Flight Change Back to Original Flight - after $550 in Change fees - What to do?
#31
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Apr 2013
Location: PHX
Programs: AS 75K; UA 1MM; Hyatt Globalist; Marriott LTP; Hilton Diamond (Aspire)
Posts: 56,478
Technically allowed under CoC but a shabby customer relations experience. I would be pissed and would ask for compensation (but would not necessarily expect to get anything).
#32
Join Date: Nov 2012
Posts: 552
Where do you get that this was a last-minute flight? She changed her flight a WEEK BEFORE the flight.
#35
Suspended
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: DCA
Programs: UA US CO AA DL FL
Posts: 50,262
Bottom line is that OP's friend ought to send in a webform asking for a refund of the change fee + fare difference and explain in not one word more than 3 sentences, what occureed. Leave out all of junk about change fees because it's completely irrelevant and only gums up a CSR's ability to quickly and efficiently review the complaint. Park the outrage at the door.
On a good day, OP may see a credit -- not refund -- for the fare difference. On a bad day, $0. Maybe a couple of miles.
Forget the Greek Chorus about CC disputes. This one is dealt with in 15 seconds by UA and will be denied by Amex. Amex is really good about valid disputes and really bad long-term about attempts to use the dispute process for inappropriate reasons. If it's a corporate card, it's a lot worse.
Breaking this down issue-by-issue, which is the key:
1. Friend bought a ticket for $600 for a specific itinerary. For whatever reason, the friend chose to buy an inflexible ticket which carries a change fee of $200 + fare difference. There are, of course, flexible tickets which cost more.
2. Friend's gamble did not pay off. Stuff happens and itinerary changed.
3. Friend coughs up $550 ($200 + $350 fare difference).
4. Friend's newly-scheduled flight is cancelled. Flights get cancelled.
5. Friend accepts change to later flight. If this did not meet friend's needs and it was the sole option, friend could have cancelled for a full refund to the CC. But, friend chose to fly the less convenient routing. That's a choice friend (and we all make in IRROPS).
UA fulfilled its contract. Many of the posts in this thread are about life as the poster would like to see it, not life as it is under the contract friend and UA agreed to (read the COC).
On a good day, OP may see a credit -- not refund -- for the fare difference. On a bad day, $0. Maybe a couple of miles.
Forget the Greek Chorus about CC disputes. This one is dealt with in 15 seconds by UA and will be denied by Amex. Amex is really good about valid disputes and really bad long-term about attempts to use the dispute process for inappropriate reasons. If it's a corporate card, it's a lot worse.
Breaking this down issue-by-issue, which is the key:
1. Friend bought a ticket for $600 for a specific itinerary. For whatever reason, the friend chose to buy an inflexible ticket which carries a change fee of $200 + fare difference. There are, of course, flexible tickets which cost more.
2. Friend's gamble did not pay off. Stuff happens and itinerary changed.
3. Friend coughs up $550 ($200 + $350 fare difference).
4. Friend's newly-scheduled flight is cancelled. Flights get cancelled.
5. Friend accepts change to later flight. If this did not meet friend's needs and it was the sole option, friend could have cancelled for a full refund to the CC. But, friend chose to fly the less convenient routing. That's a choice friend (and we all make in IRROPS).
UA fulfilled its contract. Many of the posts in this thread are about life as the poster would like to see it, not life as it is under the contract friend and UA agreed to (read the COC).
#36
Suspended
Join Date: May 2011
Location: SFO
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 1,961
I'm just curious, how many times have you requested chargebacks in situations like this one, and what percentage were successful? Dozens of attempts?
#37
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: ORD
Programs: United Plat 2MM, Hilton Gold
Posts: 2,727
I agree with College...er...LawSchool...er...Esquire Flyer. Your friend paid United $550 to get on a different flight, and he didn't get on that flight. Any other business about refundablility, flexibility, etc. is just a distraction.
That said, the motto of Jeffnited is "Once you've got their money, never give it back". I doubt very much United will issue a refund.
That said, the motto of Jeffnited is "Once you've got their money, never give it back". I doubt very much United will issue a refund.
#38
Join Date: Oct 2012
Posts: 638
Friend had a ticket that entitled her to fly on flight #2, and in the case of irrops, a re-booking at no charge on flight #3. She paid $550 to get a ticket that entitled her to fly on flight #1, and in the case of irrops, a re-booking at no charge on flight #2. That's what she purchased, and that's what UA delivered.
