Any cards that are still churnable?
#16




Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: LAX
Posts: 670
#17
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: DCA
Programs: AMC MovieWatcher, Giant BonusCard, Petco PALS Card, Silver Diner Blue Plate Club
Posts: 22,314
No, Chase does not let you churn (under most usual circumstances). They used to, it was really sad when that went away.
They currently seem to be limiting most people to opening 1 card every 6 months. You can still get the bonus miles for each type of card, e.g. United Visa Signature, Visa Signature Gold Class, Visa Signature Platinum Class, Visa Business... but they'll only give most people 1 card per 6 months.
Bank of America may say one bonus for eternity, but in my experience this hasn't been enforced.
They currently seem to be limiting most people to opening 1 card every 6 months. You can still get the bonus miles for each type of card, e.g. United Visa Signature, Visa Signature Gold Class, Visa Signature Platinum Class, Visa Business... but they'll only give most people 1 card per 6 months.
Bank of America may say one bonus for eternity, but in my experience this hasn't been enforced.
#18
Original Poster
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 96
This raises an excellent question: what is the minimum value for which one should consider incurring a hard pull?
Obviously, the answer won't be the same for everyone, e.g., someone getting ready to take out a mortgage/refinance ought to be much more conservative in most cases. And some hard pulls aren't reported across all 3 major CRAs. (For example, Barclay's seems not to report to Experian, in my experience.)
A few months ago, every hard pull carried a heavy opportunity cost: one fewer Citi AAdvantage cards. But with the apparent death of Citi AA churning, and Chase's new 1-card-every-6-months rule, the opportunity cost seems much lower.
So what's a sensible minimum threshhold benefit for pulling the app trigger? $150 (ballpark value of the current Amex MR 15K pts bonus, at 1c/pt)? $100 (CitiForward signup worth 11K TYP)?
Obviously, the answer won't be the same for everyone, e.g., someone getting ready to take out a mortgage/refinance ought to be much more conservative in most cases. And some hard pulls aren't reported across all 3 major CRAs. (For example, Barclay's seems not to report to Experian, in my experience.)
A few months ago, every hard pull carried a heavy opportunity cost: one fewer Citi AAdvantage cards. But with the apparent death of Citi AA churning, and Chase's new 1-card-every-6-months rule, the opportunity cost seems much lower.
So what's a sensible minimum threshhold benefit for pulling the app trigger? $150 (ballpark value of the current Amex MR 15K pts bonus, at 1c/pt)? $100 (CitiForward signup worth 11K TYP)?
Good point.
I thought about the citiforward cards, but at last I decided that doesn't worth the hard pulls.
The problem is that I don't know anything about the churnability of other bank's cards, like application period, max cards allowed, etc...
#19
Original Poster
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 96
No, Chase does not let you churn (under most usual circumstances). They used to, it was really sad when that went away.
They currently seem to be limiting most people to opening 1 card every 6 months. You can still get the bonus miles for each type of card, e.g. United Visa Signature, Visa Signature Gold Class, Visa Signature Platinum Class, Visa Business... but they'll only give most people 1 card per 6 months.
Bank of America may say one bonus for eternity, but in my experience this hasn't been enforced.
They currently seem to be limiting most people to opening 1 card every 6 months. You can still get the bonus miles for each type of card, e.g. United Visa Signature, Visa Signature Gold Class, Visa Signature Platinum Class, Visa Business... but they'll only give most people 1 card per 6 months.
Bank of America may say one bonus for eternity, but in my experience this hasn't been enforced.
#20
Suspended
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: On strike
Programs: FT badges are idiotic
Posts: 7,950
Mrs B and I use this in the same way we use the Associated Bank (co-branded Citi) card that gives 5% cash back on gas/grocery/drugstore purchases: as a category-specific purchase method. It isn't going to make us rich, but a 5% discount is better value than we'd get on our primary card (Starwood Amex), and splitting the spending didn't get in the way of hitting the $30K plateau to make SPG Gold.
#21
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: home = LAX
Posts: 26,113
Airline partners? Very few, but they're slowly building, mostly smaller airlines in adjacent countries, WestJet for Canada, Volaris or something like that for Mexico.
It's irrelevant to this discussion anyway, because the "loopholes" for earning lots of Southwest awards fast through hotel partners (and most specifically, partners of those hotel partners, like Amtrak), and for doing three-way transfers, are long closed up. And Southwest itself uses Chase.
I only brought it up to point out that one such hotel partner, Choice, would have been churned left and right if BofA had allowed "heavy" churning of the Choice card. But we know (because someone tried) that they didn't. (The deals for transerring to Southwest at great rate only lasted a half year at most, so "slow" churning was of no use to people pursuing those deals, only "heavy" churning would have been.)
It's irrelevant to this discussion anyway, because the "loopholes" for earning lots of Southwest awards fast through hotel partners (and most specifically, partners of those hotel partners, like Amtrak), and for doing three-way transfers, are long closed up. And Southwest itself uses Chase.
I only brought it up to point out that one such hotel partner, Choice, would have been churned left and right if BofA had allowed "heavy" churning of the Choice card. But we know (because someone tried) that they didn't. (The deals for transerring to Southwest at great rate only lasted a half year at most, so "slow" churning was of no use to people pursuing those deals, only "heavy" churning would have been.)
#22
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 271
American
Given that churning appears to be over on the Citi AA cards, I was intrigued to read that the Bank of A Alaska cards can be converted to AA miles.
Can someone tell me:
1) Which card to take? How many Alaska Miles will the bonus be?
