Go Back  FlyerTalk Forums > Miles&Points > Credit, Debit and Prepaid Card Programs > Credit Card Programs
Reload this Page >

USA EMV cards: Availability, Q&A (Chip & PIN -or- Chip & Signature) [2012-2015]

Community
Wiki Posts
Search
Old Sep 20, 2013, 11:40 am
FlyerTalk Forums Expert How-Tos and Guides
Last edit by: philemer
Posts from 1/1/16 onward can be found here: http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/credit-card-programs/1739359-2016-onward-usa-emv-cards-availability-q-chip-pin-signature.html

EMV wikipost volunteers: kebosabi

What is EMV?
EMV is a defacto global standard of technology where there is a visible microchip on the front of the card. It looks like this:

Who issues them?
See Google Docs spreadsheet in Post #1

SFOAMS also has created a list of excellent webpage that shows US EMV cards in a more interactive interface

Another site, which lets you narrow the search for an EMV card by various parameters, is http://www.spotterswiki.com/emv/index.php.

Several credit unions issue some form of Chip-and-PIN credit cards or prepaid cards. Prepaid EMV cards however are not recommended due to junk fees. USAA (currently restricted to members of military) used to offer Chip-and-PIN cards, but as late has backtracked to Chip-and-Signature priority.

Hey that's a cool Google Docs list! I know others that aren't on that list. How can I help by adding them to the list?
My bad for not putting this into the wiki sooner. Right now, the Google Docs is locked out of editing and only in "read-only" view because there were instances in the past where people would just delete the rows not thinking that it affects others viewing the list.

If you promise not to delete any rows and input all the pertinent info (annual fee, rewards, FTF, etc.), I can provide you with edit access. Just shoot me a PM to kebosabi with your gmail address and I'll provide you edit access.

Thanks for helping out!


As of October 2014, no USA-based card issuer offers Chip-and-PIN priority cards except for BMO Harris (Diners Club) and UN Federal Credit Union. Other major USA-based banks such as BofA, Chase, Citi, as well as others issue Chip-and-Signature cards which may work at many automated kiosks. However, bear in mind the word may is used above is a context where there is no absolute certainty of success for certain environments such as automated kiosks due to different natures of offline and online transactions. It is highly recommended to read Post #3 which lists real life FTer examples on how Chip-and-Signature worked and did not work at various transaction environments.

Can I upgrade it right now?
If it's listed on that Google Docs spreadsheet or SFOAMS' Silk page, wouldn't hurt to call/twitter them for a free upgrade. If you get the response you don't like, hang up, try again.

What is the difference between Chip-and-Signature and Chip-and-PIN?
You insert the chipped card into the slot. The physical contact terminal will read the EMV chip and the terminal will automatically read the preferred cardholder verification methods (called CVM) for that card.

Chip-and-Signature means that the terminal will printout a receipt for you to sign. This is the most prevalent authentication for most US issued EMV cards. Chip-and-Signature helps in a way that it will get through to face-to-face merchant transactions where you and the merchant do not speak the same language.

Chip-and-PIN means that the terminal will prompt you to input a PIN for authentication. Some credit union issued credit cards will have this CVM as secondary if Chip-and-Signature cannot be done. Chip-and-PIN is the more prevalent method of authentication used outside the US, especially in transaction environments where no human interaction is needed (i.e. automated gas pumps, toll roads, train kiosks, etc.).

The Google Docs spreadsheet will list which CVM are used in the EMV cards listed. Some cards can only do Chip-and-Signature. Other cards can do both Chip-and-Signature and Chip-and-PIN. And others might have a third option called No CVM (no authentication needed) which is reserved for low value transactions.

One chip can hold a lot more data, therefore it is capable of doing multiple verification methods. That's one of the great things about EMV over the mag-stripe which can hold very little data.

I want to know for sure what my EMV chip does. Is there anyway I can test out my own EMV card to see what the CVM list is?
alexmt has written up a nice step-by-step procedure on Post #3615.

If most of the EMV cards in the US is the Chip-and-Signature type, doesn't that mean it's still useless abroad?
Depends if you see it as glass half empty or glass half full. See Post #3 for further details on how Chip-and-Signature has worked both successfully and unsuccessfully depending on the merchant transaction environment and use your best judgment whether which one is right for you.