#39
Suspended
Join Date: May 2011
Location: SFO
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 1,961
Friend had a ticket that entitled her to fly on flight #2, and in the case of irrops, a re-booking at no charge on flight #3. She paid $550 to get a ticket that entitled her to fly on flight #1, and in the case of irrops, a re-booking at no charge on flight #2. That's what she purchased, and that's what UA delivered.
However, it ignores the question: what are the ways to get her money back, or some compensation for what's obviously a raw deal?
UA gives compensation to people all the time even though they aren't entitled to it by the ticket contract. There's threads hundreds of pages long describing example after example of that.
Purchasers also have contracts with their credit card providers that are different than, and in some cases provide more protections and benefits than, their contracts with the vendors.
Considering that people complain that $200 compensation isn't enough when their video entertainment is broken, it seems a bit odd to pick on this passenger who got screwed.
#40
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: BOS
Programs: UA, Hertz Gold, AA Gold, DL Silver
Posts: 825
Too late now, but if the change was made to make a specific meeting then a flight became cancelled, couldn't the OP's friend have made the argument that it had then become a "trip in vain" and tried for a refund that way? Would not have refunded all moneys but could've helped.
#41
Suspended
Join Date: May 2011
Location: SFO
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 1,961
Too late now, but if the change was made to make a specific meeting then a flight became cancelled, couldn't the OP's friend have made the argument that it had then become a "trip in vain" and tried for a refund that way? Would not have refunded all moneys but could've helped.
#42
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: SJC, SFO, YYC
Programs: AA-EXP, AA-0.41MM, UA-Gold, Ex UA-1K (2006 thru 2015), PMUA-0.95MM, COUA-1.5MM-lite, AF-Silver
Posts: 13,437
Hello all. I'm writing this for a friend who occasionally uses United for business (I'm a DL person so I don't know UA's policies). Any help/advice/recommendations you guys and gals could leave for her on here would be great.
Here is her message:
"I need to rant and I hope you all listen. I purchased a $600 plane ticket on United. One week before the flight, I paid an additional $550 to change my ticket (don't even get me started on change fees) to leave earlier as I had a meeting I was required to attend. The day of the flight, United cancelled the earlier flight, put me back onto the original flight and refuses to refund the $550 because "they still got me to my destination." How is this okay? How can the airlines dictate such terrible pricing and customer service strategies? And I as the customer am just supposed to accept this? Grrrr....I'm beyond irritated. Any advice from my traveling friends on how I can get a resolution?"
Here is her message:
"I need to rant and I hope you all listen. I purchased a $600 plane ticket on United. One week before the flight, I paid an additional $550 to change my ticket (don't even get me started on change fees) to leave earlier as I had a meeting I was required to attend. The day of the flight, United cancelled the earlier flight, put me back onto the original flight and refuses to refund the $550 because "they still got me to my destination." How is this okay? How can the airlines dictate such terrible pricing and customer service strategies? And I as the customer am just supposed to accept this? Grrrr....I'm beyond irritated. Any advice from my traveling friends on how I can get a resolution?"
Apparently she did get on the plane, so the meeting wasn't that critical.
In situations where it would be nice to take an earlier flight but not necessary, it is best to standby or do the same day change. Even if she is not exempt from the standby and sdc fees, it is much cheaper than paying a change fee.
That all said, I think UA should refund her change change fee since she derived no benefit from the fees, and UA incurred no cost (there was an open seat on her original flight).
#43
Suspended
Join Date: May 2011
Location: SFO
Programs: UA 1K
Posts: 1,961
She wouldn't get all her money back. She would get the fare back, but that wouldn't include the change fee.
#44
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 583
However, I would argue in this case, the change, if made, were reversed by the airline.
As such, the change service, that the merchant charge the customer's card for, was ultimately not rendered.
Last edited by Ragnarok; Jun 29, 2013 at 3:12 pm
#45
Suspended
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 981
Credit Card disupte? Goods and services not received? The additional payment was specifically to move to a specific flight and time. They put you back on the original flight, so any payment made for the change should be refunded. I bet you win with the credit card. UA is really very very quickly going down the tubes. And to think, I have 2 big international work trips next year that I was going to give to UA so I could make my PQD, but now I'm holding off on booking and thinking of going back to AA, or God forbid Delta. It probably is time to walk. The thought of going to Gold from 1k is just very emotionally difficult.