors, etc.)
- Are not mainstream tourist merchants (smaller merchants/shops/restaurants that are off the beaten tourist path)
Credit card companies are quick to point out that to outfit the USA with chip and pin readers is a very costly task. I would agree. But the cost to add the chip and pin support software at the card issuer back-end, and the cost of the chip on a card itself is, in my mind, minimal. This way USA cards could use chip and pin if taken abroad, while still using conventional mag swipe here.
Anyway, this is my $.02.
-Alex
Maybe I'm just picking the really wrong places to buy stuff but I've had problems at 4 places with my US cards in the past 24 hrs. One of them about had a bird when he couldn't figure out how to do a swipe and I said I would go down the street to an ATM and get cash. He wouldn't let me leave and called the cops. Fortunately the cop was level headed and told the guy he'd escort shifty old me down to the ATM and back.
I'd love to find someone that will give me a cash-back w/ chip & PIN that works in Europe.
I'd love to find someone that will give me a cash-back w/ chip & PIN that works in Europe.
#3
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: ROC;SIN
Programs: ROP
Posts: 426
I wonder if the US is just moving to RFID cards and leapfrogging over smartchip cards entirely. It's possible and RFID is probably cheaper.
#4
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Ontario, CA
Programs: UA 1P; Marriott Gold
Posts: 21
JCB Credit Card
On this topic...could someone tell me what technology JCB uses in their cards, i.e. is it a chip and pin system. Mainly I'm wanting to have the convenience of chip and pin in Paris and Rome this summer, and was wondering if the JCB card would provide that convenience.
#5
Original Poster

Join Date: Oct 2008
Programs: NWA Tears
Posts: 986
I don't think anyone has yet to come up with a security scheme for RFID that is generally believed to work. With a Chip & PIN you control your cards information. It can't be read unless you place it in the reader. If you're sitting in a cafe your RFID card can be read by someone in a nearby car or walking by with an RFID reader in their bag. It's encrypted, but...
#6




Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: EWR Ionosphere Club, LAX Clipper Club, Still Traveling Global, yearly BIS miles
Programs: EAL Silver Wings, I-Club, Flying Colonels DL, WorldPass PLat from the olde Meatball and PE SMARTbank
Posts: 2,132
So just to be clear are there any banks or cc issuers that offer chip cards?
AMEX
visa
mc
usaa
nfcu
BofA
etc...
this is a real issue in rural france on a sunday night petro station
Just to stay on topic?
AMEX
visa
mc
usaa
nfcu
BofA
etc...
this is a real issue in rural france on a sunday night petro station

Just to stay on topic?
#8
FlyerTalk Evangelist


Join Date: Aug 2001
Programs: DL GM, AA Gold, Hilton Diamond, Bonvoy Plat
Posts: 12,171
No issuers yet. I see the arguments for why the US doesn't want/need to convert their sizable network over. What I don't understand is why they don't start by upgrading the cards first for those that need to use them overseas. Then start offering dual terminals here to merchants and let the upgrade happen organically over time.
Interesting blog post here: http://www.andreae.com/Blog/Payments/ctst-chip-and-pin/
Interesting blog post here: http://www.andreae.com/Blog/Payments/ctst-chip-and-pin/
#9




Join Date: Aug 2004
Programs: Delta SkyMiles, Hertz #1, HHonors
Posts: 105
For customers and card issuers based in the United States...No, not a single one.
There was a discussion on another FT thread (can't find it at the moment) that Amex, or one of the other issuers may start issuing pin and chip cards, for certain select customers in the USA, subject to a $50 one-time fee.
There was a discussion on another FT thread (can't find it at the moment) that Amex, or one of the other issuers may start issuing pin and chip cards, for certain select customers in the USA, subject to a $50 one-time fee.
#10
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 1,762
No issuers yet. I see the arguments for why the US doesn't want/need to convert their sizable network over. What I don't understand is why they don't start by upgrading the cards first for those that need to use them overseas. Then start offering dual terminals here to merchants and let the upgrade happen organically over time.
Interesting blog post here: http://www.andreae.com/Blog/Payments/ctst-chip-and-pin/
Interesting blog post here: http://www.andreae.com/Blog/Payments/ctst-chip-and-pin/
Chip and pin, of course, is a small solution to a problem on the local retail level but the vast majority of fraud comes via the internet and phone orders where chip and pin does not one bit of good. Also some of the vermin running these credit card theft rings have already compromised chip and pin cards.
What I would like to see, however, is a requirement that restaurants in the US be forced to use those portable terminals they bring to your table in the UK and France. I hate it when giving my credit card in a restaurant that they disappear into some back room with the card (where it can easily be cloned or copied and the number passed along to the Nigerian and Eastern European vermin running the credit card theft rings). With these portable terminals, I see the card at all times......and the sales slips do not have the complete card numbers as a further comforting security feature.
#11




Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Austin
Programs: AA P4L, WN, BA, DL, UA, HHonors, IHG
Posts: 3,505
ATMs Needed Chipped Cards?
In preparation for a vacation to Paris and Brussels, my wife has read various warnings online about needing a chipped credit card in those nations.
According to apl175, no such credit card is available in the US, so it looks as if we may be getting a lot of Euros from ATMs.
Do ATMs in France and Belgium require chipped cards (e.g., Visa branded check cards)?
According to apl175, no such credit card is available in the US, so it looks as if we may be getting a lot of Euros from ATMs.
Do ATMs in France and Belgium require chipped cards (e.g., Visa branded check cards)?
#12
Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 591
In preparation for a vacation to Paris and Brussels, my wife has read various warnings online about needing a chipped credit card in those nations.
According to apl175, no such credit card is available in the US, so it looks as if we may be getting a lot of Euros from ATMs.
Do ATMs in France and Belgium require chipped cards (e.g., Visa branded check cards)?
According to apl175, no such credit card is available in the US, so it looks as if we may be getting a lot of Euros from ATMs.
Do ATMs in France and Belgium require chipped cards (e.g., Visa branded check cards)?
#13
FlyerTalk Evangelist


Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Florida
Posts: 30,343
In preparation for a vacation to Paris and Brussels, my wife has read various warnings online about needing a chipped credit card in those nations.
According to apl175, no such credit card is available in the US, so it looks as if we may be getting a lot of Euros from ATMs.
Do ATMs in France and Belgium require chipped cards (e.g., Visa branded check cards)?
According to apl175, no such credit card is available in the US, so it looks as if we may be getting a lot of Euros from ATMs.
Do ATMs in France and Belgium require chipped cards (e.g., Visa branded check cards)?
Most businesses in large cities are equiped with card readers that still read the meg tape cards. However, some smallish restaurants may not have that and thus would require you to pay cash.
The real problems are, the unmanned gas stations and toll booths would only accept the Smart Chip Cards. If you are caught with low gas on a Weekend in Switzerland or France, you are completely out of luck when all the manned gas stations closed. Or if you took a wrong exit on a toll road, and then realized the toll booth for you to return back to the freeway is not manned and only accept Smart Chip Card... Or you are at a train station, the only way to get train tickets is thru the machines which of course only take Smart Chip Cards...
US travellers to Europe need to be aware of such scenario and not to be caught off-guard.
#14



Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: YYZ
Programs: Hilton Gold Mariott LT Gold Aeroplan 25K NEXUS
Posts: 1,321
It's likely cards will support both standards in the future for increased functionality. RFID could be argued to be a touch less secure than the chip and pin (fancy encryption notwithstanding).
#15




Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 610
The real problems are, the unmanned gas stations and toll booths would only accept the Smart Chip Cards. If you are caught with low gas on a Weekend in Switzerland or France, you are completely out of luck when all the manned gas stations closed. Or if you took a wrong exit on a toll road, and then realized the toll booth for you to return back to the freeway is not manned and only accept Smart Chip Card... Or you are at a train station, the only way to get train tickets is thru the machines which of course only take Smart Chip Cards...
US travellers to Europe need to be aware of such scenario and not to be caught off-guard.
US travellers to Europe need to be aware of such scenario and not to be caught off-guard.