Are there any places in the US that are accepting transactions via the EMV chip?
tmiw has created a dedicated Google maps webpage to show where EMV has been proven to work here: http://emvacceptedhere.com/ Per his Post #4240, feel free to add any places with active EMV terminals if you come across one.

As of 2014/05, the EMV terminals in most Walmarts and Sam's Clubs are being turned on. Hence, the best place to try them out would be your local Walmart or Sam's Club. For other merchants, it's slowly being phased in.

I hope people will post them in the Post your receipt of your 1st EMV based transaction in the US thread. cvarming has shown us an EMV transaction receipt from Brooklyn, NY in Post #2380. I myself had my first EMV based (Chip-and-Signature) transaction in two stores in the Los Angeles area, as shown in detail in Post #2705 (courtesy of WhatWhatTech for pointing these two stores out)

I don't want a chip in my card. I heard horror stories all over the media saying hackers can steal my credit card info from a mile away.
There are two types of chips. One is contactless and the other is contact. Cards can be either one or the other, or both.

In the Google Docs spreadsheet, the cards that are capable of contactless payments are listed seperately under the "RFID or NFC contactless chip" column. If it says yes, then that means it has the ability to do contactless payments. If it says no, it doesn't have that feature.

The one that the media has overhyped about hackers "stealing your information wirelessly" was the contactless type like this:

You are worried about this happening, right?

You don't have to worry. EMV is a chip standard that can have both contact and contactless interfaces. With the traditional contact interface, this means you actually have to physically insert the chip into a POS terminal for it to be authorized, like this:

With the contact interface, nothing is wireless. No data is sent out in a stand-alone contact type EMV chip. With the EMV contactless interface, data is sent wirelessly.

Furthermore, contactless chip cards are required to show a symbol (looks like Wi-Fi symbol) somewhere on the card that to denote it's capability as a contactless card. For example, here's an example of a Discover Card with contactless capability (in which Discover calls "Discover ZIP") showing the contactless symbol on the back of the card:

Don't believe everything that the media says. Besides, millions of people all over the world from London to Singapore, uses contactless payments daily in extremely crowded subways and mass transit with nary any problems. There are multiple layers of encrypted securities and keys that are needed to break the code.

Frankly, giving your physical card to a waiter/waitress who takes the card out of your view is much more susceptible to fraud than contactless payments.

Why should I care?
If you are an international traveler, you will want this because majority of the world has or in the process of converting to this payment format.


In fact, in 2012, even North Korea moved to the EMV format, leaving the US as one of the countries in the world that hasn't done so.

In addition, VISA, MC, AMEX, and Discover have all agreed to incentivize the USA shifting to EMV payments by 2015 by shifting liability for fraudulent transactions to merchants if they do not have EMV equipment and the cardholder has an EMV card. So if you travel internationally or would like to get one before the others, you might be interested in getting one.


BS! I had no problems using my card in [insert whereever country], [insert whatever point in time]
If you stick to the tourist path where they have lots of visitors from the US, you should have no problems using your mag-stripe only card in hotels and restaurants, at least for now. But as things can change as things go forward.

However, consider that once you start taking the off-beaten path, go to non-touristy places where they are not familiar with mag-stripes, rent a car and use toll roads, fill up gas, or try to buy train tickets you might end up into a trouble of the machine not recognizing your card because it lacks the chip. Furthermore, a lot of toll roads, gas pumps, and automated ticket machines lack any human assistance to help you when you need it the most.

But [insert credit card company] told me all merchants that display their logo must accept them! All I have to do is report them for violating their agreements, right?
There are several factors against this.

1. You can only speak English. The merchant representative, most likely a part-time clerk earning minimum wage, speaks in a different language, let's say French. If you have no French language skills, how are you going to get your point across? Are you going to whip out your cell phone at exorbitant int'l roaming charges and hope the customer service is going to translate it for you on the spot? Or maybe you might actually know French. But how about Swahili, Farsi, Balinese, or the multiple languages in mainland China?

2. Just like US, the rest of the world's businesses uses part-time minimum wage workers as cashiers to cut down on labor costs. Most of their SOP training manuals are written by MBA types to not to do anything they are not familiar with. Do not expect them to understand the intricate details of credit card mumbo jumbo. You don't expect Taco Bell employees to understand the minute details of Discover-JCB-Union Pay agreements, right? Same thing the other way around: be respectful as a guest in their country, prepare in advance in their ways, avoid being an "ugly American" stereotype.

