Most Underrated Credit Card?
#16
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: Miami, FL
Programs: UA 1MM, AA Plat, Marriott LT Titanium, Hyatt Glob, IHG ♢ Amb, Hilton ♢, Hertz Pres
Posts: 6,028
I rarely hear about this card, but it's one of my favorites for its earning potential for most people:
The Sallie Mae card from Barclays pays 5% cash back at gas stations (up to $250 per month), 5% cash back at grocery stores (up to $250 per month), and 5% cash back at book stores including Amazon (up to $750 per month).
The Sallie Mae card from Barclays pays 5% cash back at gas stations (up to $250 per month), 5% cash back at grocery stores (up to $250 per month), and 5% cash back at book stores including Amazon (up to $750 per month).
EDIT: I just read the details on the Sallie Mae card. They cap the spend at $250 per month (I thought it was the cashback that was capped at this amount). I spend well more than this in groceries... making this card worthwhile for about a weeks worth of groceries. Might be too annoying than its worth to have to keep track.
I also found this card https://www.usbank.com/credit-cards/...rect=cashapply Offers 5% off restaurants (or other category you choose) and 2% off groceries. Might be worthwhile just for eating out.
Last edited by TravelinSperry; Feb 27, 2014 at 12:54 am Reason: added new card and edit
#17
Join Date: Jun 2013
Posts: 510
The Upromise card is the most underrated, IMHO. You earn 5 percent on all purchases made through their shopping portal, and there are many travel vendors in the portal offering 5 percent additional payback, so a total of 10 percent off of online travel bookings. Also pays 3 percent on gas purchases from Exxon/Mobil. This is a cash back card. It is not just for college students or their parents. Anyone can register with Upromise.
#18
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: PHL
Programs: US; AA; UA; Hilton Gold; Club Carlson Gold; IHG Platinum;
Posts: 389
#19
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: SAN
Programs: AA Platinum, Bonvoy Gold, DL Gold
Posts: 1,209
I think the card is underrated for some but not universally a great card. Frankly with the Internet there aren't any big secrets out there. The Chase Freedom is still better for most people. The Travel Rewards card is possibly a better candidate simply because no AF and no FTF plus 1.5% is competitive (yes the cash back can only be redeemed by applying against travel charges).
#22
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 424
I am going to say the Barclays Travelocity Amex is somewhat underrated.
Essentially each mile/point you earn is worth $0.02, or 2%, on travel through Travelocity (sure, it's not ANY travel site like Arrival, but it works for most people with plane tickets, hotels, etc). 20,000 = $400 redemption. Note that you have to do it in 20k increments to get the full 2% reward value.
The current no annual fee signup is for 1 point on everything and 3 points on Travelocity. And you get to redeem after the fact and have 90 days, like the Arrival, so you earn your 3x points on bookings BEFORE you redeem the cost.
So it works out like this:
Everything (1x) = 2%
Travelocity (3x) = 6%
The sign-up bonus for this no fee card is 5000 bonus points, a $100 value.
The $39 annual fee card gets you:
Everything (1x) = 2%
Gas, grocery or restaurant (2x) = 4%
Travelocity (5x) = 10%
The sign-up bonus for this $39 card is 12,500 bonus points, a $250 value.
BUT, right now on their RewardsBoost website, you can buy Amex Gift Cards for 2 points per dollar spent bonus, so if you buy a ton of those and use them on everything:
Everything = 4%
Who knows how long that will last though. But I read that before Valentines Day you could get them for an even better value, which is awesome, so maybe at some point the point value for them could go up again.
The biggest downside is that the rewards are strictly Travelocity only. But if you're like me and are just a casual flyer, it's great for plane ticket or hotel redemption.
Not the best card in the world... but not bad either! I use mine all of time because I don't qualify for some of the higher-end cards out there currently.
Essentially each mile/point you earn is worth $0.02, or 2%, on travel through Travelocity (sure, it's not ANY travel site like Arrival, but it works for most people with plane tickets, hotels, etc). 20,000 = $400 redemption. Note that you have to do it in 20k increments to get the full 2% reward value.
The current no annual fee signup is for 1 point on everything and 3 points on Travelocity. And you get to redeem after the fact and have 90 days, like the Arrival, so you earn your 3x points on bookings BEFORE you redeem the cost.
So it works out like this:
Everything (1x) = 2%
Travelocity (3x) = 6%
The sign-up bonus for this no fee card is 5000 bonus points, a $100 value.
The $39 annual fee card gets you:
Everything (1x) = 2%
Gas, grocery or restaurant (2x) = 4%
Travelocity (5x) = 10%
The sign-up bonus for this $39 card is 12,500 bonus points, a $250 value.
BUT, right now on their RewardsBoost website, you can buy Amex Gift Cards for 2 points per dollar spent bonus, so if you buy a ton of those and use them on everything:
Everything = 4%
Who knows how long that will last though. But I read that before Valentines Day you could get them for an even better value, which is awesome, so maybe at some point the point value for them could go up again.
The biggest downside is that the rewards are strictly Travelocity only. But if you're like me and are just a casual flyer, it's great for plane ticket or hotel redemption.
Not the best card in the world... but not bad either! I use mine all of time because I don't qualify for some of the higher-end cards out there currently.
Last edited by ethanwa; Feb 27, 2014 at 6:38 pm
#25
Join Date: Jan 2013
Posts: 322
I would say the US Bank Flexperks rewards card is somewhat underrated aside from the Olympics promos they put up. Each Flexperks point is worth up to 2 cents of air travel and you get 2x points on grocery spend. Therefore, you're effectively getting up to a 4% return. Granted, it may be hard to get a great deal out of Flexperks points due to their tiered redemption chart.
#26
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: LAS, MPL
Programs: DL Platinum, 1 MM
Posts: 1,327
I would say the US Bank Flexperks rewards card is somewhat underrated aside from the Olympics promos they put up. Each Flexperks point is worth up to 2 cents of air travel and you get 2x points on grocery spend. Therefore, you're effectively getting up to a 4% return. Granted, it may be hard to get a great deal out of Flexperks points due to their tiered redemption chart.
#27
Join Date: Mar 2014
Posts: 74
I second Sallie Mae. 5% on gas, 5% on Groceries (if you spend a ton, you can just combine it with another card like BCP) and 5% up to $750 on bookstores including Amazon.
Also USbank Cash+. Essentially 6.25% on your first $2000 spent at restaurants (or one of many other categories).
Also USbank Cash+. Essentially 6.25% on your first $2000 spent at restaurants (or one of many other categories).
#29
Moderator: Chase Ultimate Rewards
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: SFO
Programs: UA 2P, MR LT Plat, IHG Plat, BW Dia, HH Au, Avis PC
Posts: 5,474
Charities
Car Rental
Furniture Stores
Electronics Stores
Cell Phones
Sporting Goods Stores
Gyms (new this quarter)
No annual fee and the first $100 redeemed gets a bonus $25. So figure it's more like 6.25% back on your first $2000 in spend in your two categories.
Depending on your spending patterns, it might be a useful little side card to have. It's available in-branch or as a downgrade from a Flexperks card.