Check-In agents determining baggage allowance - Computer or human memory?
#1
Original Poster




Join Date: May 2000
Location: IAD/DCA/BWI
Programs: SQ, LH, AMEX, Citi, Cap1
Posts: 4,113
Check-In agents determining baggage allowance - Computer or human memory?
When one checks in baggage at the airport, does the computer give the check-in agent the baggage allowance, or does he/she rely on memorized rules?
My parents will be flying in CX J JFK-BKK and CX J BKK-JNB. I know that the standard rule is that the allowance is 2 bags, 70 lbs. each for all flights, as the journey starts in the USA.
However, they'll be originating in Brazil, flying on JJ J GRU-JFK the day before, on the same ticket, causing the allowance to be determined at each departing city.
So with that, the BKK-JNB portion is actually only 30kgs!
Will my parents have any chance of getting away with checking 2 bags at 70 lbs. each with no excess baggage fees in BKK, claiming that they originated in the USA?
Should I get my parents prepared to hand over their excess baggage to my relatives at BKK before they leave for JNB and have my relatives ship them back?
My parents will be flying in CX J JFK-BKK and CX J BKK-JNB. I know that the standard rule is that the allowance is 2 bags, 70 lbs. each for all flights, as the journey starts in the USA.
However, they'll be originating in Brazil, flying on JJ J GRU-JFK the day before, on the same ticket, causing the allowance to be determined at each departing city.
So with that, the BKK-JNB portion is actually only 30kgs!
Will my parents have any chance of getting away with checking 2 bags at 70 lbs. each with no excess baggage fees in BKK, claiming that they originated in the USA?
Should I get my parents prepared to hand over their excess baggage to my relatives at BKK before they leave for JNB and have my relatives ship them back?
#2
Suspended
Join Date: May 2006
Location: HKG
Programs: A3, TK *G; JL JGC; SPG,Hilton Gold
Posts: 9,952
you should be able to get lucky. they usually do not know rules are dependant on where your ticket pass through. when they see you go to USA, you'll get 2 bags.
actually, no. originating from brazil you get 2 bags
quote: http://www.klm.com/travel/br_en/prep...s/exbag_BR.htm since it's from a brazilian agency i dont think there's much debate there. you might have to hint them you're going to the Americas when you check in at BKK so should be piecewise, but that should suffice.
actually, no. originating from brazil you get 2 bags
quote: http://www.klm.com/travel/br_en/prep...s/exbag_BR.htm since it's from a brazilian agency i dont think there's much debate there. you might have to hint them you're going to the Americas when you check in at BKK so should be piecewise, but that should suffice.
Last edited by kaka; Jul 26, 2014 at 8:14 pm
#3
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: Dec 2004
Programs: CX Green, QF Platinum, BAEC Silver, Hyatt Glob
Posts: 10,797
Actually the allowance should be stated on the ticket. So that is what the agent uses.
You should see 2PC next to each sector of the ticket which indicates piece system.
You should see 2PC next to each sector of the ticket which indicates piece system.
#4
Suspended
Join Date: May 2006
Location: HKG
Programs: A3, TK *G; JL JGC; SPG,Hilton Gold
Posts: 9,952
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; CPU iPhone OS 6_1 like Mac OS X) AppleWebKit/536.26 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/6.0 Mobile/10B142 Safari/8536.25)
Passing thru anericas should get the whole ticket in piecewise- but cx eticket sometimes only show baggage allowance leg by leg
Originally Posted by sxc
Actually the allowance should be stated on the ticket. So that is what the agent uses.
You should see 2PC next to each sector of the ticket which indicates piece system.
You should see 2PC next to each sector of the ticket which indicates piece system.
#5
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: May 2000
Location: Little dot in Asia
Programs: AA-PP, HL-DM, MR-LTP, HY-LTG
Posts: 26,017
When one checks in baggage at the airport, does the computer give the check-in agent the baggage allowance, or does he/she rely on memorized rules?
My parents will be flying in CX J JFK-BKK and CX J BKK-JNB. I know that the standard rule is that the allowance is 2 bags, 70 lbs. each for all flights, as the journey starts in the USA.
However, they'll be originating in Brazil, flying on JJ J GRU-JFK the day before, on the same ticket, causing the allowance to be determined at each departing city.
So with that, the BKK-JNB portion is actually only 30kgs!
Will my parents have any chance of getting away with checking 2 bags at 70 lbs. each with no excess baggage fees in BKK, claiming that they originated in the USA?
Should I get my parents prepared to hand over their excess baggage to my relatives at BKK before they leave for JNB and have my relatives ship them back?
My parents will be flying in CX J JFK-BKK and CX J BKK-JNB. I know that the standard rule is that the allowance is 2 bags, 70 lbs. each for all flights, as the journey starts in the USA.
However, they'll be originating in Brazil, flying on JJ J GRU-JFK the day before, on the same ticket, causing the allowance to be determined at each departing city.
So with that, the BKK-JNB portion is actually only 30kgs!
Will my parents have any chance of getting away with checking 2 bags at 70 lbs. each with no excess baggage fees in BKK, claiming that they originated in the USA?
Should I get my parents prepared to hand over their excess baggage to my relatives at BKK before they leave for JNB and have my relatives ship them back?
Go to this page : http://www.cathaypacific.com/cx/en_U...allowance.html
Print out and highlight : Piece System – for Central, North and South Americas (See Note 3) and carry it with them so that they can show the check in agent when problems arise.
#6



Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: TPE / HSZ
Programs: CX GO (=SPH), IHG Diamond Amb, Hertz 5*, Accor, Hilton, National
Posts: 7,243
They are allowed 2 pieces at 32kg EACH.
Go to this page : http://www.cathaypacific.com/cx/en_U...allowance.html
Print out and highlight : Piece System for Central, North and South Americas (See Note 3) and carry it with them so that they can show the check in agent when problems arise.
Go to this page : http://www.cathaypacific.com/cx/en_U...allowance.html
Print out and highlight : Piece System for Central, North and South Americas (See Note 3) and carry it with them so that they can show the check in agent when problems arise.
Code:
WQGRU/AJJ/CJJFK/ACX/CD/XHKG/ACX/CDBKK/ACX/CJ/XHKG/ACX/CJJNB-MUSD
WQ1
PSGR TYPE ADT - 01
CXR RES DATE FARE BASIS NVB NVA BG
SAO
NYC JJ J 27JUL D 27JUL 02P
XHKG CX D OPEN D 27JUL 02P
BKK CX D OPEN D 27JUL 02P
XHKG CX J OPEN JOW 27JUL 30K
JNB CX J OPEN JOW 27JUL 30K
FARE USD 12423.00
TAX USD 36.15BR USD 5.50YC USD 313.80XT
TOTAL USD 12778.45
ADT-01 D JOW
SAO JJ NYC CX X/HKG CX BKK Q5.80M6960.00CX X/HKG CX JNB Q5.80
15M5451.73NUC12423.33END ROE1.00
XT USD7.00XY USD5.00XA USD5.60AY USD22.50TS USD269.20YR
XT USD4.50XFJFK4.5
ATTN*FLIGHT RESTRICTIONS APPLY SEG 1-3
ATTN*VALIDATING CARRIER - CX
#7
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: May 2000
Location: Little dot in Asia
Programs: AA-PP, HL-DM, MR-LTP, HY-LTG
Posts: 26,017
I'd say check the TKT to be sure. US DOT rule only applies if US is the origin or furthest destination. Brazil's special rule also seems to only applies to journeys to / from Brazil. Without knowing OP's parents entire itinerary, all I can get from the GDS is below. This indicates BKK-HKG-JNB is 30k.
Code:
WQGRU/AJJ/CJJFK/ACX/CD/XHKG/ACX/CDBKK/ACX/CJ/XHKG/ACX/CJJNB-MUSD
WQ1
PSGR TYPE ADT - 01
CXR RES DATE FARE BASIS NVB NVA BG
SAO
NYC JJ J 27JUL D 27JUL 02P
XHKG CX D OPEN D 27JUL 02P
BKK CX D OPEN D 27JUL 02P
XHKG CX J OPEN JOW 27JUL 30K
JNB CX J OPEN JOW 27JUL 30K
FARE USD 12423.00
TAX USD 36.15BR USD 5.50YC USD 313.80XT
TOTAL USD 12778.45
ADT-01 D JOW
SAO JJ NYC CX X/HKG CX BKK Q5.80M6960.00CX X/HKG CX JNB Q5.80
15M5451.73NUC12423.33END ROE1.00
XT USD7.00XY USD5.00XA USD5.60AY USD22.50TS USD269.20YR
XT USD4.50XFJFK4.5
ATTN*FLIGHT RESTRICTIONS APPLY SEG 1-3
ATTN*VALIDATING CARRIER - CX
I have clients who travel RTW from Brazil all the time and they tell me that all airlines know the rule and therefore irrespective of what the ticket says, they are accorded the baggage allowance of 2x32kg. I have also asked this question once upon a time ago with AA RTW desk and they tell me the same allowance is given for the entire journey.
As per CX's link above -
Applicable if you are travelling to, from or via the USA, Canada, select Central and South American countries.
Last edited by Guy Betsy; Jul 27, 2014 at 2:40 pm
#8
Original Poster