3. You are a guest in their country. You are a minority. If 99.9% of their country's people and other tourists from around the world uses EMV, do you really think they are going to accomodate the 0.1% of American tourists who only have mag-stripes credit cards?

4. Again, you are a guest in their country. How would you, as an American standing in line, react if a Chinese tourist was clogging up the lines at a local Taco Bell because the clerk doesn't understand the Discover-Union Pay agreement and has trouble communicating between Mandarin spoken by the tourist and English spoken by the Taco Bell clerk? Same way the other way around. You do not want to clog up the lines for everyone. The less hassle, the better.

5. VISA and MC make tons of money from merchants in that country. Say SNCF French Rail. It's a billion dollar company in France. Do you think VISA is going to pull the plug of their relationship with SNCF because SNCF refuses to do mag-stripe processing at their unmanned train station kiosk? Of course not. Be realistic.

6. And lastly, if you're up against an unstaffed toll kiosk, gas pump or train ticket machine, are you going to yell curses at the machine?

But I want my credit card to be able to be used in the US too!
No worries. They have not gotten rid of the mag-stripe on the back of the card for backward compatibility reasons, just like we still have embossed numbers on our cards for backwards compatibility to using those old carbon copy imprinters.

[insert own Hyatt card image front and back together with red arrows pointing to all the backward compatibility features]

You use the chip on the front of the card abroad (for now), and the mag-stripe just like any other card for the US. Basically, you're increasing your credit card's acceptance rate by getting a card that both via the chip and the mag-stripe. You're getting a better deal for free.

And when 2015 comes along and US switches to EMV, you'll be way ahead of everyone else too!


So why did the rest of the world and the US moved/moving toward EMV?
Primarily, due to fraud concerns. You see, the mag-stripe has been with us since the 1950s. It may have been the most high tech thing back in the day, but with the technology that is available today, any shmo can pick up a $100 USB magnetic card skimming device off of eBay and get your credit card info.

And unlike skimming off contactless cards which actually need the person to have l33t programming skills, skimming off a magnetic stripe has become so ubiquitous that nary a day goes about skimming fraud going on somewhere in America, from gas pumps, Michael's stores (2011), Target breaches (2013), restaurant waiters/waitresses, to even McDonald's drive thrus.

https://www.google.com/search?q=skimming+fraud

These type of fraud used to be prevalent in Europe. But once they started switching over to EMV starting over 2 decades ago, this type of fraud went elsewhere. It went over to Asia, Canada and Mexico, Latin America, etc. etc. until they too began implementing EMV to combat skimming fraud. The US is practically the only country left that hasn't done so, therefore all the fraud that used to take place elsewhere is now happening here.


But EMV is old and it's not fool proof. Shouldn't we just skip over it and do something new instead?
Yes, EMV is old. It was developed in the 1990s and its smart card payment predecessor was first introduced in France. But as of today, it has become the defacto global standard of payments.

But then, what else is there? There is no other de facto global standard of payments alternative. For example, if we decide to skip over it and do something new, hypothetically like DNA matching technology, it still means US int'l travelers will continue to have problems abroad with useless plastic acceptance because no other country is using this DNA matching technology except the US.

Besides, nothing is fool proof. You can say that the bank vault isn't fool proof because you can crack it open if enough C4 is used. But your average low-life scumbag isn't likely to get military grade C4 easily either. But the bank vault does make it harder to get the bank's money over say a petty cash box. That's the point here. EMV is akin to a security tight bank vault, the old mag-stripe is akin to a petty cash box lying around inside the drawer.


I'm a business owner and I don't think EMV is going to take off. I'm not going to spend extra hundreds of dollars to upgrade my credit card machine. Convince me other wise why I should.
I can understand the added extra cost to your business once this switchover takes place. But before even saying that, look at your existing POS terminal. Does it have a slot somewhere to insert a card?

Most likely, if you had replaced your POS terminal within the past five years, you already have an EMV capable terminal. EMV is basically just not turned on yet from the processor and acquirer side.

If you have an EMV capable terminal, then a best bet would be to contact your acquirer to have the EMV feature turned on. You did your end of the deal already by having an EMV capable terminal, it is now the acquirers' responsibility to turn it on in accordance to the EMV switchover mandate.