2) What is the conversion rate between Alaska and AA?
3) Is there an annual fee for this card?
Thanks so much.
Can someone tell me:
1) Which card to take? How many Alaska Miles will the bonus be?
2) What is the conversion rate between Alaska and AA?
3) Is there an annual fee for this card?
Thanks so much.
#24


Join Date: Dec 2009
Posts: 1,825
I've probably reached my card-approval limit on Amex and Chase. What other banks should I consider? I know about:
* Bank of America (have held a Royal Caribbean and a Choice Rewards card from them, but don't own any at the moment; not sure what if any airline-specific FF cards they offer)
* Barclays (I have a single US Airways card from them; thinking of trying for a US Airways Business card. Any others out there?)
Which am I missing? And should I be consulting a list of banks and which credit reporting agencies they use?
There's Discover, I recall. But they don't seem to have any airline-specific cards. Not sure if Discover's mile cards are any good for converting to other programs without a really lousy conversion rate.
Here's what FF cards Barclays offers to U.S. customers:
http://www.aboutbarclaycardus.com/pr...e_products.php
Didn't notice any great offers--with the exception of U.S. Airways (already know about them).
Bank of America offers Virgin Atlantic and Alaska Airlines among others. The Alaska Airlines card was the only reasonably good looking offer I saw.
* Bank of America (have held a Royal Caribbean and a Choice Rewards card from them, but don't own any at the moment; not sure what if any airline-specific FF cards they offer)
* Barclays (I have a single US Airways card from them; thinking of trying for a US Airways Business card. Any others out there?)
Which am I missing? And should I be consulting a list of banks and which credit reporting agencies they use?
There's Discover, I recall. But they don't seem to have any airline-specific cards. Not sure if Discover's mile cards are any good for converting to other programs without a really lousy conversion rate.
Here's what FF cards Barclays offers to U.S. customers:
http://www.aboutbarclaycardus.com/pr...e_products.php
Didn't notice any great offers--with the exception of U.S. Airways (already know about them).
Bank of America offers Virgin Atlantic and Alaska Airlines among others. The Alaska Airlines card was the only reasonably good looking offer I saw.
Last edited by philemer; Dec 20, 2009 at 1:55 pm
#25
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: home = LAX
Posts: 26,113
Given that churning appears to be over on the Citi AA cards, I was intrigued to read that the Bank of A Alaska cards can be converted to AA miles.
Can someone tell me:
1) Which card to take? How many Alaska Miles will the bonus be?
2) What is the conversion rate between Alaska and AA?
3) Is there an annual fee for this card?
Thanks so much.
Can someone tell me:
1) Which card to take? How many Alaska Miles will the bonus be?
2) What is the conversion rate between Alaska and AA?
3) Is there an annual fee for this card?
Thanks so much.
Alaska miles can be used for awards on AA flights, but they cannot be converted to AA miles.
It's simply that Alaska is an AA partner, and you can earn Alaska miles and then use them for partner awards, which includes AA.
SImilarly, you could earn Cathay miles, or Iberia miles, or Mexicana miles, and redeem them for AA awards.
But there are very few airlines that let you transfer miles out, and even when they do you lose half the value or more doing so. It typically involves transferring from the airline to a hotel program and then back to another airline, or even more roundabout.
If you're still interested, go to www.alaskaair.com to learn about the program (and the credit card).
#26
Suspended
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: On strike
Programs: FT badges are idiotic
Posts: 7,950
For details, see spg.com or http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/starw...er-thread.html
Of course, as with other Amex cards, the SPG Amex is not churnable.
#27
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Chicagoland, IL, USA
Programs: WN CP, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 14,423
It's irrelevant to this discussion anyway, because the "loopholes" for earning lots of Southwest awards fast through hotel partners (and most specifically, partners of those hotel partners, like Amtrak), and for doing three-way transfers, are long closed up. And Southwest itself uses Chase.
I took my son to Disneyworld last summer and we Choice-hopped for 13 days, mostly along the dreaded Irlo Bronson. A pain, but depending how you look at it, we got almost free hotel stays, or the equivalent in WN credits. We only used the place to crash and shower.
Free airfare, annual passes to the World, almost free hotels, and Star Wars Weekends. Priceless.
This may only be useful to top off for a Companion Pass, where those last few credits are of immense value each. For just getting WN RR awards, there are probably better ways. Of course (as you well know, sdsearch), Choice has a history of hosing its point holders with little or no warning, so there is some risk.
And as far as I know, if you spend $200 in a calendar year on Amtrak, you can still use the old 1000 CO> 1000 Amtrak> 3000 Choice > .75 RR credit, with a limit of 25000/50000 out from Amtrak a year. That could be a timely dump into RR.
But the glory days are over.
Last edited by toomanybooks; Dec 23, 2009 at 7:08 am
#28
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 84
This is technically true, but I've had the Starwood Personal card 4 times and the Business card 3 times and every time I got the 10k bonus. I just got the personal card bonus again last month. The secret is not giving Amex you SPG #. If they have to create a new SPG account for you, they must assume you haven't had the bonus before.
I had the same success with the old Platinum Hilton card using the same technique. I was also able to get the bonus the first time I applied for the new version, but I haven't tried to get that one again.
I had the same success with the old Platinum Hilton card using the same technique. I was also able to get the bonus the first time I applied for the new version, but I haven't tried to get that one again.
#29
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: PBI/FLL
Programs: AAdvantage 300k Lifetime Miles, WN Rapid Rewards
Posts: 111