Join Date: May 2000
Location: IAD/DCA/BWI
Programs: SQ, LH, AMEX, Citi, Cap1
Posts: 4,113
Thanks, everyone. My parents' itinerary, which ErnestNYWang pieced together, is
JJ J GRU-JFK
CX J JFK-BKK
CX J BKK-JNB
Rest of their travels are on separate PNRs, which is irrelevant to this case.
JJ J GRU-JFK
CX J JFK-BKK
CX J BKK-JNB
Rest of their travels are on separate PNRs, which is irrelevant to this case.
#9




Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: DAL
Posts: 3,488
If JJ issue boarding passes and check bags to JNB (which they should now because they are in oneworld), the CX agent has no way of verifying the weight of the bags. The CX agent will most likely verify that the tag numbers got sent in from JJ and ask if the passengers picked up the bags in Customs and put them on the connection belt.
#10


Join Date: Aug 2012
Posts: 757
Agree with the above, you have to read your e-ticket to confirm.
Usually agent just memorize the allowance, or in other words, assuming the pax gets weight base unless your immediate destination is US. But if you remind them, they can check the correct allowance from their system.
I have once flew LHR-HKG with a ticket that touches US, and the agent simply just assumed that I have 40kg + 20kg (F + OWE), which actually works better for me because I have 4 pieces of luggage but less than 40kg. Anyway, I have re-confirmed with him that it is ok even my ticket only allows me 3 pieces, and he only became aware of the piece allowance when I ask.
Btw, last time for BKK-HKG in J, they gave my sister 40kg (instead of 30) allowance, citing that she gets extra 10kg on top of 30 kg because she is in business class.
Usually agent just memorize the allowance, or in other words, assuming the pax gets weight base unless your immediate destination is US. But if you remind them, they can check the correct allowance from their system.
I have once flew LHR-HKG with a ticket that touches US, and the agent simply just assumed that I have 40kg + 20kg (F + OWE), which actually works better for me because I have 4 pieces of luggage but less than 40kg. Anyway, I have re-confirmed with him that it is ok even my ticket only allows me 3 pieces, and he only became aware of the piece allowance when I ask.
Btw, last time for BKK-HKG in J, they gave my sister 40kg (instead of 30) allowance, citing that she gets extra 10kg on top of 30 kg because she is in business class.
#11
Original Poster




Join Date: May 2000
Location: IAD/DCA/BWI
Programs: SQ, LH, AMEX, Citi, Cap1
Posts: 4,113
Thanks for the replies. I don't have an "e-ticket" receipt as US Airways, the issuing carrier, didn't mail me one, although my credit card got charged and an e-ticket number showed up on the US Airways web site.
I read through the official IATA rules to determine baggage allowance and utilized the web site www.iflybags.com. According to the IATA rules and the site, the allowance should be 30kgs, but airlines have been known to give more generous allowances.
To avoid confirmation bias, I e-mailed the CX YVR office, in hopes of getting a favorable response, which I did.
And of course, I'm going to print out CX's reply and give it to my parents just in case.
Response from the YVR CX office:
I read through the official IATA rules to determine baggage allowance and utilized the web site www.iflybags.com. According to the IATA rules and the site, the allowance should be 30kgs, but airlines have been known to give more generous allowances.
To avoid confirmation bias, I e-mailed the CX YVR office, in hopes of getting a favorable response, which I did.
And of course, I'm going to print out CX's reply and give it to my parents just in case.Response from the YVR CX office:
Dear Pat,
Thank-you for contacting Cathay Pacific Airways.
On all the Cathay Pacific flights Ms xxx will be taking, she is allowed 2 pieces of free checked in baggages, each piece should be no more than 70pounds (32kgs). Since this is actually a US Airways ticket (xxx-xxxxxxxxxx), please contact US airways for the other flights she is taking. Thankyou!
Best regards,
xxx
Cathay Pacific Airways Limited
Telephone: +1 604 606 8888
Toll Free +1 800 268 6868 (Canada)
Toll Free +1 800 233 2742 (USA)
E-mail: [email protected]
www.cathaypacific.com
Visit us at Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIN
Thank-you for contacting Cathay Pacific Airways.
On all the Cathay Pacific flights Ms xxx will be taking, she is allowed 2 pieces of free checked in baggages, each piece should be no more than 70pounds (32kgs). Since this is actually a US Airways ticket (xxx-xxxxxxxxxx), please contact US airways for the other flights she is taking. Thankyou!
Best regards,
xxx
Cathay Pacific Airways Limited
Telephone: +1 604 606 8888
Toll Free +1 800 268 6868 (Canada)
Toll Free +1 800 233 2742 (USA)
E-mail: [email protected]
www.cathaypacific.com
Visit us at Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIN
Last edited by Wiirachay; Jul 28, 2014 at 1:57 pm