And if you don't, you are going to replace your POS terminal anyway from common wear and tear. It isn't a hard switch-over. You can continue to use your POS terminal until it dies out because EMV cardholders will still have the mag-stripe on the back. And by the time your non-EMV capable POS terminal is up for replacement the market will be full with these newer POS terminals that can accept the mag-stripe, EMV, as well as contactless payments.

In addition, you may also want to check with your acquirer or processor about EMV capable terminals. Some of them are willing to replace your terminal for free in preparation for the US EMV switchover. Call and ask for details.


But what's in it for me? I'm the one that has to pay for the upgrade.
All the major card networks have given incentives for merchants for the upcoming EMV switchover.

If 75% or more of your credit card transactions are done on an EMV contact and contactless terminal, they are going to waive your annual PCI-DSS fees, which usually costs you around $5.00-$19.95/month per terminal. The overall long term cost savings of those compliance fees will be larger than the cost of an one time upgrade for the terminal.

The downside is that once EMV switchover happens and if you do not have a POS terminal that is able to accept EMV, the fraud liability shifts over to the merchant.

I own several fast food franchises. If I upgrade my POS terminals at all of my restaurants, it's going to cost me thousands, if not millions. I don't think anyone is going to use a fake credit card to buy $5 burgers. And if they do, wouldn't it be cheaper for me to eat the fraud cost?
Remember also that fraud isn't just committed by dishonest customers using fraudulent cards. Fraud can also happen with dishonest employees skimming off credit card data from the mag-stripe as in the case of a teenage McDonald's drive thru employee skimming off $13,000 of customers' credit cards in Olympia, WA. Consider the public relations fall out that your business may have if this happens (i.e. the big Target breach of 2013, where someone used a mag stripe card to load malware INTO Target's system). Is it worth risking to take such a huge PR disaster?
Print Wikipost

USA EMV cards: Availability, Q&A (Chip & PIN -or- Chip & Signature) [2012-2015]

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old Aug 3, 2014, 1:15 am
  #5986  
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: LAX/SFO/OAK
Posts: 218
Originally Posted by tmiw
I tried the Schwab card in a BoA ATM today. It kept the card for the whole transaction, unlike the non-EMV BoA debit card that I used afterward. Also asked what application I wanted to use: http://m.imgur.com/qbeuhSd. Used US DEBIT to get my balance without a problem.
That should not have happened. All ATMs in the US have to select the "US Debit" application when it is present on the card (pdf here). The "US Debit" application provides the ATM the opportunity to select the cheapest network that is supported by both the ATM and the issuer to process the transaction. My guess is that Bank of America is still testing their own systems for their own EMV debit rollout and that's why it's given as an option for now. Eventually, you won't be able to select the application on the card.
WhatWhatTech is offline  
Old Aug 3, 2014, 1:30 am
  #5987  
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: LAX/SFO/OAK
Posts: 218
Originally Posted by tmiw
Does the receipt say what network it used for the transaction by any chance? (Also, I wonder if one could use the Arrival+ in a BoA ATM to activate a user-defined PIN. Don't try to do a cash advance, just a balance inquiry.)
I don't think ATMs ever tell customers which network the ATM chooses to use, even on magnetic stripe cards.
WhatWhatTech is offline  
Old Aug 3, 2014, 1:50 am
  #5988  
FlyerTalk Evangelist
 
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: HaMerkaz/Exit 145
Programs: UA, LY, BA, AA
Posts: 13,167
Originally Posted by emvchip
It sounds like you found a niche business for yourself! Install ATMs across USA and charge no fees at all those places where there are only ATMs that need surcharges to justify their existance.

Don't forget to pay for your armored car deliveries, the network costs, the telecom fees, the maintenance, and the lease or purchase on the equipment itself! Think of how much money you will make! And don't bother with just buying old ATMs, go for the gold with full EMV equipment too!
Actually, I'm a different business entirely, but thanks!

Regardless, if I prefer that airlines not nickel and dime me for everything, it doesn't mean I plan on getting into the airline business. Just that I disagree with their current business practices. Same here.

Many places manage with fee-free ATMs.

Originally Posted by kebosabi
This will depend if joshwex90 has another business that makes tons of money that can pay for his fee-free ATM venture as a loss leader.

In many ways, that's how businesses these days are increasingly being run. Run something as a loss leader (search engine) while making tons of money in a different business (Google Ad-Sense).
One of the most successful supermarket chains in Israel started off this way.

