Gino Troian

Heads up Rimowa owners - even the Cabin S model exceeds the maximum dimensions allowed...

Score8

I haven't checked my new Away bag in the sizer yet (it's the larger one).

wireless_999

So nervous. I travel frequently domestic and intl with this case. It’s the carry on but intl size which is a little bit larger.

my trip coming up is an e190 Lga to bos then onto Asia.

I am pretty sure the first leg will not make it. Looking for any data points on the e190s. Thanks!

WiscAZ

This is the exact reason why I carry on. If "most" of the time I only had to wait 20-25 minutes for my bag I'd probably check my bag more often. By the time you get off the plane, use the restroom, and head down to baggage claim you wouldn't be waiting that long. The problem is you don't know if the bag will arrive before you get to baggage claim or 45 minutes after you land. Heck, I may be the minority but I'd literally pay the baggage fee to allow me to bring on my carry on that may be a tad larger than normal. All for the convenience.

As a data point, I had 3 flights this week leaving PHX, MCI, and ORD and not one was sizing bags (at least during group 1). I have a flight on Sunday the 3rd so looking forward to seeing some data points here from tomorrow and Saturday before I make a decision on whether I'm going to risk a bag that is 2" too wide or just check. Unfortunately, I'm off to a week long trip - business then a wedding - and have to bring a suit.

ryan182

While I agree that wait time on arrival is a big factor, its not the only one and even if AA had the 20min guarantee I'd still not check a bag because it requires getting to the airport earlier to meet bag check deadlines and it limits options for standby etc. Personally I target arriving to the airport 10 minutes before boarding starts, so 40 minutes before scheduled departure. With CLEAR and PreCheck I know I'll be airside in time to make boarding, and in fact I typically I end up at the gate before they've even preboards and have a few minutes to wait with the gate louse. This works for my home airport and those I travel from frequently as I know the traffic patterns and travel time well enough such that I have a high level of confidence that I'll make it. While that might sound like cutting it close, when you do the maths there's a 30 minute buffer (10min before boarding, assuming boarding starts T-30 and cut-off of T-10) for unexpected travel delays and its never (knock wood) been a problem for me. When you add up the time saved, assuming you travel a lot, its a meaningful amount of time and I attach a high value to that extra sleep time on the way out and the flexibility of not having a checked bag as much, if not more than, being able to quickly leave the airport on landing.

rfrost

It was business as usual at JFK this morning.

AA100k

No enforcement that I could see in PHL in B terminal last night as I was cruising about before my flight checking things out.

Antarius

Nothing in CLT at the gates I saw. Including one backpack that barely seemed like it would be allowed to be checked, let alone fit any sizer.

AeRoSpaceman

On DL if your bag is not at the carousel within 20 minutes of arrival(and door opening I think), you get 1500 RDM's. It isn't automatic and you have to request the miles. Some people use it religiously and get some decent miles within a year.

ikwia

Noted, and I appreciate the fact that they have a service guarantee, and offer (modest) compensation if they don't meet that objective. But I travel every week, and many (most?) weeks, I would need to pick up a checked bag 4 or 5 times. That's a lot of waiting, especially when I'm arriving at destinations at ~midnight and have early morning meetings.

deac83

Departed DFW yesterday. Saw no indication of bag restrictions and I was late to the gate and was with group 4 instead of 2.

andrewstahl

Last Friday in Atlanta, they were checking bag size on a CR-900 flight. However, they always have been checking bag size on RJ’s in Atlanta.

AANYC1981

This weekend a DYKWIA right in front of me in Group 1 boarding got pulled aside because he had this HUGE back pack stuffed to the gills with shoes stuffed on the outside holders.

They made him size it and then check it....LOL.

enpremiere

No more grand pianos and entire safari tent kits complete with real elephants being sneaked in via duty free

Good bye cruel over-sized baggage!

chris8796

At CLT today, the GA made specific mention to carry on allowance (much more than I've seen previously) and said overstuffed carry ones would be checked with the sizer and checked. The most egregious violator opted to self check before trying to checking in . A few borderline cases were asked to try the sizer or combine bags to get to two. The gate next to it had no enforcement and I noticed someone with an oversized bag go through. So as anticipated, this will be a GA dependent enforcement.