Originally Posted by kebosabi
And if people are stupid to keep their passwords as their date of birth, and there are many stupid people out there, likely got hints for their passwords too.
Israel bars you from choosing your own PIN for credit cards. For other sensitive info like telebanking, you can't choose the 1st 4 digits or last 4 digits of your national ID number, connected to your birthday, or the last 4 digits of your phone number.

Originally Posted by tmiw
Out of the fifteen largest banks in the US, the only ones that don't seem to issue EMV credit cards at this time are:

  • US Bank
  • BB&T
  • PNC
  • Capital One
  • Ally
  • TD

Ally doesn't seem to issue cards at all and State Street and BNY Mellon don't seem to provide services to the general public. Even if our cards are gimped compared to the rest of the world's, it's still an improvement compared to over a year ago.

EDIT: forgot about TD
Don't know that Ally even offers credit cards - just debit cards as far as I'm aware. And TD, I've asked and they kept telling me that it's in the pipeline. Now, they're telling me that they're waiting "legal clearance," as they basically have EMV debit ready.

Originally Posted by tmiw
I tried the Schwab card in a BoA ATM today. It kept the card for the whole transaction, unlike the non-EMV BoA debit card that I used afterward. Also asked what application I wanted to use: http://m.imgur.com/qbeuhSd. Used US DEBIT to get my balance without a problem.
What's the difference between Visa debit and US debit? Just which network it clears on?

Originally Posted by bullfrog
Interesting blog post I found:

https://blog.flameeyes.eu/tag/cardpeek/


It includes a bunch of cardpeek-read CVM lists for Italian credit and debit cards and Irish credit and debit cards. Looks like Italian cards use a scheme similar to many US cards; signature first, fallback to PIN.
Been pointed out earlier that not all are at PIN priority in Europe. Though to a large extent, Italy is still magnetic stripe sometimes. So it might be some time until they fully migrate to EMV and then PIN
joshwex90 is offline  
Old Aug 3, 2014, 1:52 am
  #5989  
 
Join Date: Nov 2012
Posts: 3,537
Originally Posted by WhatWhatTech
That should not have happened. All ATMs in the US have to select the "US Debit" application when it is present on the card (pdf here). The "US Debit" application provides the ATM the opportunity to select the cheapest network that is supported by both the ATM and the issuer to process the transaction. My guess is that Bank of America is still testing their own systems for their own EMV debit rollout and that's why it's given as an option for now. Eventually, you won't be able to select the application on the card.
No, I don't think there's anything prohibiting them from allowing application selection. Rather, there's a prohibition from MANDATING they choose the first priority (Visa) or from MANDATING they allow the cardholder to choose.
AllieKat is offline  
Old Aug 3, 2014, 1:56 am
  #5990  
FlyerTalk Evangelist
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: San Diego, CA
Programs: GE, Marriott Platinum
Posts: 15,508
Originally Posted by bullfrog
Interesting blog post I found:

https://blog.flameeyes.eu/tag/cardpeek/


It includes a bunch of cardpeek-read CVM lists for Italian credit and debit cards and Irish credit and debit cards. Looks like Italian cards use a scheme similar to many US cards; signature first, fallback to PIN.
Interesting that Italian debit cards use offline PIN when in Italy. I would think all debit cards would run as online PIN at ATMs, at least.

Originally Posted by joshwex90
What's the difference between Visa debit and US debit? Just which network it clears on?
The latter enables the network choice provisions that are required in the US, while "Visa Debit" is solely for overseas use and uses the Visa network.
tmiw is online now  
Old Aug 3, 2014, 1:58 am
  #5991  
FlyerTalk Evangelist
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: San Diego, CA
Programs: GE, Marriott Platinum
Posts: 15,508
Chase ATMs are listed under MasterCard's website as being chip enabled. I wonder if it'll just choose US Debit if I were to try it there.

(BTW, we're at page 400 now. )

Last edited by tmiw; Aug 3, 2014 at 2:05 am
tmiw is online now  
Old Aug 3, 2014, 2:06 am
  #5992  
FlyerTalk Evangelist
 
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: HaMerkaz/Exit 145
Programs: UA, LY, BA, AA
Posts: 13,167
Originally Posted by tmiw
(BTW, we're at page 400 now. )
150 for me
joshwex90 is offline  
Old Aug 3, 2014, 2:15 am
  #5993  
 
Join Date: Nov 2012
Posts: 3,537
Originally Posted by tmiw
Interesting that Italian debit cards use offline PIN when in Italy. I would think all debit cards would run as online PIN at ATMs, at least.



The latter enables the network choice provisions that are required in the US, while "Visa Debit" is solely for overseas use and uses the Visa network.
Why do you say Visa Debit is solely for overseas use? It is not flagged as such on the card (that can be flagged with Application Usage Control - it is not). US Debit *is* flagged as only for domestic usage, but Visa Debit is flagged to allow both domestic and international use.

The Visa Debit application is an allowed choice, it's just mandated that merchants have to have a choice, and they do NOT have to give the cardholder that choice. But there's nothing, as far as I know, preventing use of the Visa Debit application or preventing the cardholder from being given a choice.

It's the same as today in magstripe land. Some merchants ALWAYS run debit as Visa, some merchants ask "credit or debit" (a confusing question since both are actually debit - they SHOULD ask "Visa or some random debit network that gives us a better price), and some merchants (Walmart) ALWAYS run whatever isn't Visa.
AllieKat is offline  
Old Aug 3, 2014, 2:16 am
  #5994  
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: LAX/SFO/OAK
Posts: 218
Originally Posted by alexmt
No, I don't think there's anything prohibiting them from allowing application selection. Rather, there's a prohibition from MANDATING they choose the first priority (Visa) or from MANDATING they allow the cardholder to choose.
Technically you are correct, but BOA could loose a lot of money this way. Which is why I believe that they will follow the recommendations of the Debit Technical Working Group at the EMV Migration Forum to automatically choose the "US Debit" for the customer. I believe that they will do this by the time they roll out EMV capable debit cards for BOA's account holders.
WhatWhatTech is offline  
Old Aug 3, 2014, 2:24 am
  #5995  
 
Join Date: Nov 2012
Posts: 3,537
Originally Posted by WhatWhatTech
That should not have happened. All ATMs in the US have to select the "US Debit" application when it is present on the card (pdf here). The "US Debit" application provides the ATM the opportunity to select the cheapest network that is supported by both the ATM and the issuer to process the transaction. My guess is that Bank of America is still testing their own systems for their own EMV debit rollout and that's why it's given as an option for now. Eventually, you won't be able to select the application on the card.
WhatWhatTech,

Furthering my statement that you're wrong, you should read the links you post. I decided to read it. Read item 6.1. "To facilitate routing a debit transaction to multiple networks supported by the card/issuer, the U.S.
common debit AID should be selected by the device."

Note the word SHOULD. Then read further down:

"Based on the solution implementation, the device should store a list of all U.S. common AIDs it seeks to accept and once the U.S. common debit AID is identified, the device may select the U.S. common debit AID even though it will not be the highest priority in the card. It is important to note that the selection
of the U.S. common debit AID is not mandatory; however, by not selecting the U.S. common debit AID, the merchant may limit their choice of debit routing."

It is NOT mandatory to select the common debit AID and the Visa Debit AID is NOT for international use only, it is clearly flagged as allowed for domestic use, heck the banks would probably prefer it be used.

If Bank of America wishes to let their cardholders choose, that is their business and there is no mandate otherwise.

EDIT - I just read what you wrote. Your original post was that they HAVE to select the common AID, and that's what I was pointing out is wrong. It's absolutely in their best interest to do so, but they don't have to.
AllieKat is offline  
Old Aug 3, 2014, 2:33 am
  #5996  
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: LAX/SFO/OAK
Posts: 218
Originally Posted by alexmt
Why do you say Visa Debit is solely for overseas use? It is not flagged as such on the card (that can be flagged with Application Usage Control - it is not). US Debit *is* flagged as only for domestic usage, but Visa Debit is flagged to allow both domestic and international use.

The Visa Debit application is an allowed choice, it's just mandated that merchants have to have a choice, and they do NOT have to give the cardholder that choice. But there's nothing, as far as I know, preventing use of the Visa Debit application or preventing the cardholder from being given a choice.

It's the same as today in magstripe land. Some merchants ALWAYS run debit as Visa, some merchants ask "credit or debit" (a confusing question since both are actually debit - they SHOULD ask "Visa or some random debit network that gives us a better price), and some merchants (Walmart) ALWAYS run whatever isn't Visa.
But the problem is that if a US merchant doesn't support the "US Debit" application, then it can't run a debit transaction at all. The "Visa Debit" application doesn't give the merchant the choice to even run the card on Visa's own debit network, while the "US Debit" application allows for signature (through NO CVM), PIN, and no CVM across all the networks supported by the issuer and merchant including the Visa credit network and the Visa debit network (Interlink).

Look at my post from yesterday about my experience at the liquor store. Whereas with a normal swipe debit card I would have been given the choice (as the customer) between "debit or credit", I wasn't given the choice for my Schwab card. Both I and the merchant were forced to do a credit transaction on a debit card.
WhatWhatTech is offline  
Old Aug 3, 2014, 2:35 am
  #5997  
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: LAX/SFO/OAK
Posts: 218
Originally Posted by alexmt
WhatWhatTech,

Furthering my statement that you're wrong, you should read the links you post. I decided to read it. Read item 6.1. "To facilitate routing a debit transaction to multiple networks supported by the card/issuer, the U.S.
common debit AID should be selected by the device."

Note the word SHOULD. Then read further down:

"Based on the solution implementation, the device should store a list of all U.S. common AIDs it seeks to accept and once the U.S. common debit AID is identified, the device may select the U.S. common debit AID even though it will not be the highest priority in the card. It is important to note that the selection
of the U.S. common debit AID is not mandatory; however, by not selecting the U.S. common debit AID, the merchant may limit their choice of debit routing."

It is NOT mandatory to select the common debit AID and the Visa Debit AID is NOT for international use only, it is clearly flagged as allowed for domestic use, heck the banks would probably prefer it be used.

If Bank of America wishes to let their cardholders choose, that is their business and there is no mandate otherwise.

EDIT - I just read what you wrote. Your original post was that they HAVE to select the common AID, and that's what I was pointing out is wrong. It's absolutely in their best interest to do so, but they don't have to.
Sorry about that, I should have been clearer. What's interesting too is that in Section 3.3.1 it states that NO CVM could be used for signature transactions as well! So the "US Debit" application supports Visa signature transactions through the Visa network as well (see the flow charts on pages 11 and 13).

Last edited by WhatWhatTech; Aug 3, 2014 at 2:44 am
WhatWhatTech is offline  
Old Aug 3, 2014, 3:15 am
  #5998  
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: United Kingdom
Posts: 93
Originally Posted by Happy
I dont see emv cards could have prevented the above breaches at the merchants level.
As mentioned before, if you can't create a cloned card, there's no benefit to stealing the data.

Originally Posted by Happy
In our case, despite a new number was issued, a 2nd unauthorized charge from the SAME merchant showed up.
The credit card brands (Visa and MasterCard in particular) have a system in place to notify merchants when your card details change on the same account

Originally Posted by Happy
That was when I called Chase, they told me they could not stop it unless the merchant stopped it.
I'm not 100% sure, but I think that is either a bank policy or a policy of the card brands in the US. Here in Europe, you're legally entitled to get the card issuer to cancel recurring payments.

Originally Posted by joshwex90
Been pointed out earlier that not all are at PIN priority in Europe. Though to a large extent, Italy is still magnetic stripe sometimes. So it might be some time until they fully migrate to EMV and then PIN
EMV rollout was mandated by the EU a long time ago, so all EU countries should be using EMV now - although both PIN and signature are allowed.
Daveoc64 is offline  
Old Aug 3, 2014, 4:03 am
  #5999  
FlyerTalk Evangelist
 
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: HaMerkaz/Exit 145
Programs: UA, LY, BA, AA
Posts: 13,167
Originally Posted by Daveoc64
EMV rollout was mandated by the EU a long time ago, so all EU countries should be using EMV now - although both PIN and signature are allowed.
That may be. There are still magnetic stripe only cards being issued in Italy
joshwex90 is offline  
Old Aug 3, 2014, 8:16 am
  #6000  
 
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: San Jose, CA
Posts: 103
Originally Posted by bullfrog
Interesting blog post I found:

https://blog.flameeyes.eu/tag/cardpeek/


It includes a bunch of cardpeek-read CVM lists for Italian credit and debit cards and Irish credit and debit cards. Looks like Italian cards use a scheme similar to many US cards; signature first, fallback to PIN.
One thing that is a significant difference from the US-issued C&S with PIN cards is that the Italian ones support both online AND offline PIN verification on the same card, while the US ones will do one OR the other. Has anyone cardpeek'd an UNFCU card yet? Would be interesting to know if it does both.
dmapr is offline  


Contact Us - Manage Preferences - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service -

This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.